High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6189/2013allowed

Sumit Gupta And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2016-05-24Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan14 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 24.05.2016 Sumit Gupta and others 4..Petitioners versus State of Haryana and another 44Respondents CRMM 32705 2013(O&M) Amit Gupta and others 4..Petitioners versus State of Haryana and another 44Respondents

CORAM:

Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh

! " # $

Kuldip Singh, J.

% &'( &) ''

*+,-./+ $0-1

++1$203+$0-1'4 &'# $1- $0-- $, 2 $0-- &

& '& $1 2 $0--

56 17'8 $+9

:;) # $2/$/ -- $0-0 <$0<,1 <,3<,.<2--$0+%) &' !

& -. -$ $0-$ 56 37 8 '

& 8 8 ' <$0 <,1 <,3 <,. <2- -$0+% ) '& 84 & ;8&6

*+,-./+$0-1 ) 9; := &:9> ) :9 ':= & :

& &

-/3,

:' ' :' ' 8 !

(

8 @ &8' );8 $0-0 ' 9

: 8'

' ''8& # -0!''# $<9$ 51+07$39-5,+-$7 # --!''# $15<+--7<5$+-07 # -<!''# <5.+07352+--7,5.+0725.+-07-,9-53+,7 # -3!''# 19$9$9$50+<71915-+-$7<9-9-5$+<7 ''&% A '

& '' ' '

'8'

' '' ' ' 4 8 '& && ' ' 8'

' ' %'& 8 ' ''& ' &'8&?"# -<21-. $ $0-0 ?"# -<2<-. $ $0-0?"# -.3-.,-..'' < 3 $0-0'

&' : &6 & '8'&

8 : '" '

8 4 < : 4 -./< 5 B C7 -- $ $0-0''8 # 3-< , $0-0 8 :4 >

& A '" 4 ''

& ' 8 ' 88 '& ' 8 ' & '9; := &: ''

8 ' '8' ' ' '' 8

' A '

& :4 ''

& ' A '8' &8 ' 8& '& & '' > 8 ''&;) # $2/ $/ -- $0-0 <$0<,1<,3<,.<2--$0+%) & ' !

& 56 -7 ) &' 56 $78 ' & '

& 4 ' ' ' 8 " :4 '' ) # $<<, "'

88 ' 8 &' 8 '& A -2 , $0-0 8"6 - -$ $0-0 )

*+,-./+$0-1

'' ' ) ' ' '

'' & & ' ' ' '' '' ''8 A 8 ' A ''& '''& + 5-7 '# -<21-<2/-. $ $0-09 ; := &:9> ) : ' 9 D'& : = & : '

5$7A '# -.3-.,-.. < 3 $0-0 & ''' &21"'

-' $1"'<'4 8 '4 E8

&# 3 -< , $0-0 A & '-. $ $0-0, "'<''' -2'4 8 ; '' 4 ; ''' &--"'

-/'' --"'--'4 > '< 3 $0-0$"''' 4 A'''

/."'-.' 12"'-$'4 8 :4 > E8D

& &

132./2019+ 4 ' &12 "' -$ ' 8 8 & @

& 8 && )' < -- $ $0-0 # , -/ $ $0-0# 3 -< , $0-0 ) '6 ( " < '< 3 $0-06 ''' < '' '6 8& && & 8 ''&& + - # < -- $ $0-0 ' '

' $ )''& & @& &

132./201-2 , $0-08 &8 : 4 '' '' '' - -$ $0-0 &

1/$0<$0/ ) '' && @&''&''

8 ''' 6 ' & ' & 8 A & ' : ' ' F8'

"#$ %

& $ '( ) *+, - -

.. 8 8 && 8 8&& ) & ( 8 8' & '

' '8' F8'

,/, $ , '( )+*

, - - 01 ) & ' '' 8 ' 2&3 $ ,

# 5

# +$1,<.$0-37 $- / $0-34 & : ' & &8 ' 8 ' & ' 8& ''

' 8' !%$ ,

# (

# ,13-$+ $0037-0 - $002 ;

' 8' / 4$ #3- ))1

(* - (- *0)' $0$$01$-0 ' ''''' A & : ' +' ' & ' ' 8&

" '4 (' A '

6 & & A < 8 -- $ $0-0 '' &&

@ & A & ;''8"& '' 8 '& '8 )8 < -- $ $0-0 A '' 88 ' ' 8' '& "&-2 $ $0-0 $1 $ $0-0D&' # A-. $ $0-0 6 '-. $ $0-0 ) ''&8 ' '4 ''

' A < A

8 ' ''"8 < ) 8' -2 $ $0-0 "& 6 -. $ $0-0 A ' 8 "8 < ' -2 $ $0-0 -. $ $0-0 8' ' 6 -. $ $0-0 A ' 8 8 '< 3 $0-0 '6 & <-3 ) +

$' $

$ $

' 55 8"

8 < 3 $0-0 84 ' 6 8 '

'' )'8 8 '&

<-- $ $0-0 8' 84 ' -2 $ $0-0-. $ $0-0$1 $ $0-0 A '-. $ $0-0 8 8 < 8 8 >< 3 $0-08 88

<, A 4 8"8 A "8 8'' ) '"' 8 ' 6 && 8&&'9 ' 8 & '&4 ' A 8 ' ' '6 & ' ) ' 8 56 $7 ''

#& ) '''

@& & )' '' ' '8 '' 4 ' '4 ' '

@ &

# $<<, " '

88 8 4 ' '

'' ' '' & ''' ' 4 8 '4 A -2 , $0-0 " '' '& + ''- -$ $0-0 A "'

8 & @& 132./201 8" 1/$0<$0/ A '' '' 8 8" # 4 ' "' 8 & 8 ''''8 & &8 ' '' 8 '&'G ) ' '' ' 4 ' 8 8 6&8 A 8 & 8 ' '

132./201 8 & ' A ' '' ' ' &' 8 ''

' && & ')& &&8 ' ' )' ?(

&9 ':= &:-< 3 $00.8 8&& 8 6 ' $0-0 )'

&9>) :1 -0 $00/ ?(

& 9D'&:= &:-1 3 $00. ' 8 $0-0 '6 A 8 ''8' & ) ' ' 4 8 : 4 '' ) ' '

' 8 & ''' 4 8 "'& & 4 & ' ' ' 8'(&' 4 '8 ) & '6 & ' # & 56 17 ) '

:'':'' 8 !

(

& & 8

; := &:9>) :9

' : = & : 8 ) & 8' 8 ) 8 + +' & & &-.

-$ $0-$ 56 37 &'' & '' "&@ && ' -21 8 8 ' && + +'''# $1-$0-- ) '' E $-0 & '& &8 " 88 ' ''& ''8 ' &56 37 ' ) ' 8 ' & ) &56 37 -.

' " & 86"'

)' '' " 8 " + '& > ' '' 84 ' '

''8 ''& &

84 8 '' ;) # $2/$/ -- $0-0 <$0<,1<,3<,. <2--$0+%) &' !

& $1 2 $0-- 56 17 & -. -$ $0-$ 56 37 8 % &' '' 24.05.2016 (Kuldip Singh) 3 Judge