Bimla Kumari And Others v. Gursharan Kaur
!"# $%
$%
& '!!!
!
"
$ %
"&
' ( !
"
$ %
"& ))))) !!# * "+ ,-.//
,/-0. #1.2/!% #
%'
# 3 ( # "
+ ,0 20.-1.24
5 62& 7
7#
## "
"
-.8 -, 21.69*
( * : " ( 9 * ;
"
3
" ( # "
21./1.2/
%': " ( 9 * ;
$
5 61& < %'
!%
#"
"
-.8=-,=21.6
9*
% #%' "
"
# "
#
"
<"% # %'
"
%
" ( <" (
>9+ 04 18.41.21 (
"
,.8 ,?0 9* "
@ "
:
(
$
< " & <
<%
#
+ 2 $ * "+ ,-.//
#1.2/&
( " ( (
< " %
#
+ 2 <
"
# 24..=6
%
22.,1.2-;"
"
<"% #
(
'#
'
#
(
+ 2'< < >9
" ( #
" A
%
#
+ 2
.?.81.2-
""
#"
"
% " <"<
"
" (%
%"
#
% "%
"
%
%
"'<
+ 2 < <
" < '
#
'#<
% <
%" #<">9< ( ( ! # " < <%
< "
%
<
"
"
% < 5" #
"
%"
#'%
+ 2<
#
< '>
5 ' #% 2'
?
#
"
#%
#
+ 2
#
6"
.?.81.2-< "
< #
20.-1.24 * ( % %' "
!
#"
1.1 *
#* " $#
B *
C&!
% < (
# #"
@@+ -1 2..81.2- <"% "
%
#
##"
<
'" (
( '
%
'
(
"% " %'
# < (
# "
< # "
6"
" # !
#"
1.1 *
(
' %'
"
(
!"" "
# $$ % &
!"" '
!
(
!
! $
)") "
** (!$) + !$! !
# !""
,,* ( $$-.) + / $ 0 $
, !""*
% %
"
' #
3 "
"
#
## " # <"
!%
" '
# "
"
'% '
5 %' "
' "
% <
<"# < %' ##"
"
'! "9
# #
< "! #
22.81.2- <" ' " < % ! # "!
""5
% " "
(
% <
"! '
#+ !% 1.2,
*"5
(
9
"
" #
!
22211.2, <"
" " # #
< " *
"
( # "
" ! %
'
"
(
( !
'
%
" < " # ("
(
% <
< "! "
20.-1.24 % # #
"
#"
#
< (
#"
# (
% < %
#"
" ' " "
%
< ! " "
%# "
"
'! "%
< !% 5
(
@@
'
+ 2..81.2- %
"
"
! %
< "
5 "'5 #< < (
( # %' "
#
< "
"
#
#"
#
(
6"
"
!
#"
1.1 *
"
" "
(
#;
E% * % < 7" $ & %" (
<" "% " %' * < (
'@ " + " 1.2,$2,&**8-0 "' 21
2- < ;
E% * <
# 3 '
"
1.1 *
;
% "
!
"
"
1.1 *
!%
#'"
<
#
""
" < < 9!(! ' ( #"
%
%'"
#
< "!(
(
"
" (
%' "
< < ## "
"
-.8 < "
-,
21.69*(
#
"
< < !
!
"
"
"
< #
!
"
%' ##" < < (
(<'
< ## "
(
# <" '!%
(
#"
#
( (
' # "
"
* % '5 %' "
"
<
%# ( <" '
%'
"
"
'! " "
"
%' < ##" < "
%"" #"
#
%
6"
"
!
#"
1.1$2& *
"
%"" %" (
<" "% " %' "
#
% < 7"$ &
"%
#"
"9 !
11
1, % # < 6 1 2$$
$3
33 4 2 3&$
3 4
5 3 3$ $ &$
$6 4
$3$3 7 &$ (4 $ 6$ 42 $3!3$ $6"
"
&
& "$ $6 "
$3 3
, 6636 $%
'&
4 8 3 33
4 2 3&$
35 3 3$80 ( 2 2$$ $3(
&$
$666 3$2 3 2 $ 4 6
$662 3$ $ (6 $ 3
&
0 2 $($3 $4 $ $ 4
$ 3$3 7 & $ 3 (4 $ 6$ 4 2 $3 $ 6 3$2
6 30 6$ 2 2$ 2363 & $ $ 22 $ 9 $2$4 03 2 2$$6 3 2 & "$ &
: 6$$ 4 ;
!3$ $6 "$ 3$2 2$2$$6$62 $31 3
33 4 2 3&$
3 5 3 3$< 6 $ 7 $ 3 &6$ 3 (4 $$ &
2$3$663 $ &3$ 2 $ 6. 3$6 $ $ $
33 4 2 3&$
3 4
5 3 3$7 & $ &$ $
0 1 3 33
4 2 3&$
35 3 3$< & !3$ # $6 "$ $6 "
$3 3 "
3,$6
,
6=>'>
'0 6$ $2$$6 4
6 3$2
6
2 $ 4 6
$662 3$ $
0$6$ 6$$ ; 1?
3$2
6 2 $ 4 6
$66 2 32&$
.$ $ $3 2 $
$
&3 2$2 $3 $ >3$ $6 !3$ $ $4 $ &2$ 4
6$ $4
33 4&$ 3$ 7 $ 3 6$ 3(4 $$ & 2$3
$663 $ &3$ 2 $ 66$ 64$
$ $
6634 $6$ 2 $34
33< 0 $6 52 $ 1 < 2 6 3 7 & $ (4 $ 3 & & 4
$ & 0 1 < $
& $ &$ 4$ 33$3$5$
$ 3 $ 3$ &0$6
1 < 3 3 3$3(9
4 6$ 2 32 $$$$$6 4 6 $2 ($3 2 $6 $
&3 2$2 $6 $6 3$2 3$ $2$$652 $ 1 < 34 $ 2 2$6$ 3
$4 ($$$ 7 & $ (4 $ 3 & $ &6$ $
33 (4&$
$ 3$$6 4
< = ?$ $ 2 $($3 $4 $ $ 4
$ 22& 3
6& 6& 6 4 $3$2 3$
$4 3$ $ 7 &3$3 $ $2 6 33$$6636$ 3 3$2 6 0 7 2 & "$ 34$$-) + /
$ 0
, )") "
,
;
,
( )325%4 )% , ,;
' !"" "
* 6$$ 4 ; 1 05( 6 3$3
$3
& $ 3$4/ 3$6 $663$3$2 6$
2 2$$642 $3$ 33!3
$3 $6 4 3 $3 $6 3 6 3 3 3$ $663 $ 223 $$6 $ 4 $3$2 3$
$4 3$ $ 7 &3$3 $ $3$($ $$6
$ $3 2 $ $ 22
6$ 3 3$ .$ 3 3 $3$ $63$ &"$ 2 ?$$@A 2?$$@(%3 4
## * )") "
'
; ##B ,!"" *#; ##B!"" "
*
C$$$2 $3$63
2 $ $ 02 & 4
!3$
"
"6$$ &!3$ *"
"$ 63 4
22$6 3
6 4 $6$ 2 $346
& 42 $ $($ $ $6
4$ 22
6$ 3$ 0 6 3$ $ 4 $ 6$ 2 $34 $ 6 3
43$2 $3$ $663 3$ $4 3$ $2
3 33
6$ 3$ $$
$6$ $ $ 2 4$ 7 $2 40"$$6"
$3 7 2 4 $ 2 !3$ = "
" 3$2 $$ $$ $& 6&.$ 4
$$ 3
2$ $663 4 3$4/ 3 $6 3 ( & 3$2 66$ 2 $3 $6 3$ 0 6633 $$ 2 & 4
6 4 $ 3$2 3$ $663 3$ $4
3$ $67 &$ 2$ $6(4 $ !3$ "
"6 & 33
6$ 3 3$ 4 $ 6$
$34 33 !3$ *"
"& 42 $36$ 22
30 223 $$6 $
&3$ $6$ 6 3$.6 $33 $ 3 4
2 $3 !3$ D *"
"4"$ !3$ *B"
"$$($ 2$ $ $ ( $62$ $63 3$ 0$3 $ 22
6$ 3 3$ 33 $ 6634 $8 4& 6> 23 4 $3&32 $3$63 3$ $
2$$6
< * 0 7 $6 3$34 7 & $ 34 (4 $6$ 42 $3 6$ $ 2&
6$ &E $687 &8 2 $($ $ 52 & : 3 3
2 $3 ; *.( $6$ $ 6$ 7$5 7$ 3 6 6$ $ $
4
6$ 4 $ 7 & !3$ $6"$0 17 &< 6 !3$ 4 $6"$ 6$$ ; 1 4 F7 &G ( & 7 & $ 3$3 "$& 4
$ 3$ H< .(6 $ 6$ 2 $($( &7 &$
3$3& 4
$ 3$ 7 &$2363$$ $67 &2 $( !3$ $6"$.7 &( 4
!3$ $6"$
5 !3$
$6"$5 $$63$2 $&3
& $2$$65 4 6 &05 3& 4
6$ 2 2$ $6 34 $ $ 663 4 $ 6$
$34 33 $4 7 & ( 4 !3$ $6"$< % !< < 3
( " 3 # ( 3 '
"
"
"
"" ( "%'
<" ( 5 " "
%! '
%
" ( #"
6#""( "" # ## " # <"<% ( (
%
# %(
% "
(
'
" #'
#' (# (
"
< "
(<
"
"
6#" ## "$&# <" "
# " "" %
<
< ##
%';
E% * % ! # < (
(
<" "%
" %'"
#
%
#"
" "< * "
"
"
% "
< <"
" !< % ! "
#
)*+,"# $!!% -,.*/0 A (=
F=+
A
%
F=+