High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21270/2020allowed

Bhupinder Singh @ Roda v. State Of Punjab

2022-04-21Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur9 pages

!"# $!"% & '

( )(* $+'+# , "-'

( ( $ /0 '1 ( 2 .( ( 2*.( 3/0 ''%0 *45 ( $ '2/*3/0 '1 ( 6./

!"# $%&'("&(! " "

+2 ../ 21 5 / 89 ./9 (( ( *60 6 2 (.1 ../ ,( 90 0 1/ ( (( 2 ../0 2 6 ( //3 *54 // 4* :. )*+,) - +2 . 2 5 / *( $ ;< ( 0 32( 2 .( 5/ .( 8 */9 .(= 5/ +2 (6(= (/0 9 2 5/ .(0 (( ,! " ;0 (9( / $ 1/ >0 /0 ( /0 32( * *( $

?0 ! 0 <?0 ( 65

; +2 51 ,! /9 2 =( +2 *6 /99 ,! 2 =( 0 *6 6.(0 2 9 2 .(* 56 (0 *. 9(6 6 5= 2 .(0 0 2 (.6./ (2( 6*2 (//( 2( 2 =( +2(*920 2 9(6 2 =( 0 2 .( 2(0 0 @6/ @*6(0 0 0 *(( >/0 // 326 3( 2/9 4 (.( 5*0 (2( / 2 4 (.( 5* /9 32 2 / 12/0 ( *6 < /0 -( $92 (1( $920 ( 1//9 260 +2/ $60 ( /0 2( $92 '6(4 $920 ( 1//9 @2(80 +2/ ( /0 0 ; (4( $92 %*(1 $920 ( 1//9 "*0 +2/ ( / ' 2 6 (39 2 9(6 *.( 0 *6 / 3 (10 ( 6=0 5= 2 //( (6 2 5*=(0 2 .( 3 (0 0 / 2 6 (39 2 9(6

*.( 0 2 . 2 / 5* 3 4/= 5= 2 .(0 0 0 @6/ @*6(0 0 0 *(( >/0 56 2 1( 2 51 6 .*(2( (1(0 / / 2(0 2 *. (( 2 (* .(6 89 ./ 5= ;0 2 (69 / ( 569 /A* (1(0 / 6 2(0 2 2 //( 3*/ 5 5* 9 2 51 (* .(6 (((0 (6 2 6 2 (9/ 3(0 2(*92 2( /9 4 (( ../ */= *..( 5= 10 5= ;0 51*/= 1*( 2 3 3( ! 69 2 9 /90 2 1 :.0 .( 2 / / ( //9 2 2( 2 99(16./0 569 /A* 260 32(

;

0 56 6.//= /A*0 2 (/1 90 5= 2 .*(2( 2 5*=(0 0 / (2( 569 ..(.( /(/= 5= 2 .( 5/ .(0 2 2 51 4 ../ 6. 5= 1 // (0 (2( 569 / 5( 2 *2(= (0 ( 2 2 ((( (* .(6 (0 ( 32 = 5/62

+2 /( $ */ 3// /( */ ..(9 ( 2 99(16./ 126/= ..0 2 9( .(= 5/0 2 .( 5/ .(0 0 52 *56 2 2( 2 6./ /8 2 .( 2 .( 5/ .( +2 ( *56 56 9(1 2 *60 2 .( 5/ .( (2( 89 1( 0 (.1/= 2 ./9 *. 2 .0 32 2 8 2 *5A* ../ 5(9 " < B? +2 .*(.( 1( 0 */ /8

0 6.( 2 *60 2 2*92 //= 2 .( 5/ .( 0 2 2 6 (39 2 .. 9(60 32(0 2 99(16./ 2( 689 2( 1/ 9*(0 2 2 .(.( 6= //9 2 2( 99(16./ 569 /A* 260 32(0 *5A*/= 2 ./9 ;B;0 0 < B?0 (2( ((= 2( 0 569 .(.*0 6*2 0 2 =( ;0 ( 9(6 // 59 :* @6/ @*6(0 .(( 2 4 (.( 5*0 0 5(2( 6./ 0 *(( >/0 32 60 0 2 .* $*(( 0 0 2 2 6 (39 2 9(6 // (0 2 / ( //9 2 2( 2 99(1

6./0 569 /A* 2( 6 ( 2 3 $*(( +2 51 9(6 // ( (.1/= 9 ':*( 0 0 ?0 0 ( .. 32 ;B; ' 2 90 6.( 6 2 6 5 /9( /10 0 51*/= 2 6 */ 5 (( 5= 2 199 ( ? +2 ( 6 (9*6 5( 2 *(0 5= 2 /( $ */ 3// 5= 2 /( */ ( 99(16./0 56 //= *29 19( +2 ( ( 689 2 ( /*0 ( (6 2 *60 2 9*( 6 2 .. 9(6 //0 (.1/= 5= 2 99(16./ *(( >/0 0 5= 2 5(2( 0 @6/ @*6(0 32 326 2 .( 5/ .( 3 2/9 4 (.

( 5*0 (2( 569 5= 2 ( +2((0 = 5 9 26 5 2 (/ 2( +2 51 9(6 // 3 (3 2 =( +2 6 6.(1 .( 2 9(6 //0 6.( 2 *60 2 2*92 2 6 (39 2 9(6 2 (0 (/9 / 2 (.( 5*0 *6 / 59 (10 ( 6=0 0 2((0 *. 4 ../ 32 1 59 *(2 5( 2 + (0 5= // (0 2 2 (69 / ( 59 9( 5 /A* 5= 2 .*(2( 2 99(1 6./0 2 5(2( @6/ @*6(0 0 2 .( 5/ .( ' .(*/ 2 (( ( * 5= 2 9/ +(.

( '*2(=0 0 322 : .9 " 0 2 ..(580 (1/ 2 6( 0 2 (* .

5*=( ( (6 2 //( (0 2 4 (.( 5* +2 ( 3*/ 21 2..0 32* 2 (A* .(*(/ 6./0 59 60 0 2( / 95/ 1 * ((0 2 9 5= 2 199 ( (0 2 2.. 32* 2 ../ (0 59 4/= 9*( 5= 2 .(( (0 C(0 2 2 26 ..9 2( (.1 1 2(32 +2((0 2 /* 322 5 (3 2((60 20 2 .( 5/ .(0 0 2 99(1 6./0 0 2 5(2( @6/ @*6( 3( 32 (. 2 / (.( 5* (6 26 0 $24 * $(1 /

2 6=0 0 0 //= 2 ./9 *. 2 .0 2*92 2( 1(60 2 6.(= 2 (39 2 9(6 (0 53 2 .( 5/ .(0 0 2 .((0 32 ( 2 6./0 0 2 5(2( @6/ @*6(0 (2( 2 6./ /A* 59 6 5= 2 .(0 2 .. 2( 0 2 / ( 0 *(( >/0 0 2 5(2( @6/ @*6( (2( 52 26 (1(0 2*92 2(*92 2 9(6 // .. 32 ;B;0 0 / 32 < B?0 32(0 260 2 5(= @6/ @*6( .. .(( 0 5(2( *(( >/0 0 2 / 3 2(0 (2( ((= 2( 0 .(.9 6*20 0 2(*92 9(6 //0 (.

1/= 2 =( ;0 0 0 ( 5= 1 2( 32 60 C( 2 30 .2. 32( 1(*/(0 56 ./ ((0 (2( 2 .. 6(= (6. 89 .

< +2((0 / 56 6.(1 ( 2 *(0 2 :*/.(= 19( 2 .2. 9(6 //0 0 ( (5 1(*/( +2 = 689 2 ( (60 ( (6 2 *60 2 6( 0 2 9(6 // 6 5 :* (2( 2 =( ;0 0C( 0 32(0 2 9(6 //9 2 (.( 5* *(( 6*2 .(( 2( (2( 2 =( 0 322(0 32 / 2( / :* 2 9(6 //0 2 2 (0 0 / 32 2( / (( 2(0 2 2 6 2( (.1 (390 2 2 / ( 6 2(0 .

9 (6 2 1 2 1(0 0 32 2 9*( 2( *(( >/ ( @6/ @*6(0 2( 1 ( 3 2(0 *((9 2(0 322( 2 2 2 ( 1( ./9 56 ./0 C(0 322( 6( 0 2( 3 *6 9* 6. 2 .( 2 .( 5/ .(0 2(*92 2 :* 2 9(6 //0 68 9* 1*( /A*0 2 99(16./0 0 2 5(2( 0 @6/ @*6(0 2( (.1 2( 2 / (0 56 //9/= :/*1/= (1 5= 2 .( 5/ .(0 2 6 2 //9 (.( 5* ( ! 2 51 1*(0 2 *( 2 2 .2.

2 9(6 //0 322 ( 1(*/(0 0 2 /( */ ( 2 .( 5/ .(0 0 99(16./0 0 2 9 2 *6 689 2 ( 9(6 // +2((0 32 2 9(6 // (0 .. ':*( ;B;0 2( ( (/ 0 2 2 .( 5/ .

/ 2/ 2( 2 (32/ 4 (.( 5*0 0 322 3 *5A*/= /0 (2( 59 2 1 2 .. 9(60 2 /9 32 2 .( 5/ .(0 0 2 *6 ; /0 / ( 59 /A* 0 60 0 0 $*(( 0 5 32 2 3 2( 99(16./ *(( >/ B ! 32 /83 ':*( ?0 2 * 9*( @6/ @*6(0 .(( 32 2 .( 5/ .(0 2 4 (.( 5*0 *( 30 2*920 2( 2 .( 5/ .( 2 1 "2/0 2 2 51 2 0 *(( >/0 32 2 9 3 ':*( 0 32( 2 5(2( 0 @6/ @*6( .(( 2 4 (.( 5*0 2 10 (2( .

/= 69 2 *60 5= 2 /( */ ( 2 .(0 2 = 2(*92 ':*( 0 1 *69/=0 2 6 (39 2 9(6 ( / (.( 5* 2( 3 /A* 2 2( 2 9(6 2 4 (.( 5*0 20 = 2 ( 59 *6 0 9* 6. 2 .( 6(/= (6.0 2(*92 ':*( 0 @6/ @*6(0 0 *(( >/ (1(0 *(( >/ 2 2 6 (39 ':*( 0 2 =( ;0 (( = 9(10 2 2 2( 2 / ( 2 4 (.( 5*0 3 /A* 260 (2( 2 6 /0 2(*.0 2 3*/ 21 6 2( 2 9*(0 1 30 (2( 3*/ 21 6 .

( :*0 6(0 32 2 5(2( / .(( 32 26 2 4 (.

< +2 2 689 .( 2 6 (39 2 9(6 ':*( 2 =( ;0 5 / 32 2 5(2( 0 @6/ @*6( A*9 2 3 2 9(6 .*(2 (3 A* 2*.( $92 5= $*(( 0 2(*92 ':*( ?0 .8 /* 1/*6 5* 2 5(2( *(( >/ / 6.2//= A*9 2 *60 2 1 2 =( 0 2 (( = 9(1 32 (. 1 2 2( 2 / ( (0 59 1( /A* 26 +2((0 2 1( 0 =0 56 6.//= *5*60 0 ( 1/ 2 .*(.( 1( 0 .(.90 1(* 9 5= 2 .( 5/ .0 ( 5 (30 2 2 .( .

( /89 0 0 6 *0 0 2 (A*( 6/ +2 *(2( 0 .(6. .( 59 6 2 :* 9(6 // (0 2( :/*1/= 1*( 2 .( 5/ .(0 C(0 /9 32 2 5(2( 0 *(( >/0 6/= @6/ @*6(0 32 3 / 2/9 4 2( 2 (32/ (.( 5* (2( 32 2 *(( >/0 20 51*/= 66 .( 6 2 /. (.1/= (6 2 =( ;0 0 (6 2 =( 0 *. 51*/= 2 =( 32 2 ,! 6 5 /9 +2((0 2 ( .(( /= 5 ( (6 2 *(0 .//= 91 2 ( A*0 99(1 ( A* .=6 59 6 26 5= 2 5/ .

(0 2 2 ( ,! ( 2 6.9 .(:*//= 6./ 2 .(0 (2( 569 /9 ; +2((0 2( 6( 2 .( 5/ .

//3 +2 .( 5/ .( (( 5 6 .(= 5/0 *54 2 *(29 .(/ *(= 5 2 *6 / 20 2 2 ((9 ( (1(0 / *54 2 *(89 5( 2 199 ( (0 2 2 2// 6.( 32 .(* 1 ( 2// /* 2 .(* 30 0 2// * (( 2 .( 2 199 ( (0 32 2 .( / 2(*92 3( 0 59 (1 *. 26 +2 ( 6 5(1 ( /= ( 2 ./ 2 .( 5/ .0 0 2// 21 5(90 *. 2 6( 2 9 6//* ../ 0 =0 0 .

#"% " !2/2 D22( .89C( EC" D22( (.(5/ EC"