← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10313/2025dismissed

Ashok Kumar v. Union Of India And ORS

2025-05-28Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj9 pages



         

  



!"

 #$%$!&'

(  

) * *

 

    

+  

)



  '

,-  ) .  )     

  !

  # $% # 

 & 

'()* .  ) / 

-

& 

+,-,. / "" ! 

 0 / 

 /

 "

$ 1

23  / 14256 167 & 258)   &

 

 0  

/ " /

  9

"

!



0  

 6

! 1

,,:;: /



* !

#  < 7

 =

 &  (

 !!" $

2> /

6

0"

  

"7$$ % $ "   

 

 !

   !

 )0

  !   

$ ! 





$

 "  &  ?

@

;,A, 0 80<  /3 

$  " $   B !  

 0 

  &

 

1

23 7,- 1

!23  80< 7 ,; ?6

1

23 

 $/  , 2 0  "  

$   < &  ?

@ 0     

   / 1

23 7 0 $!

:,+,- - *    ! " ! !

"   

 !

  #

" *    " 2 $ ""        

  "6

! 1

!

  $$ !

+,,0 $ $$ ""

 1

23 0$ 

 !

0 /3   / 

,,+,+

     ! 

  !/   !

   / 

   !* " /$   $

  +,-,. 

 8) 6 1 23    &

 

   /    "  "

$

  !

!

$ 

-

   ! "

 / !

 $   !

  /       /

$  

!

 @   "  !/ !!

 

"

1

 + 9



/ "



 0   !

  /  $ !   $

"    +,-,. 

 /     /   @ 

/

  !  /  "2 $"" * 

C!

!

 



  !

/ $ $$  " "

      1

 23   /   $  !$  0 

 " /!

 / !

"   /     *  "  !

 

 /  

/$    

 -,-,. 

 8    !

  ! 

3

  

2 0  $0$0  !

 0 !!

 /   

  9

 !

   $  > 

C   /1

 !

$$ /   $

  !

 !!" $ .  !  

!   !  

 "

 , 0 @

0 



"

!  4   

 "!

C

 !

!

$ !0

   /    !   

  

   /   

/ $



 ! "!  "" ! 

+

$   < &  =! !    & 

=! !      &  ?

@ * D ** 0

  

  $

C

/! !

::4!

! 6 6

!

 /!

  0



*  /$    "" !  

!

  $

0 

  !

$0  

 / $

 $  

 ! @  $ "      

  !B !4

" /$  $   

0 $



    $ 

 !

0 

0  



 

  $ $

0  0  B!



;,-,.

!

 

 0 ! " 

 9

 !

    ! /"

   &   $



!

!$

C

0

"" "

$ ;AE  $   /      3      $  $ 

 

    

 !

  $      $ ! "!   7 * 

 $ !!

 

C

 

 @  $

"

/"  $ 0 !

   

C"$   !  !!

  $ !! * 

C"

/$ 

      

!

 /   0   $ "  ! $ 

   

 $

    /    !!

$"

3

$

+,-,.

.

. 9

"

0 

!

/

 "! $ B " 

C !

  !  



!

"$  

     "

 0      " !   

 

  " 

! 1

1 !

!

?  "  0   $  "    !

 



!

2

C/& 0 

 !

$ "! / "  !

$0  ! * ! " !

 

 "" & "* 3   /   B$ 

  

 !

 "/ 0

C

  3

* " /$ 

 /  $  !

!

$$ !

-,,.0 !

$ 

  "

$   $   B ! 

  !  

 $  !

"" !    !

$$ !



   *#  / 1

 23   $$  

 " 

 F

 

!

!$ "!

! 

$

"

$



  



! 0 /

""G  !



!

$$ 

1

23  80 <  

   

    B !  " $    !



<

# 6 1 

 +,-,.9

 $  > 0   / 

  /0""!  $ " ,



 !+,0   <

# 6 10   0     

 0 " B !  " 

$    

* 

!

0 $  " ! !  

0

 !  " 

/  /$" 

! / !

" H  

"0   !

 /  !4 &   "

$     

/   "

$ "



 $!



0

/

""!  $

4 !



   /$   /!

$ !  !

  /B 9  



$$/ " !  "

!

 /  !

$  

!

$

! $"0  

!    

  

$ !

     $   

    "  

$  !

 A *   $ "

 

 0   $

/ "

0" 

,;,.,.

"

!



 "   !

   ! " ! 

 $ / 

 

$ !

!

$ 

/  



 8 /   /  !   

 / 

   :: 4!

!6 6

!

 /! !  ! $ 







  

A

  0   /  $  B!

" "" ! 

 /    *    /  ! " !  

C / 0  /

 "" 0 

 

$  !

!

/

 

 4   "

$ 

-,,./ !

$ 

!

B ! 

 

   !  

C

* / "  !

/  "! 

    $  !

   

!  "



* 0/    $ 

/  

$/$  / $  !

!! ! /  

 !



8 $ / /

/

 

B !

!$ ! 0 ! !

"4!

!6   

!

 

@ !

"    

   $ !!

 &

 



!

!



/





 $ "

/ $ "

  " !

 4 $ 





"! 

0@  "



" ! $ /   $  !

 /   !



   $

 ; " !"

/

   I!



 !0  !

/ <&  =! !   &  ?

@ 



J 

;

 

&  3

""!

$ /  !

 0   !

   ! &

 

" *   *    0    3

 

" !

$B "!

    0  $

  

 !

IB$ 

 "

   0 "$$ 0 

!

4 0 



   $   "

!   

$"

& "0  $  0  ! /  $*0 

/

"

&  $ $ " ! $ >

   "<

# "6 1

*# 1 $

I  0  

 !

  

 

 ! / 

 0  

* "! 0  

 !

 !   

!

 

$   ! 





/  B  !

  

  $   $

  +,-,. ?

 $

 "

$ 

      / ""!

/  "! " !!

$       



 !    $$ 

0$/  * !

 # "    / 1

 25 ! 

C

 !

! 

     

 0  /

 4   ! 

 @  / 

    $ 

 $   B !    

$/ " $

 /

 ! /  $

 /  0 " 

$$ 

0$

!

/  /

 0  0

" ! /   &  4  /

 

!  " !  

 

B!

!

!$ ! 

:

2

& 0    

 * !

 "    $@    !

 B!

 !

!$ 0

" !/ &  :

"



*$ !

 



!@$ 8

/ $  0

" 0   $

+,-,.&

3  0

  / $  (/  

.  ) 

1!1