Surinder Pal And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another




    
 
      
!
" #$   % !&'()*+' ,-#$+'.  +#(#()+'.
/+'.&. !#,#+ &)0,1,)#$+'    +.2)*+)#.  "  34  !
 
! 5 







 


  

 
 
 
 


!"
 


# $ 





! 5% ',-  %
  

 
&'$


(

("
 


 

) *

++
# ,$-
 
.'

,.

$,./


 
0$0
0$&
0&

12
# 0
 
.3 ,.

$,./
* 


 
0$&
4
0&
2(
5  
0$6
2(

 
7

 

 
8" 
%
4
+ 

 


)  
*
*
"




"" !

 
.0 ,3 $,./

 
9
 






(  :2 )
*  

* *

  " 
;



* 


""
2
" 



 
*  
2
( 

 
 
.3 ,6 $,./



9



 


" 


""
 9

 
9 




9 
<


 
 
"
<
)  


 %
" 
"
  

*


*
< "


 


  
=9

) 
 <

 

 




*
9 

 
 

 

*

 <
*



  <

 
* 
 

"
<

*
< "

%

 


  
 9
9
 
*

 





"<


 <



  
"

*


 

 

 
<
""

 
"*
9 
 
*
) 

9
9

"
 


 <
 
" 

 <
9
 


 

"



) 


%
"
 






) 



 <

*
%

9
 
 " 

 " 


> "
 " 
 *
 
 <

"
  9
"
 




 

 ?

< "
 


*A*

""
 9
9



"
  
0$,
(  (


>



*
%
 
  <


" *
 *

 

" 
" *


  


 *
9




<
 
<
 


 
0$,
(  (



 
 <;
9

* 


""
 9

 
;
 <;



%
 
  
 <



 


2

(
%



"

 
 
2(
B



> *


2(
9
"


"
"

"
"@*

> *




* 

 *


9
"  






*
*A

9

 *
"
%
  

) 



@*
<
 
0$,
(  (

*A

""
 9

 


8 
" 

  <


 
 

"
 ;

%
( 


" 


<


 



 




@*
 
&'$
(  (

<

*
( 

 
 

9

 <
 


"
 
9 

 9<

 

" 

"


9


  
 




 ;

 
9 

) 

 <

*
%


"" 
<

 

*

"  

) *

9

9 
>*

9


" 

""
=@9



 *
 <
9
 


  *
 <

 

 *
 *
  




 *
  


 <
<
> *
""




;


" 

""
B>

 " 
*



<



 

 
" 


""
<


 
( 






(  
*
9  

 


 

 



( 


"

"


""


 
9 


 <
@


( 

 

)  

 
<

 *

"  

"
  






 

"  

"
  



 A





@
*


 <

(  





  
< "



9 
 9<



 

  
  ;


""
 9

 

*A


 A
"
"

"" 


  


< "

"  

  

 
) 


9

 

 <


"


""

C 


"
( 

" <
 

*
 

*A*
""*




   

   !" #   $%  & 
 
$'( &)% 



 ?
D




 

 








 

 






 





 

!






"





 
 

 

 
 



 
 
   




 
 
#

$%&


 


 


 





'



 
!



 



 


  


 
 ()
* +


 



*

+



 


 


 '
  



 



 



'

!




 
 






 


 
  
 


  





 
 

  '


  
 ,
 
!




 ,








 


'





 





'

 

-
,
,


',
 





 '



 







.



'
 
 






 
#
 


  




  '
#

 ',
 '
  


  



 
 




 
 


-
/


 

0


 
 


'








 -





'
 )


  
 
 '


 




 



 



  
1







 '
  

 '
 

  

 




 





,


  '

 



 
  ,


,


,
 

,


 




-
 



 





  '




 ',
 




'


 

 



'
  











 





 

 '

 ,

'



 

 

 ,
 


  


  
 
 


,





'

 

 
 
 -
 





 
  
 




 
" 
 
!



"


  

 

 
'





 
 





  



  









  ,

 
  




 

  

  



'



















 


 

 

 

 



 





   


  



 
  
 
 






 

,

  






 
 

 

 



* +

 

,






"



2

%






<


> 
*
 


9




 
*  
2
( 

 
 
.3 ,6 $,./
"

 



 
.0 ,3 $,./

<

(  

( 
 



 
9 

<
@*

*
 
2
9



 

  


 "

 9

 

 


* <


  

 9

%
++
# ,$-
 
.'

,.

$,./

 
0$0
0$&
0&

12
# 0
 
.3 ,.

$,./
* 

 
0$&
4
0&
2(
5  
0$6
2(

 
7

 
 
8" 
%
4
+ 

 


)  
*
*
"

 <
) 
) 


  




""



 9

  #$   %  3"4


! 5   5 
-

6


7 8
5 
   
7 8