S.B.V.R. Prasad v. State Of Punjab





     

 !"#!$#%!%%

  

 

  


    !

"#$%

 

  


 


 

&  '"()*+,-  "()*+,

"

 

 #"
"()**.) 

    /"  $00   $ ,(0 (,00 

0  , 

1#  2"#  " (# ,(0    

 

0  , 3'434) )

) !

   " 5,, *,) !6 " 0  , !  5,, *,) !6  $" 5,, 0) ! 0  7  +

8  9"  - 

  ": #  "
 
" ;,0 #  " ((#  

 6  00",20,##" (2"

% /"  )  
 

"  0

   $"     " %,  " ,(1 (01 8 '""( *# 5 + < 3$ '$  (8 *%** 5 + < /" , )  
    ! "  0 "#$ %)   ; #") $"  " #,(.$ 5,"# ",(1'""(*#5+ < < ,0  "  "  ( " " ,(0  "  , "  0  , 3'434) )

) !

   " 5,, *,) !6 ) " 0  , !  5,, *,) !6  $" 5,, 0) !  " 00# " " 5,, 5, " , " "  8  9"  - 

 3,, 

4  " , " ,' #   " 0    +  " ,'  ,, 

(  , 
0  #10 = > $"," $ ( , 1 '""( *# 5 + < 3,,  4  ,,#  " ,' #) " $

# 

6 #( ,'# 

( " () (0 $ '   "  01)  $  " " (0   , (  " 5 , ,  " (0 $ ") (  /" ) "$ , , $ +  ,, 

  /" ((#   "  ,(0 $ "  

 6  $"," "  3 " " 4) 0# $" " " ,, $ ((  , 0  " 

,  , 39434) )

) !

   " 5,, *,) !6 " 0  , !3 43!4  *,0 !

< ,0  "   " "  "+    "   

 

 
 



&      !  
    ! + $"," , 

( $   "  $   " ,#

 "0
2"$1 5" #"  0  " ,(0 $0 "$ " "   , , ( 

, "  % 0)   %"1 " 0)  "  0 

,  ?01
0  " ,(1 8 '""( *# 5 + < 3,,  4 5   ( " "  , "  (  " ((    " ,(0  0  #" )



 " ,(0 5  "  ( " "  , "  , ,001 +  #"

  "   0 $"  "  ,#,001  " "   9( % 0 "    # ?01
0  ,,   ,(1 5 

"  ( "    " 

    ,,) " "  #"   , 01  ,,  , " "  " %,  "  ,(1  "  "#$ %  #"   , 01  ,,  , " "  " #,( .$ 5,"# 5   "  "  ,(0)  "   + " "  " $  $ ,"#   

" ,(1  2  $  0  " ,#  ,(1 () $" ,  " 201  " , ( ,

 , "  (  ,   " 5,, *,) !6   " " +(  "+  (  " ,(0   ,00    ,# # " " 

0,  " # "  0,   " #(  @A 0 (
 

5  

 !"#  $# %$ &  ' " %#% !( )* +#, &  '-   ./.01 
 
'

 #2 34/5  #(   ,

'

,"  "
    # 6#2+%  7 !! " %#% !( )* +#,-   ./08. 
  
'

 #2 1/  0 " #(  " , ,"  "
  9#$6 $ '  7 " %#% !( )* +#, # $ '-  
 

 

 



5   ( " ,  ,# # "      ", "
")+ 2"

<  ,0)  " " ") "  ( " " 

    " %,  ,,   ,(1  "#$ %  " #,(.$ 5,"#  ") 1 +  "  $ ) "1  0  0  " ,, 

  " ,(1 5  "  ( " " 

 

) # " %,)  + 00 5,"#  " ,(1  , ,"0 01"1"" (

/"
 " " 0 ,0  "   " " '

5
 

 

 

)  , ," 

"
$0" 00$#&
 

   

              

         !

   

  %#% !(
 !( :

  #+"  *'# # ./0/ 1 
 
'2 ;0. 

    "  ##    $ %&'($     )                 

       * ** * **  * * *



+ * *  * *,- .% ,.%&

  $       /  )    * 

** 

< : = => ?

.0 %.

,.%( *:=

( / " (0 

,) "      ! $   " ,  "#$ % 
    !  " ,# # """+ 1,"   $00#  " ,  "  ,)  $0  ,1     " 0+ +  " 0+ #(  " 

,

,   " 5,, *,) !6  , " 0$& 11 (( @  ,A @!

B#  %! 3  

  

        $         

   $    $  

              



$   $ 

  $ 

      

  

           *  4*         

5   

 

                

            6  

         

 

*



,! +      

5   %!$  

                 

              $             $   $*$*"* * *

* ** $*

  $ $ "  

 

      

  

        **  *   76   28 **  * *  $2*

!
 1         

   *

 * * 

9**

!*
 1$**  * ** $* *****  1* * 0  "  , $0 "$ "  " ,  ,(1 $"," " ,((  

,  " *,) +1 ) $")  " ( $" "  

, $ ,(() $ ,"#  )

"

 $  0  " ,(1)  " ,,    ,(1)  $00  " ,(1) "00  (   #01  

,  $0  0 0   , #



, " + " $"# 1"# ,   , 3

4)  ,   + " " 

, "  ,(( 1 " ,(1 $" " ,  ,+,  )     0  1 #0,  "   1 %,) #) ,1  " 

,  " ,(1 " ,"

%,) #) ,1  " 

, "00 0  (   #01 "

,"00 0 0 ,#

/" @A 0 (
  5  " ,  

 !"# $# %$ ,34""0&
/  + :-.

,.,%   " /

!

+ 0%00*;8*,.,.!



*/ ***<*





!

"* * =*<*;

>  

!

%, ? / 

      

 

#  0  />55%,.(,5,.%'

; < !    @ /   = < @  /$     ;  %, .- ,.,.

A** * $**  B*  * ) * * /  * + * #%#* * %& .( ,.%-$* * *  >  * + ,* 5* ?* C * /  *   $* A$ *?*?$* =* *

 *"  *# !

!$*%:$ %(* * ##$*    * * " * ,&* * *   * $ %&'(*

*  $* D* D!$*  *  

 * ?*  * 

***@*/ * * *

$* * * *

E  *$**) ** 

%'

 / 

         

  $  

 $    /    *  $**

* **  

%'

!

 

 

       

     $         

 $      

    % 

 5 /    , 

5  

)

  

   



 

     $

 "  /       =  

/       $ /   

" F <  $ ,.%( %:! "// ,:-$  

  =   /     "  G

" +/?* *  $*,.%&* %:!*"//*%&# %:

;   $  / $    >   $ 

   @ /      

          =     )    

* 

* * * ,* 

$ * * *  * * * % * 

* 5/ $ * **

 * **  **)  $* *    * * * ,* >  * 5* C * /  *   $ A$*  * ?* ?$*  =  / 

          "  ,0

0!

   "  ,.,  /  /                @ /  *

***

*+ ,* **  * **/ *** * * *$*

$* 

*    * * *) *  **   */ $*

$** *

 * *   

%( @     /

    $   

** *;** * * * * 

%& "  ##   

 B

      "  ## %!

 $        

           $         

   $   

$                 



$** $* *

* ** $* 

**     

  

                     $          

 %  

 5/ $ , 

 5    

     ,, .% ,.%#$   "* *> *E$*

 / $       

  

   /   ,( %, ,.%,              / $  * * * ) * * *  



 * * * * /      H  6  

      

  $   

$ 

  6      

  



**

              

    $  6               /       



$        

  $ , 

 5             

          %  

 5 / $ 



           



 /   )    $       $  /  



  

 $ 6        

     > E    

    

         , 

   

 ,, .% ,.%#

3

 



 6        )   

        $       =

        , 

 5   $     

         /         "  ##  

              / $

 /    

      

  

        ? $* *  *  

* * * * 

 *   $**

*

* * **  * * $*

* *  * *    * *  * * *      * @ * *  *  *   *  " *##* **$*** * *** * $  *  *  * * ,*

*  * ?

$* 

* ***  * * *"* $* *"  / $* * 

* *    *  * ,* 

* 5 *  * * * $*

* ** 

* * *$** * * ** ** * *) *   * **% *

*5*/ 

,% 

         

 /  * *

***/  $*** ** ** *  *  *  *  *  * * ,* 

* 5*   * *  ** **

*



I66 ,, 8 * *  *  *  * / *  *  *  

$* *  * * 

* + ,* 5* *  * 

 * * *  * ;* * * @* / *  %, .- ,.,.$* 

* * * @* / * *  =* <* @*  /* * />55%,.(,5,.%'* ;* <* !$*  *  

/  )  $ /   + #%#  %& .( ,.%-$    , >   5 C  /    $ A   ? ?$  =$   

 

  8  /

$   )  )   

 + ,      + F   

 + $                

         

 

  )          ? /       $         $  

* *  $** ** * 0  "  +  #( $0 "$ " 
(0 *0      $","  ( " ,# 

, 

) $"," $ 00$ 1 " @#"
 2 " .$ 5,"#  " , "  $ ( 2 ,,        " ,,) $" " 0 "  0) $ " ## %,  " ,(1  2 " 5 $  + "  # 

,   " *, ('  ,0 " 01  0  
(1  $00  "
(1 0) "00  (   #01  

,  "00  0 0   , #  0"#") " ## %,  +00 ,"#  " 

  " ,(1   ,  ,,(,  "  ,   $","

" "' 

.) $ , ,001 (   " ,"#  "  0 

,  ( " 201  " , ( , 1 "  ,(1    '#  , " 0+ +  0$)  $  + " " ,# # " , 00)  

## %, ") $ "#      , 
  $ ") 2" 2 , 00 ") "$+) "

!

,# # " ,(1 $  2" /"   0$  "  +  #( $0 01  "  , 0  " ( "00

0"  * , ,"  " ,  # 6#2+%  7 !!

 ,34""0&
  

         0(,  /  /   $ %&:# J/  /   !

 )  /   + %-  %:

% ,.%#  "  # !

! %:$ %($ ,&  ##    $ %&'( J B  !

    >

$ %&:% J >

%&:%B   !   

J"

 A = " /     ; B$  

 =    A$ 6  %! 

    %:

% ,.%# 6  ,!    

  ) 

  * *  *) ** 

,  

  

       

* * *    / $  $        $ " G<F!      ;

  /

   J B!

?   5   

      + %-  %:

% ,.%-  "  # !

!$ %:$ %($,& < ##     >

 ,:

-!

 >

$%&:%  5F = " G    



 + 0            $  

/  



    %:

% ,.%#

6  ,!       

    

          * ** */ ** **

 

               / $  $J B      

 $                  /       "  ##          /  

       

   $

     

 



       /       





    

 

  

    



      

)    

   

       

  

         /   *  * * *



*  *

* * *  *  $*  *   * * ** * *  *

* **

 *

**

** ** **

 * *

  * * * *%'**%(* **  *

***  *

 * ** * ***

*  **    * * *J *B*$ $ *  *  *

*   * * *  *    " * ## %!

            * * 

* ** *

**/ 

 %'  %(     6  %!  45 D%'

?      

  

  

   A = " /   $     

      $ A   G  " E   !$ "

*F *F *  *  * /* >    *  * * C * /  !$  *  *   *  *  $* " G<F!* F = "* G *  * @ * "* G 5  *  >    *         $ " G<F!$  )      





  ##  

$ %&'( 



 

%( ?    =

$  

 >= 

 >  +

  !



A = "

/   $   $ G  "

E   ! < K  "  >          



!        $ " G<F!$ F =*"*G   !**"

 *F * >    * * *C */  !$        $ 

    *  * * ( ;   $  

    5"      

 $           $     

           "  ##     

   

 

    )  "  ##         $ $    

% 

* ** */ *

&      

    $     

            5 

  =   @ B  "

 /    " +/?

!

    $  @ B  "

 / $        "  ##  $        

  

 @ B  "

 / $    45 D? 

        

)               

     

$     



              B 



              



              $   

 H      5  

 $  

   

                  



                 

?     

   

=             

 

          

              



   L

      

        $         

* * ** * ** *

%.

*  * *  * *  *  * * *     * 6 *%!$* * *

  * **   5* F =* "* G * *  $* *  

*** * **  **>    * * J *B

?

      6 /     F " <  

" = <  $ ,..0 #! >/> / ! (..      

*4 D?**    * * **  * * 

*   * * *   * *  * * 

* 

*  * 8 *  *   $* *  *  *

 * 

& * *  *  * *    * ?   * **

 * * **** *

* * *** **

* * *  *     *  * * * *    * **



** $*

* *   *  * *   *  * 

  ***  **   ** 

?*  *  *  *   *  * * )   ***   D* %, * * ** * 

  $* */ * *    * * *    *  * * *  *  *   * * * *   * *   *  *

*   *)  *$* $* 

 *  * * * *  *  * * * *  * *   * **/ 

%#   $* * * *

 */  *+ *%-* %:

% ,.%#* * "  *# !

!* %:$*%($,&* *##** * >

$* %&:%*  *  * J"*

*  * A =* " *    *   B* * *

 * * * %:

% ,.%#* 

* *   * / * *

 ) *   *  *   *  ) * **  * 0  "  + #( $0 "$ "  "  , 0) "  $  %,  " ,(1  2  $   7%,   0 :)  " 

 

 "    "  ,   " 9( 9,"" $     0   ?01
0)    % 0  "  , /" , ,"   ,# " + #(  " @A 0 (
   "
) "0 " " ( +(  " 

, " "  $ " %,  "  0    0 00 " (1 2(  " ) +, 0 01 ,0     "  "

0, $ 0,  " #(  " *B
  7! #

,  %# , #  # & # !%

' " %#% !( =*+#'#% & %

'-  

'

.//C1 
 
'

 #2 8//  $","  $ "0 " " (1  01   " ,(0  (' ,1 +(  " ,(0    (' " ,, +,01 0 0  01 $" "  ,1 +(  ()  ,, $0   " ,,    " (  ,  "  #( " 0  (  "

#(  " @A 0 *B
  %#% !(
 !( :

 " #+"

 *'# #-   ./0/1 
 
'

 #2 ;0.  $","  $  + " +1 %,        ,"#    " ,(1  " ,(0  2     "$ " $ 5,"#    " ,(1   0  " ,, 

" ,(1A   "   0  (" "  " ,  %, 

,)   00 " ( ,1     $" $ "    0  " ,, 

  " ,(1 "$$"(" 00 0 "(

*" , ,"  "
  " , 

9#$6 $ ' 7

,34""0&
 

          E   $        + '5 L   

 $ 

      ?            

 $

          

@* *



**

 * * *

 "           



  *** * **  >

 $      

 

       $           + ,%  .% .0 ,.%'

5%! 

    .% .0 ,.%'**) *) ** *   1* * 0  "  ,(0 $0 "$ " " 

    #"   , 01  " # " "  " ,  " ,,   ,(1   "#$

( %#" ,""#,(#$,"#  "   , , +(  "  ,(0  "$   "$ "  $  $ ,"#    " ,(1  $  0  " ,,  " ,(1A   1 (  " 1 0  01 $" ,  " 201  " , $"," $ ( , 1 ,,   ,(1 +)  "  ,)    ( " ,(0 0 "  % 0 $ "  $" $    "  0 C

,  ?01
0 /"  , "  (  "  #  " ,(0 $" " 0 

"  "+  #+  $00   #" )

  ,(0 5  0 " , , ,  " )   ,0 ( " +( (     " ) " "   % 0) # ?01
0 " 01    +$ 

,   " 5,, *,) !6   $ 0   #"

"   "   % 0 $" $ ,01 ,, $" " 201  ,""01 ,# 5")"    % 0) $" "  , ,001 (   0 

, 201,0  9#  +$ "  +  ,  ,,(,  " 0$ 0 $  "  +  #() ,  " ,# # "  $  $0      " , 
  ,,#01) " "   00$  " (# ,(0  " ((#      82") 2 "   +,-./0 121 !"3%!%%   *F  >""'#8 D8E >"" 0 D8E