← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11196/2009allowed

Krishna Shanwal v. Choudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural U

2016-08-19Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

 

  

   

 



 !"

#" $% &

 !

'!( " ("!)"! # *"!)  *!(%(!%+ '!),! 

"!

&&-   . /

 01%/!

2( (%-# *"

  

 ! "#$"% & ' '() #

 #$"% *"') " "*"')"#  



 

     



   

  

  

 ! 

(%-# *",2  "  '

  )(    )) %  "  +'

*  "*  '  )"# #) %"#%

#'" %+ ,# )

-#"'# )

-+"

#"* '

"('*" )"%#"#% #') "".  '

$' # #%"( *"') " %" ##' "*')"# #'

$

"% *(

-,"'"(,''*

   / # 0   !'

 '(+ # "* '  ) " & &" , "*" ') ."*!"

!% % "

,"* , %( (  '

(#'

-  '

  !

,'   -  , %( (

$ - &  #"+(** ,*".". "(#   %' - 1221 *"&'

%''& , ,.#

%

.%"."('

"-."(%".)

& % $#

, # ,

,* %

."'+ "** .#

+

 '+ "*'

#  "-."(  %".)

    * %  * # ,  3( - &   "##  * '""(,' 3( -  "..

%"  ,"*    

 %" 4!" # (%'

5 #!'  &

)(-  4% #.

% #

%( -**

5% ."'%"% ( "'

/

'

)"#(%#* .#

+

#& '# &)(+

%."- ."( ,"

67 27 6889:  * (#(  -   %%"# , -    &  %"..## '

%

% +, #

'

.(#!% "712 1;< 72=786 78< 762 76; 761 76> #767"*'#



"#%%"# , -

 "871# #1>;1122<(#!% "7;= 712 78? 78< #76;

"*'#



"#& , #

"

%! " $

@   "&$ /

# #A # -"*,  ""*  "17;1122<*'

# ' ) " #$

) "# #;=2;122=4A(:

:>5 2721122= 4A(:

:75 ## #121122=4A(:

:?5  ,' "* 

 +*   "* 

    / #  0   !'

 

 -  '  ) - A( 8% .">22>122=  &'

%'')"# # +"('

3( - #'

'* # ,'

* .#

+

&(+.

# #,"  .+(#!'& *".#'

'#('

$"+ #*"'

# "'.

#' ' *') " ))"

%'#'

"(+-*

,' )& ) "  ,& "*.

# .( # % ,')"# "  ( - *

-) "  #"'

"*@  /

 ''" ** # $ *

#+-')"#'"&'

'- '

$ ' #'

* .#

+

&(+.

# #.#

 .+(."'("* 67 27 6889:& %

.#+-/ !'

 *%

".

#"' 3( -)"  *# +"$

 %

.# '

' $ -'

 ,"   ,'"  #B('

*"

# ."(*".'

#("* @ /

 "&$ ) -#""'"&'

- #$"#& ) #"'"& (" %& (#" -,(

 3( -&

#

 /

#( ,'

* .))  -  )) *".' &  ."*')"#'

"'"&% (" %& (#"

/

" -,(

 3( -&

#  ))  - *" ' "'

..#

 -"'A# -"*',  ""*  ' A) #   "&  '  )" "    '

  "  #) .

 )"%# ,  &

#

'/

#( ,'

* . #'

& #"&%

.#'

"& '3( "&"( # &'' '#) .% #B(' ."("* 67 27 6889:*".'

+* "*/

'.

  &'

%'  "(,'"

+%

.# '&  .C* #') - , $ % ' .) "-  '

  A) #  "  #) .

 )"%# ,  %"( #  + 

#

'

.'.

& %" ##+-  $ "%'"*'

%"( "#$ %

&   %!$ %(#,. 4;=?2:;=<<50"

(.

,816 &' &'



,""*'* %"* '%  '

"("+$# (#:

' "



 (             

   ) (      

  *  

(        



+  (       + +  

,,          *  

       

++-./!

 

    (   

      ,,  0 (  

    

(      1  



   2.

&3 ( %( 

 +  $   44+          



   +   ) (     "  

 %5 607 

   2. 

         

      

  

   

  + (       8   

9  &

         

  (

  (: 

  

                

   





    



    

 

                ( :           



  

 (        ;

'.

&

"%" ##+-'"D+ !()."(

%

<=  $ >& 63 ( ?

 2//

//.7   //- //@ &' "+$# (# ':

(+    

  +  " & +   





 2@@@A  

3 

+3  ! (

+  +  22 ///+





 ( =  +  /A/ //0  

  =  ?

 % +! 

?3+%

 B ?

  +<=   

   





    

   

 5      +    (

   

  " &                   

 ;

'*"  %"#) .

)"%# ,&

#

'*

-) " #"'

 "'

' % "+& '' # & #"+-')"# '*"  '% %(. % '

"*''(+ #"*' ) " "+ #"'

'   ( "*'*","

,# %( " ')& ) "

"&#')"# # %#" ', ( - *

- ) " #"'

"*

/

"'

' & '

) "#"*&"."'*".'# "*% )"* % * # %")-"*'"#

",& '  ' "*=E) (. 

 3 (%-# *"4 = 2(* F'')

,9 "# 9"

F'' )" +  9"