High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44937/2018dismissed

M/S Saroj Construction Trading And Another v. Mohindra Engg. Works And ORS

2023-01-11Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

"# $ %

&' ( ) *$ (

+ & &,- ( . ) ! ( /0 1 (. .-0&&'2/0 1 . %(. . $ )(3 4$( & 3 &0" "

/ 2 6(

+ & & ,- ( 1 " # $ %

&' ( 2$55 &

7 28.$/( ( ((.

( 3 .$ ( 53 (1 . 5 ( . 5. 8

9/ (. ( .$ ( (5 ( 2$5 9/ /

"/ $ '(

(

" '.

38 ( 5 3$ ( 5

& .85 ' 22.

&7$ $ .85 ($

&5$ /( 5 ( ' 2 1 0. 5 / ( ' 2 ( $

&5$

/ /99 "/'(

(/(

. (

$ (4$3 &

/ /

"/ . .85 / '(

( . (5 38 ( .

5. 8&

( $ (5-6.85 .. 38 ';1

7 (5/( ' GAURI SHANKER 2023.01.17 11:09 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

& (. $ <0 (

<) $55 & '.

= $ 2 ( . ( ( ' 3$ 2 3' ( . .

& .$ ( (1

53 %(. (12 8 5 22(.85 3$ $ 5

/ ( 5. 8 ( ' $ ( 8 (4$ & 1 ( 5 5 2 %( . ( ( ( .

8& (. 38.

/ .

( (4$( 2 83 38 (. (7 -..

&(.85 & (

(4$ ((( /2 $ 2(. .. (.8 (&$ ((. (3 2 3 38 ( 2 2 $ 1

/ .

)(13

& ( 5 > > ?32%($.5$

!"# $! $ %& '

( (2 (/ 6< 2 2&2 .. ( '( 2

4$( & ( .

& ( $ ($2 @- 22 223 ( @/ ... . $ ($2 3 2 $ 2( 5.22

$5 0 ($2 3 ($ $ ( ((2 ( 22& (15$3 ,( . $ (

2& 34$( /(3..2 38( '((($ 1 22& 5 /. 5

32 (( 0( & (

( $ 53- $. 4$ 8/ '(( ( 22&

2 -28332 ( 381

($2 $#$ & (.33 8/2 8& $ (22& ( @

> ?32 %( $.5 $ <

($ ))!'* +'$,'"-,"') #,, #$,,) +!'$!,'

,!)'$ 20..2

/((2 ($! < 1 ' ( 31 ( 31/$ 2$ (.

.2"

$/ '(((> &($'$2 3#$ . &

5 8 "6

1 .3 . ;/ &(. 8(4$( . $ ) " $ 0

9 ( $ <

$5 '(( ( > &( $ '$2 3 #$ . &( (

1 . 3 . ;

22 ( 2 ."

(&( )/ '( 2

. "

&" 4$(

"A< B

.' $ ) " $ 0

9 ( $ <

/$ 2$ $ ! BB BB BB

1%(.'4$( &($2 3B

. &28 '

(

$5. / ( 3 31 / C 3 $ '

( ( 5 B (. 28 1 ,( 2 B5

& A<"

/ 4$( & '(

( $&(/ ( 53- $. 4$ 8(2 8& $ ('

(22& (A<"

D 2.

&$&( 3 $2 (

2&D

E$( & "A<($2 3 B . ((

8$2D

28/( $3 5$$.

( .2

( ' & ( . '.

.( $&( 1((.(D

B %( $ ( #$

8 ( .2

5.25 8/ 12..

&D B 1 B . 2 '( '$2 $2 5

&#$

/($ #$

2 . ($2 ( &

D +B

8 ( .'($

3 8 #$

( $

& '( 5 .

%( 5 . 2.

(5$

222 22 &( . %(/ '( ( 38 (.2

.&/( $($2 & ( 5 ( 22& ( A< )2

5$ 3 .5 5.2 ( < '$2 3 .5$ . $ 2$ 3 (F8

( ( "A< 1 3

& ( 5$ 3$. 2' 0 / ( &

( ( $3 ( ..2

5 38 (

/ ( &

58 2 ... ."$558 3 2 & '(

( 58 3

38 ( 2 &

((- ' . $D BB BB BB B1,( .84$( &(A< 5 38( 22&

$'( B

(.' )/ 28(

'(( ( 22& ( A<

2 55

& F32 %( 4$

5 '(( ( 5 ( 22& 5-$ & F32 ( .5 ( & & 8".2

&(22& (A<GBBB; < ( .#))' / !&&

,!)'#$,,) +

,!)'

= /> ?32%($.5$ <

( (2 (/ 6< $

2 .

3 .. (3$ 38B

$ () 283 $( (3 2 & 38.2

2 12 < . 32(2 58(13 2 & (3( .2

2.. >'1/$ (. 8'$2 #$ 8 ( ) 4$( ( 2 .

& 0 31 31/(. 82 (.(. 38 ( 22& / 2$(2 3$2 $ %(22& $ $ (0

0 ,(((22& $$ $/'$2 (13

2< B

.'$ ()/($ B5 ( 22& B . B . 228 '( . 28 2 ( ( 22& 12$

2 8 %(5.2 "

$ ( '(

(($2 34$( (

. 2'

: $( % 2 %( > &( $ &(28

( ..2

$ (); 1 &( (. /( ( 283 $ <0 3$2$

<)/ '( ( 2 2 $ ( . ( $55 & < .. ((

.$ 121 / '(( ( 4$ $ 38 ( . ' 38 '8 8('

/'(

( 5 2 (5 3&

38( $ (. .

&A$(5/. / '( ( .. . A 5/ ( 3 2 1

. 38(2 2$ 5 (3 (>

& ( 5$ 0<)/2

(3 $ & 2 ..8 (

/ - & $ .

& $ )& ( 5 0 & 5.2

. 25 (1 & 3

$ & ( . /

$3 328 8 . / '(

2 ?3 ? 1

& ( .

&/ (38

28 2

( 2'/

28/ '$2 1

$2& 22 $(/ 4$( & ( . 2 & '$2 .#$

/ 1 '

& &( 5 ( 31 > H32%($.5$ ,!$!0"

*'$!

#$ !) ,,) 1 #, + + )2!3 4 ' =)2 :

'( '(2 (/6%(.. 2' $ 31 5- 3$ 28 2(( $ ($2 32' & (2 4$( & . 2&/'( ( $2

18 (25. 8.

$2283 $(2&2

9 .$5. / ( 5 ,( 2 ( ( $2

($ (1 &

8 1

3 5. (324$2 8/2&(

.1(22& %( 4$ $2 2. . 2 & 3 &1 .32 E$( & .

& .2 8&'

22$2 2 8'

($(. (1 &( ..$ 8

4$ ( ((.. $5 /( 2$ $ 5' &( &(5 21

< ( 22' /(

583& 1 $ 5 1 &

2. 023 $(2&2.$5. /'( ( & $

.$ 38 ( ..22 / ( 32

1 ( & 1$( ". $ /(

22(1 $..$ 8

2/3$(.$5. ; < 1 '(31/( $

( 5.$& 38 1- & ( .' $ )/ '(

(.(B. 2'/(13B

. &28 (

$5. /( /'(

((. 22$ 0

&28/ (. . 3 1

5 (38

1 3 &1 ,((.- &" ! I" ,((.32 !I"