High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44593/2018allowed

Gurpreet Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-10-17Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi34 pages

"#$ %& '$()*)%+

/ /

! # # $$$$$

/ / 0

, 1"2 & '()** +

,-./0)120)234 /24 /'

3)256 -* ')2 -* 7 # 8 #

#9&# #7

:538 ##+

+ )

# #

.3141)23/ 5 5

+ 2;32)2)/ *5/4;)5)23(8 5 ! 9

.(;3;''2332)23/ 12 2225% & * < # - *# #

2;2;)230%

* 9 +92332)23/ 9

# 3(3))23/9 # # )233)23/. & + # "" = & > ? ,

& ? +

& @55 @ &

# -

7 ! 89

/3/** 5 A

/ <?

+ 2;32)2)/ *55'42/35)2318

# #

.3113)333)23/ 5 ! 9 +

.)/(3/22/32)23/ 3 ;2 2225% & * < # -*#

2432)230-

! 89 /3/** 5

# $$%

# ' # (

' 5 ! 7 9 8

# * # < #B9

242()234

)120)234 0 !#

+ 3)32)2)/ *55)4)125)2318# #

# #

.'44 3(2/)23' 3/( . # - 5 ! 9 +

.(;3;';3)2))23' 3 )0 222 % & *

< # -*# #

3;21)230-

7 ! 89 /3/ ** 5

)

$$%

* + # , # ( - , ./(0& , 1 %&

+ #

( + #

# ( '

2 2 + 3+ $ 4&

4 5 ! 7 9 8

# * # < #B9

)12/)234 ; 5

# #

.02' )(2/)23' 3/( . # - 5 ! 9

.)/(3);)42))23' 3 222 % & * < # -*# #

2)33)230-

7 ! 89 /3/ ** 5

)

# $$%5

* + #

, # (- , ./(0&,1 %& #

+ # (

+ #

+ # ( '

2 " 1 6 &2 + 3+ $ 4&

( 5 ! 7 9 8

.* 5;3')230 * # < # B9

242()234 5 !

)120)234 1 #

3'3))23'

# ? + & - 20

# 7 8 #

+? # # 20 # #95 A0 70 8/79

% C 32

# * 9 # 332/)234& * * #< 7< " # 33 )120)234

,-.22/0)120)234 /24 /'

3)256-* ')2-*7# 8#

#9& # # % # ,-7

:538 5 :# 1%' 12

)%(;<88& '= & # =; &$ 89 , ./>798.998/ #

? " 2 &+ &

/@ 8/7A

+ & %'

% %'&

, 7&

%' 1 "

+ #

# ' # , ./(0&, 1 %&

9/) &

# # &

)

+ # # ' #

$ &

%'#

7>D// 1 %' #

# # A@? % % %' 8.

/@ 8/7A

3) "

:5)89 # 5 :%' 1$ E

+ #

# ' # E #, #

- , ./(0/, %

# #

1 # &# 1&"# &%2 = & # & #' 1& "' # & $

" # & # E& ) 1# ) &# B&E + &2 + #

% 9 $

+ #

)

#$ ,>

# E) % A////

7/ /?

8/7@

1 # #' 1 )

+ # #' #

# #

" '%'F

& &

& <& &

3/ "

: 53%8.# 9 5 ! 9 # 5 :"

" %' 1 # '= -

# ) ) & ' = & # ) " ,

"#)@@/07>09AA> " 9/

* & & & B

# 2

& + # %

7&?/&///(< # ) # %

7&?/&///(< &

# ) &) = &

+ # , # (- , 8/./(0&, %& %' 1

+ # & + #

# ' #

B + #

&+ #

% 9E B

+ # &

+ #

# ' #

1 E 2 & + # &

$ B

= ; &

& + #

B + #

# ' # &1 # 1# (G)9@(879&+

B2 & & # 1# 1(- , @A)&- )

2& & " " # # &(G>/, + &

# ' # (G7/@>(9&, E"H # B & &#'

1%1 (G7A<!

,& &"' # % # ( G 8A7(8 " % $ )H& &$ " # + # (G 07A& , 7& , & & - # & # 1&6'1&%' +&+ #

& %' 1 B C

# # &

1 # ) B& # BE+ B 2 B&

# %2 =

%' 1 & # E ) & #")" & , # % 1 B

+ # &

% 7E &

# E

% A/&///(< % A/&///(< & # E 7/(/?(7@

+ # % A/&///(< B " %' 1 -

# )

& %' 1

8.(@(8/7A -

+ # -F 2 & ;

+ #

# ' #

+ #

# #

)

# 1& " " # &1 # &$ " # &#' 1& "' # &

+ # &

+ #

- 2

& &

. 3'

&3( ,-% 3;/7)8**9 );2;)2349 # & ## 9 3(23)23; <?

7 8 * !#

! ! 30 /24 ')2 3)256 -* 2'2()23(& * # < # 34 # 3; # #

,-9## 9 D 9 > ##& 9 &#

#& # # # & 3/( . #- 9

/24-* % #& 9

+ +

5 <?

3/( . #- % ##& # 9 #

# 5 + 6 ?B #& 5 9 9# # # # & #

D 9

#!#

#& + 9 #

## # #

!"# $ % & '( ) *"")++

, - *.

1*"*

**! - 2 *333*

))! -

4 2 !.

.3"

)3. 1

5 & 6 7

(5 0 - 78- $ + ' 1

.& + + + +.*21 1

9*":+ 3( # # & # # # 9 #

#&2(20)231 #&9& "

"& # 7-

#9& # #

# & # ,E 5 9

& -%

5 5 ## #

/2# ?

+ %

& ##

# ?

% + 9 #

# #

# 3/( . # - F #

7 8 B9 # #& ! #

# * # 9 # 9 #

& & 9

#& + & # <?

# <?

9 & & ## # &9# # 9# ##5

# ? +9

&9# & + 9 ##5 # # ?5 # 9% <?

9# 9 -

,- ##+

9 9# # # 9 #9B

+ 5 #&

+ 2;32)2)) *5/4;)5)23( G *55'42/35)231 #& 3)32)2)/ *55)4)125)231 31 - #

)2 6

9## # #9

/24 -* 5 ;9 + '1

+< &

C &

32; -* 5 ;*"+'1

& < !

J # <;

J < & &

9 # B H# * 3

!":

9 # :

+&7..0

F F !

# ) &

& # 2 2 & 7.?9

# ) & # 2 2 &7.?9 C C <9

F ;

F F&

F F F F

# &

+&7..0

+& 7..0

+&7..0

+& 7..0 C

+& 7..0

+&7..0

JD # K B H# * =# $+ % & '( ) *""): # 5

) &

7... '

7A/) # %&1

7A 8//7

1, # 9/A 2

# 7/?

2 # 7/?

C # 7/?

& C

1 ,

& 1,

# +

2 2 & 7.?9 B

JD # K B H# * =++

+, - '

# 5

8A # B )

*+&7..>394 %2%32470AD37..>47#22?9&

& C

2 2 12

# 3

,2$ 48//.3>4%2%3247.AD8//.3@4

+ 8?0D38//.47A#22A/@&

; F

; < <

& '

;

# 9/A 2

& < < -

9/ B H C

9/A 2

2 &

9/A 2

JD # K , B H# * /0

+ 1*"*

**!: # 5

& C C

# 9/A

2 & &

# 9/A

# &

2 * + 34

(

& &

C &

K +

# B ) 8/7/374%2%324 A>9D8/7/374% C+ 3%

+ 470>D 38/7/47#22?/?

# 9/A

& 2 # # 2

1" '8/7/3>4%2%324AAD8/7/3>4 % C+ 3%

+ 4A8.D38/7/478#22 7./

* 3 - + 2 *333*

))!:

# 5

# # 9/A 2 # 9/A

C & &

& C

' " &

# 9/A 2

& #

# -&7..0394%2%3248AA

JD # K * -

4+ 2 !.

.3":0 # 5

7@ , &

< 9 8A

&7..9

9/ > 7..9

# 9/A 2

# 7/? 2

J34

J34 & &

&F F

& &

9 # 7/? # 7/. 2

L# # %'

# -&L8//0384%2%324 07/D8//0384% +8?8M

L; M ))

# # &

/24-*9 9 #

# # &

# 5 * 5

)3.: # 5 A77

& &

2 #

# 2

6 &B

* 1

5& 6 7

(5 0 -78-$ +' 1

.& + + + +.*: # 5 A7/

# )

8/7>3#22, .@/.8/7>#22 , .@7/8/7>4

8/7@&# ) # # , 798/7@ 8?

' @/N

2 B , 7/>80 8/70&

# +

# &8/70 &

8/7> 8/7@

2 +

& &

C << < C

#22, .@/.8/7>

C < C >

+& 8/70

)

# )

, &

& & #

;

, &

& ' &

# 7/?9/A

- %8//7# 2 909?&3% 1

# 2

4 % 8/77# 2 7890&3"

# 779 779)

;

C 2

# 9/A7/?

# 7/?

2 &

& # 779 779)

;

2 , 78.78//0&3"" #

# ' * 4 7?

& 8/7/2 , 8/0A8/7>&3# 1 *

# = ,* 4& 79

&8/7@

# 7/?

( 2

< &

- 2

2 2 &7.?9

# 8.>34

' 2 , 7@@8/7.&32 #(I

# "

4& 0

, &8/7.

2 # 7/?

# 7/?

2 !

& # 9/A

2 &70A/#

& &

# 7/?

2 &

# 7/?

7> 2

& #

2 C

D = $>

C %

, 0@8/7.

# * 21 1

9*": # 5 A7A ;

)' * 5 3?6

<<. 9*<*3 "+*+9: # 5 :8/

# 9/A 2

- &

# 790

< H

- &

3 # 790

, *

70 8/79

- &

/9 7/ 8/79& 70 8/79

87 8/79 !

# 790

O 5

# 790

, &

- &

" &

# 7/? 2 # 9/A 2 !

<# ' #

2 &

& !% , 9@ 8.

/@ 8/7A # 9/A& >8/& 78/<) 9> 2 # % &$ 3 C < 74

)0 * 5 =-

<< 3<*3 *+*+9: # 5 :89

& &

!% ;

;

& &# ' # +

# &

&!%, 9@ 8.

/@ 8/7A # 9/A& 9>& 78/<) 2 # >8/ 23 4 # % &$ 3 C <74&

# 7?93842

)4 - #& ,- D # 9

% 9 # #:# 9 + +

% # #& #

# # &

& ## D

+ #&

9 !#

#& + #9#&##9

9## ); - 9

,-./0 )120)234 /24 /'

3)256-* ')2-*7 # 8 #

#9&# #

:538 3;/7)8** ##+

+ + )(

/ /

(#%4$1

L ?

M. L # M.