Sunder Lal And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"#$%&#'()($* ++ ,-*&#./!0!*&$"1#.) ++++#"("($*#.) 2#.)-) ,"!"#$% !.3!*!!*&$"1#.) +++++#)4$*&#*") 5 6/5+,27, /
!
27, /9+ /
# $$%&$$' ()* + ,"'
-.
$-$./0 .1 #!
2 $* !* , &
$
!* , $-".$-"3 ! , , $"
-.
$-$$/0 "1
#,(4 $55%6 $-$$* * #!( ($.
"$ $-$$/0 $1
* , $"
-.
$-$$/0 "1 ,
) * ! *#, * , .
) , "'
-.
$-$. /0 .1 * , *
* /0 .1* * ## ! ! ! * * ,** * #!& *
* 7 *
# # *
!
!
#!
#!
!
!
!
!
$!
!"
!
!
! %
& !
'
!
'
(
)
*
!
'
!
'
(
)
&
$ !
#
!
#"
!
#
!
#"
!!
#
$!!
#"
'!
'!
!
!
!
!
!
!"
!
!
$!
!"
!
!
"
+!
+!
"
!
!
"
!
&
$ !
&
:
$ , $!
$!
'!
' '!
'!
'!
#!
!
!
!
"
&!
&!
"
+ !
!
!
!"
!
!
$!
!"
!
!
' -
.
!
'
!
'
(
)
/
!
'
!
'
(
) + ,
!
'
!
'
(
) # 0
!
'
!
'
(
)
/
0
0
0
2 #* * 2 .' 35"- !**! 8 2 $* * !"9 -"
$-"%"'
-"
$-"% )* # , !,: ! , !
! * ,
# *
&#! # * !
* , ;# < (#,
=
!" " # $
% & ) * # , *
,* *
* *#! !$-"% ) 2 $ * ,
# * !*&(&!"#)!;#
!"#$%#0(#<(*= > $-"6 ?, $-".
<> $-".
7 $-"9 7 $-"3 @<, $-"3 A $-"3 2 $-"3 ? $-"3 < $-"3
2 #0#!
* ! *$-"%
8, * $-"3 0 !, , $"
-.
$-$$* , * * * $-$$ * 2# #,
, ( ! , * # ,
B# < ( !
0 # , * ,
!# , #! B# < ( ) '$$ (" " $ " ) $ !* +, $ " - - ( , .
& /0/1!2 * ,,
, , (*
, ( !9!*##! ;# < ( * ! (: * ! # , ;# < ( #! , ( 9!* * # '
;# < () '!" " 3"" $4 $ $ " ! ! $ !$+ , $ $
"& 50 1 ! # ! ! #* , * * *
(; ; * 0, , * * 0 !
)' $3 # 6 + $ $ 6 * $"!$+ 7$ & 801!/8/ ;# < ( * *, ! !
(! , ! * *
#,
, B# < ( '!" "
3"" $4 9 / 1C # , B# < ( ,"!"#$%#)"#*=!0 2)+ #>!>.!"!(?!.(!*&"1#.).#4$."#&!) :,*0(*#,
7 # *
1
)4
) "
6
!!'
5
5
(
$(:"
(
(# $";$
"
",
. );8!/ 9
6
!!':
5
+ 9 !" " ( # $ 6 * 0281/!88
;#
6
4
9
(
7 "
6
0
<
1
6
.
1
1 "
0 "
0
1
1
0
0 .
"
7
6
0 ;
& =
"
< 3
(
1
$
'"
9
"
>
"
?!
@ !
55 #"
1
< =
" " ""4 4)" " "
$ " 4
" ".
$ 4" 4 $ " $ $" " $ "$+"
" 4 + $4"
$ "+"
4 4" $ - 4 4" $4 $$ " $> ! ) .
$
$" " $"
"4
"$" " ")
$ " "
" & "- )* # , B# A -'
-'
$-$$ :#?22?
2 '!" " # $@ . $ " !$+ !$+ $ "& 7 ** ,@ * * <# * !* 7 #,* # ! * # , ! , ,# , ##! ( * * ##! ! 7 * ** * !
# , # !
,## 7 B# A , * *#! B# < ( , , 6 4 . A4"
+)7($
;$
B"
$ $ " 201!* !" " 3"" # $ " $ C
! "
0 1!5/# , # # ,, , <, ?,* * *
!
7 , # * !
0
,
0
"
$ #
5/
6 $ !$+ !" " # $@ . $ " #
8/ !$+ !$+ $ " !" " # $@ . $ " "
2"
,
(0
A"
6
B *
#
2 +$ !$+ $ " !" " # $@ . $ " $+*" "4 $8 8
& 53( / &$+ "
!&$$"
+''"
$ #"
$ !"
$ " $'$"
$&"
$+ "
$ +"
!#+ "
!&&!"
!+++ # ' !
"
(01 6
BC
$ " $+$ #
8/
" *4:#
22 2 $*
+ $"
*" "" )* . .$+ $ ? )$+"*""" $
$" ")4 " "") ) "
)
$ !4 # 4%4 - 4 .$" $ " *"
" *$+ 4
$
*"
"$+ $)$ "4D
5
6
B
.
"
,
<
0
!$+ !$+ $ " -!" " # $@ . $
"250/1!
"
1
(
= !
1
?@
1
$
"
1
E ?@
.
1.
6
B
1
$
1 "
B "
,"
:#
5 6 +@"
!$+ !" " # $@ . $ $ " $5
"
1
##&
5
"
(01 6
B
! !
'!
#
53( / #+&
!
!
!
.
0
6 4 . A4"
+)7($ ;$
B"
$ $ " 201!
0
'
.
#+
8
"
?
%1@
?
6 @
"
4
.
1.
/
1
%.
"
7
F
%1F6
.
%1F6
F
?
@"
7
"
F 1
"
G
H I
1
G
4
H I 9
"
"
H I 9
"
7
F
"
#+!"
1
4
%1F6
F
"
7
9
"
1
1
)
"
<
1
"
7
9
<
.
"
+
1
"
?
@
7
"
1
"
1"
"
. .
0 I
#
1
.
"
1
.
"
.
1.
/
4
0
G
1
.
1.
9 "
4
F "
"
1.
"
D
0
1
7
4 D
1 "
1. 2
"
"
4
1
,
&
5 9
4
<
0
<
D
.
D - "
%
"
!!
?5@ &
"
1
(
0
D 6 2
->
"$!" " @ " ) ": - 8!0:7!1 * > $$+" $+ + $" "
;"* 44 $+) " ""4* 4 $
) $ $ 4 $E $4*$
** " $$ 6. $C$ (
$ " !" " ",$+ $
"0 1 !/*$ . " $ $ "* " "" + $F " $
$" ) + $F " $ $ ")4
$ ".+ F $ 4 $4* 4 $" *$!" " ( $ C ( $+$$"
!$+ $ "0 1 !//" ""* $" )4"F$ 4 $ "*" $ .)"A+
"$ @( $ $"
- A 0/1!- /* " ""* $ " $" " $ $ ") $ "4 $"
-A $,$4 "A+
"$" 4 4
"
"4 $4 $" "
4
$ ".
.4 $" $ 4 " $4
$ ".$"" $
$ "
$" "-.
$ 4"2
!! 9
"
"
4 1
1
1
,
.
,
53( / #!!# +"
,
*
(01"
' '!
#"
1
:
.
9
1
,
1
,
,
.
6
B
6
"
$!
? 7
<!@
)
.
1
1
.
1
! 9
"
0 "
1
!& ( / ++"
+#"
++$"
++'
++ +
( / $' "
$ "
$ "
$##"
'!&"
'$'"
+&"
+$"
++"
' "
$& +$$ #
53( / &$+ "
!&$$"
+''"
$ #"
$ !"
$ "
$'$"
$&"
$+ "
$ +"
!#+ "
!&&!"
!+++ # ' !
2 ""
* * , ,
> "6 $-$$* *""
""
$-$$ 7 < >/( 1A! 965$&$-$. , ,-'
-'
$-$$""
""
$-$$* #! B# < (".
-.
$-$.
"$
* # * * * # , * # , ! ".
!* # # # , *
& # * * * !* ! * * ! # 7
## !
, ) # , A (> "-33$-"3 * 2 $- #
# , ! + * ,, ,: , !,: #,, : ) ,!
# , ;# < ( 0 1* * ,*
* ! *"- .-!* !
# *+#, : ;# < (, , : * , #! , (, 7 , # * &
4
6
B
6 ( (01 /5%
-
F 6
B
G
$
.
. 6
B
1 .
1
9
1
G
'
( "
"
6
B
"
.
1
<
$
6
"
?@
!" " ( $ $ $ " C
( $+$$"
!$+ $ "0 1!// 9
1
D 6
B
B 6
G
6
B
9
6
B
G
5 10
5
1
6
B
$
9
5 0
"
A .
>
? @
"
1
2
6
B
<
6
B
"
1
.
1
$$
.
- 6
<0 D
B
/5% - 2
9
6
B ?B <. .@
( 6
!+
"
1
!!
9
1
G
0
6 ( (01 - 6 2 "9
8 $" !
"53- * !
D , , ##!
!, &
! , &
, ## , ! * "6
,* #
* # , ! 27, / 5!39
& ,E F # E F