← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11964/2019dismissed

Prerna v. The State Of Haryana And Others

2019-12-20Mr. Justice B.S. Walia15 pages



     

        

    !"# $ %     &'        !" # $%!%      () ( *+, "'   $ "&"*# +-*$ %   #  " ) ( *+,   './0% *+,    +".) ( 1 0*+, 2 333  # $%!%&   45  %  "6 '  "   6    

7 " 80 *+

: ;  ;  8"' 

 " <006"' (     *2;:=* 0 * +

 : 

   

( 8 " '  " " 7   > 8 . 

" 006"'( "> ?00 +

: @2  "(

  % 0 "   6   (    8

    0 " ( 8 (    <006"'    8 %

(  A A ;

5 5 /   "0 8" 0 8 "6 '   ""' 7  8  /# =0 "% 

( ) ."  B , %* ) ."    !"  * " ('0 " # "( %   " % 

( ) ."  B , %   ('0 "  /C   " % @

( "  B , %   

2  8( " "' ( "( %*) ."  , %* ) ."   !" '  0 7 0  #D&=C!  (>  *(> * @ (>  >-+!C9( "%  @*    A ',0%#"07 0 /+&=  B#=-# C9(    A0$ % !" E C08>0%!*  -! 

" 7 0  A=#D&=C!1&< 425  "' 7 0 % 8C! (>  *">( 0 $ % # 0< #  !"

08% " F G$##!H<006"' ;*:=' ( "0 86" 8 %( 

(       (   $##! <006"'  8 (( #"( +

+=:++' " (  #"(*'  ;*:= ' ( "'%>0 " 6%  I *:=

(" % "       " * +

0  8  -  *:= 0(>0!"' > 808>0''0 $##!<006"'  , 0  +

 :

    A* " 6    ( '

    A  ,      (    7  0%* " ' ," 

    0 8 6" 00 "  %  ( :    , 0   A A* " 6 0  0  " 6    1   & " <006"' 1&<  $##! <006"' 8 (( "6  ""? 8 ' 

425    7  0%* " '   >( "  %  (  0 8 6" . 8*+

:

 ; A 5 !",0 @  A*"' 6    (    *2;:=       <006"'    8 %  " ' 

; A22 A "(6>  "> . "'  (> * A,0 *+

:@@  A 4@5 !"   " ( (* " '  ''0  " '  +     "( % '

    , (    >% " $ %   >0 # , ((    6 0   @ A $6, *"0 6"00 8> " >%6%   @2  A   "  

 6  '    "     '' (  0    " 0   6 % ,   

  AC,  00%*"6 ' 0 86"" 

6  '  6 ( >% "   , ? 8(    A ;* 6"  '  " ' , '' (  0 * +

 :

   A ;6" >%"6 ? ((0% "   

   - 0*$8" C  *$ % * ". 0!" ' " ? +   "( %  A ;0  !"  * " ' * , 0 * +

 :A  2A ;  >(" 8 

($##!=1&< ? 8+   008  " >? "( %6  A ;<!"

8  0 6 6 >%" :B , %   :$##!,0 +

:;2 ; 5 !""' ,0 *+

: ;  ;

("

    8" 

" ( *2;:=  <006"'  8 %D " *"

5 '   >( '0% , 0   ;  ;  8 " " " 6 .  $##!=1&< <006

( ; A   A ;   " "( % ' (    <006"'    8 % 6    "'  ; A22 A *2;:=!"  *" 

, %( <006"' " ( 8' 

(  A A ;  " ? 8+   008  " ' (    $8"  C      A ;* " "  >( "

8  2A ;*" *" >  %('"00%    " '0%   " ' * " ,  0 * +

:   

( 8"" 7 "> 0>% "

  7  0%*"" 0

" ( <006"'   8 % ( 8   *2;:=  !"  0  6 006 >% " 0 *+

: @2  "(

+' " ' * "   0    (   2* *@ :=  " ' 

( A AA ;  <006"'  8 %(  6""%>'>%   4A5 ((  *+

: ;  ;*+

:     +

: @2    8"' 

 "   (    <006"' ( 8   *2;:=* >* 0 8  '% <006"'    8 % (   " ' 

(   AA ;",> "00 8>%"' >%6% "  6 '  "8 ""'' ( 0 " ' +   6 A ; "6  ? ((0%+ "*"?   A ;0  " 6   "'  >(" 8  > "  " ,6 "( *"'  0 > 

"

4@5 ( <006"'6"""" , "  "6 ."    J.6* "  (0 0%     6" 0 8 <006"'

(B-=#D&00 A ;" > .

" ( * 7  0%*" " 600% (  %  ,0,   + 0     "       D  >* '0%* +

 :  ;  ;   " '   " ((  * +

: ;  ;6 ?>%  ,0 * +

:   >%' 800% %'  ='. 8  4;5 &'0%"> 0 >"0  :$##! 0% 8 ' 0 " " . 8+

:

 ; A8, >%"' '  6  1  & "<006"'1&<

"$##!<006"' 8 ((!"( '

   =

                               

    !

   " 4 5 "08" " (  *0 " " . 8* +

:

 ""' " .  %' (

(  :$##!> 0, 8"<006"'!"'0 " ' 09    0  " " >       0  &0 "0> '0 0 , ">08  & " <0066"" 

=

5 #  $    !

 

         ! 

                    %&  

!   %     

 '                                         " 45  D">  ""'   >( %0 8    :$##!"

 88 %  %0  

(  6 , "

 8" " -    ( "   , *  8'    > 8>0 "<006"'*" * ,0 8" (   8  '  < " *"7  0 8

" 8   " '  0 0% ,0 " . 8* +

 :

  8  >% " ' 6" ) # 8"*# ' , "  &8 "B , % 45  !""' " >(" 8  "" ( * ' ( "( %*) ." B , %*) ."  2A ; +

:A    :$##!"

 88 % !" '  "  ,     " '%   " 8   0

(   :$##!< " *' 0 , ">08  & "<006! (    "#"(*" ' 6 7   >(" 8    :$##!

4A5 "

 8""-  ( " , *  8'      8"<006"'6""6 " >%"'  " , % (> " 8  "' "

 8"0  2 ;  :$##!6""6 , @ ; ''

9(0%"

( "06""6 " ,0 0  ,

>, 4 5  &'  2 " 0 0 '0%   6""  " > (  ""

 88 %  :$##! ' " 8  "' "'0""'  ('0% 6" 0  "   " . 8* +

 :

   >( >% "  

  :$##! 6"0 ,0 8 " +6    & " <006"' "' 0 " " . 8 >(>%"' * '  "+6  & "<006"'*"6 0 0," $##! <006"' 6"  ' (    $##!:

         0, 8 6"  ' ( * " 6 0

 "   (   <006"'  "  0 "

 8" B , %:D   6"    ( " $6, * " '    >  '

  ''

,0

(   :$##!    >( " 8     ? 8 J "'  !"

 8 8 %  $##!:

   

" 7   28

 " ( <006"'( 8 *2;:=

( " '  6"    ( "

( "         0 * +

 :  "

 8" "7   ,    " #  % C* $##!*  ". 0!" '

  "' "$##!:

 

 88 %6,

 (    0 " "

. 8 6 ?  !" * " (  6 7  0% >6  " '    D"

" > (  ""

 8

4;5 8    "  6" ( " >  (  6  

 6 ", 8

 (    6  <006"'

  0 8   

"<006"'(  425  !"' " 0 '0 *+

:2. 8'0  0   "  > 8 ,  6" " '

'0   (     %  D  "  6 * " 06   

 ('>0 &0 "> '0 " , / " "  &?

"- 8*+#"

 " J0)" ," C0 0

 * $ %  "   ">*">  "6 ('>0 "'  >(" 8  > 2A ;" ?   +     "( %    A ;   '

    +'' ( J *+

:

 A ;   * 0 "   ""( 7  0%, >%"8  (    4 5  D ",    "  >(    0

  0  " '  4@5  0  "   " . 8* +

 :

  ; A 8  >% " '   " (   '    6    & " <006"'(. %00 ""'  0 0,"$##! <006"'6" ' (  :$##! "  0, 86" ' ( *"6

" ( 006"' " 0"

 8"B , %:D   6" ( " 4 5  !" '  , ((  * +

 :A  2A ; 7  " " ( * ' (    "( %* ) ."  , %* ) ."   ' " 8 

( $##!=1&< 6   A ;<  ", 8? +   008

4 5   " >? "( % "' ( $8" C   A ;+!" 8  0 "' 6 6 , +

 :; >% ) ."  B , %* ) ."   " #  %:C* $##!      !" ( 6 ? , +

 :    "  " " '  " 8 

( $##! <006"' 6"  ' (    "  0 6"" 6 8  " . 8 8  >% " '    '    " 6    & " <006"'    (  0  "  +  80%* " '  6   

 "   ( <006"'( 8 *2;:=6" ( "

("      " 0  "

 8" "7   ,    #  % C* $##!*  ". 0!"(6 006>%((  *+

:

    

" 006 >% ((   +

 :   @2  

(+( 

 *+ =D"" '  *' ( "( %*) ." B , %*) ." 

( 8 " " $##!:

     " '   " "  0 

 " ( <006"'( 8 *2;:=" ( #"0 "' "' 

( ; A22 A 4A5  !"  &?

"- 8E# '

 0 ' >%" 0

 0 "' 6' 00%  >  '

  "(", 8> ' "' 0     (  " (0% ""   *$ % > 8 >0   ,0

(   >60  " 8 "     0(  6"     >60 >%"  (*  0 6""" "0'   0  . 

   "   >6    >60  " 8 "> 8 2 )($6, *"' %(( = (= &

8 

 * 1  "  00% 

( " '  " " "

45    6  ' (  % ,

8"   " & $   1 : 6    @ '(  !"  '   7  6 (  " " C0 0 

 * $ %    " , 8   @    600   " C0 (( D  @  (  8"  " " 9 =  %  ( * 6"""    0  0%

(  >60" 8 ". 8  ""6" "  '. 8 ' " =  " 8 " 6 0",> 9 (0% 

 0 ""    ,0  2 )(  "+ ,  / "   "   >% ''0% 8 '

'0   (     %"0""06 

('>0> "" >  '

  "("> ' "' 0

   (  " 4;5  $6, * " ? 8(  6 0 >   ,0  " '  ">0%'

("(  % %" 0>6"   0 " 6 *"'

( ">('>0%>% "  0 "'  7  '

(" %*  ( , 6"""' 

7    '

( "  % "    0  00  +    " 

   (  "     $ E>0 " # '

(      '

 !% !%"(% !'!%)*%%#(!!+%' $%)!+ ! , '

& -..- /01 # 02  &0,  9    " ( 

'

  = G)* +    (       (       %     % %  % %  %      %,    %%     -

45        %     ,  .

    %    

  %               %       )/ 0      % %  %           %

  %  %     

  

   

             %                  '  (  %  12  34(  5  &



 

 "(  (  "5          %   

       %  % %      %        .    6 4(  

 " 073 4(    % % % -

                  ( 8             %              

( # 9  

% 

4 5  ( %       (     %        %  % 

% 

 (                  %     . .        %(               %       %        (

 

 

   3   3:   9 +        %           %      %                 %% %  " 4 5  #(0 0%* $8" >%

8" (    $ E>0"# '

(  %3! %'

# %  " ! 33!!)%)!'%

 %4%5*%+%3&-.67/01228> , 

= G;<      

  

 

 

!  "

#   $

 



$ % && '(

              3  =%   '&    %   %   (        % 

 (    

      >   : =& ?   : %

   %                 5     (     (

425      ( (     %   (              % %           (              %   @+            %               ( 7      % %    %    % %   

     .'

  %. (+   '                         % %  %  '   ;;   (    (   

  ((  % (      % %            

   %  

 (             

 %  %         %          %  % %    ,              ,       "

4 5 4 5  !"'

'0 (  %6 0 ''0% "      (    "   * (0% " '  6 6  0 " " . 88 >%"  "   ( "8 ( 9 6"" *"6 7  .'

 ' (    "  >  0, 8 " $##! <006"'  #"  0  0, " $##! <006"' 6"  ' (     :$##!   0, 86" ' ( *"6 7  

 "   (   006"'  "  0 "

 8" , %:D    6"    ( "  < " *  '  " >08    & "<0066""' "8 0 (    & " <006"'*   006 

   ":"  <006"' 6"  '

 ''

,0 $##!  ":"6" " 006"' '

   ('0    " 

    (     8 0 >?, 

 "*":"6 7   >(" 8  $##!"

 8"" -  ( " , *  8'     8" <006"'  !" <006"' 6 0    "   

( "  ' 0 "$##!0 ''

, 8" 8   5   "    * " '  6   '' (  0 +

:

 A ; "? +   "( %   A ; 0   !"  * " , 0 * +

 :A  2A ; >(" 8 

($##!=1&< ? 8+     008    " >?  "( %  6   A ; <!" *6  > 8('>0 "'  ", > "'

 ' ( "  0  "(  0", >  > ? 8 "0' "0   0 0  6"" 6 ( " '

    (   ", 8   * "  

4@5 7  0% ,  >% 0  "   " . 8 +

 :

 

; A8 >%"' 6000 , ">08   & " <006 ! (        " #"(   !" ' 

,0">  "? 8(  0 '  "(9(

 >,"66  " 0 '

  " 0  0 " ( 

( ,0  %" .'

 ' (  8 00"(0 "6 ' 

5  & 0 0%*D  (  "6 '  "( ( /#0 1 8     (  "" '. 8:

  K:

 "" ' >0

K: