High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44830/2016allowed

Lal Chand Sharma v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2023-08-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul27 pages

#$ %

$%& &

'% ! '(( (

) '(* (+

( '( '

($(

, #$ &

- ( '(+.

)

/ ( &

( '%( 0( 1&

2 .

3 (!( ( 4 *5 / ( 00((06

37 3 5!

9 $* 9 ( ( &

: ;< 1 &9) &

) ) 9)

0((03

(6 ( &

*5;

=!:0<& (7 &

0((03&

= ( ;< 1

9) &(& ) & &&$

& & (1 9

94 9

35!

( ;< 1>

? )

)

9$ )$ )& &

$ )

) (

9& &

)

@7( 9 9$ 1, )

& 9$ (

; < 1 ) 94 9

)

35!

( 1 $ 9 &

)

. &

) 9 $9

) -& )

&& (5) $ $ 9$ & & ) 9

0(0((A &$ 9$ *5) B $ = C ) ) ) $9 9$ ( 1 ) & )

*5 4

). &

$ )&

9 & )( ; < 1 9

) && ) #D 9$ 9

( &

;

= !< ) $

$ 9

9$ ( ; < 1 *5 ) $

4 99

$ 9 9$

$ & $( 5

9 9$&

;

=!:<

9 9$ $

37@ 5!

) )

9$ & *

9 $( 1 )

)

) 9 & ) 9

9$ )

$) )2 &

( ( !

&& 9$ -&

&$ &

)

(* ) && &$

;< 1

& &

) & $ 9

E / (7

) &= &

9 (7 )

E / (6 ) & )

) 9$&

(* &

9 $ 9$&

E 4

)

E/ (6

7 9 99

& $ ) )

( ;< 1

) &

& 2 1

E 4

(5) 9$2 & 1 &

( ;< 1

;

=!:< 9 $& )

& &$ 4

) 9 ) 9$&

= ) &

E 4

) 9

(( ;<

)

4 & &$ 4

)

9$&

;9<

E/ (6

7 9 99

E / (6

) 9 : 99 ( ; < 1 $ ) )

& &

& $ 4$ &

*5 4

. ) 9 $ &

0((03 7(6 9

) 9 9) &

) ) & ( & $ 4$ )

9$ &

) ( *

) 9

0(0(9$

( ; < 1 9)

4 99

E $ )

*5( 5 & ) &

4 &

)

(1*5

9=& 9 $

& 9

$ & &

9 =&

*5 ) ) & $

) ( ; < 1 $9

)

9$&

9$ )

) )

9 &&

)

& 5

51<( ; < 1 &

)

37@-37 ( 5!

)

)9$ 9$)

& 4

37@-37(5!

(F ) &

& 9

) =

$ &&

)& 9

0(0(0@ & 9$ #

G9 #

( ; < 1 $ ) ) *5 9

00((06((&

7((0@(& ) )

9 & 9

$( ;=< 1

3 (!( (

& 4

) & )

9 & *5 4

9 4 ) & 4

9 & ( 3( 5 &

( 6( 1&

2 .

3 (!( ( 4 *5( 8 & )

9 &

) 9$#

?9 &

)&*+*,+-.+/++/0*1,-2 1 1+4+/%+5+/0*1,-2$ 66 & () . &

&$ 4 *5 ;0< 71,-, *1, +55,8+*9/2 :+0, 9/ *1, 9-2* /-:+*9/ ,;-*-*1,<:;5+9/*(,3,/9*1,.+-,*+=,/+**1,9- +<,3+5>,+/0+<<,;*,09/*1,9-,/*9-,*.0/*;-9:+

+<9,</2*9*>*,+/.,/<,-:+=,>*+<+2,+8+9/2* *1,+<<>2,0? ;< F

$ & $ *(5((

H9 .$

067;0<

' ) & )

066;<

I ;< 71,-,*1,>/</*-3,-*,0+55,8+*9/2:+0,9/*1, - <:;5+9/* +/0 *1, ,390,/<, <55,<*,0 9/ 2>;;-* *1,2+:,0/*092<52,*1,<::9229/+/.,/<, +/0:+=,>*+<+2,+8+9/2**1,+<<>2,0? ;3< F

H9 9

: H9

& 9$ &

) '

066;<

I ;6< F

*5 9

$& 99

9 )

& &

& I ;7< F =& 9 $ &

;

) & <

- ) & &

& &$I ;@< 71,-, + <-9:9/+5 ;-<,,09/8 92 :+/9,2*5. +**,/0,0 @9*1 :+5+ 90, +/0A- @1,-, *1, ;-<,,09/8 92 :+59<9>25. 9/2*9*>*,0 @9*1 +/ >5*,-9- :*93, - @-,+=9/83,/8,+/<,/*1,+<<>2,0+/0@9*1+39,@* 2;9*,19:0>,*;-93+*,+/0;,-2/+58->08, 7(

*5;

=!:0<

)

! "

! !

" # $ !

# ! % &' " ( " ! " "

"!%&) *+', - " . " "

/ "" 0"1" 2 ! 3 * .

&4546 !. $/ "" $ " !

! $ # ." " . $ # # " 7"$

" 38 ( !2 7"

" 7"

! $

# #

" $

" " 7 "$9 , "

" ( #

$ ! ( ! " : $. " ! 7 " $ "$

"" 9

# 7 "$ ,

! " #( # !$ !

# . " 446 9" " #( ." ""!

!! " #( "

." $ #. ." # . . "# #7"

$ # " #!$ $ # " ;$ %!! ." $ # "

7 "

" # "

( "2 ## !$

7 " !

# #! # ! " " #

! $ # # 9 #

( #!$ "$ #! !

" ! #

" " # ! !

"!$ #!

7 "$

! )444440< 2 . . # ( / # !

(" . "7"

! #=

@( 1*5 4

)

00((06(5

) 9$ $

& )&& 9$&

9$) &&

( 94 $ &

1 ;

51< ) 9$ &

;

= !:< ) &

3 37 5!

( F

070 (!( (

;< 1 &

E/ (6& ) 6( 9 &

((

((030((03

6((03( ;< 1

6((03&

26(

$( F 4 ) #D 9 9$&

)

E 4

$( 1

9&&

2 4 #D &

& 4

((

E / (7

E/ (6) ) ) 9$(1

$ 9

E/ (7( ;< 1

0(0(03 ((

) 9

) 1 E = ) &

&( ; <

) &)

9$&

& @6( 9 2 1, ( ; < 0(0(03 &

)

7(6 4

E 4

)

9$ $) ( ; < 1 &

) 0(6 ( ( * $ )

9&& &

3 5!

) &

375!

( 64" " # $ #! # >"$ " " #" # " $ $ # # # 9 # " ." # ! $ # # " ." "

." " ! $ $ # "

" . " ! "

! ." " # ( $ # "

!= ( & 9 &

35!

& 9

35!

;< 19 &

& ( ;< 1 &

& &$ 2

$& 9 $( 0( 1

35!

((

) 9 &

9 $ &

4) 9

( 00( )9

E/ (7 ) #D 9

)

$ 94 $ 9 ) 4 #D( # ) 9

2 :

E/ (7 ) #D

E/ (6(5 9 $ 9

)

9 )

9 & ( &

*5 $ ) )

)9 ) 9$&

#D4

E / (7 4

$ (

)

$ 9$ &

)

) #D &

E / (7( A

9$ *5 4

070 (!( ( &

2 )

E 4

((

E / (7 9 ( # ) & 9) &

6((03 & ) 9

) &

= ( 0( 1 99

E 9 )

9$&

)

4 99

*5 4

070 (!( (5)

= 9 2 99

9 & &

E 4

9 : 99 9$ &&

(* & 9$ 9$&

0((03 &

: 99

E 4

((03 (( $ = $

) ) 9 94 $) ) 9$

(# 9 $

& &

)

E 4

( 0(

& ?

070 (!( ( & 9) &

6((03&

&$ )

) &

E/ (6

E/ (7

$ ) (

:&$

= ( 03( 1 9

$ 9 4 9& 9$

94 9

(( &

( 5 ) 94

9 $ ) $

$ ) $

& &

)

) ( 06( 5)

9&& 9 2

9) >94 9

> ?( ' 94 9

)

9 $

35!

$ 9 &$)

9 &&

)

$9 9$ ( 07( )-90+.+ +/8+/ 0 B,-:+ 32 &*+*, 91+-$ !# & ( #

?9 &

)

35!

94 9

( 1 9

?9 &=

) '% ! " ! " " ! " ! " .

! ." " " $# " ! "# !

# " # $ # # # "

! ! " " " # " ." " " $. !". $7 "!

! " !

" 7 "

! " !

" )7 ", " 9 " " . "! "!! ! " !7 " ! "

" ! ." " # # " , ! " , " - " !

" !

" ".

" " ! " " " ." "!! "$ " ! " ." " " ! "!! " #! " # ". " "" !

" " !9 "

" ! 9 , # " " " " ." " "

+? " " ! " $ "

! " " ! "!! !

" " 647

!! 656*" ! "!! 6)& '46 4<1 $ "

9 " "

" " " . " "! #! !3 # " $ 1" / " &&@A 22

@ A*5*@ A ".

! # " 2 " $ " #

" ! " ! "

" " ! " ! "

" " ( #

# "

" " "

" "#

" " ! " " " ! ." ". " , " " ! .

# "

# 9 " . " #

( # $ # " " ! " ! " $ " < $

"$ " " ! $ 7 "

! ! " "3 " . "

," " " "! "= 0@( #

?9 &

)'>/*932 &*+*,**+- -+0,21$! #& 6() ))4

&3.$

" . " " ! " !

" ! $

" # $ " B " ! $

! " !

" ". " " ! " - # "

!! 9 .

B 4 .< " ! " ! "# $ % &'

& (' )* ." " !! . " ! " !! ! " $ " " " ! "

" ! "

7! " ! "

" "! ! " . " " "

#. " 7+,!-% ./&'0 ) ! @:

" - ?A $

B6" -" 12-" 13&' (( 4 &' 5 6 $ " " # ! "

(

! "

#."

#! $ ' " "

$ #

" # 7 2 # 7

3&('(0(4&(' &'

**6 "

$ " $ .

, # " ! 0

" ! " $ " @ # 7 2 #7 8

3&(' (0(4&('&' **6 +6& *A B* #!! $

." " $ $#

!! # # "

" B 3$ " $ .

< "

" " # . " #

# #

" ! "

"" ! # $ = 0( 1 9

& 9

35!

9 9 &

( 0( &

35!

9 & &

375!

(

365!

>9 ?) &

64' "! >"$ # . "

# . "#$ #" # $ ". " # " # ! " #$ !# ! .

"." " "

" !# ( ." """ " " " ! " .

# !! # "

"! B= ( 9 = &

365!

& 9

36 5!

)

9 & &$( # ) &

*5 $

$ ) $ $ & &$ 9$ &

( #

& 9

37 5!

( 0( 1 &

37-35!

$ &

0((03 7(6 )

) 9) &(1 9 &

& $ 4$

9$&

*5 4

( ( 5 9 ) &$ 4 *5

94 &

= .

(!( (

& -

& 9$ &

0@;<

(!( (

)

2 & $ 4$ 9$ &

& &

& ('

& &

0@;< (!( (

9 )

37@-37 5!

(

)

) 2 &

$& * 9 $;* <) 4(5

( (

& & *5 &$ &$ 9$ ) = )

$ )

&$ 9$ &

&$ ) 9$ *5 &

B & $

C(5)

*5 4

@7( &

) )

( # ) ) ) & 9$ )

2 $ &

( 3( )2 9

&& *5 4

$ 9

)

&) $ 9 ( 5)

9 9

9$ #

?9 &=

)+1:05932 &*+*,$%93, %+@!&# ) )

" . . 9 $ " >"$

! " $9 " " " . 65! " !

&+* @

A ( #

)! " "72 "

# " " " ! #!

$ $( . " " $ ! .

9 $ " "

" . # 9 "72 . "

#># " "

. " $! .

9 $ "". " "720 $ # .

! . "

" # "

. " "$ " 720 " " "#

" # "

!! " ! .

" ! " 9 " $ "720 ! " ! ." " " #

7 !

$ $( " . # 9 # "

" ! " $ $ "$ ! . "

. " " ." (

65! "

&+*

)! " ! # " ! . 9

" $

" 0 ! " .

" ! $ 9 ! " " - 72"$ $ ! 7 " ! "

" ! 72 " # "!.

9 $ ! $

?9 &

9 $ &9$= & &

& (

3 (!( ( ) &

9 )&

)

9$ #

?9 &

)'+;95 88+-@+5 32 &+/4+. &1+-:+ " *1,-2$ !#!-9:9/+5#

9&& 9

9$ #

?9 &

)+-+:4,,* +*-+ 32 &*+*, **-+=1+/0$! # & ) )

+ >" (

65! " "3 " " " . # #! " !

$ ! " !# " . ! >" "

!! " ! !

" >" " !

!! " # " 3 "

$ # "$

( 1 " 3 " ." " ." "

#! $ $

!! 7 " !

$ # $ ! " " " "3 " " " ,"

$ ! ! =

7( 1

&9) &

$ ) $

& & $9 & ( @(

& *5 / ( 00((06

37 3 5!

9 $ * 9 ;

= !:0< )

4 & )

9 9 &

9$ 4 (1&

) ( ! '%# >8>2*(

F&2 -

J-/ F& 9 J-/