Puran Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR
!
#$% & ' ( )
* ""
+
* ""
,-.#
/0 .1" ! 23 2 " # .% (% -3! 4 .- -(-3! ( & " ."! 5%40(- 0-3! (2 0( !'&0 666666 23 2 00(1 7 " ' "00 "&" 3 ' 4 3 & "( 0 0!!" % ( 0 89
0 0!!" %4% !00
' &"" 0 % ""
" 1 ( & 4 !3 ! 00 & " % ! " ( : 4
% ! 0 ( + "( " ! 0 1 0.
" " 0""(& 3 ' )
;"
& 0 7 !" !'&0 "
& "' 0 % ( 0 89
( %4% 0 4 !$ !!" 43 "
! !< ' 040"" '0 & %4% 3 "04 '!'&0 -' =" "04 ! 04 0 &" 0 " 00 & ( ( 3 044 >
'
' "&"
& 0 89
3 04"
2& % "!'&0 % (& 0"00 3
3 5 !504" ' 90 =( $
$04 !'&0 00?;
4"
" 0 ! % =0 "
"" ' -'= &0 ! 0 !! 00 & !'&0 4""!" 0 & " !'&0 7 !! 00 &4"4 3
4 !'&0 0 -'=7 & " & "0 4 2' 0=(1" = % "4 "'' 0 ! 0 ! " % ! " ( ( :(
( ; $9 4 3 ( 0 ' )
;(4 0 !< !!" ' 0 2' 0=(1" =% "(!3 ! & " & " ! " % ! " ( : 4 % ! 7 && 0 0 & "!00
" ' 4"0" "'
"" 0 % ""
"1 (& 3 '& '
-
3 4 "' ( & "3 0 & " 3 &
7 0 !" 0 & "( 4 0 "" '& ' ( " " 00 "'
! 4 3 & -'= @ 3"@" >'
00 "& % " ' 0 & B> C9 004 ' # D " 3 0 & " 3" E : 7 0 !" 0 & """'
" ! >'
!4 3 " & ( & "! 00 0 3 0 ! @ 3"@ " "'
3 .F" !@ " 3 && 0&3 ""! !3 ! & "!"" + , ( 0 !" 0 & " % ""'
0 3 ! 0 !'&0 " 4 ' !0 3 ! " '
'& ' "("(& "'
""0 3 & ) 3 !"
30"'
" "" " 4 ""
"! 0 !" 03 0"& " ! !"
!" (4 00 " ! !!" 3 !" C 3" !'&0 " &" ! C!'&0 "0 " !' > " ! " & " 3 ! ' & " !" ("& .F"-'=
B> C-( 2& % B> C 90 =B> C1( 4 !4 &! "& ( 004 4 & " "-'=# D
00 && !
"4"'
904"& "
"!5 -"
"
G )> :!' "
&& 0 & "& '
904"
& " -3 " 0& -"
4"& " "! 04 0 & 0 "
! % G 4" )> :!'904"& " 3 !
" 4!'> !'> !'"
G & " 0 0 '
0 &0
0 0 !0 04"
& "
!
" 4:!'> !'> !' "
G & " &" "& !
' 0 3 0&& C 04 C!0 04"& " E "2& % # D .0 &0 " "& " 0 "
!5 !
( $ ' ("
G 3 '!'>!'+!'> !'( !0 .0 &0 " "& "
"
!5(!
!
$: ' "
G 3' !'>!' !'>!'
" !0 -"
0 :!'> +!' "
G (& "
"!&0
(H$4"3 " ! "
.9 " "( $+ ' ""
G 3 !'>!')!'> !'& "
0'
" !0E "90 =#
:
D
'&0 & 04 '
" ' "5 !5"7 " > 0 " 3 '
" -'' : '" , - B>'
" 4 5" "
G ( 5 & " 3 - " 3 4" !0 "
'&0
E ; -" & " ' "& % ( ( 0& (4" !0 "@ 3"@-'=("& .FB> C-0" 04"& " "!5
""!!" 4 & 0
"40 < " < !" ! !" " "0 0 '
0 " "!5 ( & 0
"40 " !0 < !0 @ 3"@ % ! 4 ! "@ 3"@ ""004"# D2 3" I 7 004 5 " 0 "
"D 3"@#I ?
" I B'"!0 % !0 I ' & 3 "
7 0 I ' & 3 ?0 I 3 ' ' ?
0 I "! & ' '& &4 "' ' % >0 I ' "
! % 3 0 I ?! "0!
0 I -4 ! "0 4 !!" "
+
" "&! 4 " " 3 0& (0 004 " &" "E -& "0 " "4"!" "0! 40 !3 !0" % ! -!" 4 "0" "0 "0! 0 '30 '
"!5 40 < H$ >'
"! " &"
!0 ! 7 !''
(&& 0 !
& (
0&3 !4"' !$0 00 >'
" "! 40 " ! G "@ 3"@ 3 4 "!""
' 3 ( ! & 0 !" 0 0 >'
!4 !0 -'= @ 3"@ "0 !" &" ! 400 '!4
4 3 ( ' 0 "" & " !" " .F"
!0 .F-'= " &3 >'
! 4' !0 00 >'
A 0 ' !00 >'
>'
%0 =4& & .F" "' 3 &!
"& 4 &" "004"# D'&" "' !0 !
0 "& 0(= 3 " %.,&! .F !
' !'&0 4" >'
%0 =4"4 3
0 ! JJJJJJJ HHHHHHHHH
)
4"&"
0 "& 0=
4"4 4 >'
54
& "003 >'
!" >'
4 !! ' & " ! , 0"" '&0 ' 0-' % "&" = " ! !"
"3 -' % % =" ( " 00 '&0
0 "& 0= "4 "
" 3 &" 0" 0E -& "0 " " ' "& "4" """
>'
% = "" 4 3 ( !""$ >'
"" " "" '&0
0 "& 0(=7 ( 00 &" ! "0 3 >'
% = " 0 3 ( "' 3 0 !'"! "( & " ! !0 " ! !' "& & % = .F"!03 &3 "' 4 "'
4 "
"4 "& % "' 4"" 4"40 " 3 4 % ="4 3 " 4 "
"" 4 ! "
" % = .F" 4 ""
'&0" " G %., 00 "'' ! % ! (!" 4 00 "& !"
( !"
" ' !0 3 ! ( &" ! C!'&0 "03 5 ! .F"&3 && 0 !" ( & " ! % =!0 " ! ( "' !00 C 04 4"'
4 "
4 !03 "''
' "& 0""&3 .F" " ! && 3 !
" ( .F"! " 0&3 "" ' "
"&3 !' > " ! " & " !'&0 ,! " 0 !'&0 " 0 "0 " !'
"!! !.F"3 && 0&3 ( !3 ! !!" 3 !" C 3" !'&0 ! "" 7 3 & "
!! 0' !! &! !! & 7 '& ' "
)
; " "
!!" !< 00 ! "' " '
!"#$ ' A "& 5 C " K "C A &0 K "C