Binder Singh v. Harcharan Singh





    
 




















 








!"

##$$ % & ' " 
!"
(
$

" 





#      

  ) 

 
) *
)$
!"
+"",
-

"
##$$  
&#
".,
-

"
# //// 
 

+"
##$$0#$


!! -

"
.&!*

   
12
"
$3
##$$
4& ,
3" 12
"
&

.
# 
"
&
# # 2

$
.
#

"
5


" ,
" 1
*
12
"
$3
##$$
4& ,
12
!

"
.&!* 
 

"
 $
4&   
) *
)$
!"
+"",
$ 
&$
## !
 1"$
##$$0#$

&1*
"
 

3"


$ 1&
"
"

"
#$

3"
" 
"
# # 2
*
"
" $#
!"

!  "

"
#$

,
"   ,
"
# # 2
 "
"
3
 $

& ,
"&,
&
"
.
"&
*$2 # # 2

"2
3 

**
*,
,
3 7

3 "#
+"

  #$

,
 
 8
1!
*$


$!
*
"
$

&
! 

.
3 

"
5

"
#-
"  ' " 
!"
&$

"-
$
3"
"
# # 2

"
*
 *


"
#$



2
*# *


 

5&
2
* !!6$



  ,



 9:

,

 : 9:


+"
 $
4& 

"
1

"
 $
 &* 2
-
 
"
&
+"
.*1

"
2 
9:

:8
;5) ,

8
;5) ,
:
;5),
9 0
;5) ,
9 80 :
;5)


#! 
1$
;5)8,
"-
1
# -

 



# - "
"
" 

& 

"
# # 2
3
 $
+"
 $
4&  

73$!
"


"
 

"



"
" # # 2
3
$ 0<& 
1&
"
$3
##$$
4& 
"
1
 
5*!
"
  *
&* 2
-

"&,
" 
 $$!$2

# - 2 )
4 ,
 
&#
".,
$ 
&$
## !
 1"$
#0 

&1*
"
$$
"
&* 2 -

-&
 



"
# # 2

"-
$$
* " 
! 

#$

1!
& "
! ,

,
$$
" .*1
"3
"
# # 2
"
$$

' " 
!"
*
$# !"
3"


! 

$!,

"   ,
#$

* 1$2

$

# -
"
& 

" 

"
# # 2,
*&"
$,
 #$

 
=71

#
"
'!"
4& 
&$

  
&#"$
12 "
4& 


  

   

 

"&
& !
"
4& 



 *!
"
!

"
$3 ##$$
4& 

  =
"-
" 
$ 
&$

"
# 

## 
" ##
17


"
-3
"
" 


 

* 

" &1*

 
+"",
 ,
##$$0#$

"
* 1$2
$
 " !
"
&

" 
&


"
=
;- ,
 ,
.*1

"
2 
0 ,

,

8,

&1 "3
"
3 "#

"
# # 2

$#
!",
-
7" 
&*1  #
$
"-

1
"3

1
$
,


" .*1
 

"
*

' " 
!"
$#
!"
 !  "

"
##$$0#$

,
"   ,


 
1-, # # 2

1


1
 $

& 


"

1
" 

*
" 
! 

$!

#
# 


&$$>
'&
?3


;
=
*

"
-3
"
!
!-
12
"
$3
##$$ 4& 
1!
"
$
4& 



$3
1
&#
"
## 


"
 $

&* 2
-



$$

  ,
*&"

$,

&1$
<&

$3
 

 *  !$2,
# 
##$

* !" # "$ 
 

    %&'%& ()& *+,-.

& (/,&01 &(./ %&'%&  &)/ '

&1 &(./