Board Of Governors, National Institute Of Technology, Kurukshetra And ORS v. Mess Kalyan Employees Union And ANR
!
"#$
% &' (' )
!
#% % *
% +' ' ) , -.
/
-
/.
00- -
1'
- ,"'
2-- 0/
2/-
'''-
- 23 4/ 2'
-
2
-/
!!!! 2
-/.
5/6 " # $$%&$$' ( ) * $ + $+$$ , - .%/*012 0 ( * * $
" ( #) # ) "#1 $++'
" * ##1 3 (## * * 0 # ( # 41 ) 3
) # 1 31 # (. " 4* * *# " 0 4 1 0 0
01 (
" #
01
(
31 1 (
* #1 *
"4
2 0
02 0 ( 01* 1 "##*6 * 2 0 ( . 7
! "
# #
# "8
"4# *
:
0 1 # * &( #; #1 <
" 04 * * = ( ( ( (
2 1 > (
? ( * 1
"1 *## $5< 1 "1 * 01 =# (
* # ( > ** 1 #41 %
"2 0 ( #01* *##
41
# . # 0* 41 0 4 "1 0*6 # * " ## * #1 41.
" 01 : '
" 2 0 ( * 0 : $<+ * 1 1 #
# +1 * ##6 #0 " * 0#*. 7$%&
'
(
! '
)
&
(
*+ ,+
( ( - .
/ .
.
.
0 /
.
1
/
. # 2 &
'
!
'
3
#
4
& $5& ( #
'
(
(
( #
6# ' $5+
#
( 3
& -
) 3 6
#) )
)
*+
!
#
7 ' &#
8 @
** " * 1 " *
01 (
> &(> 1 #* 0141 " * #1 1 31 1 * # #1 * (
" (
## 1 1 * A 1
# *
### "41 (A * (0 * (A3A 1*
01 (
# "41 ** "41 # 1 1 > &( > # 41
**
01> &(> #* > "41 * * #41 * "1 *
5 * 1 "1 :
*## 1 # 0#
#1 41 =C0# ( D
! "#"$ 2 0 ( * : * ) * ( D! % & '(& !(
)
"!* "
.
* #
1 # *
1
1 +
"
0 #. ,/ #) "#1 01)" $++'
,/ ) ##1 01; ) )
10 *
3 ,/ ) * ( #;
,/
##
* 1 ?
# *## ?
# # 0# 0# #1 ,/ 0
1 1 # ,/ " . * * 01 ) .41 ,/ "1 * 41 # ; ) ,/ "1* 0 01 *
0. ,-/ "
**
,-/ 0 #1* ##* ,-/ "41 #
#( # ? * ,-/ *# ** * 0 *
01* ,-/ " * # #
" *
#10 ( + ! , * ,&- ./ 0 !()
#1!
) * ? " ( ## ( # # 0 <%B
+ # 9 ? " 4 4 2 0 B' , D2
/
*!8/ "***1 1 # @ *1 * #1
"*&# * # 0#1 #1 0
# 1 0 1
#1 0
1 "
## ) #"0 #=( ( " ( *) # 2 0 ( 5+ ?"4
42 # ( E ! % / 2 . .
"! ?"4 42
*) # 2 0 ( " 0 * ## . !
4 # 0 #1 #1
0 #
# 1 * 0 #
#1 *) # 2 0 ( 5+ ?"4 42
## ( E " ( .!
) # 2 0 ( C 1* 5+ *5$ ?"4 42 "# - 0#*. 7$8& 7
9( (
1
2 02 / '
'.
:
( ," !
&
'!
1
02 /
(
(
'
;& 1
2 02 / #
0'
.
'
'
(
'
' ' '
'
(
'
'
'
# # ' #
'
'
/& # (
0'
.
,+ (#
(
(
< (&
'
# '!
(
(
'
8
;&=
'
'
0'
.
# ( (# (
& (
1
2 02/
#
0'
.
( #
( ,&/
'
#
( ,&
'
'
# '!
(
(
( 8
;
#
0'
.
,+
/
!
'
.
: & ># > & 2> 0 > 4/ &
!
'
( ,
' '
#'
( ,(
' # .
#
( ,#<
#'- .
/ $$8
.
/ ,$
.
' # ( '
#
'
'
( ' &
( , (
.
/ ,$
-
.
/ $$8
'
# #
&
( ,
0'
.
#
,+ #
,$
1
2 02/
# # (' (
'
8
; #
# ( ' < &
( ,
' ( (
#
0'
.
,+
1
2 02/
'
8
; ' &? ,%& 7
# ' #
#
#
= 5+,
#
&
'
= 5+, '
.;
.
#
' (
(
:
<
( '
'
=
'(
&
&
'
.
=
(
'
= ' .
'
&
( ' < ' .
'
)'
= 5+,(
'
#
' (
(
&
.
#
#
'
& # '
.
.
.
(
.
'
)'
(' ( .
#
'
(' ( &
(
# (
60'
.
,+*'
(
#
'
(
#
#
'
'
&?
$
) ) # "0 # # * 0 #
# 1 * 0 #
*
# 01 !#9 %:
!;
"*;
<) " 1 0#*. 7*+& # @' @
# '!
(
(
# &8 "2 0 ( # % #9 ?"4 42 *1 +< #) 0 * #
"-7 # 0 8 0 $, /) $<." $<.4) 0 #1
# 0 "2 0 ( 0 -*# * )
# 1 + < #) "41.
* 1
# 1 *0
0 * D # 0 C
$, / * +< #)
E *2 0 ( * * # # 0 :
* #0 # $, /$<."$<.4 59) * 0#*. A 3 %
0 04
B C * % %
0 0&D
#
/ *E$8 *8
*E$8
'
& -% 0 ( %
0 0 &D/
#
'
' '#
# <
<
#
# <
# '
& 5"(60%%%0 &D* .
3
'
/
'
(
'
F (
& $ .
G
'
/&8
A # . 1 + < # #1* 0 #
# 1
1 *0 #
*
# 0 $<."0
# 0 $<.4 0 59:
A #1*
1 # 0
0# * *
1-% ( :
#
01
1
; <
) *
2 0 ( 01 ( #; (#
.,/ 0., / 0.,$.
/ + ) " # - + ) 0#*.
,% 0% 7 )
* &D* F (
<
' # D :
C
' '
# ( .
7 C '
#
(
0'
.
!
C '
#
( #
'
!
9 2 ( #
F (
0'
.
9 2 ( # ' (
$$ ' ( F (
' ( (< ( # '
<
')
#
/
(
9 2 ( #
# . F (
F (
'
F (
0'
.
' '
' F (
& */ <<< <<< <<< $ <<< <<< <<< $//
0'
.
'
'
# # 0'
.
'
' '
#
(
9 2 ( #
#
( #
<
9 2 ( #
'
#!
0'
.
'
'
<
0'
.
'
'
< <
' # <
'
92 (
')
#
'
0'
.
'
' ' ' !
. ( .
' < 9 2 (
'
0'
.
'
'
')
< #
'
&8
%
"2 0 ( *
01( #; +, /,/) (#
# # "0 # A 1 # # ) 0#*. A- .=> .-> 0
H
/1 --G 1 >.==B0/:= 1.= 1 *&
'
C $&
C ,&>
#
# #
C %& #
( C 5& #
) C
8&/ &? A--1> .-> 0
H/
/1 - - G 1 >.= =B > 1/0 1:
/0 *&
C $&.
# C ,&-
#
(C %&0(# #
C 5&:
(
C 8& # # #
C H&.
' C I&1
C E&1
C *+&1
#
' C
**&/ ' ' &? '
"
# # #1 < # " # # #1 # * #1 #1 # # # * " < # 0 * # 0 "
0 ( &"0 # * # #* # 01
( * 0 ( # # (# @
"2 0 ( -** ( 5+ ?"4 42 5+ ?"4 42 *) # 2 0 ( 4 ) # 2 0 ( *# 1
D # 0 C
5+ ?"4 42 0#*. @,+&2 #
0'
.
&) *
'
)
'
' ' '
#
'
C '
'
(
'
'
'
# # ' #
'
.
'
/C #
'
'
')
*
$+
$,'
&
$
'
/.
!
# #
#
9 2 ( .
' ( # ' & , B
7
/.
( #(
.
)
'
( C '
<
C
C
<
# & %.
( #
'
#
#
(
'
'
#
'
7 '.
(
' ' &@
" ( # ; ) # "0 #.
.2 0 ( ) * 015+ ?"4 42 ) # 2 0 ( " ( ,&- . / 0 !(
#1 # 5+ 5$ ?"4 42 ( E. &"2 0 ( )
*# *
+ ) # -*015+ ?"4 42 ) #
0 ( 2 0 ( *#1*# 1 # 0 6 # $+
"2 0 ( #
1*
# 1 1 + < # ) 0 !#9 + %:
)!;
"*;
< ?"4 42 *
# 0 "2 0 ( # %9 # ?"4 42 *1 +< #)
#0
) 0 0#1#
% 9 # ?"4 42 * 1 + < #) * ) #1 ?"4
42 "*2 0 ( * 0 ) 2 0 ( ?"4
42 "2 0 ( **##
0#5+ ?"4 42 * # "0 # # 5-=#76 "2 0 ( 0 * 0 ) "2 0 ( #010 ) 31 ( *## 6
. #
# ## 1 * *# - 0 * 0* =* ( 6
. #
1 #01 "**0* (
1 0-01
$
".41 0 01; )
#1 ; ) ) ##1 01 ( #; - #1
## " 41 " 01( #; " #1
* ** #0 ) # 0#1
**
1
#0 "41 ( # ; 1 * " 2 0 ( : * ) 0
* 6
*
#1 )+ 8( 0
.
- 29! /(
: ! 5" ) ( *# # * % 9 # ?"4 42 # ; * # # 0 0
01 4 " 01 = ( # * 6
#101 % #9 ?"4
42 0 " #1 0
1 "# - 0#*. 5 ' ! - .
#
' .
' &
- .
#
& - .
#
#
' '
F (
'
8
;
1 J2 02/&
- .
< $+++#
(
'
&
' ! ' # $+)$)*EI5& # #
7
# & '
- .
#
7
&K' # -
.
( # #
' ' # &
"B 8
;
1 J2 02/
#9 A8& L' M
# '!
(
(
&?
#
( &- .
#
' &=
' #
#
A' ? # '!
(
(
" '
#
F (
&
#
( &
F (
#
'
'
'
( &
( ' - .
#7 ( ' 8
;
1 J2 02/
'
! '
& #( - .
#
#
' .
' & # ' <# *)%)*EI5 &$H
*EI%
&? $$
F E( %%0;
.<-
)
1
!
* " # 00 #1 " @5E&
'
6
'
7
& # # < (
& /
'
'
7
&
! ( # .
# #'<
# <
' & .
(!
'
' '
& #
! ( # ' <
(
' ( '
& 8+& ! %= -.. >
1! ?
1 !@!5:5A> (
:
# G +, .! %/ > #:5 !
? #:5!@!
A/ 7.! % &> #:"5! A! %= -.< ,& !( > #: ! 1"" ? #: ! @! 55 A !( < . % B > #1 5 ! # ? #1 !@! #A
8. 2 !( .C(
>
"! 5?
!@! 5A
9. 0 >
1 ! ?
1 !@!5:5A ..&H+*% @ # '
# (
C ' #
<
( C
'
(
( ( F (
#
C
'
'F (
' C # '
# F (
C
'
'
'
# &@ 8*& ! % / 2 . . >
" ! ?
! @! :
5A .
: (
<
# # '
'
'
'
' #& 8$& 8 . % . =
>
1 ! 15 ?
1 ! @! 1#A # )G :
9 ..&8II*5 @*5&
&.
(
< ( (
< ( (
& .
< ( (
( (
& -
( #
&
( ' - .
(
(
'
' &G
$5
A 0 0 # ( & 0#
& &. )*
- * # *#
* # 0#1 $9
) #1 &
* ** ) * *
# 0#
#&
#& 1 0 ) *
& E1 2 0 ( : ** 0 # 3 ( #( 2 0 ( 0 ( :
&
1 * #1 1# * 01 $<
=( *## ( $++%
1 &4 ) : &* & .&
#& #1 * #1 " ## * # ) $++% ( E . !
* 6 :
1& & & #1 * #1 " - ( #1 1&
# #1 # -1
0 " ( # :
# #1 * #
# #:
0 " :
#1 # # 9 %H5+B( ) " #1*
* #1* # 1 0 # #1 #1 " = (
# #1 0 :
# #*
#1 # = ( "
# * 0 #1 #1* 1 0 # 1
0 00 "# - 9 @%,&
7 ' '
.
#
.
# '
'
(
/ *%
(
# 7
/ *% # / *8
.
&
#
' .
#
#
(
7
#
&
#
# ' #
#
&
'
<
& '
' ##
'
#
' ' ' ' (
#
'
( '( &
(
#
# '(
7 &- .
/ $$8
.
'
#
&
'
(
# #( ' @ @
! #
' '' ' ( & - .
'!
' '
! # ' #
#
'
#
7 & '
#
'
( '
& %%&
@7
7# @
# ( '
' ' '
( ' & .
(
7
7#
&
7 .
( ' & :
#
#
' ' # '
&>
# '
7
& #
!
'
.
#
'
( )' ' '#
' &
'
& < D 0
> ## !5# ? ## !@!:"? ## 8*# ? ## !, ""AF (
' ( &
( ' '< (&
(( '
&#
'! <
!
/ $$8 ,$
.
<
#
/ *%$
.
'' ' ' '
& .
! # '!
#
' .
.
#
# # & %5&
' # '
#
'
&
#
#
& - # & '
' )
4 ) ( '
(
#(&:
#
' !
( #
# ' '
&:
# '
'
#
'& # (
#
( 7'
#
#
' &/ '
' ( <
#
#
' ( #
'
& /
' 3
(
&
<
' #
7
& # ( #
#
&
& 7 ' #
'
'
' (
'
( ' (
&
' #
#
'!
( # #
#
# ' !
' ' #
'
# ( #
7
/ *%
.
& %8& 0
.
'
<
.
<> ' '
< D > ## !5# ? ## !@!:"? ## 8*# ? ## !, ""A !(> ##"!
1? ##! @!1 ? ## 8*"
5? ##5!,1 AN'0+ ./ E 8 -) ## !1? ## !@! ? ##
8* #:O
N
& 8( 0
.
-., 70 )
5! :"?
! @! 5O
( ( <
( # ' &
'
(
(
' (
' ( # ' '
) !
# < '
( '
# #
# ' (
C (
) #
'# # # (
(
'# # &N 0 > 0% . ! .0 .+ %.! .0> #1 85:"? #1" 5 8 C, #5 ? #1" 5 E,
:" =A 7 (
0 .!,( > ##1:! ? ##1 !@! ::
A
0 -< .! %,& >
55!"1 ?
5!@!5A&O
# ( ' F (
#
#
#
'# #
<
# # & ( #
& .
.
<>
# &
( ' ( #
( 'F (
< D0 > ## ! 5# ? ## !@!:"? ## 8*# ? ## !,
""A&
#
!
/
( '
- .
' .
&
(
(
<
' '
' (
'
&
( (
'
'
<
& #
& '
'! & %H&
#
'
3 ' ( #
7
'
&
(
<
'
#
'
'
# 2' ( .
&
<
' ( '
&
'
#
# &
& '(
' ( (
' & %I& #
/ *%
*8
.
( &
'
#
< #
# # #
# & '
#
#
##
&
#
#
' & # #
#
' (
# ('
'
( & '
# '
#
(
' (
7#
7# &
# ( '
#
' ( '' ' ( &/' ' .
' '
'
'
# 7
/ *%
*8
.
& ' 7#
#
'<
7 # # # &# ' 77&
'
'' ' ( ( ( ('
( & '
/ *%
*8
.
( & %E&
#
# #
#&
#
( ' .
# (
&
' #
' ' ' '
'
'
&
(
# '
'
# '
'
&
'
'
#&
'#
# #
'
'
&.
(
' ( ' ' ' '
( ( ('
(
/ *%
*8
.
&G $% A ( E <. 0 # # :
* 0
1* * 0 # 01 # 9 %( " ( -
#1* ##* 0 I
#& #1& * "- # 0 1 # " :
0 * # - # # * *##
# 9 % ( # - 0#* / " * 0# #1 ( *## 1*# * #1 # # # #
6
#
* # 1 / "=( #$$%( # #1 0
# # *
#1 # / # # * #
* ##* 0# 01 # * 0
* #0 #6
#1 1 " *
1 # 1
0 ( * #
##10 .01 0# 01# *
0# #1 / ) * 1
# * #1 = #1 *1 )
10 0 . J#. 0 #1 ## * E
# * # 0 # * * #1
##1 #1 # 0 0
#1 E1 *## 0
0# * 0# / #
# 1 #1 0# - * # #1 # * # #1 #1
##1
##1 * # 0 #1 * #1 0 #
/"
0* *##0 *
* #1 * * # 0# 0#01# * 0# #1 * # # * #1 6
#1 1 # 9( / > 1 #1
#
#* 0 # 01 # # * 6
0 1
#
# / 0 # 01 ( 1 0 0 # #0
#1
01
* 6
# 9 %( -/ ) #1* *
* ## * " ## * #
01 (
* # G $'
0
-(
* ##* 0 *
# # 9 %( ) $@
* F E ( >% %:
>7
%!;#"
$'
,7#!7?
/7@%# >% .
5 6 ) - # :
# #1* * 5+1 * E ? I :
" # - 0#*. :
4
' ' ( '
:1=
'
'
(
.
# '
#
' ' '
' ' ' ' (
#
( '( &N!
(&
( ,N$++8% ..*9$++8 ..0J H5,OC=
0 7 (&>
N$++I*+ ..*9$++E* ..0J E%,O C
(& F . N$+*+ , ..**59$+*+* ..0J I+%OC
(& .
N$+*+$ ..%$$9$+*+* ..0J ,I5OC 2(&
: N$+*+% ..*HE9$+*+$ ..
0J ,5,O
1 #>(&
1 #.
.
&0 &N$+*+** ..H,,O? $B
*F E ( %B
.8B* (
)
# !::5##* 2
) #
# #1 # :
= (
#1 :
# #1 5+
E( 5 +< $+ @
F( *-( .! %= -
)E : %
" #1 :
01 " (
#1 :
# #1 * 0 * ##*0
0 1
# # 9 %H5+B( ) 5 &
*F E -( %B.B<.) !#
6 :
#1 4) "( *# ( # =( -* : #1 "( # #1 # 1 1* #1 "( ( 5 9 %. B* 0#* @,&%& :
!
N % B.B<.)
!@=
""O- .
#
#
9 >( N%B. B<.)
!@=
""O ..= 2J-$$)$,
@$$&
( # (
<
# & 0
' #
<
(
& $,& < '
(
( # '
# (
$+ ) # ' @
@ '
F @>@ #&& & *)%$+*5
$+
( # ( &@ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< *8&#
' .
)
#
'
) &2 (
#
F (
7
7# & *H& / #
' .
'- .
!
N % B . B <.)
!@=
""O
$$
$, '
'
#
! ( #
- .
<
#
/ $$8
.
&( # 7 '
6> '7
#
,+)8)$+*% # '
# #
' .
( N! %/ 2..)
"! ?
! @! :
5O #
) # #
#
& /
#
'
' 6F (
'
&
'
# (
) ) ( # #
'
3
,+)8)$+*%& *I& #
(
$,
'
F >4
# (
$+
)
#( ') # # #
(
# F 4>4 &- #( ( #
' .
G:G
>%B.B<.)
! ! #55O #
#
7
$, !
N %B.B<.)
!@=
""O
4
& *E& ( #
'
(
'
('
& !
N % B.B<.)
!@=
""O ' - .
$$
$, !
N % B . B <.)
! @=
""O ' 7
&- #( '( 7
$,
!
N%B.B<.)
! @=
""O
' $,
!
N%B.B<.)
!@=
""O '- .
&G 5$ A 0 1 ## #1 * 0 ##* 0
0 : )
0 1 ) #
# 9 %( )
#* # :
# = # # #$ ( ) " ;
#1 ##* D C # 01 # $() )
1 ( # " ** ##* #1 " * * * " *
> &( > * 01 &A (
* ( # E *## . E ( #1 # #1 * ##* 0 0
# :
"1 0 : 01 = ( ( " :
* #
# #:
0 1 # # 9 %( ) "2 0 (
( E.!
. ( "2 0 ( #1# ( !
.
** 5+ 5$42 " 2 0 ( # * #1 .41 " 3 #1&3 #1 # 0* 41 * " ( #
*
* > ( > # 41 1 # * " ** * 01>
" "0 # .41 ) ; 41
* 6
#1*
10 1 "410 # A # "
01 (
#
1 # ##1 * 1 # A 1 # > *# 1 1 # # " *
01 (
1 * 01 (
" (
1 #1 * # 01 > " * 41 " * 0 0#1 ##*D* C $,/ ) 1 # # 01 ) * 10 #1 41 " 41 1 1 0 3)&A "0 # . # 0*41 * 5< )* 0 ( 0 ##* #1
##* " 01.
+% +B $+$9 A2
-/B
> & K& > 0# K&