High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1816/2011disposed of

Subash Chander v. State Of Punjab

2023-09-05Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary9 pages

! ""# $%%&'(&#)*+,-. /0123452678739:);<)=<#)#" >?@A08A$A0952B <<<<C21717392B DEFGHG >101234C?9I0@ <<<%28J395291

KL M N

! OOOOO CB28291: -B<P78A091%0IQA09RA08ST5U3601243B1A2J21717392B -B<V<><>?WW0BS>B</TQC?9I0@ OOOOO

! M M < $A0WW29R2 79 1A2 7981091 B2U78739 J2171739 78 13 1A2 I?5RX291 50125 )"<)'<#) J08825 @Y 1A2 T55717390W >2887398 Z?5R2 *T5A36.S [081 \B06] $3?B1S Q?B508J?BS ^A2B2@Y 1A2 0JJ20W JB242BB25 @Y 1A2 J21717392B 0R07981 1A2 I?5RX291 50125 )"<)#<#)) B2952B25 @Y >?@ /7U787390W Z?57670W -0R781B012S C01A09]31S 639U76179R 095 829129679R A7X 43B 1A2 3442962 ?952B >2617398 #_= 095 ")`&T aC$ 34aC$A08@229578X78825< #< >?XX0B7WYS 09 [a% ^08 B2R7812B25 ?952B >2617398 #_=S ")`&T 095 `#_ aC$S 39 0663?91 34 09 06675291 1A01 133] JW062 39 )#<)#<#)); @21^229 0 V0BY090 %305^0Y8 @?8S @279R 5B7U29 @Y 1A2 066?

825&J21717392BS 095 0 @76Y6W2< T412B 79U2817R01739S 6A0WW09 ^08 JB2J0B25 095 JB2829125 79 1A2 $3?B1< bJ39 ^A76A 6A0BR28 ^2B2 4B0X25 0R07981 1A2 066?825&J21717392B 13 ^A76A A2 JW20525 931 R?7W1Y 0956W07X251B70W< "< T8 X09Y 08 ^71928828 ^2B2 2c0X7925 @Y 1A2 JB3826?

!"#$ "

%& # "

() & (( '&( + & ,-, ./. *"01

& & &2 (& ' %$ *"

" " (& (&(3((#3 %3

& 4( (&3(&1 (& &"

(#& 5 !" 3 .'

% "

& 3'

& " ' & (

$ &(

( &231

( " &)

( # ##& '&( + & 67 &( ,859$ :/. &(

&& ( % '&(2 2'

&%& # (#-1&(1# &#;

<88=) & '&31 < 922 (

() &$ "( " 9(( &3 +

& >'(2 ?9( 4 @$ ! B .'$ C'( '$ *"01

( ( %'2&(D'(2%&((8, 8E 8-- F 4& $" &

& & 6 G&(

'& 3 " '

'0% " " & ( &

" & & & % &( 1 # H&( &2 " 0&# # 0 & '&( !" /0 & # I##&( $ -7<E$

* # " 2 &2

'% & 0 &2 "$ "

(& & " 1 88<J " &

2&%& %31 " &( #

J 3(1 '&(2& , %&"

&( - (1 ' # "

&& *((J &

( "

& # 3J % ##&($

3 0(* &&$ #% 31

& 3'( &2

#$ *"'&(*& & '21&("

E813(%" E I& " " "&($ 3&( +

'& 3 " 1 %($ &(

'0% " " .' 03* " 2"31

( "

() & & " (& ('

( 01 " ' & 4

"*$ '&03

& " '% # & & " &2

( "

& # 3 !"#$ 1 "" &

& &0(

(

!" #$% &'

()*+'( ,%)-.)/0 12$ 1 (2 ( 1'( 0 2 3(4$'3&&5 (( (2( 12 20 -'(% #2

0 -.)6

3 0 1 4$'

4 ($ (2' 7'&&4 (2' 8'353& 0 (2 8 8'

4 9$ ,:;)<< 8'

'7 2

4&'4 %

85 (2

('('$ (3= (2 353& $> (2

3 ?2 8$7 >3( ($$ 3$$8$( 85 (2 % '3& 7'

& $ (2 ((% ( $> -.)60 5)1'( ($ (2 3'

( ?2 0 (2 #$( 8&$1 27

$ &5@%'

(27'

'42(&53$ 7'3( (2 ('('$ !! * 4 (2

5 % 82&> $> (2

('('$ ' 3$ 3 0 '( 1$& 8

$ '( ($ %= > 3 ($ A3('$ / $> (2 -$8('$ $> B>>

*3(0!6C012'32 (2 D E FG HIJK HL HMKN NH KJOJPQJ RJKNPST HLLJTUJKQ HT VKHWPNSHTHLXHHURHTUMRNG Y!Z .2 5

$ ' >$

4'&(5 $> 27'

4 3$%%'(( $>> 3

' 28& 1'(2

(2 $ '% ' $ % >$ &'>

(2 #$( 85 12'32 (2

$ ' >$

4'&(5 ' $> '$ (2(0 27'

4 4 ($ (2 3'3% ( 3 $> (2 3 3& 4 (2

( $> (2 $>> 3

(2 323( $> (2 $>>

0 '( ' @ ' ($ & 2'%

$8('$ $> 4$$ 3$

3(0 (2 0

$(1'(2 (

4 5(2'

4 3$ ('

5 $(2 &1 >$ (2 ('% 8'

4 >$30 (2 3$( %50 ( $> ( 3'

4 2'% ( 3 ($ 5

' 2%

'3( (2( 2 8 & 2' ('

4 ($ 8$

0 1'(2 $ 1'(2$( (' 0 ($

3'7 ( 3 12 3&&

4 32

'$ 0

$( @3 4 (2 5 0 (2 #$( %5

'3(0

(2 % ('% ($ = (2

8 $> 4$$ 827'$D -$7'

(2( (2 #$( 2&&

'3( 32 & $> $>>

& '( ' (' >' (2( (2 $>>

$ 2' (50 '> 50 2 >'@

&3 $> 8$ $ 4& $33 ('$ (2

&3 $7 12'32 (2 #$( @3' +'

'3('$ $ 12'32 (2 $>>

' &'=&5 ($ &'7

4 (2

'$ >$ 12'32 2 ( '

($(28$

Y<Z [>$ %='

4 5 $

8) 3('$ Y!Z0 (2 3$(

#"$

% &$ % #"'

( )*+ ,

" - !

" -'.

)/+

$ -" 0&$

% %%

" ! % #-'

1# !

# -# "2

" !

3 %%

" 0

- !

" -# "2

% #"'

0 !

" !-"

3 - !$

& "$ 0& #

$ ! 0&

- -# "2

0# -

"& %" !- -# "2

% %%

"( )+ 4 -" 0

3 -# "2

" - !

" -'.

)*+ 5- %%

"$ %"

!$ " - -"

$ ' "2

- "!

" ! - !!

# !

$ '

%"0

1 " " 0 " -" 0&$ 2

3 3"! #" -"

" -0

0# %" #"

% 0 %%

% " %%

'& %%

"( )7+ 4 -" 0

3 -# "2

" - !

" -'.

)*+

" "0 !

% "!

" ! %"6 %-"

#& % -# "2

% %%

"$ -"

% &$ ! #"'

!(8 /9( : 6-! 6"6 " ;-!30

% <=<> ?<@ ABC D=<=E FG H>I<J K:L /MN7 OP $ 6 '& Q R' 4 O-#"

P-"$ 3"!

3 #-"# ! ';

% S4 T"'

% U%%

" K $ /M7VR ! ' "2 ! ! ! $ W4 K

#"3"

% 0!

" "

! % %"0

! %

3&( :

- %

% ! "

%"0

!- %%

" #-

0( X"!& ! K !

3- %%

" 6 9/ & " % 3 ! '2 3 $ ! %%

" 6 "

3- & % 2

3 ! %%

' !

0#"

%" !

! " ## ""$%& '

$ %# " ""$(# )* " +, !#- )# #% $

*$ % # . " (.$

$ $ /) $ "

( %$( % - )0% %$(

$ ($

$ /// /* $ " 1% -

$ %# " ""$(# ) " +, !# $

$0 $% $

## ( % $ #$ $% .

./ #$.$

$##

# # #"

( * ( % .# $%# " %#-

$% $ " ""$% $( %% " ""$(#-

# $ (# ) ( . $(2#&3$(4" 1% &5 ,3& 6$7) 8 /. 9

$ :;<=>=? =@A=B =BC DB>E F@E :<=<G HI J;K=>L 1MN +OO 29 334- )#*( )$"

" /) $ %$ ) P $(( // * $ # # - $( ( - Q R P% / %

# #% $!- 9 # %$# ( % .# $%# " %#- $ " ""$% $( %% " ""$(& ' %$# ( $ " ""$%- 9 .

# S % "

* ! " ""$%-

./% % ""$% ( $ .& 8 )$"

* ) %% #(

$( 2% $ 4 " T) $ " U""$(# 1%

# )0%

$ .)( (

$ /* $# $( ( V.!V %!

$( % # #% $ *# # 9 # ""$(

$ P% # " /#

$( 2% $ 3 4 " T) $ " U""$(# 1% * ( $ " ""$% $( %% " ""$( $( * % .# $%# " %#& 8 /#

$( 2% $ 4 " T) $ " U""$(# 1% *# 9 $ $! /#$

# " $(

! " ""$% %..

(- $ / #) (

./ #$.$ "

"& 8 # / %$ ) P% #( )! 9 # $( /#$

! $(

" 9 $S#

! !"#$!

$ % !$ !'"

% %% !

! !

% %%

% $ "'

)

!!"$

* +

)

(, - "

** ''

$ ' $ '$ (, $ - "

** ' "

/0 % - $" % 1 23 /42 1 + "'

'$ %"' #5

# $ 789:; :;<=>? ;@ ABC D9;9> @E 7CCF /GH/ IJ"**K J-- /L& 7CC ;MN ABC D9;9> @E

?8BB;F /GGO J"** IPK J-- 0HO

Q ?;R;B: ABC D9;9> @E ;?S;<;F IPTT/K /T J-- 4LL& D9;9> @E U;?<;9;R; ABC

N==;VV; /GGG J-- I- K /T4& +

W X('

Y J"*

- "

)

"#Z !*'

! ! +

[ \]^_[[ `]a[

#$ ($ $ !$ %

$ '

J ! PLG

+ J ! 0T4b. 1c- ! ! $ % $b# %%

+ $ %!

'& *"

* $ + "'

$"%%

#* $

2 /O2 Y$ - "

d8B:;< D8<e: ABC D9;9> @E N<M;fF -ggb/PH0bPTTH&

PL2T/2PTP0&

( (, ($

%! %

#' !

P0 , $& "$ %"' *"

* $ + "'

(, # (!5 6'&

$ & + +$ '

#'!$ 2 /2 1 ;Nh i>@?e> AB D9;9> @E jCCkC @E l>h:8 PTTH I4K J-- /HO& ** ''& + +$ W - $('

! # b%!

! #

%%!& +! +$ %!

!"$

& W X('

Y J"*

- "

" % " +$ !'

', #

+ ! ' "

",& "$ +$ !

(, J ! /4T % m ' c '!

.!& +

$ %

# $ & !

)& !' (# %'*(+ $' '( +% % +' (' , %' ' -. , '& '( %& +% %' +

&* '&

&#!$ &% '!

&&' (/ 0/ 1% & ' % '

$ 34567 869:; <=> 8?5?@ AB C9457 59D 59A?;@E # 2FFG-HI0G-..J#

.K/.K/-.--#

& ( % ) %' !

(* ( L ( K.MN '( -J '( M- OP2# +&'( )& !' ' %' ( &+ ' ( (

$ K (% '( Q ',

$ - , '&

$ % ( ( '( $' % )& &' &'$ &'))& R"' ,J, '&/ 0H/ O( % '

$ 5E5S46? 869:; <=> 8?5?@ AB 5ET595 -.00U-V F2F U2&/V HII# % &

)& !' % ')) '(#

' ' W'&,'(' X */ &*'(# & "'( ( , 00 ',# $$ & '+ (,

$ )& &' &' & & %'( 0Q , '&#

' ' )& * (*# %' " % (

$ !'# %' I % & (#

$ '(

'+ )'& ( )) &#

% '(

! &*' %' % &* %' !

'$$ ( &"

$ L 0-

$ % P& !'

$ Y$$ & N/ Z[

# ( 2FFGMMMG-.0J# ' 8C96\ ]CS5E <=> 8?5?@ AB 5ET595^

--/./-.0J# % &

& & % &

$ % ) &

)& !'

$ +

( # ( *

$ % "+'(+ &"'( # !

(+ ' )& * (* %' %

!'(* ")& ( ( % %'&' '$ , '& %' )' !,#

!& '

'&( '( ' &* ( W'&,'(' ',#

! &*(+ %' % )& !' "', '$$ % '&

( &"

$ L 0-

$ % P& !'

$ Y$$ & N/ O( % '

$ _S@D 869:; 59D

?;@E= <=> 3`5D 869:; 59D 59A?;@E^ 2FFG-KMG-.0I

.M/.M/-.0J ' % (*

$ % )

' )% '( % ( (

' $ '( % ) &

& & !

)& !'

$ - , '&/ 1% '

# $ %"& "' " $

$"!!

!%( )$

*+ ,!

-!(.$/ *0/ 1 3!

$"(

4567899: ;<=>? @AB ;C6C9 DE F=G6HI 2JJK*LMK+N*LO $

PN/NQ/+N*LO " !"(

!O # #"( '

$ 3! )$

( PPR " PNL. S,2

(!'

T " #"( " T '!% % &O " "T

(!'

$O "

!# ( " "$ !

T !

! "% ( 0 &"!(/ ) "!&O

2JJKP+L*K+N*+O

6GD7 U6< 6G6= @AB ;C6C9 DE F=G6HI $

P*/N*/+N*PO

!O " V"W !

.!%& " %

$ #"(

!"(

T " 3 % ( (!'

PL &"!(

.!%& " #"( 3

! !

"( " O " " 3!T P (

($ "#"! "$ % ("XJ( $"( V.21/ +N/ J'! T "$(

!( $"( "( !T"!( !"&! %"

$!O 3! ( !

T T" T !$3%("$( " W3T%( !!!

( " (

W3( $ 3

"Y3"& %

T!"

$ 3$/ +*/ .( " (Y3$

'O !( !'

! & (

" !$

T!" !

! " !

&"!O

( "( (!

3! )$

-!(.$O*0QZ [*\ ] (" ^$3 "

! T

3! # ' (3! (

" (3%

J(/+QONNN_K # $ ("

^$3

! !

" 3! " !

!"#$% &'(%# ))'$&(*$ +$&($ ,! -$ %# )) '$ %.'/$* #$ %.+$0&%&( #$ 1'

&( 2&*$

( %.'/$* #$ *(&&(% ) & 3( &( #$ 1'

&( 2$($%4*

5 &% *) &&$ # &( %$ #$$ &%

'$ *# #$

$% & *(&&(%6 #$ +$&&($ 3&)) #3&# '$ 7$( &( *.%

( %# )) 0$ .($8#$%$($(*$ $#&'

#$& )9. :

:;:<=:> ?<=@A BCDECFGCHIJ K L M#$#$%+$ 7&(8N$ %($ O P$%NQ M#$#$$+ ')$ O P$%NQ