High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-CARB/17/2023dismissed

M/S Dashmesh Rice And General Mills, Hathoor v. The Punjab State Grain Procurement Corporation Ltd. And ANR.

2023-09-20Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan14 pages

! "# $!%&'&"( ) )

" " " *+ ) , ),) , -+ *+ ,) , . -

# $

"% & ' ( "% & ))))) . -/ ) * + & "

" *, &

-.*/ 0 0 " "" .1.,-.*2 3$ " ,4 &

*551 6& 7 89 3 "

" " 3" ""

.-.:-.*4 6;

<*9 3 " 0 " " "" *,.,-.-, 6;

<*:9 " $ ""

= "0 !

" 3 "

" & 0" " ""

.1.,-.*2 3 " 0 % 3

- % & " " >* "

0 "" -.*.-..5 6;

<-9 3$ " 0" ""$ & -..5<*. ?

$ 0 "" -/*.-.*. 6; <,9 3 ;

" 3 & -.*.<** +

" %"

3 0 0 -,5-41: ?

& $ -..5<*.

3 0 0 -,:4./.

" " %" @"

& A"

6& 7@ A89 "

<% $ & " & @ A + & "

% B >141/ & -.** & 0 & & "

" "

& & 0 &

& -.*.<** + & " 3 3 " & % " " "" .2.4-.** 6;

<49 3 "

" " " &

" 3 3 3 " & 3% " " 3 " 3 $ " >*

& "

>*141 & -.** & 3

" " & % " " "" *5.,-.*- 6;

</9 $ % 0 $ & & " & 0 % -* " >* & " & %$ & 0 "" -.*.-..5 " -, & & C " 0 <

<= @"

% "

0 3 & " & & %$ & 0 "" -/*.-.*. + & " " %$

& %" "

0 3 &"

0 ' <" >- 3 "

" $

" 3 " 0 & " $ "

" 3" "" .-.:-.*4 " "" & %$ & *.*/.2/,:< 03 D *-E & " &

& F " & /....<

" " "

0 -- + %" " ,4 & $ & 0 " 3" "" .-.:-.*4 3% " 3 "

" $ ""

= "0

" % " 0" " "" .1.,-.*2 -, + & " " 5 & 3 $ ( $ " >* 3% " 3 "

" % " " "" .:.*-.*1 + % 3

& " $ 3 3" $ ""

= "0 !

" % " " "" *,.,-.-, " " 5 & & " $ 3 "

" & % " " "" *,.,-.-, 6;

<-*9 $ 0 =0 ! & ( 0 ( & 3 & &&

& "

& @ "

3 " &&

& 3" & $ ""$

( " & "" % &&

& & 0 % & $ A 3 "" $ $

( " & & " >* , + ""

= "0

" " " ,4 & $ "

0 $ " %

3 "

" $ A 3 %"

0 " $ & "

0 & "

" *: & 0 3 "$

" &

& 2..< ?

& $ -..5<*. " & 5..< ?

& $ -.*.< ** &

3 "

3 " 0 "

" 3 A 3 & %" "

" $

& 0 $

+ " $

" "

$ & 3 @ A 3 " & "

" $ A 3 %" 3"

$ 0

$ 4 !"

& "" "

0 3 &" " >- 3 " " $

" 3" "" .-.:-.*4 6;

<*9 3 "

3 0 + 3 3 3" &" $ C " 0 <

<= @"

% "

0 " 3 " $ " >-

" &&" " 3" ( & 3

" $ ""

= "0 !

" 3 "

0 " ,4 & / ' 0 % 3 " $ "

& " % $ & " <( 3 " & "

" 1 B % "" " $ "

: + & ,4 & " &

" ,: & "

" $ 8 ; !

3 $ !

" % & " 6-.--9 4 **1 3 %" $ 8 ; " #<

! ! !

" ##$ % & '

& !

)

! &

+,-+-+-

! !

.. ,/0 & "

" &

& " &

.. &

1 &

4 5 !

& ( 6

& )* , $

9& !

& 2

& &

1 7 "

" : $ ! +6- % '

; & % .

) , $

! &

1 . " 6 5 % & = = ' > ?! % & !

& #:

" " & @

% A

= " ?! % ' :

& $

) . BBB"

& "

& &

8 !

& .,

4 ?(" & "$:

+"- % ,0 "% & ;

$ % ,.1 ,/ " : $ ! +6- % +

4 &

) ,0 # &

& !

$ &

1 , !

9 # 9!! C %D9# % E ' A " %

) , "

! &

= : $ ! +6- % &

; & % D: $ ! +6- % &

; & %

$ & ) , $

! &

& 2

1 "

! $ : $ ! & ) + , ,0- ,0 # &

& !

$ &

1 D

E1 2 B % "" " $ "

& 3 3 & & & "

0 & " >- & " ""

.-.:-.*4 6;

<*9 "" $ $ % "

0 3 %" $ 3$ & & -,./-.*4 "

3 " & & .4.1-.*4 3% "<& 6 9 "

" " +&

3 0 " & *2.1-.*4 "

" 0 % & " & ;" C 3 & & *2.1-.*4 0

3 " & .-.:-.*4 3% " %

" & & +& %" " 69 "

$ & "

& "

0 3 "

" " 3" 3 " 5

& 3" "" .-.:-.*4 6;

<*9

" & " $ " " $ 3 "" $ ""

>1 & 3" + & %"

>: & 3" & & 0 3 6 " ""

9 " 6 9 " & C " 0 *:.5-.*- "

" & "

0 "

0 $

+ & "" $ "

0 3 "

" 3 & + ( " "" *,*--.*- " $ '

3 & <& 3 "$ " % 4:

( &

& $ -..5<*. " 5-

( & $ -.*.<**

3 & "" 3 % 0 (3"0 & "

0 " "

" & " >- & "

0 3 &" &

*. !"

& & " " >* ""

( "

$ " " & 0

& " " ( 0 " %$ &

& $ -.*.<** 3

& $ -..5<*. 3 &" & & + &&" 0 & $ -.*.<** "

% ( ""$

$ & ""$ & $ -..5<*. 3 "$ "

& 3

" %" @ A + " $ & @ A & 3

" & */....< 0 "" "& "" ./.:-.** 6;

<19 " $ & **....< 3 " $ 3$ & "" "& "" .,./-.** 6; <:9 ** + & & "" ( "

" $

% &

& " " "" *.*.-.** 6;

<29 0 *--4*:. ?

& $ -..5<*. " -1/,/4 ?

& $ -.*.<** 3 % &

0 $

% &

+ 3 "$ ( % $ " >* " 3 0 &

A 3 & 0" % &&

& " >* "

% &

& " " ""

*-*--.** 6;

<59 % &$ 0 % $ & ( &

$ -..5<*. " -.*.<** " " 3 0 & (

& " $ A 3 & "" ?

% &

"" *..:-.*4 6;

<*.9 " *2*--.*: 6;

<**9 3 0 &

*- A 3 " 3

"$ & " >* 3 "

" ( $ " %

( $ 0 " "

" % % & &

(

" $

*, !"

& "" 3 & & " & $ " "

0 0 & " >* 3

3 & 3 ( 3 " % ( 3 & " >* 3% & % (

" $ % "" $ ""

= "0 3 "

0 " ,4 & *4 B % "" % + %" '

3 & <& 3 "$ "

& " &

" ""$ " 3 "$ $ G & " $ 3 & <& "

"" "

" & + "" % "

3 $ @ A 3 "$

" %$ &

& 0 & + "

% 0 0 " 3 " " "0" $ 3 0 & @ A

3 0$ " $ " "" $ " "

*/ B % "" " $ "

& " $ & 0 ""$ & & @ A "

" $ 0 "" "& 6;

<1 <:9 "

" % %"

" ( $ & 0"

3 0$ %" $ $ & "" "& "" ./.:-.** ""

.,./-.** 6;

<1 " <:9 0 */....< "

**....< %$ "

&% & 0 @ A !

" "3 3 0 $ " & 0 & ""$

3 &" $ @ A A & "" "& 6;

<1 " <:9 "

&% & 0 @ A !

" "

3$ " 3 $ " $ " $ 0"

0 & & 0 ""$

& & @ A + " $ "

" ;

& 0 & ""$ 3 0 &" $ @ A " " *1 + & "

% % &

;

<2 <** " " 3 0 & ""$

" B % ""

" & & 3 (" + % " & & & + "

" $

0 & 3 & "

0 &

" $

" 0 " 3

3 % " & ""

= "0 +

<2 " <59 & *.*.-.** " *-*--.** %$ 0 & 3" "" .-.:-.*4 C& 0 3" & " " ,1 & + 3 "" $ & 6;

<*19 & % & "

0 3 0 " ,1 & 0 " & < $ 3 3 "

&& 0 & $ -..5<*. " -.*.<** %$ 3% 3 & " $ "$ $ & @" " 0 3 0" 0 0 0 % 0 0" $ & & <& & " ( 3 0 3

% " & ""$ 3 " " "$ 0 "

69 3 " 3 $ A 6;

<*19 3

3 & " *:.1-.*,

3 ( 3 "$ " 3 0 " %

& -..5<*.

" $ ; & 0 &

@ A 3 % 0 0 & + " 0 " & & & 3

& 0

"$ "

0 A & $

0 " & " & & & & "3

"" & " % " "

*: + 0 $ & "

0 %" $ 3 $ ""

= "0 !

" 3 0 0" "

$ 0 "

0 3" 3" & %$ & *.*/.2/,:< 03 D *-E 3 " 0 $ -.*4 " & & .5 $ $ " " >*<

" 0% 0 F 3

" 0 3

& &"0 *2 + 0 " 00 $ % 3 "

% ( $ 3

& " % " $ ""

= "0 !

" 3 0

0" " *5 A % 3 & % 3 & "

$ "

" 3 & -....< " $ " >*

) ,) , -+

. -

) ) % ( B ( 0 "

H> B H>