Manohar Lal And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others
!" #"$%&%'( ) *
( + ,-,. / , + ,
!
"
# #
$
000 / % &
'
"
& ()*+!$,-. % $
) /
01230202
"
4
"
5(&.
#
(
67. +
"#
(
67.
4
& "
+ &"# 8 &
5 "
02,2
& "
5 & 92 4 "
02,, 8
& "
&
&
,-,,02,0 : "
#
&
4&
5,12002,1 "
&& "
:
&
5 (&. &
" #
; #
&"
"&&
5(&.
(4
.
(4
.
02,< 4
&
5 (
.
& "% #
&
5(&. &
& "
"= & % & 5
>? > ?
5 #
& "
&
&
&
5(&.
"
5(&.
' 8
)*+! ,-
'
5 & &
"
@
"
& "
5 (&. "
" &
% &
" %
(%". & "
4 (
63.
& "() . "
&
"
5 (&.
#
& "& &
"
& * 922<0202 ( 6,. #
4
& '
4
( #
.&
'&
& &
1
5 (&. *
#
"
4 )
&
0 4
0202)&
&
4
&
"
+ &
#
29270202&
) A )&&
(
6<.
'
5(&. )&&
21270202 ) &
) A )&&
(
61.
21270202
5 (&. %
5
" #
"
&
8
21270202 #
&
) A )&&
(
6<.
5 (&. )&&
"
"
" (4
.
5 (&.
6< 2<270202 % " '
A
5 (&. &
& "
63
,022 & #
(
67. '
"
6<
:
0 "
&
#
6<
'
6< " "
5(&. #
&
"
5(&.
&" )&&
(
6<.
"&
4
63
"
&
" &
& "
6< + '
#
)
' :
5 (&. &
" +
"
6< &
&
5(&. &
"
"'
& " & !
&& *
$ &$ +& *
(!)*.
"
% & !)*
21270202
#
(
67. :
) A )&&
2<270202 C
#
(
67.
)&&
&
5 "
02,2
5(&. 4 "
02,,%
&
5
67
02,0
5 &
67 " ,2 &
67
" 60 ( 5. "
5 (&. &
- "
% )&&
(
6<.
5(&.
& "
2<270202( B <D,.
+
&
"
5(&. "
" ) A )&&
@
5 (&.
"
"
4
&
&
2<270202( B <D,.
" ) A )&&
=&90
11 4
4
()
) .
02,< ( >02,<
?.
& &
"
"
'
0(,1.( . 02,<
& >
?% B >)&&
?
0(00. 02,<
& >) A )&&
?
03
03
#
&
"
& ) A )&&
)&&
)& & &
#
& &" ' +
4
4
()
) .
02,7 ( >
02,7?.
&$ ,< )&&
:
=&90
=
&
0E
& & )&&
:
& 8
"
2<270202 ( B <D,.
" ) A )&&
&
" " & & )&&
%
=& 90
& "
&
11
B >&!"1 1"?
"
"
"
" )&&
;
" A
2<270202
"
) A )&&
&
" #
(
67. & "
'
6
2<270202 F
"
#54" 6
"
:
& & &
F
"
=
&
" !
&& *
21270202 )
5(&. "
&%
'
&
6< " & ) C
"
5 (&.
"
2<270202( B <D0.
"
"#
)&&
'
"
2<270202
" ) A )&&
"
5(&.
#
(
67. "
' "
%
&
"
67 & "
&
" &
8 " #
,-<7 # A
,E-2%
4
"
"
67
"
&
&
"
5(&.
&
= &
"
D
&
4
"
B&
"
5(&. -"
"
& 8
) ) 21%!3 4,%'567,! !" 8'9 : '#!6"1&/# !"# ;<
<* <* )
<*(""!8-"12 7,! !" 1= ' '#!6"1&/# !"#
; )
<>; <
<*?,82 ' ! 7,! !" 1= ' '# !6"1&/# !"# < *
<><
< ? '##%&6@ 1 %'7 '%' '#% '# '!6"1/
,'%'")
)
"
#
(
67.
5
5 (&.
,-2102,0+
5 '
5 (&.
&
" #
8
#
& "
+ &"
"
4 )
5 (&.
(4
.
(4
. 5(
. &
5 (&. &
"= & " 9 5 ( 60.
5 &
5(&. ( 6,. =
5 (&.
& & &&
"
"
"
"
'
&
' 6
5(&.
"
" "D + "
#
(
67.
5 (&.
) A )&&
(
6<.
2<270202( B <D,. &
& "
&
"
2<270202 ( B <D,.
B&
"
4
'
02,<
02,7
AB<*C "18& 4
%' 4 1#"1 # !"#
)
''"D81"E)F<3 &&"#:=!6"6%4#G"4 1"22%!!""/ !% 4 @84#&6@!6 !!6"1#"16 &:""'3 &&"#:='4= !@"2:"1& !6"22%!!""6"1#"1'12;
%&%' 1"&3"$! &!"1 $ 1" 34 $"2"'! @%!6 2%4= 1 5183
&!"1$ 1" &!"1$ 1"%&#"
%'"#8'#"1,"$!%' !6" $!%& 334%$ :4"'4=%'1"&3"$! $6%4#1"'%''""# $ 1" '#31!"$!%'/@6%$62" '& $6%4#/@66 & 3 1"'!1 58 1#% ' '#&8$63 1"'!158 1#% '%& 8'#!:"8'
%! 1%'$ 3 $%! !"#/:=!6"22%!!""1!6" 1#/!$ 1" 1 '#31!"$!!6"& "!= '#@"44E:"%'5 !6"$6%4# B<>C 6"1#"1# !"# )
/3 &&"#:=!6"6%4# G"4 1" 22%!!""/ !% 4 %& !! 44= &%4"'! :8! !6"
$!82 3"!%!%'"1 '# 6%& 2%4= :"%'5 8'
%! 1 %'$ 3 $%! !"# 1 ! H%'5 $ 1" '# 1 31!"$!%' '# @"44 :"%'5 !6"$6%4#6" 1"& %#1#"16 &:""'3 &&"#:= 6 %13"1&' '#'""2:"1 !6"22%!!"" & 5 %'&! !6"1"I8%1"2"'!%'!"12& 317%&!,"$!%' * !6"$! @6%$631"&$1%:"&!6 !!6"1"&6 44:" !4" &!!61""2"2:"1& 31"&"'! !!6"!%2" %' 4#%&3& 4 !6"$ &"
C G%!6 !6" &&%&! '$" 4" 1'"# $8'&"4 1 !6" 3"!%!%'"1 6 7" 7"1% %"# !6" 4%&! 38:4%$ 64%# =& %' 8'9 : 1 !6" =" 1
! %& 8'# !6 ! )!6 8'" @ & 1%# = '#@ & 5 J"!!"#64%# =' $$8'! , '!818 . :%1 = '!% 6" 1#"1 6 & :""' 3 &&"# ' 5 J"!!"# 64%# =/@%!68!!6"1":"%'5 '=#%&$4&81" '#98&!% %$ !%'
1 %'$234"!" $23&%!%' !6" 2"2:"1& !6" 22%!!""!@1H' 5 J"!!"#64%# = K <C ' 1"34=/ %4"# := 1"&3'#"'! )/ 1"
"1"'$" 6 & :""'2 #"!!6"1"31! 12 / , '5181@6%$6@ & 1"$"%7"# '
" 1'"# $8'&"4 1!6" 3"!%!%'"1 @6%4" %4%'51"34%$ !%'6 &31#8$"#'1"$1#''"D81"E %"8'&"44%'5"31!# !"#
31"3 1"#:=!6"
%&!1%$! 151 22"
%$"1/ , '5181 6" & 2" 1" #& & 8'#"1(E A
! "#
"$
%
&
'
& # ' " ' ( ' ) '
*+ ,
- . $ ' /
"
* ,
$
*+ + $* ,
*+ $
) 0# #1 2 +
+ ' ( 3 + $
' + $
, 024)21 3 *
3
* '5
'5 ) /
' 6
C"18& 4 !6" 1"& %#$8'&"44%'51"31!@84#&6@ !6 ! !6" 8'&"441 %'!"1 $!"# @%!6 !6" 2%'1 '# 8'# !6 !!6"2%'1@ &4%7%'56 33%4=@%!66"1 !6"1 '# 4& @ '!"#!1"&%#"@%!66%2'!6"31"&"'$" &8$61"31!/ @6 ! 3123!"# 1"&3'#"'! ) ! #3! #%
"1"'! 331 $6%&:"='#$231"6"'&%' !6%&81!KL + '
"
4
:
"
"
2<270202
" ) A )&&
"
5 (&. &
& " (#
.
'
@B
#
(
67.
5(&.
&
7 8 " #
,-<7 *
"
" " "
5(&.+
&
"
+
) "9 &@%'% 8# '# !6"1& 7 ,6"H6 1 5#%&6 1 & #"@ 1% '#!6"1&/
<> ,
&
& &
A<; G1%! 6 :" & $138& %& 31"15 !%7" 31$"&& 1 &"$81%'5!6"4%:"1!= !6"&8:9"$!:=
1#%'5 '"
"$!%7" 2" '& %22"#% !" 1"4" &" 12 ' %44"5 4 1 %2313"1 #"!"'!%'6"@1%! 4&"D!"'#&%!&%'
48"'$"!1"&!1"!6" $8&!#= 2%'1 ! 6%& 58 1#% ' @6"' @1'5 844= #"31%7"# %!6"#"!"'!%' 2%'1:= 3"1&'@6%& '!"'!%!4"#!6%&4"5 4$8&!#=%&!1" !"# &"I8%7 4"'!! %44"5 4#"!"'!%' 1!6"3813&" 51 '!%'5@1%!/#%1"$!%'5 $8&!#= !6"2%'1$6%4#11"&!1 !%' !6"$8&!#= 2%'1 12 3"1&'@6 $$1#%'5!!6"3"1&' 44 @/%& '!6%&4"5 41' !81 458 1#% '/%' 33131% !"$ &"&/!6" @1%!$81!6 &981%&#%$!%' < ' 6 1 "582 @6"1" !6" 2!6"1 6 #/ 8'#"1 !6" 3"1&' 4 4 @/ !6" 4"5 4 1%56! ! !6" $8&!#= 6"1 %44"5%!%2 !" 2%'1 $6%4#/ !6" @1%! @ & %&&8"# ' 6 1
"582/!6",831"2"81!#" 4!@%!6 3"!%!%' 16 :" & $138& 1 1"$7"1= ' %44"5%!%2 !" "2 4" $6%4# 6 1 44"5"# !6 ! . '%J "582/ 6 1+& 2!6"1+& &%&!"1 @ & 44"5"#4= #"! %'%'5 6 1+& %'
'! "2 4" $6%4# %44"5 44= 6" ,831"2" 81! !H '!" !6" 3&%!%' 8'#"1 !6" 6 22"# ' @ !6 ! !6" 2!6"1 ' %44"5%!%2 !"
"2 4"$6%4#%&"'!%!4"#!%!&$8&!#= '#1" 8& 4!1"&!1" !6"$8&!#= !6"$6%4#!!6"2!6"1@84#1"&84!%'%44"5 4 $8&!#= !6" $6%4# 6" ,831"2" 81! 6"4# !6 ! . '%J 6 7%'5 ' 4"5 4 1%56! ! !6" $8&!#= !6" $6%4# '# 6"1 1"
8& 4!2 H"7"1!6"$6%4#!!6"2!6"11"&84!"#%' ' %44"5 4#"!"'!%' !6"$6%4#@%!6%'!6"2" '%'5 ,"$!%' ><1 !6"4##"6",831"2"81!6"4#!6 ! !6" $! !6 ! 6 1 6 # 1%56! 8'#"1 !6"8 1#% '& '# G 1#& $! %& ' 98&!% %$ !%' 1 #"'=%'5 6"1 1%56! 8'#"1 ,"$!%' >< 1 6" ,831"2" 81! :&"17"# !6 !
6 1 "582/ :"%'5 !6" ' !81 4 58 1#% '/ %& "'!%!4"# ! 2 %'! %'!6"@1%!3"!%!%' '#6"4# &8'#"1(E A ' !6"&" 8'#%&38!"# $!& !6" 3&%!%' %' 4 @ %& 3"1 "$!4= $4" 1 '#"1 !6" 6 22"# ' 4 @ @6%$6 334%"& ! !6%& $ &"/ !6" 33"44 '! %& "'!%!4"# ! !6" $8&!#= '982@6%&6"1%44"5%!%2 !"# 856!"1/' 2 !!"1 @6 !6" !6"1 '982 %& 6" 1"&3'#"'! 6 & ' 4"5 4 1%56! @6 !&"7"1 ! !6" $8&!#= !6" $6%4# "1 1"
8& 4 ! 2 H" 7"1 !6" $6%4# ! !6" 33"44 '!!6"1"
1"1"&84!"#%' '%44"5 4#"!"'!%' !6" $6%4# @%!6%' !6" 2" '%'5 ,"$!%' >< 6%& 3&%!%' %& $4" 14= 1"$5'%&"# %' !6" '54%&6 $ &"& $'$"1'%'5@1%!& 6 :" &$138& 1!6"31#8$!%' %'
'!& 'M8""'74 1H"<*) <* (<<>/ < < 1# 23:"44/ /& %# !3<>;( 8!@%!61"&3"$! ! $6%4# 8'#"158 1#% '&6%3 1 '81!81"/ !6" $6%4# %& &833&"# ! :" 8'4 @ 844= %231%&'"# @6"' 8'4 @ 844= #"! %'"# 12 !6" $8&!#= !6"58 1#% '? '#@6"'#"4%7"1"#!6%2/ !6"$6%4#%&&833&"#!:"&"! !4%:"1!=L 6"$81!&%'81$8'!1=6 7"$'&%&!"'!4=! H"'!6" & 2" 7%"@ 1 !6%& 3813&" !6" '#% ' $ &"& 6"1"%'
!"1 $%!"# 2 = :" 1"
"11"# ! 6" !"12& ,"$!%' >< @84# $4" 14= :" 334%$ :4" ! !6" $ &" '#!6" 33"44 '!"'!%!4"#!!6"1#"1&6" &H"# *G"!6"1"
1"!6%'H!6 !!6"4" 1'"# 8#5"& !6" %5681!@"1"$4" 14=@1'5%'!6"%17%"@!6 !!6" $6%4# '982 @ & '! :"%'5 %44"5 44= 1 %2313"14= #"! %'"# 6" 4" 1'"# 8#5"& 6 7" '! 5%7"' '= 1" &' %' &8331! !6"%1 7%"@ '# @" 1" $4" 1 %' 812%'#!6 !7%"@%&8'&8&! %' :4"%'4 @
KK < G" 81!6"1 &"" ' 1" &' @6= !6" 33"44 '! &684# 6 7" :""' &H"# ! 31$""# 8'#"1 !6" 8 1#% ' '#G 1#&$! 11"$7"1%'5!6"$8&!#= !6"$6%4#,6"6 # $81&"!6"1%56!!#& 8! &6"6 # 4& $4" 11%56!! '1#"1 1!6"$8&!#= !6"$6%4#8'#"1,"$!%'>< !6"#"6" $! !6 !&6"6 # 1%56!8'#"1!6"8 1#% '& '#G 1#& $!%&'98&!% %$ !%' 1#"'=%'56"1!6"1%56!8'#"1 ,"$!%' >< 6 ! %& @"44 "&! :4%&6"# & @%44 33" 1
12!6"$ &"&6"1"%'
!"1$%!"#L'#"14%'%'5 ##"# +
&
"
"
"
#
(
67.
' "
5(&. "
'
%
"#
(
67."
&
(
.
"& &"
#
&
" " &
(
5. *
&
&
&
"
D & " &
:
:"8
A
B&
D
"
;
&
" &
&
" & " : A &
N #
(
67.
5(&. 6
" & '
5 (&. % & #
(
67. & & &
=
"&& "
5(&.
=
5 (&.
& 8 (#
.
4 ) &
A
&
#
&
4"
020,8
"
%
"
5 (&. $
" (#
. ;
"
D
&
"+
"
"
5(&.
& "
"
4
) &
& &
"
+
&
"
4
% &
" &
7%,6 'H"1 6 18' 44% 6%"
8&!%$" 8#5"
) *
9 ' A
' D
G@ A
G@