High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/43709/2015dismissed

Mandeep Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-02-01Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!" #$% &%'()(*+ , #*&%%-.(*/0 %$($(*%1 2%1)3) .$#$% 3*4#5#*&$0%1) %)-*&%*$) + 67 .8 7 .

1%)%*$+ 14#(9(1.(*/0:&9'#$%: 1$0%-%$($(*%1

;0%$0%1$0% %-1$%1) <'#<*%=)-#-%1>#?5%#<<=%&$ )%%$0%43&/>%*$@

5%1% %11%&$$0% %-1$%11*$ ;0%$0%1$0%43&/>%*$)03<&5%1%-1$%&(*$0%&(/%)$@ 7 . 7"

7%#1*%& '3*)%< 1 $0% -%$($(*%1 0#) (<%& =%1

$$1*%?*5%0#< $0%-%$($(*%1(*31$$&#?:=($0*54%'$(*

1>$0%%#1<(%1'3*)%<:=00#& (<%&$0%-%$($(* >-3/*%& (* $0% -1%)%*$ -%$($(* () $0% 1&%1 &#$%& **%A31% ":-#))%&5?$0%<%#*%&&&($(*#<.%))(*) 3&/%:#<#*&0#1:9(&%=0('0$0%1&%1&#$%& B **%A31%

":-#))%&5?$0%<%#1*%&3&('(#<#/()$1#$% )$<#)):#<#*&0#1:

)3>>*(*/ 1%)-*&%*$ #) #* #''3)%& (* $0% '1(>(*#< '>-<#(*$:=#))%$#)(&% 1(% #'$) $0%'#)%#1%$0#$$0%-1%)%*$-%$($(*%1 (<%& #'1(>(*#<'>-<#(*$3*&%1.%'$(*) :,:,:,B: #*&

#/#(*)$ #9*%%$ #<.(*/0#*& 3-(*&%14($8#31:&#3/0$%1

31>($.(*/0$=#)#<<%/%&$0#$ #9*%%$ #<.(*/0%*$%1%&(*$#* #/1%%>%*$ )#<%&#$%&

(* #931 $0%-%$($(*%1 1)#<% <#*&>%#)31(*/ C#*#<)>#1<#):)($3#$%&#$9(<<#/%#<=#<: #&5#)$:%0)(<0/-31''3)%& 3-(*&%14($8#31=#)#<) -1%)%*$$0%1% )<#C0)=%1%-#(&#)%#1*%)$>*%?$#''3)%& #9*%%$ #<.(*/0#*&/$$0%#/1%%>%*$%A%'3$%&)-%1 $0%$%1>)#*&'*&($(*) $0%#/1%%>%*$:#>3*$ )<#C0) -%1#'1%=#) (A%& 1$0%<#*&#&4(*(*/$$0%1#&#*& ),<#C0)

1$0%$0%1<#*& 0%&#$% %A%'3$(*#*&1%/()$1#$(* )#<% &%%&=#)>%*$(*%&#) B (%# $%1#53$ D?%#1)$()

31$0%1#<<%/%&$0#$#''3)%& 0#&)$#$%&$0#$0()51$0%1 #4#*

#<0#)%A%'3$%&*%3*1%/()$%1%&;(<<(*0() #931#*&0%0#) 5%'>%%A'<3)(9%=*%1 $0%)#(&-1-%1$? ''3)%& =#) #<)-1%)%*$$0%1%#$$0#$$(>%#*&)0%#<)/#9%#))31#*'%=($0 1%/#1&$$0%/%*3(*%*%)) $0%)#(&;(<<3$:* , :=0%* $0%'>-<#(*#*$5$#(*%&$0%'-? #1&4#>#5#*&( 1>#<E#

#$=#1(:$0%*0%'#>%$C*=$0#$$0%<#*&0#)5%%*)<&$)>% $0(1&-%1)* * B :=0%*$0%-%$($(*%1#--%#1%&5% 1%$0% .35 %/()$1#1'*'%1*%& 1%A%'3$(* )#<%&%%&:#''3)%&

&(&*$#--%#1 0#9%0%#1&$0%<%#1*%&'3*)%< 1$0%-%$($(*%1#*& 0#9%#<)'#1% 3<<?/*%$013/0$0% (<% 0%-%13)#< $0%1&%1 $0%1%9()(*#<'31$)0=)

$0#$#''3)%& =#))$#$%&$5%-1%)%*$$0%1%#*&>%1%<?* $0#$5#)():)0%'#**$5%)3>>*%& 0%<%#1*%&'3*)%< 1$0%-%$($(*%10#))$#$%&$0#$ =0%* )<#C0)=%1%-#(&#)%#1*%)$>*%?:*&'3>%*$ $($<% =#)'0%'C%&0%'-? 4#>#5#*&( 1$0%?%#1 ,-1&3'%& (*31$$&#?:&31(*/#1/3>%*$): )0=)$0#$#<<$0%)#<%)=%1% >#&%(*$0%?%#1

(%# $%1$0%%A%'3$(* $0%#/1%%>%*$ 0%1% 1%:#/1%%=($0$0%9(%= $0%1%9()(*#<'31$$0#$*'#)%() >#&%#/#(*)$#''3)%& :*#>%<?: 3-(*&%14($8#310%'-?

4#>#5#*&( 1$0%?%#1 ,)0=)$0#$)#<%)=%1%>#&%3$ # $%1$0%&#$% %A%'3$(* $0%#/1%%>%*$ )#<%$)0=)$0#$#$ $0%$(>% #/1%%>%*$ )#<%:$0%1%=#)*(*$%*$(*$'0%#$0% 3*1%/()$%1%&;(<<($)%< :%9%*( #<<%/%&:&%)*$'* %1#*?$($<%:

3*<%))#3$0%*$('#$%&5?$0%31$0%

%*'% '0%#$(*/()>#&% 3$( $0%#''3)%&0#&#*(*$%*$(*$'0%#$ 1>$0%9%1?5%/(**(*/ )35)%E3%*$<?:#''3)%&$31*%&&()0*%)$:.%'$(* ()*$ #$$1#'$%& %1%:$0%1%>%&?<(%)(*#)3($ 1)-%'( ('-%1 1>#*'% #/#(*)$-1-)%&9%*&1#*&$0%)35)%E3%*$9%*&%%*$0%5#)()

-1(1#/1%%>%*$ )#<%0%1% 1%:$0%1%()*(<<%/#<($?1(* (1>($?(* $0%(>-3/*%&1&%1&#$%& **%A31% ":-#))%&5?$0% <%#1*%&&&($(*#<.%))(*)3&/%:#<#*&0#1%*'%:$0%-1%)%*$

-%$($(*()&()>())%& 7 ."

, )4C)