High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20851/2019dismissed

Harmandeep Singh v. State Of Haryana

2021-12-22Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal4 pages

"'()#(*+ , "-" #((. /0 ('' ( 1 '"'()"2" "" #" '0( (+. #( '+ , 34 54

(+( ', 5" 6#7*"'(6)'0(.('' ( "0890" 66"2" " :0 "78.'"6#7*"'(6)(+. #( ' ;;;;;;;

546< 4= 08/0 '0( .(+( ' .('' )9(# 8 #( (*' >$ '0( .('' (+((?+" '*."'2:"9 #"'(# &(/+'((#8 #( (*' + 6 6

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

2'0( :"9" *( "-8 ' ) +> 9"?0+6 " "..9*"' B"+ )9(# :2 '0( *-.9" " '!(+. #( '+((? /#+-++"9)'0(.(+( '.('' :( /.8'' '*()+8*0"..9*"' 69(" (#*8 +(9)'0( .('' ("..("(#:()('0+8' >" #+'"'(#'0"''0(.('' ( +0"99."2'0(:"9" *("-8 ') +>9"?0+B'0 (- '00+8'"**(.'

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

+'(#'0(-"''( $ $6%G)'0(#8("-8 '( %9"?0+B"+ '."# 'B"++8:-''(#'0"''0(.('' (*89#"" /( 92 +>9"?0+'B"++'99)8'0( +8:-''(#'0"''0(:"9" *("-8 ') +9"?0++0"99:(."#:2'0(.('' ( '0(( +'"9-( '+()+''B) +>%9"?0+("*0" #'0((-" / +>9"?0+0( :( (79( *()'0(8'* ' 8(#" #+8*0."2(-"#( :(0"9))'0(.('' ( B"+"9+"**(.'(#'08/0B'0"#('0"''0(.('' (+0"99."2 '((+'H G.( " 8- '0(8 ."#"-8 ' +.(":7(6 +>%9"?0+B(((C8(#':(."

'0(.('' (."# 92 +9"?0+**(.' /'0("++8" *(-"#( :(0"9))'0( .('' ('0"'0(+0"9997(8.'0+8 #('"? /'0+8'"#A8 (#'0(-"''(

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

":8''B- '0+'0(.('' (## '."2 9"?0+''0( *-.9" " ' 8')'0(:"9" *("-8 ') 9"?0+'0(.('' (."# 92 + 9"?0+ $ & 9(" (# *8 +(9 "..(" / ) '0( .('' ( 0"# .#8*(#"#(-" ##")') +9"?0)"78 /'0(*-.9" " '" #0" #(#7('0( +"-('9(" (#*8 +(9)'0(*-.9" " 'B0*0B"+"**(.'(#8 #(.'(+'' B"+)8'0(8 #('"?( :(0"9))'0(.('' ('0"'0(+0"99*9("'0(:"9" *( ."2-( ') +>9"?0+:2 "? /" (@'(-(929( ( '7(B '0( -"''(6'0+8'0"#/" '(#+8*09:('2''0(.('' (" #"#A8 (#'0(-"''( ''#"2B(7(6'B"+*9")(#'0"' *"+('0(.('' (#(+ '97(8.'0+ 8 #('"? /'0(.(+( '.('' +0"99+'" ##+-++(# #"2"9+6'0(.('' (0"+ '."

#'0(:"9" *("-8 '''0( .('' (" #-('-(++8/0')'#'0( ((#)89 0(":7(+(C8( *())"*'+*9("92(7("9+'0"' +(7("9**"+ + '0(.('' (0"+ '97(#8.'0+8 #('"? /+/7( ''0+8'.."( '926 '0(8'.*((# /+0"7(:(( '"?( '9/0'92 -"926'0+0"+:(( + :(*"8+()9( ( *2" #:( (79( *(+0B :2'0+8' -('0" (**"+ 0(8'0"+.(-''(#'0(.('' ('*9("0+#8(+B0*00"#:(( ) "992+(''9(# :('B(( '0(.('' (" #'0(*-.

E F 8/0+( 8/0 +-++(# 99'0(-+*(99" (8+"..9*"' <+=6)" 26"9++'" #<+=#+.+(#) E 54F +0"-+0( D0('0(+.("? /!("+ (# , (+! D0('0((.'":9( ,(+!