← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19938/2006dismissed

Nagar Council Samrala v. Surinder Pal

2015-03-25Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih8 pages



    

    

    

        







 % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+ (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/((    0%1    0%1    0%1    0%1 2 % % 2 % % 2 % % 2 % % %. (4 5 %. (4 5 %. (4 5 %. (4 5  % 0%1  % 0%1  % 0%1  % 0%1 " " " " 







 % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+ (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/((    0%1    0%1    0%1    0%1 2 % % 2 % % 2 % % 2 % % 6()**/( -*4 5 6()**/( -*4 5 6()**/( -*4 5 6()**/( -*4 5  % 0%1  % 0%1  % 0%1  % 0%1 

++ 

++ 

++ 

++  % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+  % &'()*"+,"#+ (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/(( (-( ),%(/((    0%1    0%1    0%1    0%1 2 % % 2 % % 2 % % 2 % %

4 5

4 5

4 5

4 5  % 0%1  % 0%1  % 0%1  % 0%1 '& '& '& '&  86'

 %  86'

 %  86'

 %  86'

 %

 66 

 66 

 66 

 66 

5 & ' /5*%*(/(( 3'5*( 3* 9(, 3 )(5,!

*9

 '5%

(% -*,3 )(,!

59

3   ' %'(

,33

(3 )( (,

7(:,!

59

3    **  9 5  !   )(  ;59(95  /(<  : ( ;3 5*7.3-/ =%> " :!3 * 9  

=% ***7.3-/ 5* .3:9 3 * 3-5=%>   

 66,0 (1 

 66,0 (1 

 66,0 (1 

 66,0 (1 33(3#+"##$0

?. @1,9(553:< *6(:

.,6.3*( (,3;*)**(99)(

5/(3 :<*;

%. (,6()**/( -*( (/ %( ,.

3%)

@0"1 !* 3.5(59.5),  BC0!

5* 8*)81,)(/ -;(-5!

-53

%(.3(<5,  ;  9(<  ())93,  5  : -  (55(3    *5 9

     ;

.3  :  (99 5    9   .  *  *(  * *(

9!3  (55(* 3 D.5

% ),  (  *  *  (99)(

5,  (5   3)(3  (:

,  ; 3)333() //

36A;5,*5 35*(3)3 *5*;9

50

5

 ,

( 3

++,( !"##$1

(5 *5,* (!,;

.3:!3 :< * - (9 5

5:!

*6(:

.  5* , *(99)(

5/ 3:<*;

3%)

@0"1 !*),*<)(/3 *((5*<

 53*'( 

<%(.3(<,;*)**(99 3

:( !!3(< (9(3* 3(< (*39(/ 5>9.:)

!!)5>.

3(A -5.

3* 7(:  / ,*!

, *<; ;(-5!

35)*(- -3.5

(* 3(< *)(/,*(;(55 . *5-(3(35,(5*.5&@     







       

    

 

   

  

      

 



 !   !  "   #$ %  

 !!     3! ),    ;(5  9(33,     ((,  *(  * 33

().(<;

A3. -*359.39

()*( 3<%(.3(< 3 !(),%. (,6()**/(

% -*( 3  ;- -E$B##>@,EBC##>@( E+###>@,9/

*,(5(5) (<,59)<5*;

((3(

/( < ))(5

5

%(.3(<5,%.

3(<5(

*(F3 * 3(<5,*!

,*<;



)(/;(-5!

-;

(*%(.3(<5 !(),* ().( ./: !3(<5;* *;

, 33,53* '( ;39)3 

?.@,(99 33;** ;   ;(5)(/3*(*;

33

*(( <?5 --* )(/5((<!

-;

%(.3(<5  :<

3  (  9 3  !    <(5,  :!

  ! -  !  * (99)(

5

()

53(

!*/( 55.( 3* 3 )

) 3,*6(:

.!

3*(*   ;

A/( @

 %. (0@1)

)33 *5) 55@?(/ (

*(,( /5,%(.3(<5!

((F3>(

(* 3(<( 3**(3 (5 9 )33

(

)@;)

%(.3(<  .*,* .3

5(<;**

?.@,(99 33;**;

5(/ ,!3:<*'( ,;(5) ) 

*( : -  5 ,    ;(5  :53  *(  (* .-*  *  ;

A/(  *(3 )(/3 EB",B##>@!

-  53 

 "# %(.3(<5,:.

* -  ;(5  : .-* 

 ) 3    5* ;  (5   * ;  *  5(3 (/ ;(5)().(3*(5,*3 

?. @,(99 33;**; ,9 3* ./:

!%(.3(<5!

;*)**;

A/( *(3().(<;

A33. *  359.3  9 3   5  *  )(5  5  .    *  ;

5(/   5!  ;(5  *(  *  ;

A/(  ;(5 

   3  

;(-5:<

3(9 !<(59  * 5.

!* (99)(

,  *!

,  *  ;

A/(  ;(5   3    ) ;(-5!

-;

%(.3(<5!

(9 !<(5 9     *  ! -  !  *  (99)(

   $#

 

$#"##"   .*,  (5  /(3  .  ! /  *  3 0

?.@1,*/( 3

(!

(9 ! 3(<5, *!

,*;(5*3 *(;

A3!

BC%(.3(<5 +$  G   H  BC   )) 3 -<,  ( 3  (5    ! )    * 3)5

!*

8:%.9/ . '.

)9(/9 <5

0 -31%* 3( *55%( ! 7(:( *5, 0"###1 %.9/ .(55B",;(5)

).33*(* A/( ;(5 );(-5!

-53

BC%(.3(<5  6A;5,;

A/( @6()**/( -*;(5(5

*3 3!

;(-5!

-53

%(.3(<5;!

 $#

 $#"##"(9 !<(5:!

! *(99)(

 539)3 *3 ,

?.@, 5 ) */( 3 

 ( 

%(.3(<5 3. - * 5(3 9 3,*!

,*().(<;

BC%(.3(<5+$ G   H  BC    3    (5  -(35  (/  %( ,    ;(5

).33*(*,

,;(5 );(-5!

53

%(.3(<5;!$#

 $#"##" 3(55 /(3 .! /*3 0

.?@1,*/( 3

(

B%(.3(<5,*!

,*;(5 ;(-5!

 B"3(<5+$GBHB"  5.( <,;

%. 3

( ( 3 6()**/( -*;*3  *(;

A3 !

BC %(.3(<5! /$#

 $#"##",(

;(5*3 *(;

A3!

B"%(.3(<5*'( ;(53)3 /(A*D.59(</ ;* $/

*5 ;* 5(*( !$I9(

./,! /*3( !

(99)(

$#"##" *55* ;,(5 3)(3(:

,*'( 5 :!

*5 . *59

*(*(3*( 3) 5!

*9(5( 9.53*9(9:

A 6( 3 ) 5!

*9

5/9<5A5

(*5.:/55

5*(;(3( )3:!

*6(:

. .  ( 3  7)3  (!  (  3.  ( 3  ) /9* 5

53(

;*(5.-35*( .C0(1 !* 7(:

'.

)9(%(!(J((/)*(%) .5, B0!

5* 8

.581, 5(-5*(()*//:5*(*((9(3* 3(<

)  (  ;A  ( 3    (

(   3(<5    "$* ( .(<,  +*

 .-.5( 3"

3 ) :,( 3B ** 3(<5(* 9

!

*//:

( < !*!5(559)!3 99 3?88

 35  *(  (5  *  ;

 ;  -  3  .

3  *5

.5,*!

,*<; :-(3 ;

A!

$3(<5(;A ( 3,*.5,*)(/!

;(-5!

-;

%(.3(<5 ;(5;* </5)

)3

  )

(,  ( 3  ) 5  !

  *  59

3 @ )

 35*(*5))

3

5 !*;

; 

  -  3  :<   B  .5  ( 3,    !(),  :<  7(:

'.

)9(/9 <50(5521%) .5, $0!

5*  8 $ .581  3*;

;/9 <3(5(55@2 /9 <5 ,3(( 3'(>3(%*)

 35*( * $ .53

)

( ( <9 5

;*)* 5(-5( $3(<58;A!

*/9 <5-  3.

3*5(3 .5 %*!.*5.:/5*(5 )*6(:

.())93* )(/ !*;

*:(55 !*3 0

?. @1,  9 3.)3  :<  *  '(   5!,  *(  5* ;3  * ().( ./: !%(.3(<53. -*9)3 -*<(5 ! /*3( !! - !*(99)(

5,;

*(3;

A3 !

,

 ! )5;(( 3 * 3: -(55(3

(3.( 3* .-*!.)

53(

!*/( 55.,(/ !*)

533;*(*59

5( ;* <3 3 !/( 3(,*.5,(: :35/553!

 *(5

5*((: -) 33* (!

)33<,  * )(5 5  . :< *  '( 5! 5; ;(5*(*;

;

 ;(-5:<

3(9 !*<(59)3 -*

 3(  !  *  (99)(

5      0

?.  @1  ;(5 9 3:<

 **( *'(  5* ;*(* %. (( 36()**/( -*,*(3, 33, 53*'( !

BC%(.3(<5,(

!

 B"%(.3(<5,! /#$#

 $#"##" 59 *(: -5 ,*;

) .35:393 !*;(-5  !*<*(3 3353

%(.3(<5,!.

3* .5  -*5),*<; :-(3 5$3(<5 ( ;A.*(5

5  ( )9()3:<( 3) 5!

 *  9

  .9

  B  .5  5  ;* <  /59()3

)33<,;

; -(-3(5(55@2/9 <5( ;  ;

A -  (5  ,  3(  ( 3  '(>3(,  59)< *59)!)5 ! .5*(-  *5))

3

5( * $ .5,*!()*(5

359.3:<*( 3 5!

*9

 6( 3) 5!

*9

 .3

9  .( <9 5

.

3* $ .5;*)* 5.(5($3(<5;A!

((55@2/9 <% /.)*5 ,

*( <* - *5-(3;(55 .:<*'( 5; :!

*6(:

.

( <5.)* (-./ ;(5(3( )3  7.5*(,

* -59()3

) 3 !*59

 5.:5( (5.)*(9( 6( 3) 5!

*9

) .3

9  . (5 * ;*)

).5

*(*(5: (3(:<*6(:

. .;(5*)

(< *9 5

) 3 5.!!3 ! /( </((-(<  *;(A !*9 5

(55 .(:

,* *(3<?55( <- 3,(59(.5: (;,  !;*

 * 3: -(55(3 *95 9

*5(/: 3 3 !/5,()) 3 -<,35/553 ' "+,"#+ ' "+,"#+ ' "+,"#+ ' "+,"#+     0

 661 0

 661 0

 661 0

 661 J( J( J( J(