← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12383/2019disposed of

Surjit Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-04-29Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri21 pages

           !  "  ! 

 !#$%

!%&'('

) * +*     

        

      , -  * . .  .  

     

    !

"

#      $# 

  % & '



.  .  / * 0#1 2 2   2     "  " ( 

$    "





 ) " *+(,-./(+0 (12113!  "

 

$

   % & '  % 4 +

! 5  (6 (.

    "  ""

 

 ) "  "

! 5  (6 (.   $

 

  ""

     "  

  

9   

"

  11-:11,

+   

$ !     



   :    ")     "4+#

    +" 

"

#&$3#1 #$0'4

9         ! !

#"; ! !       4   

   ) 6./& 9  6.

2/ 122. 5 (6 

!

" ;

)   9   !   !   % & '

8 $ 8   

8 *8883 2- 0"

 ! !

$    ;     ") 16 2/  "

 "

!  ""

) 888  

      <  !  !      <  !    ")  

888 6= 1261 5 (1  

 ! !!  "

    ") )  #  !     9  

!  " ;

  26 122&  4 8  

+   " )

   !     " 

    "

)

  !  !

 

        26 122&   "      #05#)( -#1 6%0(3( 7% .$#$%

3)8#5 #)9 $7%0( *+0 (1=,6 1262   

 =6 2/ 12623  5 (/ 9

     !  "  $ + 7    "  



     

 < ") 5 (,

   + 7 6& 2= 126&    "  

  

 

!  4 8 

+   * 3 > ""  ")   "" !

 

=

0       



     888  ")    )   888 5 (=  12/

126.  ) !      

  

 

 #  "

      

!  "   

     <  ! !  ""

    ""



      % 4 +   

 ) ?  (4   !  <        !     % 4 +  )

     $   ")

9  

5 (& 1.

126.  "

 ! !  )

888)    ") <  ! !  ""

   

       = '2':(                  11 2/ 1266   2'

2.

126.  !  $      % 4 +  9"

 !      " "

 ! )   "  ?

  "8  888       ?5

 ?

  11 126.* 5 ('3     = '2':(       

 +  9  !  "

    ?5

 ?

888

    5 (,  66 126.)

 "")  

     ) "

$  

    $ )!

  



   ")!      " !     !    4      >  ""  



  888!   

  ) 888       )   ) ")  9       !

888  

  ")    "

 "    )   ") !     "

   !

  26 2= 121=  )

 .35:'(('

)

1%#0)%9 & 3)(%1

0 $7% ;%$'$'

)%0 &

9 "

 "            888!

 "")""

 "

  )   "    ")"

   ") !  "  " 

 =22(    16 +   >       ")   ! !        "

!    ") " !     !

""

      <    6=  <  !   $ )!

        !     5 (1!   

  

           ?"

    @ ?

 )

 <       ) >    

<   "!  )    ") 

 "")! )!

  

! 

  888     % 4 +

      ")  )

 >



 "")      )

!    )

  !

    )   " !

 " "  

  ) $   !  

     

 

    " ) 

  5 (1 >    ! !   ""    ")     )  "

 !

!   5 (=  5 (&   ! !    % 4 +

"   

          ")  = '2':(!   !  $ )   

 

!" !

>     !      )            #         ) ""

! 



   

 )

 ;   !  ! )5    ")  

   

 !     )

! 

'

>       ")   ""       "

     888  "    ")!     

        

  = '2':(! 888   "



"   ")

     

 <

   "   "  "

    ! 

    !      >      !  

6/ 2,   !      

     ")    )       6, 1211   " ) !  

26 2= 121= -

 "      

      888!   ) ""

 "

>     888! !    ) " !

    

)   )!  "

      

  !       !   

 

!" !

!  ") 

         

!   "

)

  !   )       ")       ")        

 $ )     

  888   



 ")  (    "

 ! ! 

!  " !  )   !  "   ")  $

       = '2':(!      ")    ) 

"  

  ! "     ! !  

   

 "")

  + (6.  !   

!  ) ) >

 2       !

 ")    



   "

    

" )  )  ! " !"  !) 7""8   + *.* #)97#=# 6%03( .$#$%

3)8#5 #)9 $7%0( 6..,*=3+9&-/  "     = '2':( "

! 

888

888!         ! 

 ) )

  ) " !   $    ) ""

!

 

     ") "

) 888

      !    ! 

 ? !  "

  5 (1   " )     ! ) $ ) 1261

.35:'(('

) 5> 1%#0)%9 & 3)(%1

0  ,

B           $  #  "

 

 "     % & '(888              "

    )   )  888

  " )

    

888!  " "

  ) " )  )  >           % B

     ")     )  

!   <  ! !     

  "" ) 126.  !    !)  ! !       = '2':(

  

  ) 

>        

    )8   C?%:9 ! 888    !  

+     



   

 )

 !    )  ")

      

$                 "



      

 "  

   ) 



" !!        $ )         >       "  !   )   

888          11 2/ 1266 2'

2.

126.    "  "

  5 (&  ('

       ")  >     

 !     5 (&:=  1, 2'

126.!          ! 

 ! 

"  !     !  )   "   "

)

! !

"    26 122&

 A

 "    !  

888 

  ) " " )    ) )

 

.35:'(('

) 5> 1%#0)%9 99'$'

)#1 96 &#$% %)%0#1/ 3)8#5 /

B       !

"

"

#   !"

         ") "

 )                

!    888!          % B

+ !  <  $  888  888   % 4 +   !    !) !   " )    ")   

    )

       " )

  

 !

 "")   "

 !  "    "   !  "   ) 122.

5 (6 9     4 8  +    * 3 5 (/  "

)

! !

!

$

  ):!

$   :

      26 122& ) 

 " ";

  !

"

  " 

 + 

" 

  

+ 7!   6& 2= 126& 5 (, 

5  !   " )    !

""

      "

 ""   "  " % B

+  888

"       ")    6& 2= 126&  !!         = '2':( 888  888    % B

  

!  5     

    ")  "

!    ""

 26 2= 121=  " )  "

  )#1>('(

(35:'(('

)( .

    "

 "  

  !  ! !    2/ 1266!"

 !    888     9

!  !   "

)

  4         ) 

     ")   !

   )

   

 

!" !   ")  "

 "

   " ) 



!

 7")  "")

  !   "

    ) 



!    "  "

)

!  ")     4 8  +   * 3 

"



  + 

     + !         >                 + 7  6& 2= 126& 5 (,  

  

 "" "

6& 2= 126&! + 7!   )  !   "

    

9

   " )!   888   )% B

+     !  

 <  !  !      !  )    ") >    " 5 (1 " !    

!       ?"

  

+

 "  (4     @   ?

 +

 "  (4

888    !    ) 5 (1 

      "       ""!

 "

 5    )#";  6=  ")"

) 888   

  !      )  

 



 " "    5 (1 

   "

! " 

"" 

 " 

     

"

)888!  

 " 

!  !

      "  ")  "  

"

) 888     

!         )     888! "

   5  (=  (&  12/ 126. 1.

126.



 ") )! !     !         !   

       ! % 4 +   

   !  $   = '2':(

   ")  4

    "

 "   % & '(888    



         +         1261    

    ) $  

!

     ) ) "   ")

     <    )$ !  $  !  ")    )  

  "

 !     ! " "



   ?     !   !    "

 )   )  "

  )  " !

"       )  

888  !   

      "  ) 

  "

) 888 9

 !

  ")    ) 1261""126. !   $ ) 888 %

"

 !      ) ) "



")  

     ) )" !"  )    ")  9

888!      $     

  = '2':(!     

   

% 4

   + A

 " 

      ! 

""

  

     "

  ")    "

   )   % 4 +

 ) 888

9+   !  888 ! " % 4 +   "

   !   " ")  ) ""

 " !  )  ) " !

7

888  $      !  ""

! )

  )     )" !  

 "  ) !  "  9 !

"

"

     "

!  6=

     

!   "

)

  !  ")    888      ")     )     )  !

 )

    26 2= 121=  6&

9   !   )"

"

#  !    "") !   "

    ") 

 !    "  "

)

    !

  4 8  +   * 3  ! 

"





   + 7!   ! !  "  ")  ) 6& 2= 126&

     2/ 9

   



" ) 6& 2= 126&

      ") ") >       ) "

    

!

<   !  ! ! #";    ")

 #"; ! !  "       

 ) "

    "

 

  

!   " )  !   

 ""    )  6'

   

  "

"

#    

  (")  % 4   + )  888     ")   

"  

  

 "   "

   "")  !   

  !   "

)

  ! 

  )    

   ")    )  ")

 

!" ! !  (    "

 

    " )    )  ?     $    

  = '2':(!   ")

 ""

   ) "

   ")

"  



! " 7

  

   !  )    

  ) ) 

  ! " 

    

888!   "")    % 4 +

 " !  ")

"

$

  )  ;   !

   888 !   " ) 7

 

 ")"

 +  )  !  )"



 !  )

  

 "  ) 

 

       $

  "

         

    %  4 + 888

6-

  !

"     "   <  $



   ";     

 "")  ")  5  ")  "

   5

     ")    $

"

       ! 

"

    ")   !)  

 

7

  "

" !     )   

 )  )     "   ) 

 

!" !   )  ! "  

  

    ""



 

!    )  

   "

D

 +" 

"

 

   ! "         "

1 1    +" 

"



     

 $   )    

  ) )  ) ! "   ) ")     

 

  ""

 "     

6,

   )    )      +   "  =22( +  

0 ) $ ) 6.,6  +  8  Hon'ble 

+  !% ?')#)9#) 0#(#9 6%0(3( .$#$%

'7#0 #)9 $7%0( 6.,6*13++==2 "

 <  !       ! "    ) !    ) " !     

 )!  7  " ( + 

    !  +   

+   " 9        

 (      



   !

"#$ % &  '

()#*+,-.  /-0* .  !

 

       

     

 1  2  %    2 2  

     !

'    % '  

            2

32    4 %           %  % 4 %   %(2    

   %   

     

    

  

   2           

              

      '

%   '2        1       

   

    %  '     2     %   

 % 2  %     2

      5   

  %  !%& %

#     !  5

    2    

2 



     

       %   

2              & ( 

    '

  1  2   6   2 

                  6 '  

 2   %  



 1  

  

   7  2

 2   1    

 '

   '                        2            





2

     % 2

     

    5   %   

 '  

 2 

2  % 2 



 2   %   

           2

32   4 %    '    '     %   %  %   % / !

& 8    %#

 &     '+,03&!#90+ 

  1  2   :

 ::   :2     

   ;  +*.*.*.  !

  !

   2   '  %: %          < 6/

9  +   "8  Hon'ble 

+ !    ""

)       .$#$%

7#0?7#)9 #)9 $7%0( 6%0(3( '$%)90# @3:#0 .0'6#($#6# #)9 #) $7%0 126=*613++162     Hon'ble 

+          )    )     ! "   !   ) " !

 % / 6-    

 

  ( 0(

        

    ;  

                '

 ' 3   %

!

 

    =&76>?@ (A*+0.

 2  &!!BC 5

=;= '2  

'     '  22 D 0       %



  2 '1   2   ; 2 2 1     E( 

'2 

  2  %  & '     E (     

  % 

2  

%  

     

    

 

    %

+F   EF       EF      ' '

6 % E(

6 %    ' 2  

 %      

 EF



62     1   

   

 2

      /B   1                             2

2 

 

    ' '      

   !

 

2       

  !



 =

67 %&  >G+-H& &!#  ,9  2      !

   %               

        4 %   %     4 %   %

2         (2       

      I  (   

 1    %  %

                    

     

       

  

%

   2  

 

      %    % 22   &

  

 ;  ?(1& *,.< (     2  

   

     <        

6 2 2   

 2   %  ;  BB3;  !

 ( ,              

%   

J      < ;   BB3;      !

     (       D

 37      %      %     2< >

2 

    ' 2   1          

 

% ;

     %     2     2'2   !

    ;  BB3;

 !

 (  2      6

2       %  %   2      %    %

   

 

< 6.

9 Hon'ble 

 +    1A# %11'( #)9 $7%0( 6%0(3(

:5#> 3)'&';#1  0;

0#$'

) 6./'*=3++'&'

      "  "  " "

9   ! !!    

   )    " "

   

    16 +    !

""

+   "8  Hon'ble 

+  @* .* 3$$#(=#:> 0%$'0%9 #)9 #) $7%0 6%0(3( )'

)

)9'# #)9 ) $7%0 *126.36++6 !"

"! " ! "    )        16 +   ! )! 

   

     "  " "

  16 +   

  ")       

  "       "       "  "

       $ 

"  " "

 

 

 $ "

     

  !           " )  !   !       

  

   "

  !  % B

+

" )  

?     $ 888  !  ") )!    )

" !  9  "

!     ! !  !   "

  61 )  

   

  16 =22(

+                 +"   

  "

  !   

  ) 

 3?#0#: @#)#

(7' #)9 $7%0( $70 3A7  =%0

$$ 0)%>  19%0 6%0(3( **!** #)9 $7%0(  126=*63++='=

> E"



+               )     ! 

          ")  +   "    ) "     .      

  ( +                2 

            

          '     !

     

     % '

    '   % 

'    

    7 2 % '    %   

         

  %       2  *? D  

   

  ! "#$

%&'

())**+,

-(  ( -"#$ '

&'

())* ,#$ '

&*())#)&$."(/  0 1  "#$ ''&%())+%23 4!$ ''

()'.+."( /56 "#$ ''&'

())* *3 #$ '$&  ())  #)&  %7.3  4!  $ '$  ()  22.        (#&  (8 "#$ ''&.()) 2*3#$ ''&*()) #)&7% 3 4!$ '$()2% .<

 !  

  ") ""

9

    888  "")""

 "

  )       

9  "" "

    F-G     ""

!

( 3  ! 



 ! 

  

  ""  " )  )   3 B  ") ! 

 6& 2= 126&!

    + 7""    ) )   3    = '2':( ""   ) 888

 "

! F-G         )  888 ""    " ) 

1=

9    "  )    

888   !   

  ) ! F-G* "

     

  !              

      )     

    "" "

     F.G    -G  

1&

+          

!  !    ""  

$

   

   ")    )     " ) 61)     

   61) !  "  !  ! 

"

 " !

+ 

  !   " "

 " )

!        222:(* " $3 !  ""  )   !    

  ) 1'

A )    5  ")

 "*3

!  " ) 

  ")

 

!" ! ) ""

! <



  "")

  ) " 

  "   888 ") ""

!



  

 

!" !

.  .  

! ;0'1  /       0  $  :% 0  "

 :%