Pappu @ Dhani Ram @ Bhola And Others v. Nikhil Chopra And Others

  
    
    

   11#33%(&;

= 

 ! "#$%&# / "#$%&#  "#$%&# '#40&# 5 6"#&"#- 1-(*(2 1-(*(2 8 "#$#3%7 )*$+,#(&   #1($#(&;

;= '"#(&"#)*$+,#(&'%-##-.

'"#(&"#)*$+,#(&01-(*( '"#(&"#)*$+,#(&0*13%$#$ .#$ /> // / (2#$

! 5/ / $(&"#

! 5/ / (371#-%&0.#1%-& &"#)*$+ 2#$-'"#&"#-&"# *33)*$+,# 2#$ 790 %(79 &"#1-(*(2#,#(& +,#(&0
*33 (&0 & *33 &%11302%43# &9%($-#%(&"#-#  :
 































































































 


  
 



 





 





 




''






 !



  
"
#
$
%

&'

())


"




 



"
 
  9999




*#+


,!

!
 


'
'' 

)
'


 
 
-.

-% %-#/
 
)!

'

 
('
0) '
1)
= = 
)!
2
0 ) ':;
)!

 

< 5%.---3>

  

 
 



''3'
' 


4
56

 






'

'

''

'7


 
 


 
 '

 
 
#- -% %-#5

*%+



'
 


 




'

  

?

 
  
)!

' 
0) '

'
 
 


 


  

 



)!

ARGUMENTS APPELLANTS S ON BEHALF OF LEAR RNED COUNSEL FOR T HE S/CLAIMANTS.
*8+ @ 
 '




'' 3'
'



 




'
 
A


 









' 




 '
 
 '
) 


 '!

B


 



 


 




!

 '
 '

'

0
' 
 '
 )

 

#3 3C
 
'
D 


 
 ''!



D
  




 
  
 


)
#3E E B
'
 


 

 
'

'
 




'
 
 ''!

 


'
 



)
?


@'!




 


 
)!

0) '

 

' 


 
 ARGUMENTS RESPONDENT S ON BEHALF OF L TS No. 1 & 2.
LEARNED COUNSEL FO OR *C+  

'
 '
  

 
"
#
$ $
%




 



 

'




 
'
  
 )




 
 
 
 

  

)!

'
0) '
''


  ARGUMENTS RESPONDENT S ON BEHALF OF L T No. 3.
LEARNED COUNSEL FO OR

*E+ @ 
 '

 
"
83A 
( !
  



'

 
"
#
$
%
 
 )


  

)!

'
0) '







  
 




   
*.+ A
 

'
 '




 


)

 


''






'
0) '

A



 
 
)!

'
 '

 


''3' ? 

 



 *F+





A



 

C%
!
'






) 



''

 

  
'


'

) 
 ''!
'!


 A 


?



?

 



 



?

 
 

#- -% %-#5

 
 


!

%-#5

  



'
 

)!

'
0) '



' 

)
'
 


 


'
 






 


  

''!
 
 


 

 

'

'



0  

( 


 



'!
 



4
< 5---3>


< .-- -3>

)!

0) '

? 
6 

  9   

@ 

      *5+





 
'!



 
)!
>
)

 
( 





 !"#$%  !& '  !"#(
)
)* + +*, 

  

')'

)

 
'


 




 

?



) 



G
 '






)!

BG)'



( 

 
  & !- &  !"

"# &!-  %  $%  & *!&. !

!% &!/  *01&!2  0

- & &!-  #

%(
  

5+6 $9

)!


'


 
 

 


'

')'

) )

 
) 
<' 
D 

 
  
 >

 

 

    & & 3& &-#4& 5%1 &6      

   

  

 

     

         

   

   

    

    

    

 

 







0  






 


C%
!



 
%E6
 


 
 
 '

#C



' ? 





     */+ A
 

BG)'
 D
( 

0

& .&$

0& &8  %  $% 7 .#  &!%1*

 * 1* & *! 8 !

!

 56 9  
& * *!&. !% &!/ *01 01&!2 - :% ;

&!&2

# 8  % 5=699>
&!- !

- !- &!% &!/

*  - :

& !-

& < & 4 !-

& I
 

5 6 =>
  

 '


'
?

 

)
 '!

'

'

< #5---3>  





'
D  

< #5---3>
 
' 
 
@

  


)
 

 
 

< %55---3>
=<
C5- ---
D
.;



'' 3'

'

 '

'
 H
) 
 ' '!

''3'


 '

 

 

'

'
 


 

 

*#-+

A



) 
 
)

''3' 
''
)
'

 


 


'' 
 >
Sr.N No.

Nature Amount (in Rs.) n 1.

Annual Income of Decease ed 96,00 00/- 2.

Add 40% future prospects 24,00 00/- Net Income (Rs. 96,000/- + + Rs. 24,000/-) 1,20,00 00/- 4.

Multiplier of 14 as per age e of 42 years (Rs.

16,80,00 00/- 1,20,000 x 14) 5.

Funeral Expenses 18,00 00/- 6.

Loss of Estate 18,00 00/- 7.

Loss of Consortium (Rs. 48 8,000 x 6) 2,88,00 00/- 8.

Total Compensation 20,04,00 00/- Amount Awarded by the Tribunal 8,26,00 00/- Enhanced Amount 11,78,00 00/-  '!


''3'
''
)
'


) 






 
' !

)!

' 
0) '

*##+

0 



4
56

 




 

  
 
H

 


)

)!
BG)'


 
( 

0

 1  7  &!

!- * #

% $%  & *!&. !% &!

!/ *01&!2  0

- &!- * #

 56 5?6   @+





 )?




'

;

&00&&!-* #

%$%  & &2&!&

--2&!-&!* # #

 ?56 5 5 : .6??+
 





/6

 






' 




  
 '

 ''

'7
A


 
 




 



 
''
)
!)'
 
'

#%6


D !
  




!

"'







'!



'

'
''
)
 


  *#%+

A

 
 



'

 


 '' 


'=;

! 
''
'

 


1-03 !9/ /

 ;   =  J J 
 3

K 
 )'

K 3" 3"