High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20616/2025allowed

Shinder Singh @ Shindi v. State Of Punjab

2025-09-17Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

0*$ )

0*$ ) /"

5( C /"

5( C8 9 8 9 8 9 8 9 #"

*&* #( $% & '# D2 */$

) ) ) )

:+ 2

+ + + + 2 *

/ #8 3$0 0#"

%$ "

2 #,/

" 8 & '#( (2 ;;;;;

;;;;;

+ + + +8 2 <+1 8 2 <+1 8 2 <+1 8 2 <+1

" " #* (

B?6 $% ##",# # #- &#-*# # "#8 6 < <%$ *$" = :1 %$ # " $%

&.# (#.

"$ "

$26>

C26268

$%%

* /& *#(.

$% "

#0$"0 & *

*,0$"$ $/0 &(*"# * 0"8 >?9 <%$ * $" = 0":1 < > $%

0 0"18 #" $.0 "#"$ @$"

8 *"0" $ #2 2

#3#5

*"$ * "#" "

* #

#00&*

$% (

/ "#

0" 3$.3 C "#(.

"* $% "4$.#5 7 6B26B #5* * #..

., 0$3

%$5 "

0$& . %$ "

#* "

"#" "

, * C26262 +

0$&

. #* %&" *&(5""

"#" "

#"$, / $3*$ * $% "

0" #3

0$5/.

7"8 #

"&*8

/$* *&%% * %$5

0"*2 +

0$& . #* "

"#" " "#. *

.#,

.#(.", "

$% 0#

%#*"

2 +

0$& . #* %&" "

"#" "

#* *&%%

%$ 5$ "# , #*2 &*8 &.# (#. * /#,

%$2 B2 +

0$& . #* $//$*

" / (, # &

"#" " #..

* #*

# # *" "

$&*

#"&

8 "&*8

&.# (#.2 +

0$& #* %&" *&(5""

"#" " *"# " (#. /.

# * (#

$* $%

6C $% "

0"8 #

"&*8 " *#5 $& " "$ (

*5**

2 +

0$& . *

-* "$ /.#0

, 0 "%0#"

2>29

$&" "$ #,8 70 * "#-

#3 0$& . %$ " 3#. /#" * #

"$& #3#.#(.

* $% " 2

7#* # *"

C2626 7

#%"

*" #"$ 7#* 0#

$&" #

0#..# 7#* /

?2C262 $"#.

9 /$* 7"

** * #3

8 $&" $% 708 9 #3

E#5

/#" "..

3#. 0$

* #*

#" # 3

(#"#(.

**& *8 70 *#.. ( #"$0

& 0$&*

$% "#.2 * $&"

5 " #//$/#"

/ 3#.

*8 #" "* *"# 8 .

*" " 5#, / 0 "#.2 $" "# (.

($& " %$7# "$

0#"

.- .$$

#(*0$

%$5 " /$0 ** $% '&*"0 $ 7" " /$*

&("#(.,8 "

" / * " " #""

5/" (, "

"$ * 0&

&.# (#.2 .#*" (#. /.

# /

7#* *5**

#* 7" #7 62292 8 -

/ 3 7 %&"

%$ # / $% 5$ "# ? 5$ "* #

*&(*"# "#. /$ ** "#.8 "* $&" * 0.

"$ #%%5#"3 ., 0$ *

*"# " /.

# %$ (#.2 /$%"#(.

8 "* 8 0# 5#

"$ #

" $% "* $&" /#**

66 66 66 666 6 6 6 "".

#* #%A @#

#%A @#

*&* "#"

#,# # #

*&* "#"

#,# # #

*&* "#"

#,# # #

*&* "#"

#,# # #

3# " 7

* #* &

) G2 * #

/.$ & "$ " #($3

*0&**$ 8 " %$..$7

/ 0/.

)

H*&00 **3

&.# (#.

<*1 %.

5# "# #(.

.#7 I

*&0 / $& "

$" "$ (

*$.

., $ $&

$% 5# "# #(.", "

$%2

H*&00 **3

&.# (#.

<*1 5# "# #(.

7#*

*5**

#* 7" #7 *5**

#* $" / **

*5**

/$*

#. 7#* *5**

"*2 $ "

H*&00 **3

&.# (#. / <*1 "$ *&00

8 "

H#//.0# " *#.. (

"#..,H/ "

".,

"$ *$7 *&(*"# "#. 0#

00&5*"# * #

*$7

$% # 5

*&/ %0#. $ $*"

*(.

7$&.

$" *&%%0

"#/$0 $% *

H*&00 **3 (#. /.

#<*1 $& "

#(*"#0"

"$ ."

#. "

* $% / <*1 7"$&"

*&(*"# "#.8 %% 0"3

"#. 0#

00&5*"# *2

E#&*"3 &

* 0# /$**(., ( .#

#* "$ 7#" 7$&.

*""&"

*&(*"# "#. 0#

00&5*"# * #* #* "* $7 A& %#0"*H00&5*"# 2 #- *&0 #

#""

5/" * $" (&" # &"$/#

#3$&2 $8 "* **& *" .

%" "$ " 0#. 7* $5 #

*0 $&"

7" *&0 *

H*&00 **3

&.# (#. / <*12 J

# $&" 0$$* * "$ # " *

H*&00 **3

&.# (#. / <*18 0$

" #

.&0

#*$ * # "

"., A&

%$ # " *&0 /.

*/"

*&0 # /.

# (

H*&00 **3 <*12

7$ *8 " 0#&* %$ # $&"

*&00 **%&.., 0$&

*&0

H*&00 **3 <*1 $& " "$ (

., #

#.,

0/ #(.

%$5 "

/#**

2K 22

"#. *

/$0#*" #"

%$.., "

$% 0#

$" (

2 * / , 0 "%0#"

2>29 %.

0$& .8 "

#* #.

, *&%%

%$ # / $% , #*8 9 5$ "* #

#,*2

"* 3 7 $% " 5#""

8 "

$ 5/$*

6C $% "

0" *"#

.&"

. " $% "

"0.

$% " $ *""&"$

262

* $&" # '&

" "".

#* @&.7

*&* "#"

@&.7

*&* "#"

@&.7

*&* "#"

@&.7

*&* "#"

& '#( & '#( & '#( & '#( /#**

BCB BCB BCB BCBB B B B <9)

)>91F #%"

$% "

"* $% "

:(.

&/ $&"

&**# ## @#"$$ 3*2 $5 0,28 "#"

$% # <>?1 ?F ( &.

5# "&.#, 3* 22 #,#- <>>1 9F #3

&.#5 #( #- 3*2 "#"

$% ###*"# #

8 B<61 <5 #.1 B>BF $

&*.5 !

&**# 3*2 "#"

< $% .1 /$"

#* 6

6F 5 #. // #.

$2B9H

C22 "".

#* G""# *7#* .#* &(#* 3*2 $% L *"

#.KF G "* -#, ! #/# 3*2

$% L *"

#.K8 / 0#. + #3 "$ // #. <.21 $2996

2?2 "".

#* G$#55# #.5#

% #- 3*2 &'##"KF 5 #. // #.

$2> $%

92?2 "".

#* $/#.

@* # #"# ! $/#.&*5# 3*2

#8 #

-& #& #, 3*2 $% # ,# #

*8 B<B1 <5 #.1 CF #* 8 "&*) GC2?2

" "$ # */

, #

"$&* "#. * $" $ ., # 3"#. *#% &# "$ /

" &

$// **3 F "$ 5" #"

E ", #

#00$5/# , #00&*#"$ #* 7 .. #* "$ 0&"#. # 5/#5

" #(.", $% # #00&*

5* .%8 (&" "

* #

$3 #0 *$0 "#.

*" /#3 7#, %$ # */

, "#.2 * " #*

., #0"&#"

" /#*" #

$% "

#($3

"$ &/ $&":* '&

"* #3 .#

# * * $%

0*$ * $/

7 3*"#* $% %&

"#. "*2 /" $% */

, "#. * #5#. #5#"

"0.

#* #

"#. /#" $% "

"#. " "$ .%

.( ",8 &##

$& $ *""&"$ " "$ */

, "#. ( * 7" " #0"&#.

*"# 5/$*

#" " "5 *" $% " #00&*

70 0$ " * #" #.. *"# *8 #5 .,8 " *"# *" #"$ 8 A&,8 "#.8 #// #. #

3*$ *$ "#" # , /$**(.

0 "#" 5#, *&."

"$ 5/ 5**(.

#3$ #(.

.#, *

"5 0$55**$ $%%

".. " 05 #. /$0

*&55#"

"$ # % #.",8 0$&.

, "#.8 #., #

A&0- */$*#. # *

A&# $% 05 #. '&*/&

$3 0$7

$&" $0- "*8 " #3, 3$.&5 $% 7$- #

*&."# **& /$*

$.0 8

&("#(., -

/* "

05 #. '&*/&

"#. 5 0# *5 &

** #

*"# 8 "*

E0&* %$ -

/ *7$ $% #5$0.

* #

#00&*

%$ #

% "

$% "5 $" * , 0

" "$ "

05 #. '&*"0 *,*"

58 #" " 5#- * %$ # *# *"#"

$% #%%#*2

&##

$% # */

, "#. *

"$ #3$ $//

.#, (, 5/$* $&" #

/$* $(. #"$

/$0

7" " "#. 7" # #*$ #(.

*/#"02 &##

* #

%$.

/&/$* 2 *".,8 " /$"

0"* " #00&*

# # *" $// **3 "#. 5/*$

"F *

.,8 "

. * " #00&*

E ", #

/&(.0 *&*/0$

"$ &

*$.3

05 #. 0# * #

.#*".,8 " /$"

0"* # # *" " *- "#"

7.. ( .$*" $ 5 5$ 55

(, "

/#**# $% "5 8 "&*8 5/# #(.", $% " #00&*

5* .%2 " $ * 7"$&" *#, "#" "

* $% / "#.

#3 2 00&*

8 / *&5

"8 ".. /$3

7* 8 #

*&('

"$ /*,0$.$ 0#. #

/,*0#.

/3#"$ * $% '#..% 8 &*&#..,

$&* 0$

"$ *2 A&#.., 5/$"# "8 " (&

*&0 # #00&*

"., %#..* #3., $

" 5 5( * $% * %#5.,2

* , " # #*/ 0" $% " 5#""

#" "* *"# #..

" 0#*

.#"

#00&*

.#" "$ 0$55 0#. A&# "", $% "#(#

0"8 >?92 L.

# (#. /

# 0#* 3$.3 0$55 0#. A&# "",8 " $&" #* "$ -

/ 5

$&*

6C $% 0"8 >?9 70 5#

"#" $&"* 0# " (#. "$ # #00&*

., #%"

# /&(.0 /$* 0&"$ #

#%"

#3 *#"*%

"* .% $% "7

"$ * 70 #

#*$ #(.

* %$ ( . 3 "#" " #00&*

$" &.", $% "

$%%

H#..

"#"8 $" .- ., "$ 0$55" # , $%%

(#.2 *"

" $&* $% 6C $% "

0"8 >?9 5&*" ( "0&.$&*., *0&" 4

# # *" " (#0- $/ $% #00&*

:* %&

"#. " "$ # */

, "#.2 " "$ .%

*$ #. .( ",

& #"$, (, & 7##

.#,* 0#. /$0 **8 /#"0&.#., 7

*&0

.#,<*1 *

" #""(&"#(.

#00&*

'&*"%

#" "

/$* (, 0$

#*$ *2

3 &#.

$" ( - /" (

(#* %$ # $% "5 (, "#-

%& $&* .#

6C $% "

0"8 >?92

*.#"& "* 7* $58

*& */

, #

"5 ., */$*#. $% * &

0"8 #* /$3

%$ " *""&"$ $% */ 0#. $&"*

6 $% " 0"2 8 "* $&" 0#

$" "&

.*$ :*

/$"#0"

.#,* #

*,*"

5#"0

%%0

0, "#" %&*"#"

"* *.#"3 /&/$* 2 $&" $% .#7 * &",($&

*& "#" "

0$5 0$5/.0" 3$.#"$ $% #

3 &#.:* %&

"#. "*8

$"7"*"#

," "#

# *"#"&"

2 L.

#. 7" (#.

# 0#* $3

$&* $% 6C $% "

0"8 >?98 " $&" 5&*" *"- # '& 0$&* (#.# "7

*.#"3

" "$ 0&( "

#0 & * #

*#0$*# 0" " $% " #00&*

"$ # %# #

"$&* "#.2 $.$

8 7"$&" '&*"%#(.

0#&* 8 *-* "# *%$5 "#.

"$ /& "3 5/*$

"8 $&"0$5 "" "0#. "$ " / 0/.

$% '&*"0

A&",2 $8 "

A&3$0#.

* "#" 7

"#. #* %#.

"$ 0$ 0.&

7" #*$ #(.

"5 *&." /$.$

8 " 5."#"

* # # *" " 0$&* %&

"#. "* $% .%

.( ", #

.#7 #

8 #* *&08 0$

"$ #. .( ", $3 *"#"&"$, 5(# $ 0

6C $% "

0"8 >?9 $& " "$ ( *

#* / %#0"* $% # 3

7$ *8 # " $% (#. # 0#* "# "$ 0$55 0#. A&# "",8 $

$% &

.#, "#.8 0#

"$ ( ""

(, 6C

0"8 >?92K

2B2 &" 8 #* / , 0 "%0#"

* *"#"

"$ (

<*12 8 "* %#0"&5 0#

# $&

*&%%0

" (, "* .%8 "$

&.# (#. "$ "

*"$ 7

# 0#* * 5#

$&" %$ # " $% &.# (#. A&# "

*"$ (, #"$0 #" %#0"*H00&5*"# * $% " 2 .# "* /.#0

" $% "

:(.

&/ $&" #&.# # $ 2 5 #*# 32 "#"

$% 22 #

#&.# # $ 2 5 #*# 32 "#"

$% 22 #

#&.# # $ 2 5 #*# 32 "#"

$% 22 #

#&.# # $ 2 5 #*# 32 "#"

$% 22 #

<1 <5 #.1 9? <1 <5 #.1 9? <1 <5 #.1 9? <1 <5 #.1 9?F # 3*$

0 '&

" $% "

:(.

#.0&""# $&" $% # #* 32 "#"

8 >>? <1 <5 #.1 # #* 32 "#"

8 >>? <1 <5 #.1 BCC BCC BCC BCC I '&

"* $% "* $&" $26?? "".

#* -.

* -.

* 32 "#"

#,# 32 "#"

#,# #8

>228 #

#.#' 32 "#"

#,# #8 >>? <61 <5 #.1 >2

#,# #8 >>? <61 <5 #.1 >2 &%%0 "$ *#,8 %&"

#* #

"#. *

$" 7##

%#0"* #

00&5*"# * $% " C2

3 7 $% #($3 8 "

" / * #..$7

"$ (

&.# (#. $ * %& * (#.H*& ", ($

* "$ "

*#"*%#0"$ + 2 0$

"#. $&"H&", # *"#"

"$ "$ 0$

"$ * "#" 5#, ( 5/$*

"#. $&"H&", # *"#"

8 "

*#..

5# ($&

%$..$7

"$ *) <1

*#..

$" 5*&* .( ", #

*#..

$" "#5/ 7" # 3

8 $#. $

$0&5

"#,8 & "#.2 <1

*#..

$" #(*

" 5* .% $

"#.2 <31

*#..

$" 0$55" # , $%%

(#.2 <31

*#..

/$*" * /#**/$"8 % # ,8 7" "

"#. $&"2 <31

*#.. 3 * 0 ../$

&5( "$ "

*" #" %%0 H $% 0$

$.0 "#"$

*#..

$" 0#

* 0 ../$

&5( 7"$&" /$ 5**$ "#. $&"H ..#A# # *"#"

<31

*#..

$" , 5#

", "$

.#, " "#.2

<31

*#.. *&(5"8 $ %*" 7$-

#, $%

, 5$ "8 # #%% #3"8 (

"#. $&"8

%% 0" "#" #*

0$55**$ , $%%

#%"

(#.2

* %$&

"$ (

, $%%

#%"

(#.

" 8 $ (#** $% * #%% #3" $ $" 7* 8 " * 5#

"$ 5$3 %$"7"8 %$ 0# ..#"$ $% * (#. 70 /.

#8 (&" $% 0$&* 8 *#.. ( #"$0

"* "

$%2 ?2

$% ( #0 $% # , $% " #%$

"$ * #

"$*

70 5#, ( 5/$*

(, 0$

"#. $&"H&", # *"#"

#* 0"

#($3 $ &/$ *$7 , $" *&%%0

" 0#&* 8 " H0$5/.# *#.. ( #" .( ", "$ 5$3 ..#"$ $% (#. $% "

#00$ .,2 2

#($3 *#.. ( *"&

#* #

$/ "* $% " 2 5# #* (

8 /

5*0 ..#

$&* #//.0#"$ 8 % # ,8 *#.. #.*$ *"#

*/$*

$%%2 < + + + +1 /"

5( C /"

5( C8 9 8 9 8 9 8 9 5##3 L */ #- #*$

) *H L

/$"#(.

) *H