High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26561/2021allowed

Nirmal Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2023-03-20Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj5 pages

## ! !"

$!"%"

!& % '(

! ## !") *!

! !"#$%& '()*+&'&)$,'

!"!

+# ,-, .//0*12 !& !)! !"- ,-.% !"

.%"

00 % '(- ,- %) *! 0*12 !&!") *!

-3- '&)$,' ' !-. !)!"!

)! "(!!

&!*% *!!2 563- )7

&8%"

& -9:* !*;;-;<-3<3<!

" !!*% *! "!2 "95;093=095 2! 0,!

0" 2 " % -;><* !*>-;<-3<3<% *!!2 "5=30935053:0;56 *;5?

" !!* 2! 0,!

0" 2 " %

! "%("!8%!

)2!!*

" "

!!& ! ("" & 2)"!* !*5-;3-3<3<

!A%! #9- 8%!" @" !

" !!*(72) #!") *!

-3 * ! 1!" 2!

2!* !!

- @!1!0 @ !1!

&!")!2 (!"0& 7 !) !"1!* "! !!

!7 !"1!* ! !"!*")% !0@ "))!

& !2)"!-

!(""& !"!0 !)! !" 1/

)@!& "

% (7)7

2 !"!)2!!*

"@%*(!&% !

!A!2"! * (%"!&)2!""& %"0 ! 8%!"

* !"%("!8%!

)2!!*

!!&7(!8%"

!!" &'%" 2!- "% 1*!*!"* !*;9-:-3<3;*!2 !* ))! (!&! ! 8 , " ! & !2*

! " !!

"0 "

*!*(!&! !8, " !@""*!2 !* "!

* "!) - )%"% 2! !"!0! !*,0(/ ( "!

"!) * !*;9-?-3<3; "% -B !!) ""

!A!* !) 2)!"&" !!

"&2)

" !!

&22%"!*C)! !"

0 *!!)

@ " !!

&,!(! 7 '

!2*!*

;3-6-3<3;-

2)7 & " !!

& *!1

!2*!*

3<-6-3<3; ""(!!

!A!*@ !!) - !(""& " !!

"0! !*,0(/ ( "2 2%*!* !!)

))!" 1!!

!!* 2)"!1% 7 * !! " ! 22%"!* ! )!"!

2"! * )! !"C22%"!* 1! (!!

*!2!* 2!* &&!

*! "

2"!- 1! !*! !*2% "!& !) !"0)!%"!* !!2* !!) "!

(7! !*,0(/ (- (!)!%"&" % 7)1" !563- --@%* "

@ !

% 7/!"%2 *!"0"7(! !2!""7

1!!&&!2 7*!% *! "*! )!1!

(%"!& !)2!""

& 7% !@"! "!2%! !!

*"&'%" 2!-!2 93<- "!8%7!!1 &2 "*! 0@ )!"2(!" !)2!*%!& 2)% *

!&&!

2!"% *! ! * *!-

.!!)

1!@ %!&&&!

2!"!

!*72 !* !&2 ( 1!2(7"! !* !*")% !0 &2 )"!2% @%*(!&% !!A!2"!- ! D(!

%)!!% %(!&2"!" 2%*

B.S.Joshi and others 1"State of Haryana /0- )12-31-

&@!*(7 "% %!

2"!&41.5 /-) 60/ 0- 7 )189/0-:

1!*! @ !))" 11!* !)!"!

2"! *"! !* !@- !!& !0 D(!%)!!% Gian Singh ;

State of Punjab and another )12-31- &% !*! @ !""%! !!!@"! !*(7 !%)!!% &8%"

& State of Haryana ;

Bhajan Lal:

)122 ) -

>;& !'%* !

!*""% *!+#

%&'

(

)*+ , #

- +

(

!("

( - "

(

.- -

(

(- (

. 0

(

(- *

(

2 ( 3

(

- -

(

( -

(

# "

(

+ ,

4 ))7

!@"! !*(7 D(!%)!!% )!

&'%* !

" "

% 0 "))!

@ 1!

!!* 2)"!0 2 !)2!!*

"@%*(!

!!7 (%"!&)2!""& *(7@

*22!)

)7!& !)! !"(78%"

@%*(!"!2%

*"& '%" 2!0 @ ")7 !('!2 & !!

" %!!

% *! !2 563- "!"% 0 "% & *" !2"! *"8%!7&"

@ !( *)! !""! !*(7'%*2)!2!*!

" 2!0 -9:* !*;;-;<-3<3<!

" !!*% *!"!2 "95;093=095

2! 0 ,!

0 " 2 " % -;>< * !* >-;<-3<3<% *!!2 "5=30935053:0;56 *;5? !

" !!*

2! 0 ,!

0 " 2 " % * ! "%("!8%!

)2!!*

!!&!8%"

!*8% !)! !" !(""

& !2)"!- !!*!"" "7 !) !""

! (% *(7

! !" *2 * "& !2)"! !" !!

"!2*!* (!&! !2% (!@-

! " *"@!*- '&)$,' '(<& %2/7 !")!/

C!"

!*+ !"C ! !) (!+ !"C