Rajeshwar Pathak And ANR v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR

   
    
 





 !"#$!%&'&"() *+ +

, 

  







      


   
  
 








 

)  - .+/
 /0




 

 
!"# 



 

  
!"# 

 


$ %
&


!




   
 

'(


)
 
!"# 
 

'*  /01+

. 

 
#
+,*




 %

# 

-
 

. 

/0
'+1,
 
*2(3*3(4   
 
# 
+*3
(*35)



6



0 78
  #
 
#  519
  
 

-.

# 
  
  %
 
-

#% %
 (((**3(4
 "
  
 
 
*939*3(:


 
 # 


- 

 ;0 .
 




 %

# <


  


#% %
0
#%  #
 

=#
 
(
 
  
 
3+((*3(:
 -
#"
  


- #

%



- #% %
- 
 
"

-# 


/0
 .

 
 % 
%
-# "
 




 %

# # 

#
#  # 

>

. 
 

  
 


"


 
#
 
 # 
 




 
- 
 
 
 
# 
%
-


 %

 #"
 
 

#  # 
- 

" 

"  

#
  
#
 % 


# 

#

? #
-   %

" 





 
-
#% %
 # 
#% 
 
# 

# . #

 

?" 
# % 
 

#  
 # % "

 




 
  %


# 
# . #
 
# 


# % # 

# 
# 
# . #
"
 
# 


 

  


# -
%


" 
%





@ %
%


 #  
 


# % 
# 
?"
% 
 
#"
 



 5 #  # 



 %
% "



# % 
 #   


 %

%  

 "

#  # 

<
 




   
" 
% #

 .
# 

 

% %A

)
 

# 



 "
#  # 

-


 

  
" 
# % 

. 

"

 





  # A 
# 
 


 %
 
"
 # A 

#% %
- 



# % 
  #
1*3
  


@ 
"
 
 

#


"

#%   
   
- 
#%    "

  

" 
 
?"
-
 
" 
 
 
#  #
1*3
  
#

-

 
   <
  
#





#% %
- 
"<
#  <

-
#  

 #
  
 

 #
# -
 

  
 


% 
 #
# -
 
0 

B" 
 # @ 

%  
 

 %
%
%
% @ 
 #

-
 

 


" 
%  

 
 #
 
- 
# 

"

#  #
" #%


# 
 
. 


 
- 
#
1*3   

# 

#% %
- 

 

) %

 
 # 

# 
# -

# % 
 <

  
#

-

"
- 
# 
# -
 

# 

? #


 " 
#
+,*
  
-

?  
) 

- "
-"



 


# % 
 
 

 
-
#



# % 

"







- 
# <


# #
 
"


.

# 

 

  

 #
#%%


-
  " "

" #

% 

#.  
#

  
@ # 
#

#

-



-
#% % > 
" 
 #
 " " 
 

" 
  
-

 # 
 " 

# # 

 " " 
#




 
#





-
@  
%%

 

 
<
#

-


-
#% %
B@#


-"%

 "
 #
 

" 


 
 #
 
-


-
#% %
-

 #


 # - 


 
 " "


# #



 

  




%

-
#% %




 

# 
 
  

#.


 ##
-
-" 
% 

# % 
 #

!




" 


 

% 

# % 
 #

 #

# A  


# 
 
-


 

-"  #
 %



 
 
-
 


 

 #
  <
#% %
- 


# A
 

# A
% % 
 
#%%





 


 %

% 
  #

 
.

 #
#



 

# 



-
#% % ? 7- 

 %


% 
#  





# A 
#% % 
#






 

  !" 
- "
  5

  

           



 

        

      !   "

   

  #

 

        

       $

%&'



  

  





 (



 "

   

 

    )*+ ,

  #

 +

,       

(

                 !  (   "

     





   

              

  

             (       - "

   -   

 

   

(     

 

   

(  

.- -

(- 



 (   

 

/ 

(  

 

  $  

      



 

($

 (-(  

 



  

  





.0





1  

  

( 

 



 .



  

(   *  

        (  

 

    

     2      ( 3

 ( 

  

   



  

  -  

  (    



       -    -  

-   

-      

.   

   



   (

  (-    

(

   





(    

   



  



  

  (  - 

 (

    

 -     

           

-  



(     

 

 

     .  



        



 # "

 #

      (

  



 

   



 

 

  -  

 



  

     (  

#

   

  

        



            

       

 



   

  

       #

-

 

  

     

  

+ ,

 

-  



2





#

4



#



 


@#

"
-"
? #

"




=#
 
(

 
  
 
3+((*3(:
%
   #


 
 *939*3(:

-

 

 


  
-
 "
-
 # 
 "

0

-
 


 


 #




%

#
- 

##

 !##   



 
/0
'+1,
 *2(3*3(4
  
 
# 
+*3
(*35)

0 
  #
  #  519
  

 

-.

# 
    %  
 -
.
.


 
 
-

#% %  
(((**3(4
 "
 

 /0  

*+ +

, %  C 
  
;


D ' C 
 - 

D '