← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44238/2016allowed

Mandeep Saini v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2019-05-21Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj15 pages

 

   

   



 

  



    ! "

#$%& '()*+& !

'$!'!'

        





    



! 

 "

 # 

  $ %

!

'$!'!''

       &  '#        (    

    

  )*%  +

+     ,     -.  $ /0    %0 % %1/2

)12)%1.

+  





.' 

 

, (

     

  



 -. 

    

 (33 (  4

&  $ % 3  

 

 10 /1 %1/5

/6*

$

(.  

/**/7  

8



89   4    ,  $ 111/1) 111/15   

 :11111& 611111&

(4

;-.7 < /9(    

4  $ %

  (( 



 

 4   4 

' 

+ + 4 

 (3 #            ((

;

   7

94    

4

<      (    (( (4#

   4(   5111121111& 

 

;

               51111&   <  (4      

   1/)/111/1*1*)0%)3  $

(=#

.' 

 

3    

  ((    4 >  3    

43 (  4

?

((  <       ( #3    



 (   (  .

3  ((  

# 

@ #

# #  4  3 ((

   3    

(  (   ;

3 ((

  @ # 

 

(    

  

  

  :

%1/5(  3 

     3

+ 

 (3 #        



 @ #3 ((4 A'.



 

 .

3      

   ( 

 

   (  (43

  ,   

 :11111& 611111&     

                %6 (#   (  

  

              

    

 (    

   

   3    ( A   

    , 4  3  #  4       

     3   3  (

#  

 4    

7.9   , 4   %6 / %1/2  3 



4   & '#  ( 

 B 3 #   4        -. %0 % %1/2

)12)%1 .

+

.  



3  /) /% %1/2

;   C        

  4  (

( 

 -. 

  

  (

 

    

  /6*  $

(.  

4 

  .

 

((4

3                /1  (      <            ?    

 

(  

   ( B3        4 34 , %6 :

%1/51/ * %1/5 

  :( D 6( 

(4

 3 '-+=# =



 

 (  " (    '=  $  ( 7 9

 $

 1:

1) %1/:

. 3 ( 

   

 (+ ((  4

3  



 (43 (  4  4

    

F

( 



 -. (  

  

&



3 3



/6*

 ,   

 :11111&  611111& 43   7

  

9

   F

( 

 10 /1 %1/5

/6*

7 < 69



 



   /111111&

3

  3   

 

         ( 

 #           

            /111111&        ,   

 

     3  ;  7 < %94   $ %3   33 3  

       



  F

( 



   

   , 

4

3  %:

* %1/5     

& 

    -.(  

<  .

  

  -. (( 

   16 :

%1/53

3 4

/:

%1/23  (  

 



   (3 (   

 .

  

,

     -. 

3 (   

  

3    

     ((   

 

<  (( (   51111&       (

A

(

(   $ %

   

  ,   

  4



/6*



  

 

 (   55111&     

 61111& 1:

/1 %1/)  /1111& %% /1 %1/) /1111& 6/ /1 %1/) 5111& 15 // %1/) F

( 



    ( 3

 4 

   3  ((       ((4

  

  

     

3   

(4    (( 3

  

  (

(  <     ( 

  +    4



 ((<( (4  4     

  

(( 

 (

 3 3 4

/:

%1/53    

  (( 

    (4( 



   

$ %1/) ;((   3   #

     3 4

  3

  ;







  16 :

%1/53

(( (43



@ #



    

      #  4

    ;

$ %6  (  

9    

   (  

  ,   (( (4        :11111& 611111&

(4

;  

 /:

%1/53 ,  

 3 

  

3  

 3  3 



4   



@ # .

   (( 

((( 4

 

   

  16 :

%1/5 

  

        

 

,3 

 

 B 3 # 

((    >  (43       

  



/6*

 

  

,    :11111& 611111&

(4 4      ;    ,  "(4   %1/5 

4

  4

3 4   %:

* %1/5 ;    ( (4 (

   



3  



 

 

  /:

%1/5 

                

 ,3      (4  ;  

4 

 $

(.  

 /**/(443   3( 

   , 44     (4

( 33

     

  

   

)12)%1.

+

 4 (( (  

-

    (4    -.(  

    4        



       (

)12)%1.

+   ; 

  (    

  

)15.  (+ 

 ., / 01  ?        4        3    4    3   4         4    (4    

 

  3    4    (4   

  4  (

4 

(3       3     

          4  ( ( 



  <  ( 3 

      

    3 ((((44

 

 

G   (  

    # (  (    



  (    CH    4E C'    E  

   -. (           

 (

3 ( 4

 

  (4( 

   

  ; 4      C   E C   E( #     -.  

 B 

 

)12.

+ 

  

  ((4      

)/5 .  (+ 3  ., 02 ? 4    4 ( (4    (4               

( 4  4

4 



 4     ((      4    4 

 

((4       



 4   3 3 (



    3  

         3   

    ( #(4

  

   4 

  4  

G 

H<(

  

( 

   

3       

        

 (4           3 (

 (4      4   3

 

(  

; +  

(   

(( 



 

           ,        3  

(      3  4   ; (( (   <  (4 51111&3 4

 

4%1/)  

(

 

34  $ %  ,3  /111111& "(4&   %1/5  



  ;(( 



     (  ( 4  3





4  ,          3

4

3

     (  ( 4 ,3  ; 

 B  

 

)%1 .

+ ( 

  (

H #       3

((4    (     ((   4   

  3     

 7

9 (

   3 (

(   ( .  (+  .

3 ((

(4  

8(+  ) 03 )004

  )51630 +  ( ($ 0 %1/07   

F 7+( 9$ 5%%6 %1/*9  16 / %1/03   (

     (    4 (   3    

   -.3 , ;(     C

          

                               !                    

  "   

                     #

                       "     " " $ "         %&  $'&    ())  *+ , ,-

.

$   $    #            $       & /  / ,1

$      

             2.  #                  3     $   2.   $                    4    5 $ !      

      & / 01     6

    3 (((

   

8(+ <   3

)*%+

+

;   3

  

)*%+

+ 

(  

3   (

  

3 (  

 <     3 3 

  

 (3  . )" 30   0

$06%30



)17789)171  ,

<+ ( C; (( 3       434

 (( 

3  <   4 3

( %%2    3

)*%+

+  < 4 +  

  

 4

3 

   



   4

  (

(4 34  ((4    (4 (  (< (  ( 

  (

 < (  4 # 

3   3 (<  7/9 ?    (( 

            

 

  4 #   (    

          4    

    



  4       #         



7%9 ? (( 

      

 

    (    4  

4     -.    

  

 B(   4   

4   

/527/9 + <        3    3 

/55 7%9 + 

769 ? 

 (( 

  -.

  

((

   

  

  4   #     



7)9 ? (( 

  -. 





 B(     



  (4     

 B(

   

 

4

A                

(    

/557%9 + 

759 ? (( 

  -.

    (4  (   3     

(       

     



729 ?  <( (   4

    + 



7 3    (

    

9

 



 

  & 3              +      

 

     

       

7:9 ?   (

     (4

3  (     &   3    

     (

(4 

3 ( 

 3#   





3  3

  

    (  

?(  





 3 ,     (

   (< 4   (43  



  

 I

3 ((

   #       , 4   

  (  ( 4      

3       (( 

        -.   

 <   4    3

     4   

     

 

  

3   ;  33   4 +   :

;7 <3 %3 4

)7 '13   2 

-89  89-  -   ) = ;>4

)$089   89  ,-    

      ((      

 

        +   J      +     +  (



8(+ 3 ((  3   3 

)*%+

+   (( 3   

 7.)                     8       & .

.

9 :;   1 

$         $                             &   /<.       1 

 #       $  =     $ 

  $    1  $

                    &   /<.      1                      $               $   $        

                        " $> 

 & /<.

  1 "$   

        $$   6

         

     

 

   

4   3    



  3

 B ((   

      -.3 #4  

/::/:* +  +  (



( (  , 4  (   3   .--  3  7     ?1  3  H4

 ((   (4 ,  

  4

3  3 (

( 

3



- ; ?1  79?        3     (  (

(         3

 79 3   

 (4  (

(

  (4 

 3          

     





  (

( 

 79 3

   (

   

( 4 ,  

 4 +    

4  (

( 

( -.( 

3 4   

  16 :

%1/5 

3 

#( 



@ # (( 

3      ( A    (

3 (  3

  

   -.

(4 

  (

)12)%1.

+  ; 

  (  4 4

 

(4    (4   (        (       

;   +    3((  3     ( #    

 (  

4

   ,   -.    (  

       (4(

   

   



((4  

 

)12)%1.

+ 3  -.    ;4 3   

 

  

 

(     

     

  3



 (  

(      #        



  

3 (4

, 

     ( -.     



. 3  

         +       <   3 

)*%+

+  -. 

    

 (3 (  (4   -.$ /0 %0 % %1/2

 )12)%1.

+  





.' 

  

      4,

;

 (( 3

  



 8 !

'$!'!'9 @6 !

6 '(5& ? #  &  K&$ ?  ( K&$