High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11160/2024dismissed

Ram Narayan v. The Adviser To The Administrator, U.T., Chandigarh And Others

2024-07-01Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal8 pages

"#$%&'&

#$#($) "#$%&*&

!"# !" $%&&$ "' " ("

% +,

& -

,, +,

& -./ , )

&*'"(+' +( , $!"#-$ . (&

&/#*0$!"#-$.

&*'"(+'

$!"#-$ . ("

"' 1

'2"& 000

,,1& ( (". .003'

#0.) 23!34 35

5353#$ ($"

6 53)4 7* #8 59

#$535(53#$#8$"361: 6;3$<8# 3(6$) #86= 353$ $65( #8 >(693$<59 # "

"65 "

:6 "?;59 :#$"

$5 $#&9

3$!3"

=93)959 !33#$:

5353#$834 "?;59

5353#$ 9

3$ ($"

- )53#$ * #8 59 6 ;6$6 #(3$< #6 " )51 @* 6 A5 $"

" 5# 59

96$"3<6 9 6<63$559 # "

"65 "

B##&@*7 7 #& '@7C :6 " ?; #6 "1 96$"3<6 9#(3$<#6 "1 196$"3<6 96$"59

# "

"65 "$34644 < "5#?

3$53B65 "#$&& :6 "?;59 963 B6$6$"59 # "

"65 "&&* 8# 59 )6$) 44653#$ #8 59 :

B3 3& 1 &#& D1

64# 61 196$"3<6 96$"8( 59 8# 553$<63"

!3)53#$ $#53) "65 " && 6$" 643$< 59

B3 =3596)#$ >( $5364 85# 5# 59 35 3$ 86!#( #859 :

5353#$ ?;"

643$<59 6B 196"

$"3B3 "&E 5" - 0 . (

4 #" 0.

00""6 7$889 $ "= 443$<($35#&D1- )5# '1

64# 6#4#$;1 196$"3<6 9 " 3 00" 6B 96$"

6$< (4 "' 1

'2"&13#$ 00$ #"*!$00$!.."#"!'+00 $:- " )5#?

*1@@*$ ." .# .!

.+3 +' &!" 00$#!

$ 6;@1*$ ."

' " (

6B6 6;6$&13#$ 0 $. " '000 "-

"-4 0"'

#0 ;"# "#0" .00$ 3 #"3 -$"" 8$ $ 3-

$ 3 004 --00"& 2 -$ " ( 4' .."" (( $ .0" # 00'""# ;#0 $#""""<4 $=

9$ ("2"--00" 00&!"4'''#"$

6B 96$"

# 3<3$64 644#55

0" " . --00 .

0043.((0 & 9;=$3 - 3#3 "

-4$ >& .$#-(-"'

3""

#""""6 9$9 $ " '0003

""4#-". " &

4" .-" 3 $ " - ( "-@ " " $ (."((0 "+-=!. 11

'2"!-$ 8= . $ A 8= !-B$

0' " . --00 .

00$ 0 -4$ 3?3"$#"3 - ((0(."4 '0003 "

"&? '" -. '3

"4 !((00!

($"3 03 $ -""#4$$3 ..:" " $ (0" ((0(."4 " -4"

"#" &98"">&&& .$

4" # # .0"4 ( "+-=2. 8=!-3

"4 # 0 &

$ (& 5"- 0. ($3 .- "-

""4 C# 2- 0 < 002- . 6B #5 4,5"& !& $3#$ 35# ;196$"3<6 91@D 3!34

*@$"9

6-3$<9!& 96$"3<6 9"B$&1 3!34 @*$

(--00.00 ' ".

0"4 0 &!"$ 00 004'"# (( # 00'" #0 ;"# & ? '" ( ""300'#00

- #0 "$ .$ ".--00.00"00

@ " 4 "$"

4 " (& # "0"- 0. ("(

" -"

-""0$#"0.00""6 7$889 $ "300' &7 $ +- 9$ 0 0$ %$ "' 3

00" ";

' & .00$ (

- 0"04

". "0( ( &< $ 00- 0"

40 "300' -

"" 0 3 ( ((#0. 2"&? " ( $. " '0 00-

"0' -0"" "0 " $ 3 #"3 3-

-""#49$9)

-563 )6 96?

$)#$5 ()5 "#$#!57 (?43) 46$"6$"56F $5#584## 6$"8 #B584## 56F $5#$"

84## 8 #B

64)#$; 96 ?

$ : #!3"

" 65 5 84## 6?#!

#!5&7 (?43)46$"&

&&76591 ##B96?

$)#$5 ()5 "65$"84## A5 6 4## & 3!

&7659 96 ?

$ )#$5 ()5 " 6?#!

#!5&7 (?43)46$"65$"84## &

&& ##8: #G )53#$96?

$: #!3"

"6?#!

#!5&7 (?43)46$"& !3

$ #;53 #"

4 -)9##4 3 ($$3$< 3$ 59

7 $35&E !"$ "-"0$ -" (("(( 00.0"# #0 ;"# $ 2"3 - "

--0 00& .$ 6B96$"

# 3<3$64644#55

.0" ((0 & 9;=$3 - 3 "

"$#"""" -4$ &+'.-0$( "

0. ((0$ "- (

00 ".--00

-".0&!"$." (--00$ " '0 00.0"#- ( $ 3 #"3 #--

"+-9 . 8=!-& .$ ".#-"" 6 9$9$3 (

""(

3 2"#4"

- 0( -0(

. ( & #= 1 96!3$< 63" 59651 59 >( 53#$ =93)9 6(B

3<$383)6$) 3% 6 5# =965 4#)( 6$" 3<951 5354 # 3$5

5 "# 59

5353#$ 96!

3$59 "

B3 ":

B3 H "-"4#$ - ( )5#?

*1@@*$ " '000 ." .# . !

, / & !" 00$ #" *!$ 00$ !.."# " !' +00$ "" 6; @1 *$ !

, / ( ( # ." ' ; (

6B 6 6;6$& 13#$ ' (0-"-" )#$)4(3!

4;(# :- "#- . "- &+'.-0$ "!

" ( (-"'

&-""0$ ( "#.0"

D -

' "." .,'.-40(

( $3 - 3

@ 03 "3&2 $. 4 ,3 ($ -(. :463$5 # " #" 3 - "

3 ("43 "3$ ((""3 (&? -0." . ""!

30 " (

" ".-$.$ 3 4 (-# 3 & < $ # -- - (00" (3 "3

#4:(0" & +'.-0$ ' " (.$.-"3 ".

--00.00$!

#0""&!". $3 3 " (

"&D

$#.

" 3 ;

:- "#-. "- 3?3"$3 - ."4 . -0. ($ 0034 # ( 4. . @ (0"'

0 (# . 03 3 "' $0 "# " (& 4'

- -0 (- . ) 00.# . " '0 00 3 --00"

? (6 ;1*& "- $(

3 ( -0 #-@ "' ; " $3:- "

("-

6;@1*&

$#.

" !

$ "' $0 ( $ ( --00.00$ (

" .400& !04$. "'. ( '""$(

"4 # 0 $ (( "" "# .

00$ 4 3 0 .' ' "..-0

. 0 .

00$3." -0

$ '#-- - $3 0"0 # "- #4'

) 2& #(9644$#5 441645 $65 # 5 6$8 6$;#8 ;#( 3<95 # 3$5

5 3$ 59 63" : #:

5; # #59 =3 :6 5=35959 :# 3#$#859 =9#4 # 6$;:6 5#859 63": #:

5;5344;#(?

)#B #=$

# 8# 6:

3#"#8;

6 8 #B59 "65 #86)5(64 :# 3#$=93)9 3465 (?G )55#59 ($"

$53#$ " A) :53#$& 6

, 8# 6:

3#"$#5 A)

"3$<';

6 656 53B &

= ?

9 3<951 5354 6$" 3$5

5 )6$ ?

B# 5<6< " 3$ 86!#( #8 59 #!

$B $51 ,38

$( 6$) # :# 653#$# 6$;-)9 "(4 "6$F# 6$;# :# 65 6$F3$# "

5# 63 4#6$8# 59

:6;B $5#8: 3) #8?(44(:9#( 5#59 #6 "&

#!3"

" 5965 59 #6 " 9644 96!

83 5 6$"

:6 6B#($5)96 < #$59 63": #:

5;8# 59 ($:63"

:# 53#$#8:( )96 : 3) 6$"#59 "( #(556$"3$< 6<63$5;#(13$)4("3$<:

$645;1386$;&

#!3"

"8( 59 5965()94 # B# 5<6< 5) )6$#$4;?

) "=35959 : 3# :

B33#$#859

#6 "I 6$" #6 " =344 ?

)#B:

$5 5# 3B:# 6$;

)#$"353#$=934 < 6$53$<()9:

B33#$& 3

" #$!%!" & " ! &

%E !'$3( ' "-" ($ 3$" ( 004'

4D--0

3?3"$ "

'000- 0"0 ' ; " .# . ("-

( & ?- (-

. 4#$"3# "-

""4 ' " ( )%"* # + &, 3 0" #4'

& ?" " & # (."4 (3

" 4-, (4;'1*$3 ( ( 4 .0"0.= : 34D1&

.. .'

:(0" "" "0& .$ 3,. (

,- " 4#$ 0" #40--0

- 0"4 - ") ( " 0 4.. 4 0 0-,

4." & C

"& ($ 6443 ("< &*&

6G6$7/-96 B6 .3F 6B<<6 =64

("<

(,'; ") EF+;

(40) EF+;