Birbal Singh v. State Of Punjab




   
 



 "#$$  %&'( ")* $$+$$

, %!-! (

-".&  +$$

"0





  
 


"# 1%$ $2$($ *

'3405 

%$ 1%$(%&. ( ")**

644 -".&$

 


 % 7! %

66  ") *

/-" !*&'

 -"0

0-' " 4 89 :

% !* % ;*  <=$ , 0 .-0)6 " "0

% 0 0 $9$4 '

0 -0  ' 1) !% 4
! '!!4 1"!4 * '0 * % )- '>

 ! 0

  "0 0* 6


> %"0 />

!$?"04 "0

-'

/>6

4 -%* %-"0



%*%

6 "*!$ ))% ) "!4* 0"//

0( "!-0) 41"!$, 0 .-0)6 "0 $$4 * 0 00  "' ( "! -0) 4 1"!4 0 !6 !!

 // %4 * &> 

%6 ") .-0)6 ""0 %/!!

0% '1) !% $ ( ''))% 04* %*!/%

%% "% "$

:= % 6 "'/% - " "* "!

7!!

 " 6 6/' " 0 &> %$  %6' ( ")*4 1 0 '

%4 1 "  4 2%"0 4 (%0-')%*4 " -* % @

 $ " A$$  & - $ $6$4 *

6/' ""'

")7 *%$ -/ "0 %2-6%4(1 2* ' 2'"4 !% 1"!4 "!/ 6 !

%4 ! - 0 "* % 

,

%)%4 %2' 1"0 %4B%0$ 4 1"! "0

-"0 *  -!

% " /

7  *-"0% '00% "3& '

6) *4

!'

*-6" "!-6/ "$* 6/' ""/-%*!

0! C& '

'0 0% "3 

  6) *

%  !-6

!$? 6 * -!

%$ ( 0 & '

! 7  0 5 0 0 "  *%

 /%! "0 */%7!'& 0"0* "7%// 0 "!% ")* 3 // %$* "0!

// %7 /! 07 *)-6$* "!' / ! )"

' '*-* % >41"!47!/! 7%//

* & '

$  % /% % !

' ")

 !6/'

'

!4! )"-%

%7 '!

& "

0$ '

0 !6/'

 /3  7! !

"  -&'  "'>!

-".&4*"0 )%*&>*"0*% -)*!/  '6 ") %$* 6 " ") 7  !6/'

 /%! 7 !  0 7 * *  D  '*-* % >41"!$

%!7 60  .

" "0 "0 7 "

!4 &- " 5 "$ ' 6 '>4 * %

  -&'  "'>!4 -".&47!%

** "!

 !6/'

 7 "6 " 0 7 * ' 

%6 & %  "0 !-!/ "0 06 %"0** !6/'

'!

" "

0!-)%"0 !**% " 7* * 7  "

 0 '%  '& ' "  %0"

7 ** "!

-'

!60 $*

:= ! / %4 *  !6/'

 7! * '0   &  6 !&%"0 0 "0 0-' 0$ %0 ")'>4 "%

/

%4 6/' "7!

0$* 07!!-66  % '$
"* *%) 5 0 6/' ""& ! 0

C6 " ") * 6!

 ! B4 *0 '!

C6 "

B 7" 2-6% *%6 !4

  5 ' (-%)

"4 1"!E B 6

.4 !/*'

%3"0 B9 6 .4

"$ *%)  -"0

  7! %6 ) "! *  -!

%$    *%)  "0 ' 6 0% '$
" * ! 5 0 4 "

B! 7! C6 "

6/' "" ! *  -!

% 0 0 "

 /

!!

C6 "

- "7 "

!$ (

0-"0 "%$ $7!

04 7* " 7* '

"> ") *  ''

) "!4 *  -!

0 %/'

0 0 ""

 &! !

5 0 04  !

0 /%

0% ' -%** !6/'

& '

!/-%*!

0

6 *  !* /

 -!

% 7  0-' 0 "0 6 !&%"0 0$ * 0

 -/ &> *  -!

% * * 7!"

 7"

!* /"0** 7!"

/% "*  6

 % 0 "0- 6/' ""4 % 6 "

-"!-&!"  0&>'

0 ")"> ) ""0 "5 " ") 5 0 "* !% )%0$ %0 ")'>4!"

0& %7!

0 -"0

  "0 !

 %0 ")'>$  *  //  -!

% 7! 0 !6 !!

000  "'( "!-0) 41"!$

:9= * 5 %> -!

4'

-"!

'

0 % 0

! "

 '> "> *''

")  

%-"0 "

"0% !% !* !/%> % F-"-6

!

"'>$
 !!-&6  0* -

'!

> % 6/ 0-/ %4 %*!'% 0>-"0 86 "*!"00>!$
 -%* %!-&6  0** 6 " 6-6!

"

 !! C6 "*!$*-!4  !/%> 0* ! * % *! '% 0> -"0  "

%'>  /

 ! C "*!4 *  6/ 0 -/ % 6> & 00'% 0>-"0 % *"04 * 0 ( -"!

' *!4 7* '

"% % ") *  

! 0 !-&6 !!

"!4 %)- 0 * -)** 6 " 6-6!

"

4> *5 ") 66  ! 0

""

& * %0/'

0 ")** !!-&!" 5 !

!* -'0 00'% 0>-"0  ''>7* )- '

%  !

0 0-'> /% 0 &

  -%! 7$  *-!4  /%> % ! 60

% 0 !6 !!'

"$
*5 * %0'

-"!

'

/% !"07 * %&'

!! !"

4*5 ) *% -)**

%0!

!

 * *   -%! & 7  % *5 ") !%- " @

5 0 "%

%0*5

0 "0 ")

)- '>$*-!4*

% -"0

 4 ! -/* '0$

:8= B* '

6 ")   /%4 3 ") "

"! 0 " * * % *! &

 ") *  ) ">

% '

'!6 *"> %!"0* * -

'!-&!" 5 !

%*!'% 0>-"0 86 "*!"00>!4 "6> / "

"4"

-!

-'/-%/ 7 -'0 !

%5 0&>!

"0 ")* %& * "0* &%! ) " 6 " ")!

$* !  ''>!

7* 6 " 6-6!

"

 !  6 "*! "0 * %4 ! "

0 & 4 *! "

%'>  ! 0 / 0$  *-!4 "0!

 .-!  7 -'0 & !- &'> 6 4  6/ 0 -/ % ! 00'% 0>-"0 &>* 6$

 6> &  60    .-0)6

 "<&'

 (-/%   -% " 1-"  /'  %/

  '*  ,!$  3*"0* 4
G(47* "7* '

3 ") "

"! 0  6  ) ")  %-6!"

!  * "0

-!

"4 *   "<&'

 (-/%   -% % 0-

" 0'% 0>-"0 ! 0!

'!

% -

0 ")!-"0 "

$
"5 7

& 47* '

-/* '0 ")*

% -"0 "! 

 4 *  !-&!" 5  6/ 0 -/ % ! % 00  '% 0>-"0 &>* 64&-!-&.

 />6

!$8? ! %"0& 6 -"

 6/ % '

:= -%$ *  6 -" !*'' & ! 

0 % '  -%4 7 * "  /

 7  6 "*!

6 0>$

" !0 !/

 "* &  %6!$







  
 


!

$$ 0!
B* %(/ 3 ")?

!

0#  !? B*

%&'

#  !?