High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2780/2023disposed of

M/S Thind Motion Films Private Limited v. Ishdeep Randhawa And Others

2023-05-04Mr. Justice Vikas Suri20 pages

#"$%&% '

(

)* (

+ ,-+ +

! " !# " $ %%%%% ,-+ +.

$ & "

''( )

$ "

## *+*,'*'- .

) /& # 0/& 1 2 & .

3 4&"

. # $ $ # $ 5/ 6 *,*,'*'-

.$ $ $$7 8& !# "

$ 8& $ " &" $ "& 3$ $

& 1$ 9 "

$ . # $ :

!# ) . 4

;&<9

!# ) # # ="& +'+*'*+'.

# . $

$ & $&

$ " & $, ** ***3 $

8& !# & #

.. #

8& !# *-++'*'' & .

! / ;& $$

$& $$ "

8& ;& ## $ . # !# ) . 4

;& " " > 7

1 4 1 4 ) $$ $ " &

# $ " #

) $94 !# ) /& #0! 1 2 & " 8& ;& " > $

1&# "

" & $$ "

:/ < .# " & $ *,*,'*'- $ ."

$$3 ?

+ ' & # $ 3 ?

# 1 4

0 $ ?

'2 #

$ &# &. " # .

$$ 8& ;&0 $ ?

-2 $ 3

" $ . $ &" .

7 ?< & .

!8& 7!#! $& "

" $ $ .

$ $ 31 4 1 4

- & *+*,'*'- # " & A -B& + '))$ # $ 3 4&"

A 3 4&"

# .

$ $ # $ :/ < *,*,'*'- =" & "

= $ # *C*,'*'-

" & " $ 3 4&"

. & .

.& "

$" $ $

$$"

*C*,'*'- &# ) 1 "

" &

& $ "

&# & 0 =& 3-2 .$

$$3 ?

+ '"

.& $

& #

# ) &# # # +'+*'*+'

. $ " # " 33 $$ & "

"$". !"

@' ) # +B,(0$ 5 62

.$ ) /& #0/& 1 2 # &# *+*,'*'- "

. .$ 1 "

) # 4& "

" ) ) # 4& "

$ $:1 "

'0D2

) $) " &

D A "$" E& .# &

& # # &# .# .

& A D-& +02)) " # " $

. &.

.# !"

@' " #&$$$ 4& "

$."" $ & 4& "#.$ &# &

# $ $ & $4& " . "

" $ #& &# .

" .

# & =&3-2 &3 5!& $ # $4& # "$ "

$$"

# #

="& .

$ ?

- $ &

$ &.E& # $ $ ## #

$ . # $:

!# ) F .

;&<

# &

# & &# &. " # &"

G # +'+*'*+' .

8& ;& G !# )

$ & $$.

"# &

!& $

4&"

# $

&" # &" . $ $ ## #

$ . # $ :

!#) F. 4

;&<

, $ # $4& # "$ 4&"

# $ #

$ 5/ 6 . # $:

!#) F. 4

;&< *,*,'*'- &# "

$& &#

&. " $# $ & $$ A? 9> !! A A ?1 1A)H>? I >1>?)> %%%% $ " $ # $ "

$$"

# #

="& .

$ ?

- $ &

$ &.E& # $ $ ## #

. # $:

!#) F. 4

;&<

# &

# & &# &. " # &"

G # +'+*'*+'.

8& ;&G

!#) $ & $$.

"# "

& " $

4&"

# $

&" # &" . $ $ ## #

$ . # $:

!#) F. 4

;&< "$ # $4& # "$ 4&"

# $ #

$ 5/ . # :

!#) F. 4

;&< *,*,'*'- &# "

& &# &. " $# $ & $$

. $ & $$ # $

$ 9 <.

) $ . $ & $$ # $ 6

@ &. #& & . #

& # $

!# ) $ # ) # " $ !"

@' "

& $"

D @ C B +' " & 3 D $ ?

# $&

8& !#

# +'+*'*+' # $&

# . # !#)

& . # !# )

# "

& # & &

# # #

# # "

& ".

4& "

# .$& # & .

$"E&# # # $ # . # $ $!

!#) "E& .

!8& !# "

# . .#

$8& !#

" $ # # &.E&

$& & ! 8& !# &$$# $ $

%%% @ $$"

$ ?

- 08& ;& $ ?

+ & 2 " 0'2 " > 0-2 7

0D21 4 1 4F0,2 ) ## $ . # $ :

!#) F. 4

;&< $

(

$ ?

' &" $ ?

- 1"

&" $ ?

D ,

# $ A E& $$"

$ ?

+# #$ & $ $ # #

$ . # $ :

!# ) F . 4

;&< !

$$ " $ # +'+*'*+' ="& .

! 8& ;& $ &

$ ! 8& !# $& E&

# # #

="& .

$ ?

+ $ & $

# &

$ &

$ :

!# ) F . 4

;&< $& &

# # .& "&#

& !

$$$

" &

8& ;&

6# .

" # "

$ ! 9 !# )/0!12 & "

$ & $$ 8& ;&

$ . # :

!#) F. 4

;&< '+*-'*'- &

#.$ "

$= $ *-*,'*'- $ $ # " /"

!/"

02 %'!

3#"3 %& !! $/"#

%%% C $ &# "

" & 8& ;&

$$ $& "

:/ < .# .

$ " "

& "

# #

C *,*,'*'- $ #

$ &# &. " # . $$ $ ?

:/ <. $ &" .

5 7 ?<

& !8& 7!#! $ & # #

*,*,'*'- $&

$ $ "#

) ! 01 4 42 4

;& ;

;&0? ;2 "

" $ .

57 ?<!

# & 3 #?

'@ # ?

' J !# ) # $

"& $& &

-+ ) "

#$ # #?

D( G !# )

;&< $ # #

;& "

# $ ) #

!" G !# ) $ 7 $

)

!# ) F . 4

;&< &#

" $&

B .

$ "

9 1 4 4

$ $$# $ #E& .& $

#&E& $$ $$ $$ $$"" & ="

.# & B $$ E& $

# &" . $ .

## #

$ . # $ :

!# ) F . 4

;&< .& $

$ ?

D 1 1 4 .# "

# "

$ # $ . # !# )

;& "

" >

> > "$"

$ "

8& ;& 1 4 1 4"

" "

# #

$ %%% +' "& $"

$$ $ ?

- !8& !#

# # +'+*'*+'

!8& !# " 8& ;&$ "

$ $:

!# ) F . 4

;&< &# $

&7 # " . #

$ :

!# ) F . 4

;&<

&# $ "

&7 # "

. # $ :

!# ) F .

;&< H!

) ! 8& !# $$ " $ ?

+ # +'+*'*+' E&

. #

+* :

!# ) F . 4

;&< & &

8& ;&

$ .& &

$ ?

+ #

# # $ & $ " > # $ $1 4 1 4 ) $$ "

$ ) !& " # $$

. # $:

!#) F. 4

;&< $$ $& "

$ "

" "

5/ 6 $$"

# &

5/ < $$ E& $

$ &

5/ < .& $

#&E& $$

*,*,'*'- $

& $

" "

. 4+"$!% '

56 5 6 $

K 02 " &" " L 02"

#$ L 02 & "

38& %'

9/%$/ $ 013%:/!

&;<&%&!&K0+2 !&.4"

++ "

&. &# $

K 02 # " &" " L 02"

#$ L 02 & "

# 0'2) #

&. "$ &.3"

0+2

" $!"

D* !"

D+

& K 02 " $&.

$ &.

$ &" &.

" " &

$ " 7 $ L 02 " $&&.

$ " "

& & $ # " 7 $

" L 02 " $ $ " "

& " K " $ $4 & "

$#"

# "$

&.3"

. $ .

& 0-2) #

&. K 02 "

# $ $ &. $ $# #

L 0.2 & "

# "

" &" $ # & "

# "

# &" .$#

+' 0D2"

# "

#$ & "

$$"

# "

$" &. $" $ " . & "

# 0,2 " $ $ " "

& "

" ""

" $"

(" '%':

$ 013%:/!

# 6 ="

& # &.4"

& # $

$ &. $

K 02 " $ " &"

.#"

& # K 02

&" $ "

& #

# $ & .

"L 02

.# ""& L 02

$ &.

" "

"L 02

# $ & "

L 02

&.3"

&02

02L 02 " $"

& # K 02

"$ "

&02L 02

# "

" $$$ $ "

" "

& #

+- &""

& # # $

.4"

02 " $ " K 02

&" $ "

& #K 2

# $ & .

L 02 "

3 $ L 0)2 "

3 $ 3 L 02

"L 02

.# ""& L 02

& "

#$ L 02

L 02

&.3"

&02

02L 2 " $"

#$ K 02

$ "

& #K 2

# $ # $ #

$L 02

# $ &.

L 02

# "

" $$$ $ &" $ L 02

&" $

"L 02 " $ & "

# K 02

& "

# .

# "

& #

# $ & .

+D 02

# "

" $$$ $ &" "

& "

#L 02

&" & "

" K

& "

" .

. ""& M

$ 013%:/!

"=$"0!

>%#"# %'

!/%& $!K ?

# # &.

&&.

& ""

$ .#$ " .&

# "

& . # # # 4& "

." & "

$ " %>%2 3"?"#%"&

%'3%':"?"'!

$ 013%:/!K0+2 G "

# . $# "

&" .

$ 4&"

# ""

. "

$ .

$ $# $# $ $

# & $ . # # &.

4&"

$# "$

$ .

$## "

""& " .

0'2G " $ " &"

" &.4"

$&.3"

+, 0-2 $!"

+- "

#$ & "

# & #

. & &.

" . "

" $ "

" # "

$ $# $ "

# &" . & & "

. &

" . 0-2"

" # "

$# $"

. " "

;3%&#%$!% '

$ ;3!

>"3 ? !!"3& 3%&%':

;'#"3 !/%& / 0!"3K0+2 > &

" " # # & ) "

$# $"

# $#

# $ .

#4& "

0'2

& $ &.3"

0+2 5 "

# 4& "

# ) $) " & +B*C0, $+B*C2

$ .# $ " "

& "

" $ 4& "

" #

# &

" #

&" "

" .&

$ #6

& .

# # !"

+D ="

& 7

# "

"$ "

+@ &. $ 5G 6 $ & !"

'0 2

" &" " L"

#$ L & "

5 6 #

" $# $ "

. #& . .

& $ !"

# # =" # .

.# $"

# $# $"

. $ &"

& $ $

" $ & =" $9#) <4& "

& "

''(

) $

" "

) " =) ! " "#$% $

" "

$ "& 9# ) "

$ =" $ & " & "

''( ) "

) $) .& &.

" =" "

) $ $)

.& &.

. =" .

9# ) =" $ & " 9#) "

4& ."&

) &.

+( .

4& "

. #

=" $ $"& "

''(

)

. &

& $4& "

$ & $4& "& &

$ " $&"

# .& ) &.

9#) &

' #()

$%.

=) =#

# $

& !"

+(-

+BCC

$ . $

9#)

& "

''( ) $ . & 4& "

$ 9# ) & "

''( ) $

$ "

.& "

&" $ ="# & & "

''( ) 9# )

9#) $ & "

''( )

# "& " $ "

.& &

" *!

+(),

, -.

$ & 3 5+, G = &

&. "

& $ "

& # &

" "

#7 " # # =" $ 4& "

9# ) &

''( ) $ H &.

9# ) & "

4& "

E& 4& " .& ="

& &

9# ) 4& "

9# ) & " 4& "

9#) 4& "

& "

4& "

& "

''@ ) $

# # # " "& =" $9#)

$ ="

=" &" # " "& ""&"

=" 4& "

& .

# "

.=" N.&

" N

$ 4& # $ "

.& "

# $ 4& "

4& "

".=" "

. # "

$ &

$ # .& $$& " 4& " +@9#) "

3" " 8

&. "

& $

& " .

E& 4& " .&

3 " "

. 4& $ =" & # 4& " .

& 9# ) $ =" &" " "&

+B $"

$""

.4"

$&#

"# $4& "" "

& $

$ "

&# 3 4&"

# " & A -B& + '))$ # & .

" $A D-& +02)) G "

# 4&"

& & & + & ' $A -B ) " &) .

& A D- & +02

" /& ; 9# ) +/ " 0

+/ 1 + 2.

"# *34% #

$A D-& +02 $ #.

$ ".

# & $

# .& &

&" $ & "

3 .

$ # &

&" .

$ #.

$ # "

&E& " #&# $A D- & +02

$ .

" . .

$ #.

$ " &#

. &#

#& &#

.&# .

$$"" & #

" & $ *,*,'*'-

. .

) " 4& "

'* ) "

" & $"

&"# " " #

4& "

& $$ &#

" &

*+*,'*'- " & $ *,*,'*'- ) .

$$"

"& $ .

"$ & A ,& B0-2)) $"

# $ 4&"

= ) "

=" " $ =" $4& "

& "

''( ) $ "&

"".

) $ $ # $

# &# & !"

+*D A D-& +02)) $

) ""

" ?

$ "

$ " )

. .

& = " ""

5,-+ +6

*D '*'-

G # I?

G .