← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12818/2022allowed

M/S Chirag And Company Pvt Ltd v. Additional Deputy Commissioner Cum Collector Sbs Nagar And ORS

2023-03-23Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur12 pages

   

   

  !"

#$#%&#'(#)%*+%, - %(*(.#'(!+%./- !0$/1%+2 34+(,&561315#'

#5151(#% 7#%$*$ ''151(+8 #4*5,331$$1(#%9.*3988#.5%:/+/##' /+2+5:1(2/

+2+%-*(;+)+('5/#%$ #$4('#(5$ !9 < 6!:::= 

     



    

:=- !

"  #   #  $ % &     !'

( ')'! *+  ,-.    / !) ')'!

*+  !-.  #       

  -!0-'(1,       

'

"   

   #     !( ')!-    $#  ,  3  4 #    #    5& 6   6   7 21  ')!)   8 4%  #  "        

          & 

     #     3 9+  '2 !'

')!/ * !.

"  #         &  &  

  " 8 4%    6   7 1-  ')!:   5& 6  $&         

         &  &  # # #    '

/ ')!: *'.

"     0 '

')'! *1.   8 4%           %          

      +      6%      +     #  

;& <      # +   !'

( ')'! *(.      11!1')), #   :

( ')'!

        --'')))),     &       +    6  5# 

;& < = 7 1  

  !'

( ')'! *-.

        6

 

7&   (:   3    !200 *  >5/# .5>" &      &  

  +     

3  &   & #             #   7

1   7 !       !'

:

')'! */.   7 ! &    $             (:        "    # +&,    #  

?   / !) ')'!  #   7 !  #

  $&  (:                -!0-'(1,       

   #  &   &    # 

(

4      #  &     #              &  8 4%    8 4%   +      %            $&     6  6  "  (:      $                  

3  

   %   # %      # #        &                   

    

5#    #   # &    &  5   # 

-

        #  &             &   

       #          6 #     6 &          & 6  #  

  &   



  6   :5+5#    +;+$5/+(  7$  !0$  =/+('+?+  +1( #@#88#%$ "1&18"

 &        #     & 3   &     #       &    &    

       #     6

 ;

&               6  #   #  #  

 

/

3              $

:

"    %    #        &           

$            

 (:   3    !200            

         

         

 

           

  

        

     

          

   !"#

     

   $    

 



        %  &            '(       $                   )   

         

                  

        

                        

               * +                              



    , - . $       

          /     

   

 0    

   !"#$   1, 2 !"#                         $     /       3  ' /

               

     4            

                   

                 

   4    

    

    

          

     )          & 

                     

                               

 

               % +                              



    , 5

 

    $  

 & ( -   

                       6$

 7                              

   , 84,(9                     $                   

    4        

  ,:

"     (:       #  #  &         

     &        

  &   #  

 (:    #  6           &         

  

@   &         " 6

          &     8      

  

  +&    &  #     

         (:    #                             9+%    

3

  $             #     $     #     # 3   #         #    

  

$        A   +

!)

"      #         

     #        

     $      #      #   #         $       #  & "  &        7   #&+'$$  &  /1#  #&#(*#  (5%8  1.#9.*39 ($4#.5% %$- "C: B #         #    (:   3    !200        "  7  &      <  3   B ;  *<3B;.                 6

 3  

 

  6     >    ' 5;             ,.   < $ =       , . 

             ,.      4 

  ' 5;(    



      

                         

 ,> !!

      +88,+)$(5#%(+51(+861315#'& :5+5# #$5 #(2+8"+8 -   <  6  #  # C    #  #                 C  ;   B   9     3  '))'   &    #    $    6           C   ;B9 3 

$& #     #   #   &    $     &&  

            #    &      $

!'

3    &    

  6   #21$5%+%$$*%+(.#$&:67,+4+%%1&+5#65'  " 1&18" A- # & #                     #    >''

                   '  5;

     

      ?

 

         



     , &-,                         

        

          

  ,@                              ,A   

     '   

 A @  

    ' , ,                      

      

    (       

     '     

 ,'    

               ,  .                     ' 

       

   

  ,    

    

                  ,    

       , .                      

     

     

      

   $ 

       , &5,

  , .     ( )  ) 4  

        

        ,  8                         

  ,   

                           

          ,> !1

3           6  6          8 4%       6         6  

"                       &         +  5& 6   "  #       &     &&        &      

!(

4       &  

  6     &    :5+5#+;+$5/+(:*4%+"          $       #      &       

        6 5#   &   &              3           #             &     #      & "        $   + &   &                     "       &          +&  3            

&              5& 6 

"   %   &   &     

!-

"              &           "       #   +&                  3  &   

     &    

  6   '%#;

:+%+  6##  65'  7$  D.1$#  +('  +D+51(  1.#%9*39$$#$$1(2 *5/%15,::"C - #      #    %   #         &        %     #    3!+2+'/ :*2+% (#%2,61315#'7$/#:5+5# 1/+%+('5/#%$  "

6 -

  6    !0    &    #   #  #    +      &&       

3              "     #          $       &            D "     & 

   

       #     +   &       

?  

     +&  #         !'

( ')'!

  &     !'

( ')'!      6  / !) ')'!    (:    "   #

          

     &

!1

" #   #     

!+%./- :="



  @ $&,  E @ ;   7