← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11608/2020dismissed

Malviya Shiksha Sadan v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner-Ii And Others

2021-01-06Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill13 pages



      

 !""# $%& '!()*+','- .""

 

                 

       

 

!" # $%    #  



 # $% &' (       # $% &)*     +++



 /* 0' * 12 '3 ,4 ! /'2 /,2/ ( )!)2(,,1'3!/4'(0). 56

8%9*%'-':/3*/':'('.:4'/'*!(/* ; 4 *32 <,'*/2 ! ( ('(

7 #=,

& 4'**(1-/ ,(00**6 ! !')* )**'- ! '(>,()' ! / 0' ' /' *4(804-*  *4(* ?@'2;/*0/*. !( ' )04' ('( "A @ "@ 2'(2 / 60 '* 

001*!0/(';/)//-1)'021!/*'0*'(!

 / ***' ,( 00** ( ( ('(

.4'**(,(:)@!/04-*C ,(*'( %*)',* ** ). 7A" #! */ 8 D/ )C&. )),(( /' /!/)04''*904-*;1)*((!0/('*'* 0(/*'((/1'**!',*(),0*3=4) )!)'.(-)'(!/*)/'()00('!/*)/

/))2',/- *'1*/084.;'*()(4( '/1!*(,!0/('!/>2/*,00,0 ;'2*,4/(';

 !

;/)//-/'(1)0001*!/

 

  '( !,/0  */' !0 / 04-*C *( ;,( 1 '3 !0 / 04-* '( 0''20 ;'* ()(  1' / *'0 !0*;*,)* *''/**'2/'/)*-.;/)/ /'( 404( ' ! 4)(2*. ( ',( / 4( !0 ;/)/ / *4(* 8 04-* ; 21 ! / 1!*  / %''20!/46*,/'('(0(-1'31-/ 4* %''20 ;

 !

 A

"@ *4(* 8 04-* ; ('*001*!/

;

 !

;.*4(* ?  @ ; )'02 21- !0 / (' ! / '440*  / -'* 77@67 ) ( ('( "

 ;'* )/'2( 1- / %''20 1! / '( 04-* ,( 44' 1,' ' ; /#!*/8D

C& E'(

((('(

#=, B&.1*(/'/***' ,(00**(( /'>,*()()(;//'04-*(.<,( 1)0/('!0;/)//**(<,(1)0' 001. ,( 4'' "

6 ! / 04-* ,( :)/0. 7A" #! */ 8 D

 *)/0C&   /,*. / 0' ;'* 0'(( 

,(00**!/))(''()(/('!0 ;/)/ / 04-* ; (  1)0 001* ! 4,4* ! /

,()1,*

,*,'  / 0'(. 04,2( ( ('(

7 #=,

&;'*4'**(1-/ ,(00**#&

/ ,( 00** ;/ '32  ')), /' / ; %''20 /'( !'(  4(,) / )( ! 04-0 ! *4(804-*./(/'0)/'2!%''20;*/4 )'(4/04-;3!/*'(*'1*/0!0/ *)' *),- 1!* ,( / )  E'( ,( 00**2'('(*)1(/*4)!)(),0*4(,)(1- / 04-*  <,*. '* * ( !0 ' 4,*' ! ( ('(

7'(4)((/(*4(* ?@121! 001*/4!/04-*C ,(*:)/0. 7A"#!*/8 D

*)/0C&'*1;+6

 :/ '0*/F,0';

 !

"

?

77   :/ /'04';

 !

"

?

77  ?

 :/ (F,0';

 !

?

@

77   :/ :/'2;';

 !

"?

@ "B  :/ /'0('*;

 !

7

"

8*'1*/0;'*()('/04-*'* 

001*!0/('!/>2'((4*/4(!,( )1,;//-#?&('-*!)4!(.!'2;/)/') ,(:)@!/);,(1'(

80''204!(''44',(:)@6!/ ) '2'* ( ('(

7 1! / '( ' 0 (,*' 1,'6),06E'1, ,6. /'(2'/  '-. '( 

((('("

7()(/'))*4*1'3 '2'*/4 :'((;'*0(!(""

7#=,

& ;/ )'!-2 /' 4)(2* ,( :) @ ! / ) 0'- 1 '(9),('2'*/'44' *;4;'*/'! !( @ "")/'22(('(

7#=,

&.

''./2,(/'/'( ,(00**8  /'* =)(( * >,*()  ()2 / 4  (4* /

)1, ;

 !

 !0 / (' ;/ /-  ;3( ,( / 0''20!/48*,.;!/!(2)((1- / (,*' 1,'6),06E'1, ,. '4' ( ';'( ('(

?

  * '*4'((/'' '44' * 0'''1 1! / '( ' 0 (,*' 1,'6),06E'1, , ! )/'22 ( ('(

7 ;/1- / )*- ( * ,(4''"

6!/

*)/0

 '* 4')(  )( ' '44)' ('(

""#=,

A&0(1!/'('0 (,*' 1,'6),06E'1, , *32 ;/(';' ! * '44'. /,2/*!0(;///'44''),'-*'(*;/('; E'(),*!/4/'*/0-'2,(/' '44' )/'22 ( ('(

7 /'* 1 !( 1- / 4 ,( 0*'3 '() !0 * ),* '* ( 4'**( 1- / '(

,(00**,(4''"

6!/

*)/0 *!''('44'*,(:)@6!/) :)@!/).  * *,10(. - ('* ;/ (0' ! / '0, (, !0 / 04-,(/4**!/) *!,/)((/'/* )),*4!!04-0!*4(* B@!/4( 4

E'(),*!/4/'**,,*-( ,4';'(('(A

?4'**(1-/(,*'1,'6),06E'1, ,. '4'  *4) *4(   B. ;/)/ /'* 1 4'**( ' !),(:) # &',*#)&!/(,*'*4,*). 7B@. 2'(2 2'-  >,*!)' ! 0' ! / *)* ! / *'( ;30'. 1- / %''20  1,'-. "

  * *,10( /' /

'( E'1, , /'* *4)!)'- /( /' / ;30' /'( !'(  4  )( () ! *''-. (  )( ! '440  2'20!/4(4

:'(!/%''20 / !!) /' )( 4  "@ ;'*  '''1 ;/ /0. /'* 1 )( 1- / '( E'1, , '* ; '* / !') /' '*4 (4'0!/*,;'*)*(/-'" '(/04- ;'*04-(1-/%''20 /*;!/0'.*'2,(/' /'( ,(00**/'*;2-(,4 / (),0* 4(,)( 1- / 4' *4(* '( / ! ;2- '!!(( *./,*.4'-(/'/;41';( E'(),*!/*4(*;/!,2/'1 *'('0**,10(/'/)<,**'1!)'2*' '(4'/'*1/;/)/*,*!,!0!/4,4* ! /* ) ** ! / ). /,*. )' 1 4(  ' '; 4(')0' *'2,(/'/4*!')(,22!,0 /,2 **,10(/')/'(

/'(0(!(9)'!( (('("

72'20!./4*4/'*1 !(   %. ' '44' ,( :) @6 ! / ).  * *'(. * 0'''1 1! / 

  / ' 0 (,*' 1,'./4**,' E'(),*!*:)@!/ )'( ,@#"&!/

# )(,& ,*. 77@ )(2*,( 4'' "

6 ! / :)/0.  * *,10(. 0''( !0 / 4)4' 4)(2*,(:)@!/)'(/0';'*0'((/ 2,( /' / '( ***' ,( 00** /'(  >,*()  ()( / *'0 '(  * / ,( 00**. ;/  * 04;(  ()( / *'0  E'( ),* '2,*/'%''204'-(/('(*3;//',/*'(3'

) 4'!  12 4****! / )(4  "  '( "@   * !,/ *,10( /' 1*'*  ';'( ('( A

 4'**(1-/'((,*'1,'6),06E'1,,. '4'( /''-')/)*-/'( /***!/'*/' 1! / '( E'1, ,. / 04- ;'* )/'22 /* 0'  / -' "  1- / *,  1 )) '( ;2!, %- 1)',* / 04- ((  )/'2 / *'( ';'( 4'**( ' ,01 ! -'* '! /* 0'  1,'-. "  )' 1  /( '2'*/04-*.;/'4;3* *4(*804-*.* *,10(. ; '(0(- ;32 '* (* ;/ / *,. / %''20!;/)/;'*'31-/4*/-'"@  * !,/ *,10( /' *4(* /'( (,- 4( / (- )'(*. )!

)'* **,( 1- / ,0 *' *')/ **)' */;2 )04 ! (2 '2 42'00* 1*(* ',* / )!)'*9(),0*'*;'*)00('*!// )4'!/ 46*,!;'!/04-*C));/)/'()'( /*'(*4(6;30121!/1!*,(/).

  *. /,*. 4'-( /' / 4* ; 4 1 (*0**(12((!'-0  /' /'( '( ),* ! / 4'* '( /' 2 /,2//!;//'***')  / ,*.  ;,( 1 ,*!,  ! / 4** ! :) @ ! / ). , @#"& ! / 

 # )(, ,*. 77@&. :)*@.@6.@6 !/)'(4''"

6!/

*)/0 :)@ '(*'*,(+6 @  



 66 # & / ' 0 0'-.1-!)'/ !!)''G.'((.H'0( '-. / 4*4)-  *4)-. / :)/0.

/H *I:)/0/*,'):)/0.'*/)'*0'- 1I H#"&-!)'**,(,(*,16*)# &*/' 1'(.'**'*0'-1'!***,(.1!')/,* ! ''0.;/****.!''4(!/- ('-*.;/)/0'-1)04*(***;0 *,))** ****. '( !. 1! / =4- ! / *** 00('- !;2 / ***  / *,))** **** '!*'(.1/,**'20'32'-0(!)'/ !)'.1/,**'2/'/!)'*/,( 1**,(./!)'*/'/'!/'!!)- *,)/0(!(!01!!!).'*/)'*0'-1J*. /;. /' '- *,)/ 0(!)'  ',0 */' 1 ;/, 4>,()  / '(- ! '-/2 4,*- ( ,(/'!)' I :)@'(*'*,(+6 @          

  K# &/ ' ,( 00**. '- ((' '

,( 00**. '- 4,- ,( 00**. '- ,( 00**.  '- ***' ,(00**0'-.1-(.K #'&')'*;/'(*4,'**2'(2/'44)'1- !/*)'*'1*/0.()(*,)/(*4,J'( #1&(0 / '0, (, !0 '- 04- ,( '- 4* ! /* ). / :)/0  / ?H *I :)/0  / *,'):)/0.'*/)'*0'-1.'(!'-!/'!*'( 4,4**0'-)(,)*,)/<,-'*/0'-(0)**'- #"&/!!))(,)2/<,-,(*,16*)# & */'.!/4,4**!*,)/<,-./'/*'04;*'*' *('),,(/(! )(,. 7 #A! 7 &. !-2'*,*4)!/!;20'*.'0-+66 #'&!)2/'(')!

'-4*='02/0 '/J #1&<,2/(*)-'(4(,)!(),0*J #)&)2()'!!('J #(&**,2)00***!/='0'!;***J '( '- *,)/ <,- */' 1 (0(  1 ' >,()' 4)(2 ;//0'2!*)* 7?'("" .'(!/4,4*! *) .!/(' '(#BA!

& #?&(*/'10'(,(*,16*)# &.,**H/ 04-))(I*2''*'144,-!4*2 /*)'* H#?& / / 04-. 04-  '- / 4* <,('(/<,-,(*,16*)# &!'*'(*,)/ <,- ;/, '**22 '- '( '*  !'*  4(,) '- (),0!'-4,;/)'(,4(*./ !!))(,)2/<,-0'-()(/'44)'1-!/) (0/'0,(,!0'-04-.'*/)'*0'-1.

/1'**!/()'((,)((,2*,)/<,-'(/ (),0*'''1)( I #B&/'(,(*,16*)# &*4'**('2'*' 04- . / 0'-. ;/ / 0/* !0 / (' ! )00,)' ! *,)/ (. '44-  / !!) ! *2 '*( *,)/('(!/*'*!*/!!)/'/*/;)',*) ;'*(,-*(/'/;'*4(1-'-*,!!))',* !0'44'2;//<,-;'*/(./!!)*/'0'3' ( *2 '*( /* ' ( '( */' '44 ' (' ! 4)(2;//<,-+

(( /'  *,)/ ( */' 1 * '*( 0-  / 2,(/'//'*1'2,'-/*)!/*/; )',*)!/!!)**'*!(/'/04-/'()! / (' ! /'2 '( /'( *,!!) 0  '44' 1! / !!)    

66/''44'/'*14!(,(/* ) '2'* ' ( 4'**( '( *,)/ '44' /'* 1 (*4*( ! /;* /'  / 2,( /' / '44' /'* ;/(';/'44'.'44)'*/',(/**,16*) !*2'*(/( #A&(4'**(,(/**)*/'1*'*('- '44)' ,( *,16*) #B& ,** ) /! /'* 1 *(/44*4'- :)@6'(*'*,(+6        K # &- 4* '22( 1- ' !)'**,(1-/'0.'(4'**(1- / ' 0 '- ',/-. ,(/4* *,16 *)#?&.*,16*)#B&!*) .*)?.*,16*) # & ! *) @.

  *) @ H=)4 ' ( >)2 ' '44)' ! ; !(   *,16*) #A& /!I.  *)@.*) B.0'-4!''44''1,''2'* *,)/!)'( #"&- '44' ,( *,16*) # & */' 1 !(  *,)/ !0'(0'.;/*,)/0'(1'))04'(1-*,)/!*.

   66'44'1-/ 04-*/'1'(1-'1,',**//'*(4*( ;/  *-6! 4 ) ! / '0, (, !0 /0 '* (0(1-'!!)!(:)@+

((/'/1,'0'-.!'**1)(( ;2. ;'  (,) / '0,  1 (4*( ,( /* :)

,@#"&!/

# )(, ,*. 77@&'(*'*,(+6

#"& - 4* '22( 1- ' !)' **,( 1- / ' 0  ' ( 4'**( 1- / ' 0   



      

#04/'**'(((&0'-;/ ('-* !0/('!**,!/!)'9(.4!''44'/ 1,' (( /' / 1,' 0'- !  * *'*!( /' / '44';'*4(1-*,!!))',*!04!2/'44' ;//4*)1(4(.=(/*'(4(1-'!,/4( ! ('-* ((!,//''44'1-/04-*/'1 '(1-/1,',**//'*(4*(;//1,' '0'('!4'-'1/ ,('(1'2@AL!/'0, (,!0/0'*(0(,(:)@6 (('*/'/ 1,'0'-!'**1)((;2.;'(,) /'0,1(4*(,(:)@6

''"

6!/

*)/0'(*'*,(+6 !"#     + ! '- <,* '** ;// ' 04-*(<,(1)0),'*'001.  '* 2'(* / (' !0 ;/)/ / * * (  <,(  1)0 ' 001. / *'0 */' 1 !(  /

,(00**;/*/'()((/*'0  (( /' 1/ / 04- '( / 04- */' 1 /'(1!4'**2'-(/0' /,*.  * )' /' / (*4*' 0'( 1- /

,( 00** ,( 4'' "

6 )' 1 ()(  / ** *,2/  1 '2,( 1- '( ),* ! / 4  :) @# &#'&!/)4(*/'(*4,2'(2'44)'1-!/) ' *'1*/0 ;,( 1 ()(( 1- / !!)9* '0( / '( / '0,(,!0/04-,('-4*!/*)./:)/0.

* :)/0  *,') :)/0 ;,( 1 (0( 1- / *'( !!).;/**(;//4;)(,)*,)/'<,-'*(0( )**'- ''"

!/

:)/04(*!*,!(*4,* 2'(20!'04-.1)0),'*'001 '*2'(*/('!0;/)//**(<,(.1-/

,(00** /4*)'*.)'1(*4,(/' 4)(2* ,( :) "

 ! / :)/0 )'0  12 (,2 / ),*!<,-,(:)@!/) /***' ,(

00**((('("

/'(/(*0!/)04'' 04-*1(/1!,(/)!0/',*('*'* 0(/ E'(

.0'((/0'1!/

,(00**./2,(/'<,*!0) /'*1()((1-/*'(!!)'*44''" !/

:)/0'( ***' ,(00** *<,-.04,2(( ('(

7;'*4'**(1-/ ,(00**6  (0(-.''44';'*(,-!(1-/41!/44' 1,'  * )/ ! F'' 2/ ,  $% 

& 

'(

)

* 

#  

&+ 

, 

-  . /01

'02( #-# '-+(

'! 22 /,2/ / >,(20!/C1:,40, 56

   

) * -  &+  ,  -  7 //0 '0(

- 002/

' //0(

-- !0 9:

+

;



+  

  < #  

- ) 7 //2 '1(

- 42= ' //2( 0/

-- 1339:

$%  & 

'( ) * >     7 //1 ' (

- ' //1(

-- 3 !9

  

     $%  ?  ) * "

@

'# 0=!1

- =(

/'*1*(/''(2!4''"

!/:)/0 '-/4**!/)1-*)/!0'2')'1,(*(  ' 0'  *'- /'  ! 0'3* ! / *', ;'*  ( / 4'*(!!!,0*!(0'!/'*/4'(/)0 1')3/!,0)*,(,(/*')0 /)'*!$% 

&   #*,4'&. <,* ( ;'* 2'(2 '*/4 ! ' 04-'(04-1;/4'*  / 4* )'*. / 4 /'( (( !( ' '44' 1! / '( ' 0 (,*' 1,'6),06E'1,

,6)/'22(('(

0(('("

7 #=, A&;'*'(0(-4'**(!',!/4 :'(0 (;'*)'!(""

7#=,

& ),(:)@! /);'***,(/4'(*-/'!/'/4* ; 4 ;'* !(  ,-. "" 1- / 4 *4(* 8 04-*/*)'*/'1'2'2*)2-'*!/1!* !0/('!/04-0"

/,2/0'),*/ 40'-/'12'(*0(-,(:)@6!/). 1,342;/4),'!')*'()),0*')*.*4)'-/!') /'*4(*804-*''2'2,(1!)'2*'*)' ,01!-'*.(0'444''(=4(()(/0' 0*;/,(2/*'()*- (0(-./*4(804-*')'0221- ! 001*/4 ! / 

 *)/0 !0 / -'* 77@6 77  )  /- )'0(/'>(/*,'*(* ;./-((/''- (* ! '440  '440 *  ','- /- ;   4**** ! '(') 2**  ;'2 */*. ;/)/  0' ),* ;,()**'-14****!/%''20 4,*'!/! '* /' / %''20 /'* '3 ' - ) *'( /'  /'( '3  / *, ;

 !

 A

"@ '( /,* ((  /' / )( 4 / *4(*8 04-* '(0(- 1)'0 001* ! / 4( !,( ;

 !

. '! / ; %''20 3  / *,   * / / )'* ! / 4  ' / '- *,)/ 4'(2*  / !!) /' / *,  <,* ;'*   =*) 4  "

*4( 8 04-* /' '((,)( / 1* 4**1 () '''1 ;/ /0  ()' /' /- ; 04-( ;/ / 44"

),0**,10(1-')/!/*4(*6

04-*.')'-('(/04,2((('(

7*!

/*'(*4(*604-*/'4')()(*0!/(- )'(* **,( 1- / *, *! 4  "  '* ; '* )' )!)'*9(*0* ! / / )4' ! / *'1*/0  '44)'*'((**(/E))2,/-.:4'!;'!/ (2 )) ! / 04-*  <,*  E'(

,( 00**  /'* '3  ')), )4* ! ',* 4)(2* 1!/ *(2 !!).(,*'1,'6),06E'1,,. '4'. ;/ / )4' ! / *, /'* )!0( /* *2',*  / '44)'*1-*0!/)04''*'((**(E))2,/-. :4' /*'*'!)*0(-)'(***,(1-/ '2*,.%,/'.:4';/'((**!/04-* 0(  1 /' ! / *'1*/0 )4* 2'(2 4'-0* )(1-/)04''*!0/*,/'14')()( E'( ,(00**6/'*2/- 1*(/';'*/(,-!/;%''201'')(*! / 04-* !0 / ( %''20 ' / 0 ! '32  / *'1*/0 *4(* 8 04-* /' )'- '( (; / 1'*) !,(' ! / )'0 '( /' '((,)( / 1* 4**1 ()  *,44/!

E'( ,(00**/'*('( '*,)/(),0*4(,)(1-/)04''*'*/'1(,4 ;/4'**2(('(

/*'0*124(,)(! /*'3!1- *''/**'2/'*/)'*! / 4 /' (),0* * 4(,)( 1- / *4(* 8 04-* '2,'!2(!',(, ((./**,)/4'(2

0,)/**'-*,)/().//'*'-*,)/'2,01'((**( 1! 0  E'( ),* ! / 4 * ,'1  4 , '- 2'-!0-)'2!!) /'2,0'((**( F42  ; / !')* '( )),0*')* '* '1. ( ('(

74'**(1-/ ,(00**6* ,4/('(/*;4*(*0**(;/('*)** )'*. '44' )/'22 ( ('(

7 * * 4(2. / *'0 * ((!,),,*'(*/'1(*4*(!'))(2-1-'(' 0(,*'1,'6),06E'1,, #E*'& ','- .""

 ,(2 *  //*4'329'*(+*9 //4'1+*9