High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1597/2011disposed of

Dharamvir v. State Of Haryana

2019-07-24Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill7 pages

"#$%% &'() ' %%*%%

+ '!,! -

'." *%%

!/ "0

"# 1'%!&)

'2&'340)

'% 1!%" !&

!&5' 400 "64'."%

&66 "7 "& /'

"/ " ! 8,07( 0 0 %% /!!

0 3. & 6 '"

0 00 "6 - !!

"! ,07 4 - /4 5& 3. 5& 6 0 !( !! "7 & // 6 0 3. '4& 8,07(

""0

0 0 9:%% /!!

0 3. & 6 '"

0 -,3 ) !

"6 ,0 617 !' 4",'4&!3

",/& 60% & ' 5! '

(( "7 &

,"0 '- "!4::4::;4:$%!/ /'

, "4 %%4 & /'. & 0 0 3. - )'4 /'

" "

' &'

' !"04 65.

04 - /4 ( <"

5 3 , " 0

3,! 2&,3', '

0 !

0 !"

( - <&/,'4 " 5& & (". /!!

"7 '! 5 0 &) !,! "

0 "8,'

!%-

/!!

"7 '!5 0( " 77'56 !/ 6 "0 !

5 " ' & !/ 6% "

! 0 "

'( "4 & /'. '

=> 77'56 !/ 645& '!&0/'

0& 1?

"8,'

04 "6,0 "7 "8,'

8 !&% '0 "76.4!

"8,'

8 !&=@& 3 >5!'

03.& % ! " & ! ! " & & &0 ",'

' & ! / "6 '<%",'& 3 '0 03,!3 ' "7

7 !' " % $A

"7 &"%& 5 3 , 9: /!!

"7 '! ! "7 " & 3,!% & 3,! 0' ) ' 5! 0' ) "7 & ! 0 3,! " '!& "0 "

" (""

' "0 5& " & 3,! & 0 "

' 3' << 6" 5& & 5! !6 7&6. & 0

- <&/,'4 & 0' ) ,60 "

6 & 3,! "0 !,< 7 "! &

( '

"0 & " 7 ,'"

0 ,'6 % 1". /!!

"7 '! !,! "

0 "8,'

!4 ,

5& ( 5 "! &0

@/ '

0& !/ !

% "& 3! !

! 0!

8 !&4 "& !!

5!'

7 ! 0% " & 3! !

) 0 6 04 !

0 /'

6 '"

0 ' 6 ,' & " ,"

'!& "0 " 0' ) "7

'4 5 "!4 "( 6.4 '/&

6- "7&"02' !&"&0 @/ '

0 '&) "7!,! "

"8,'

! " & 0 "%

! ( ( '

0 B:'% -%-% & 76% & !"0

0 ' & & 0 " " C, ! "

< /6 0, 3'

< "7

3 6 = >

3,!4 0 0 "

"0 ". ) ,' 5 & & ' 6 ,'4 ! & ! 0 /6 5! "

' 0 3. ". ) 0 "& !'

7'0% "!

C, "6.4) 0 8,07( "9 0 0 9:%%4 & ' 5! 0 ,"0 - "!4::4::;4:$ "0!

,"0

=:>

'A( "&! &,"0 '- "!"0:: "0

' &,"0 '- "!::;"0:$ % 77'

8,07( " "0 ' /!!

0 3. & '"

0' 6 ,'4& '/'

0"// 63

- !!

"! ,'% '4) 0 8,07( "0 0%%/!!

3. & 6 '"

0 00 "6 - !!

"! ,07 4 - /4 & // 6 5!0 !( !!

04& 3.

'( "7& 8,07( ""0 '/!!

3.& 6 '"

0' 6 ,'% - 66 77'

04 & ' &! /'

0 & /'

) !

"/ "% &) & '06 '"

,"!

/' !"05 & '!! !"

4&) 7 &'

,7&& '

% "& "!" !

3! !

) 0

'04 !

0/'

'0& " ,"

'!&"0 " 0' ) "7

0/ '4 5 / "!4 "( 6.4 '/&

6 - "7& "0 2' !&"4 &0 6 ! & ' 6 ) !% ! 0 !4 (". /!!

"7 '! &0 !,! "

0 "8,'

! " & 0 "% / ',!6

' 6 ,' '

'0 !& 5! & & ,!

0/ ' &0 < " /6 & & 0 " " C, ! "

</6 0, 3'

< "7

3 6=>

3,!4 3, !,& /6 5! "

!,// 0 3. ". ) 0 /' ,6'6. 5& " & ! ( ".

B '

!&4 5& &0 &" 66. @( "

0& 0 "63,!40 0"

( "". !,& %& ! 05 "

!!5!'

!! @( "

03.& ,"!

043,"

'".!,77 ! "5!/, & ("

=$> 5! & !< 0 ". C, ! " " & ! '

7'0% " ) 5

4 0 "

"0 ". / " 66 76 . ' / ') '! . " &

"0 "7!'

03.& ,'!3 5% 4&

'!'

03.& ,'!3 54 !,/& 60% '45& 6 ( "7 /'43."

54 '&!,"0 $( "&!"0A0.! ,

& ! 6!,3!" )

'%< "7 " "! 0 ' & & " & ! !

5! '

7 ! " %% "0 &

&& '&!3

"7& 7 ".

' 6

6!.

'!4 "(. / "

"4"

,6/,'/ 5 ,603 ') 3.!

"0 "7& '3 & "0& 3'! 7 "4 ,"0 ( " "7 !

% & "0!

8,! 5 ,60 3 !, 36. 4 !,3!" ) (/ 0,/ ' ! 6'

0.,"0 3.& (% & "D36 -,/'

,' " -

,"83 +!% -,'3&<!& 4=> =' ( "6>$45& 6 "7! 0

7& ,'4 & 3. '

0, "7 & 0 ,/ " & ,!

0 % % .

' 0 6'

0. ,"0 3. & ( % % $4 0.!4 5'0 0 &

! @ "&! ,!

!/ "0 " & "% 5! & 60 ! ,"0 '# E% " & "!" !

'!& "0 " 0' ) "7 &! 3

!36 !& 0% & ! ,' &! 3

"!"6. "

"7 & "'

" ",(3

0 0 "!"0&!6!

0& 5 ) & 6 0' ) '! &) 3

" 66. '!& "0

=> "%!

(! ,!0' ) "7 "0',"< "! " '!& "0 "

" (""

' 0' ) "7 5 & .

,& ,60) ",'

,! "&,! !(! '

',6 '"

0 ! /6 "

65&!

!7 % & /'

7 " !!4!5 4&) 6 !66 !/

' 65% (" 5 & & ( "! &!4 " !! 3 6 .4 7'0, 0 & (!

&'3 ,' & 0 & & " !/ ( & !,3!" ) 3. /.(

"! "% ' & 65 "

,'& (/6 "!& 65!& ,60 '7

36 ) ,!

& "!,& 0 "!/'

,! 6 ) !'

6 ! ) (!5& !,') ) '

' //6

' 6

5& &4 " 5.4 5 &" 0 &% -,& / "7

"! ! 0"7 ,! /& "" '6.!

.% ,"77 ""

3 /6 / 0 "66 ',(!"

!%?

(/ ,"

,! !!5 '&6 ) "7

'! ! ' & "0 & 6,@,'

,!6. '( "6%

!! !.4 & /' " /6

" "7 '

7" F ! &

) ( !,'

! 3, & '

"! 5& 0 ''

!" (/ ' ) "

!! .0 "0 "7 ,/ !

%" ,' / "

"4 ! 5& 5 '

"!' "

!.&& 7& ,' &! 3

" !5.

0 5. 3. & /!!

'. " //6. "7 & /' " /6 & /.(

"! " !

$ 0.!% ! 3!

6, 6. " & 6(

=A> ( !/6 0 !.(/&.% !4 " 5. ( < '.

8,! % ,!

8,! !G& '

5" "776 '.G4G& 7"( !'

!!G"0GC,

) ', G! &0! 0%-,&' ( 36 7&!"

"6.& 6 )

) (! 3,

(". '! '

,"0 & (% ,6 ( 6.!& '!& &

/,36 "8,0 6 !.! (% " ,' ) 54 &

' ! 0 3. & ' 6 17 !' 5& & &! 3

'( 0 3. & // 66 ,' !& ,603 ! @( "&!%H 0( 06.4& '&!6'

0.,"0 $( "&! "0 A 0.!

,6 !

6 !

' (/ 0,/ "& (%!/ ' ! !

=!,/'>4 ' ! '

C, '

0 ,"0 ! @ ( "&!

% '4 < "7 " "! 0 ' " & & ! !& 66

"6. ( "& $ 0.! " & ! !

4 " (. / "

"4 "

,6 /,'/ 5 663 ') 03.!

"0 "7& '3 & "0& 3'!

7 " ,"0 ( 7 ' !

( "& "0 $ 0.!!

! (< 6,"0 !! @( "&! " '(!

! !

=!,/'>% & ' & /'

!!5 ,60/'

3 ,(3 4& 3.,! "7 ,""

!!'. 3,'0

/,36

@& C, ! 6!

&'!!( " '%&

"! 0 ' "7& !& 66

( "& $ 0.! 3 "7 ( 7 4 & 6'

0. ,"0 3.& '= % %$( "&!A0.!>4 !'

3 ! @( "&!%

=> ") 5

3 45& 6 ,/& 60 "7&

',"0 '- "! 4::4::;4:$ 4& !,3!" ) (/ 0,/ ' !'

0.,"0 3.& (%& ' !0 '

! &

!%49 5 & & &

,0 6 17 !' '"

05 & "/

( "& (& 0

& ! '% & 0 ! 04 !&663 / 0! "! " 6 76& '!

0% ! (0 6 ' & " &

6,'

0 ! & ( ,"4& '

) !

"/ "!&66!"00 !( !!

) !

" !0 !/

"& 3 '(!% "

# $ $%% 0! B& '-/ < "79

0# !9 B&

'36 # !9