Bhan Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others
!" #$#
" %&#'
( )'&
!
"
#
$
# % !
"
& ' (((( ( )'&*#+,-./
)*&+ +
, !
- .
/&0
" 1 23
&332&32'
'&) '&' ') 4 +
2*53- '&5 + 4
0
4"
6
"
- .
/20 44 ,
"4
!"
322&&32*- .
/'0
"
- .
/)0 7 353&&3&3 +
" +
8 4
8
/
!
!! !
! #
!$
% &'
' ( ) %% % *
+
*
' - .#/0 1& , -"
!
*
23 2 % '/ / , 4%' +-' -%
5 6 * % ' 7/ + '22 68 *)'
/ , -%
! % " / 7'" 6 * % 7 -
6 -
%
% %
%
!
7 9
%
!
* * #/0 1& 9 - / %%
* "
/ %%
%%
:
# & "*7 % '
#
& " 7 " % % * 7'
#
& 1 '
# ,& * %% "
,%
7 "
#,& * , ;
# &' #
& #
& - ,
-
(
<
'- 0 / +
$ ! $ #9% )& <
= , 49 &:3'&3&& 8
8 9 +
/ >"
'
' 25 ? 5 .- %
! - *
' @ 5 .- % ,
! - * - '
" , * - " -/ % " /
%
<
'
) ' -* "
!- -* ,
1((
! > %
-* , "
((
! / +
. / 7 - % %
= In pursuance of the said order, a report has been submitted
$ by the Additional Sessions Judge, Bathinda to the Registrar General of this Court. The relevant portion of the said report is reproduced hereinbelow:- # &
,-7 A-% +- 37 3
'
* * % )%+ ' + 3 , "%% ) '4 + ) 66 ' , ; %
/ * *%7) 4 + ' '
7
#
&B0 - ,
) + ' ' % % * ' #
&> % % -
% * # ,& * % )%+ * - "
%% ) 4 + " *'7 +
* 3 , 3 %"
%% -+
3 %7 ) 4 + 3* *
%% ,
+ 3 , %
* %*'
*
* %
/ ) 4 + , %
* * % )%+ + 3 , >7,%
7 , , - % % * 7 ' *
*' * -
-7 , %7' "
7
% * 7 / '
#,& ) 66 # &' , ; % *
,
!' 1!!'!'! ;' ' " (( " 5,
) 4 + ' * * % )%+ >" %7"
-7 * % ) 4 + '
"
% , - % % * 1
% " * * ,
"
*> % - %
- " % >
* * % )%+ + 3 , ' ) 4 + "%%
, ; ' ) 66 % "
6 % >6 7
'=
4
8 4 8
"
8"
!
4 9 8 9"
"
4 "
;
"
4
8 44
& '!
"
!
4
&:3:&3&2 < =4
+
!" #
8 44 +
" +
$ $%%$& ' "(
) "*+,
#
"
"
)*&+ +
, 1 4 4
8 4
!"
4 > +
4 "
4
# "
"
"
!
1 8
4
322&&32* > "4
2
+4 "
!"
$
8/
* ;C1 ) !!
* 7
7 ' 15 % '
*
* + !
* 7 7 ' 15 % '
*
* !!
* 7 !. /%%%% %7
-7 = 4 49 1 "" 4 <
!
8
4 "
!"
!
322&&32* 8
"
/
* ;C1 )%+ !$
* 7 7 ' 15
% '
*
* !!
* 7 3 , !!
* 7 7 ' 15 % '
*
* ': /%% %% %7
-7 =
4 <
! 4 48"
6 "9 4 !
9
4 > "
9 +
"
"
9 "
4
4
"
" 8 44 1 "
4
8 4
44
"
"
44 "
" ?1 8 4444 ,
"4
"
!"
< =4
+
-" - 0 "
4
<+
)*&+ +4 8
!
"
8/ >
,
'
!
,*- '
/*-'
'2
* 7
' / %% - % * # * % &/ %%
%% , 6 * % "
'" %%7 % % % / %%
% 6% -% " -
7 * % / %% " ** %
.'!! !$ "
! %
' $ # 'D E&
! ,
/ #
%
% > -& /' .. C %7F ,
'
9 <
%2 #&'/*-' / %%
.'!! !$ "
! "
*0 * 7
!$ "
! 000000000 >3
' ' , , * -%7 % , * %% %7 %%
% ' 0
"
',
-%>3
- -%7 ,% %
-7 -
7 ,
%
* ' % 7'
, '
6"
%7F ,7 -+
%+ 7* ! %
%, 5
"
%7 , ' - %%
, % % 7 - %
% *
3
* % *
% , + %*
%7 %" ,%7 %"7 -+ %" %0
7 ' " 6
'3
0
"
' 6 , " *
'
" - , ' "
'
-
'-
>
0 0 7 "
"
- + >- % " 3
- % + / ,
"
*7%
+ '" , * ' *7 % ,
+ ; ' "
,- , ' -
-0 '
%7 -, -7
G;, +- G; 90* 7# & 000 000 000 .H
! "
%7
-7 -" D
-%E "
7 *"
6' 0 7 "+
3
,
/ %
'- 6 -7 * -
!
%' " " "
* %
- 0 %%7 0 % '- * :# &
7I #
&
+ 7' 7I#
& 7
-" , *IG # ,&
'
%,
=
4 !
8 4 8
4 .
9
<+
)*&+ +8"" !
#
'&3+ +
!
"
4
!
4! "
" 44
!
"
44
9
"
"4 4 "
!"
4!
"
8 9
" 8
"
"# !"
<+
.
" " "
8
#
! 8
" " "
" +
" +
#="
- 0 44
)*& + +
4 " " "
!
"
8 7
%
?' ? #/0 5 &
!!' !'
?'? $' . # - %7
! !!$ &'
"' ( 5 "' - $ ?#/0 5& %%
-
%
+
*
'- ? . ! -7% /
%
<
' ) '
"-7 5
' " 000J00055000
K
+
* ? . ! -7% /
%
<
'
) '
- $ ?#/0 5&'
-"
7 %-
0005500055000 >
*,
) * .!
/01 01
%% -, , " %
-
'3
, %%% "
% 7 +
-, :5 ?> % 6 "
! ' ",'
- 3
* "
%
+ $/
-0 -7% %<
" "
%
% - -" - 6 , -%
%7 -7 %
'" 2 3* ! " 5 6 01
01 7 01& %'
* % "% %%# - & -
./ %
* A * % " - %%
>/ 0
% 6
, " * + -, L
% "
-- %"L % -7
" / %
3
7 "6 / %
'
- ,, 3
"
% 6 %%% " @ > *
+
0 -%-73
%
"
, " , - %" + '
",' "
%
"
%
%7
-% "
-
! %
- "'
, "' 0 -% 7,
0 - " %%7 + * 000000 .000000 000000 %
$ *" %7 - % % ,# %
5 5 %"
&,%
* -% %*' "
, "
"
* F %
* * * %7**-"
% , +
* %7
"
%
% % * %+ " ,7
+ % ,77* 7*-
"
%
-7 %
7 %
' -
6 +
6
" -+ %7 5 '"%% "
+
* $ ! . %
?5 /
% <
%2 '3 ' - , -" * 5*
#*
*(, &"1 % +*%
%7 / 7 %%7' % * % % -7
*
- - ,5 %%7' % -7
- ,5*
$ ! ."
-
%% -
% -7 / %%
3 =
%%7' 3
) *
"*+,0/101&%'"-7 "
!$ "
* "
7'
7 %>
" %%7
+
* 8 ) * .!6 0&1 01 /
) * "*+,%0101/ %% "
!$ %%"
-,
"
%%-
* -" ' -
000J00055000 / %7'
?' ?
#/0 5 &
!!'!'?'? $' . # - %7
! !!$
&'
"'
( 5 " %% - *'
' ' - $ ?
#/0 5&' -+ 7*
?' 15' - "
+-9% , / 7' %7' +
*
'- ? . ! -7% /
%
<
'
) '
-+
7* = +
3:3'&32@ + ':3 &32@ 9*
)+! 9*
# 4
/
% - % 9* !2
(
9
60101 2
", * !
3,6: 1% >,
%+
3
*
"
% - -
+ -" ,
'-
*7
% >
"
, ,%
% ,
"
%- ,-7
>,
% 0 "
% - "
@ -% */ > % %
" 2
", * !
3,6:0 1%6"
- %7
%% " - -" "
%,
, "
' +
* . @ -7 /
%
<
'
6 -,
"
" % >,
%% " -+
?M *
%
" 2
", *- 4 0* 1 9% , / 7' " "
%%-
7 %% "= 4"
!
84 4"
< =4
+
2
", *- " 0* 1
48 +
"
!"
!4 "
"
" !4
! 8 48 4 8 !
< =4
+
5 - # &
!
4 89
8 4 "
9 +
1 49 ""
"
8"
!
4!
" "
A
49
4?"
4"
!
49 8"!
"
4
.
4
! 9
"
"
"
, "
4
"4# " 8 4 !
4"
49 ! 8 "
8 4
4
!
"
!"
9 > "4
+41
49 "
8 9"
"
"
4
84449 !
4 49
4 > 1 49
""
"
#4"
9 &32'
8
9
8 " # 4"
.
49
& '
!44 ,
8 4 "
9
!
49
"
4 "
9
8 4
""
"
"4
?
4
",
4
#
! 8 !
"
" " "
44 "
!
- .
/&0
" 1 23
&332&32'
'&) '&' ')
4+
2*53- '&5 + 4
0
4"
6
"
44 ,
"
, ,
"
322&&32*- .
/'0 9 > "4
2 +4
+( )'&/ 2, . 34* 26 B
? #C ?
B
4 C D ?