Kashmir Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab






    


      

    

   

     

     


 

   
  



 !!"#$!% 

&'

!( "

#$% "

   !

)"$!%*$ +& 

",--'$%

"

 *#"' ....



 

 



!

"
 $% 

!

-  "

 !

0

 "

)
1
 1$$--2"

- *#"'

 # ' #    -   

 --2 $  $  "

 - *# "'$

   # $& -'  2 -2 

%!

!!&   !

/"

 +&

--) 
##4 5

) - 6%$15"

   

7%168"

-  -' 

""

'&   2 

"

- #


&   

 /"

 - 
--   $" )"    #

     0   "

5

6$ $  -  "

& 2 

"

- /"

2"

"

 $ 
-- #( -' &

$  #"

'  )"

-  



 "

#  & 
  

    /"

$  2 "  "

"

  "

"

-  "- $ "

 "

-     -  )  

    "

  -   /"

 '

 #

"- $9$' #

"- $

-  
   !"

 "

 "'   $  2  )

-'

#

&-  

--'$    &  -   "  "

 2

- "

-' 

 
 








 

 

   ))

  "

# *# "'$       - ): ; 0& 
##

/"

 -    /"

% --   

 $# -

$""



- $"  2   -  )  "

  - $        

  -  $9$'# "("

*#"' $ "

-

& 2$"

- $2

-'$    -  $9$2 

) -

 $

$

"- # )

 "

--)



'&'$"

-   

$2  - - #"

-' 

  
##

- 2"

#(

$  -5

6$"-   -

&


$  &'"

 
;;  $  10$   -   < 

               < 2"

   



- "--  2       "

 "

2 "

"

 2&'"

= $

> 

)+

$ $/"

?  +&@- 5
   A)#  6%$;5"

    7% ;6$2"

&' )'

"

  )

" ) - 
 !"

$'

"


# % '$

#     & # 6     &  "

#$  &'  "

 "

   "

   )"

#$"

- 2"

"& 

) $ *#"' /"

2  - &'!4 5
-  :  6  "



--' "--   &  "

 @<&-

% >
   ))

#"

 2  - : ; 0$$& #  ) $"



 0 /" )"$"

-

 2&'"

% --

 B "

#( )5 6   -  "

- $9$B  #( )5 6   -   "

$            

 '

 $    "

'  & #  2 --  

$         

-    "

 '   

   

 

  1 @2 $"

 - 

-"

 $"

2

  


 $"

$2"

'&   "

- - 

"



#"



#      /"

$"

 "


B

2 &  !

 56"

%;$& 2 &  -'

&

) !

"

%1

 

- #(

&#

"

#$ + )# "

 

 -  <  



        !   "

$%    <2"

"

-        : ;   2  

) $  2"

   #-  & #



%

 $ "

% ;$"

 B

 -  ; 

-"

"



&# $"  -

$$& )+ )# -

 

"

"$& '

"

+ )# "

$"

    $ 1"

+ )# 5

6$2"

  > "

 $    +    & #

  $  $  "


#   % '

> 

)+

"

%;$"



&- ) $ #

B

 -   )"

- $"

'

 $

--' 

"-  -'

)  

 $9$

"-

) 

   ! "      "   

 "   #     "

  !   #

  

%&

"    $ 

  "    $    !""" "  $  $ !$   $    $      " "

#  "  

   $ ' $

" ""   "   $    $ !$  

   $    ! $$ #        !

&
 #  $ (# &

  )$  &

 $      " "



# $  "  "     "

# 

 C  $)  # &'"


# % '

  "

 %    ;  2"

  & 

-'  &   $    2   +

-#  $ B

 -

- "



) -2 --'

)     %

"$2 ""

)

-

2-

$&'"

# % '$"

    "

 >-

"

-$$& )  $

-

# 5 6$2"

" "

@<&- % >
 $"



 # 2    /" 

2"



"  "

6$2"

  > "

 $&

2"

@<&-

% >
  + )# 5

6$" #  > - -2$"2"

'+ )# 

B

" )"

 $$ ! 

##  " "

 "

 + )#  

  "

$ "

# ) 

 -$ $

)#"

     /"

$"

&# ""

 $

#  &-

$ 

& )-

)#  -

-

$"

  -'



- "



 $$-  )("  #& $

-"



2  $&

&

) *$

"

) 2"

"

-   + ,- "      "# .*

'
/0' )   # 1 #$  !

      & 2  

"     /0&    !$  $   "  $ "  #    

 /0' )   #  1 "$ 

) 34" & 2  

 "

    5 /!0- 1 #$  ) 34" &  2 "    $ !   !              

     $  '

"   

$ $    #$ $

  &  1 #$  ) 77"

72     "   " #  "  /!0 " $  $!$ "  #   $    )   34  "    &   2        ##          "      88  8     8         

1$       $    )   34  "  & 2    #  $ (# &

  (9)$ &

 $  *   $    6   "

$$  #   "   /!0 " $ ) 34" & 2

  # $  "  (9 )$  &

         #       & 

1 #$  ) 77" 7

72 ) 7:*;

 $      # #  

  #  

   #     "

     $ !"

7

72  $ !

(
/!0 " !   $    &  ""  (# &

 $!$   $$"  (9)$ &

   $    &    ! # $ 2

44 7:

" &  "  "  " 

"   $$ #   " $  #

$    6   "

"#$   ) 77" 7

72  &  "



#  $     8


 8

&!&

<

 

 
 ' 

  /" )""



- )"

$

&# ""


# % '$ > 

)+

"

%;$ -( "

 +

-# #( 

$ -

#     -   &  /"

$  " )"  "

 )

 "  "

 -

# $

"

-

 ) $ ) 2    @2 $"

&#

> -'2 ($$

             )  "

 &  ) $ 

-'

)  #$" 2 2" "

# % ' $$ 2  -'""


;;  $    &   &  "


 $  &'  "

 *# "'  $" " )"      $

 

+ )# #  "

!

  &'"

 $10$ 
;;  $

  

( ) $   2"

      )    "

    2  &'  "

 @<&- % > 
 $   $

-$" "



 $"

@<&- % >
 2  #"

 $ $# &'"

/"

$

)
" & - $"&""

 2 -- @<&- % >
 $" 

## -' "

2  "

!4"

"#

  (

  -      #     "

 # $    &  -   &  "

#

--'$  2"

  2   "

 #&     -

 0    "

& > # $ 

 + )# 5

6$"

-



2

# # "

$9$2 #

## -'" )"

( ) /"

-

# B

)$$-

 $$ # &- &

)"-- $ 

    $ 

 "

 

   "

 +

    "

 ! ' % '

 $2 # &'"

$$2"- &

  &-     "

#$  "

   "

) $  2"

      -"

#$&  &'"

$10$$-    -"

 &'"

@<&- % >
 $2"

)!45
-:  6%  ---'$  " 1$"

'





&      )) "

2 )5 6

-# $"

 "

$& 
--  $

--'

2"







-"

  

-

# 

# &

$2"

 --' 

-

-

"

2 ""



2    

- )"

$" '

# 

&#

&

$"

 "

- $

 $




 $'



"-

 - 
 !"

"

"

"

--) 

'&'/"

2 - 2 &

  "

"' $'  '


*


 2

& # @2 $"

) 

-  + 

 

 
 ' 

   + ) $#"

 #"  --'-  2  & # $ $  2  &

 B "

 - &'"

 

$"

 "

"' $2 - -'# $ 

    #    "

 - $  2  # $  "

   &-'

  -2  $- -' 

-2 --'2 - $9$  - $&

)

 "

"'/"

    # $#

$2 - )

--'#

-&( #  2 ""

 $$#'- "

--  - $'

-- )2 -2 --"- "

 -  '

  "

 &

)  &-' 

     "

 &     "

 "'$ $      '        &

)  #   8  

"  - # #

2 # $$

-' 2 $ "2 -#"

-2 - -

) -2  $"

-"- 2 "- ) -  "

-

-2 2 -& # -   -2 -

$92"

 # "

- $ # &'"

 $ - "-  >

"

-2 - - "

-2  $"

2



 -  )

  $ -2 --

 -  "

- "

"

--) 

'&'$$ -- 2 --

)  '


 8 - 

"

$- >

"

-2 -"- "

 -   $

+

"



 "

"

--) 

'&'$

  

$   "



)



 


 '



" '

2 -& # &-   $" 

)    -$$"

      $

"-5 6$"

-2 "-

-2 - )"$ - 

@2 $"

 #2 

-  

"

&

 5

6 ) /"

-
 !"

2 # &- &

)   '

 ?#" --'- 2"

   D= 

  "

 -  $       -

 

   "

 -  $- "

'- #'-2 - -

) # -  0 

-"

$" '

)

" 

"

+ )# 5

6$ > - )" 

-

 

& " )" )

 $$ !  ## " "

-

# )$$-

$-

 )$2"

"

"

#   !

"

%1$&'"

$ &  "

 
--   $  2    &-'  

' 1 ?   "

 &

&#

$  

    -$    "

 + - 

"

$

  

))

$""

2&'"

$10 
;;  $9"

# &'"

@<&- % >
 $"

+ <- "  "

'  2       -

     '

$ 

 "

  - 3     "

 !"

$2 - "

 )"

- $$ "

- )""



"- 2  &-'

 "




  --)  

' &'$  &'  "

 "

 
  %





-'  "

  &

)  &   " )"  "

 

   $$ !  ## "

&

& @<&-

% >
   

-"

)

$"

> - -2    -5

6$"

 - &- "

>-

    $

 -'"



$    ""

 "

$" )""

-' $$ !  ## "    $"



)"

 & ) &- #
  -2$"

" # #- -'

")  ; " #'$$ 

"

5

6$"

 

) &'"

% -- --2 -: ; 0$  & "

#&'"

*#"' $- 

 2"'$$  

-"

 ' /"



-   '     #  &'  "

 -   % --  % '

 $&  

& # 2"'$

  

))

$"

 ))  $  '&



$'

"

 

#    "  "

    "

 



$  & # )  #- -'  )    # ) -( "

 & '$$

"# $$2 "

) )'   $      &   "  "

  '    $$- & -'

&'"


--   $2  2 "' 

  & ""



- # $&'"

! '% '"

2 # 2"'


 
(
 


 8 8

""

! '% ' "

%$#(  )"

 "

$$

"

    

  +       "

 @<&- % > 
  $           

$   $  #   -

# 



 

& 2



2"

"

-

# $

$"

#      888

2 "

%;$$2"

 -  "-- "

)- '"

   $$ "--

-

-

-' --' $

$  "

  #   )     

- "-- $

  &

$   

  "

-

"-- $

B

)$$-

 $$-  #(

"-- & #

 &'"

   888/"

)5 62"

""

-

 5

6

& &'"

)  $" )""



$$ !  ## "





"

$$ 



"

 -- )5 6"

 )

"

$"

#

      /"

$  "

 #  

)    "

 &

) $&'"

)  $

#- -' 2"'$ $

& + 

--'$"

-

# 

-  

    $  & 2

 

-  

$  $  2

-

$"



-

$2(




 -) "

2 )



-#  -2 

 #  2  $$"

#

/"

  ) "

&'"

% --

% ' % -: ; 0$

#  $$ #  )

 

*   %!  ! % )  

*
+,-./,    ,.+,.0/1.2345670.2/85.9  ./78 ,.+,.00.180+2:-. ./78