← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12264/2022allowed

Sanjay Gauttam v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-07-26Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil14 pages

      

 



!"#

"$""

" "% "

% % %

 &'

($)   *"!"$

"

"  

+ * * *"

"$""

"%

 *

* % * "%

",

-----  

+ * * "$""

*"

* (    **  "% "- ----- * % *  " .#(

- *

*"%

% (-  

      



 "

# $ % &  

 % '

(  

  

))*

 + 

%, % - .

 $ ( "

'

'

 +   /



&  (0    1



 

 %  2,# + #  

 1

 



 1 )

 

))*

 *"%

% () 6  ##   ,    



   &

## 7,  ( /  ( 

 

8



.

  



& 0 # 



( 

    ) 8 ',   , , (

 ,  9

 0 0&

/  ,   7, & #,&

  ##  & !

(& (

( & # (& (  ((.

   & : !

& 

# 1

;

<  

*

< &.

=, 

& ((& ( / ,  . ,  

/  ,   

& ##    !

,(.

(& (

7, (    & : !

.

& / .  = 

 

 ( ,(.

,

.

> $  

   ) <

< =, )!

 &

   #  ',&#  

4 ?

=, 

/((

/  # (

.

##

-+9>   1

*4 <

 (  !

   ( (;# (    & : !

 ,

# 0 /

 #  (  (    :+ &.

/ , * # 0

/((

#  (  (    % (

 &.

/

( , * # 0

8  , ( # = 

   # 1

;

<  

*

< =,  ! &    & : !

/

 -+99>

,  /

 / # % (  &. /  +  &.

 $  &.

 / # :+  &.

8  ( 7, ( 

   , 

,

 

                ! "   # $ %  !

&' (

  # ) ?

8 !

& (& (    & : !

( #

8 !

,(  =     ) <

< =, )!

,

.

> $  

 / . 

      &

 

>

+ ,

  )

?

 ,&

,

9 ,

     &

=  # 

. 

* #

 

,&

     '

.

 ;, ( , 0& 8 !

/ ,

#   

=,  !  ,,   / 

   / = #  ( 

*

@

<

## (  ,(  / = #  /  (   

=, 4  / (( ,#   / &, 8,& ,(  

<

 / , ,.



 ,#    & : !



( 

((   / 7,  (( ,.

# ( #

 <

 /   ##

?

9 #(  

    , # 

(  #    #

.

&& ,(( #  & &  7, ( 

=

,( 

((  .

,#  /   ##

 .

 /  (   

.



=, *

8 

  ,#  

/ , ,(.

7, (

(& (    & : !

#  ,#    .

/ ,   ,  

8 ## (   ( ,( 

?

=, <!

    & : ! / #   /  &, 

 /  / (      ( ,( (  (    % (;:+ &.

, * # 0 / + '

.

% , # ,

# 0   ( ,  / ??

# 0  / = # 

?

# 0 + :# 

8, & , # # 0  (  (     ( (    & : !

9  /  #  

  ##

.

, #&

   

< ?

=, 

7,  (

##     & : !

& &  #  ( 

 (    % (;:+  &.

8  #  ((.

  (

,.

 ## 

< ?

= #  7,

# # 

((.

    (& (  

 ,   & = 

  ,

.

> $  

 & =  (     & : !

-  



  (  ,( + '

.

% , #

 "

# $ % & (  ,( 0, 

&,  

 & 7, =

  

# =, 

8 = 

/ % ,     

,  ,

 

  , 

'  &,     &  ( =     & : !

8 ,   (& *  

 (   1

*4 

< (

   

    



       ! "#$%"$&&

.

 ,



 (     & : !

= 

 &    ,

8   7, (.

 , &,( ,

.

 ,      '

 ,

=,   $ ( "

'

'

 +  



.



&  (0  

 ( $  ( >% - .

&, 

 # 7, =  / .   

 ( 

(      & : !

=    

, 



7, =



# 1 ;

<

, ,(   ( / (

.

 ,     '

,

* 1 

&,#

 

.

 

< -  (  ,(   

8 (.

7, /  



.

 ,    

 /  & =     ,

 (& (    & : !



& (& (

  .

 7,   =  / .      & : !

8 ,   (& *  

 (

.

 ,     '

,

B  (    ',&#     '

  , 

,

+,

  

&          -   " !  !    & !  

       



( 

  !

  

      -     

     & .

'&/#       001#

 !!.     

   2      &  %        "    3

  

  &           -  

/

 ( 

 

 001*04

 ! 



!(  !  ,   !       -

(     

  3 !  

     (   

 

 5  6"   &    -!   

 &     -      

  

  ,    !      & !                    '

  !  3    &((#)%*+ %,$  

     -       .

      /               

  

  (   

     &!    '   (       



 ,# 5&      

  

      

  &!' (  



    

 # 5&       

&   !

    '  (   



 

    & 

&      !      &((0)1*2+3$1 

   4-      .

  5  2 6     7  8/9:-); *   

7* +  ,  "  

           !

  - 

     &   ! !  &     3

&    

   "       !    !      ,  

        -  

    ( 88'  (.*3  . '& 9   .  



  !

  ! !   

          

   

" :   &       !  

&

  !3     '   (           

       & !

 &    !.

'& #  3     

   !       

 !     

 &' ;    ' (  



     

    

 

          .           

:   &

%  ! & !

  & 

     $   



  ) 3   5  <

=# 5&        &   &

# 5&     ! (0

&'123 +3- *&&1 !667

,3'682 21942&1 3 

 *  ,  &  !# 5&        0



7* +0  3    "   

    &      

        

     &!    

 

    3



!!

    &!  &  &  !  

!  

   &   

        

   

       :     .

:!! !          

   ! &  

&

    

&!       % !&

    



& &    &  &   &!!

 !   ! ) 3 !&    & 

      -      

     " ! 

&



( !

& .     & 

   > 

 !   -  001 

 

  

      

 !

!     

   & ! 

    (              

 !       & 



!

( &    !

   &   - & %   & ! !"  3         & !  !          -  " !

  !   

! " !

 !%         & &' 3 

!

                  ?

   '

 !    &((#)1* 5%"0,

  # 5&   ?

    !             

  !   !   !     !  3 !  $   $. 

 

   3 !  $. 

 !!    

& 

  ,# 5& ?

 

&       !  !   !      ,      &     

7* + @3 ! &   &

  !!  ! & *  >, 884 !"   3 !  3  &  & 

  " !

 A!    !3 ) ,

 

     -    " " !   !   ! & &' 3

   !!  !    @ 004      "   ! 

 &   - 

B00@< "

.*

B=! !!  ! ! &     "  ,                 & !  !     " ! 

 

   

        1 0001   

 & 

 "   ! !  

 

      !  

!!  @ 004 > 

! 

 & 

 &  



    



 

3 



 & !!  

 3 !  $. 

  & ! !        . 

$       

     &&  

          *&   ! 

&   

 

&     3     

 * // &8&01 3 %400:

'' +3- '826)

# 5&   





7* +4,   

  

!

 !

   



 &  !   !" !



          

  &       !   &

  "

            ,    &   "    3 !

  &  ! &  !" ,

    &   &   &  

    



!   %   

    !& !!     

 ! &

 , 

           !  !  !  

 !



 !   !% 

       !  & !  !      

 ! !  &  "  !

&

 !! 

 & 

       

  !  

  >   !  !    

 

&

 !!    



 ' !  ) 3             &      !  &   

 !  

      -   !

     

     

!

" 3 

  !

          !        " C   - 

   

  !        - -00@  < "

  C*-$ =

!#  !!  

              !   !

"    -  % !

            

  !       !

&    ,      "  !    ! 

   

 

7*+D7*E             &  $ 

 & 3!      

! ! &  !     

  

  !! 

  

    . 

 !!

   

! !!  3 !

     

&         $*        ! #  !!   

 . %

) 3       -

   ! 

B00@! .   

  !

        ,



 ! 

 &

!

 !  > 

     !

           !    

&   !    .       

 !  

 !   -     !3 C   -

 !     !

&

 !

  !!    

        



                  

   !         !     *&    !       

 &!  

 

     &      &              !   &  !# 5&     !

 ! & , !   &  &! 

!!  !' !  !   -3

 & 

  &  &!    !      

  

    

 $  !   -   

!

 3       !             



    ) 9     , =  

.

 $   / 

  &

 

 (   ( /

#   /  

 & 7, =    & : !

'    ,  &,   & 7, =  #( 

8 

 ,((.

(& (    & : !

## ,(   '   ,

  9 /  &&  

 / 





((/

##      (& (    & : !

    , #

"##  ,    

 / (& (

, # # 0  (  (      & ##  #

#     & : !

 -+99>

9  , (   +.

  /,(

= (.



  / # (  

.

##

) @

&(.

 .

  

(   ( 

  

*"%

% (

%

&'

($)  



  0&;

   C ;

1

 

( C ;

1