High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/486/2004allowed

Asha Rani And ANR v. Mohan Lal And ORS

2015-12-09Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj20 pages

" #$

!"#$%&'($&($)&*'

% #

& '( )* +#

')* , -.

("/

#0'( )* + #

/& ')* , 1 #

& '(

)* + #

$ # ')* #

)&')* #

')* ,

- +,-,)+./%

2" ( * 2 0"2/ *

34 "

3 ++

34", 34#$ 5

62 "2 ,

4'/ 3 +'+ *

%5 ! "!#! $# %!## !%

& !

# ! %# ' !%(!!!(!%%!)! &!!#! *!#+ !# $,

%!!#-##!#. . ' /! ! 0! . / $ 1! . !# * . ' )-#! $# !"$

! 2!,, 3%

)$ 3!!#!-! # $ , %! %#$ %%-##!#. . . /% ! ( 1! . ' #0! * . !# !

# *!# + ! %# ' !%(!%%! )! & ! !#! -& !& !

-! $ # !# "!%# *%% #!

4 4 5 .

, 0"2/ + 3

7 ,,87 8

*) " * , ,,5# $ 9

-: 3 ; ,,

<= -=?- ,

2 ,"

, +2 2

3 + "

, %5

! " #$ % @ * , ,,' 3 ,' $*/ ++

, "

4 2+

2 , /

2) "

4 ,, A" 4 2 ) ; <= -=?-) +* 2)

4A"

,, A" 4 ,,

6 * "* " 0 4 )2

4 34 / 3" -

," ,)"

,+,

5 .'+*+ 2 ',*"32 2 , ,, - 2'

* " + 4 3 +

,,' 3

/ #"

5 - 5 .+, , /#"

,, *,* 4 1D) 2

4 4+

/ 4 43 2"2

, $*/ > 1 D + / * * / , ,, B , )

4 + "

4++ 34$*/+ ) ; -=?@ A"

2 "

4,)"

, B* ,, - + / 6

/ 4 30 * " + 3 ,

62 +

4 ) "

, "

, *"

* + ; <= -=?- 3 , +* ,, , " +

)6 34 $*/)

; -=?@

; -=?@' /#"

5 -3 */ 3 " +

, "

4 ,

/ "2 2,

+, 5 .

,, 3

/2; -=?@3 *

2 * ";

; ,!,!!9,* 4: & +2)

/$ $ " DCD 9 : ; ? 0* " , & + 2) /#"

5 -$ 5 C

/#"

#+ , /

,,+2)

4+* + "

* , / "

) (2 +* ,!,!! + * "* 34$*/,

2"2 /", / + *6 ,!,!! " "

"+ &+ **" 34 ,, ; ,-=?@+2)

,, *

* ,#"* //

, , 2 "+ ,,+ 42"

3 , )

+* + 3

* "* (

&"/ , /#"

5 -'+

4' , " 2 ,, *"

3 "+,

)

/ , ,,+

* * )

5 . , + / * /2

)

-= <?

-==D

) * / 34 +4 , )

( 6 ; <= -=?-+

)6 ) ; -=?@ = 2, , /2, "

, +%5 9: ;

,, 34 +4, E

9: ;

$*/ * ) ; <= -=?-E

7 9: ;

-= <?

-==D,)"

, (/ ' . 34 - ,*"' 2 32 ,,E

9): ;

" , /3 E

9): ;

4 ) "

, "

,*"

9): ;

" 3 , 50

, * 4 4E 9): ;

$*/ * 2 ) ; -=?@E 9): ;

"+ /E

9B: ;

3 */ +

, "

434+4,)

E 9B:

-< 3 ,* *

) ) "+

; <= -=?- <> -=?@ , $*/ $ ) "2 9" ):' (/ ; <= -=?- " 4 ) ' "2' *,* ,2

2 2 , , *" , ; <> -=?@ +

* 34 ) "2 9" ):

, / ,0"2/ ) "2 +, ) + ; + " 4 ) 34 B/ , , / 2 +

+ , + 2 , * 3 , ; * +*//,* ; <= -=?-<> -=?@9:3 ; +

* 3 34 /

( 22 + F 9: 0 (2' ! -!#!2 3 ; / 2 + -- ; -=?@+* 2 " )2/ * 3 / / 2 + +

; -=?@$*/

; <= -=?- ; +

; <> -=?@ + * 3 , ; ,$*/ ( * 4$*/2)

4 ,)

; <= -=?- 3" ) ; <> -=?@' ,"

3" # $ + B* " 2 " $*/ ,!,!! "

* / "

) (2 "

"+ &+ (

34 2/ 4, /*6

* + ," "3 +* ,!,!! + * "* + "

* 34 # $ + )

, $*/

2) ; <> -=?@

B* "2#$ , /

* ,

4,$*/ ,,)"

+ "2

,* +* + 2 / , "2 + ; <> -=?@ +

" ,

+ "2/,$*/ 3) +3 2 "$*/+ )2 + / #"

5 - / , / #"

5 -

* )2 ,

B* ",#$ , /

* ,

4+ 34 $*/ -1

, 5 . */ +

, "

4 34 +4 , )

+ * ,

-= <?

-==D 34 /#"

5 - ,)"

, 5 . +

+ B ,

, ,, "

4 ; -=?@+ 2 '" ) -@ (/ ) +

) + "

B* 3

) , +

; + 34 $*/ + ,

+ + " 2/ $ "

6 , ,*; -=?@

; <= -=?-

* * *"/* , $*/ * ; 3

) $*/+ )4"

2 2

4 ,

/ 34 +4 , ,

2 , / , / 34 *"2; <= -=?- *; 2)

4 ,"

, B* "2#$ + 3 ' "*'

+ ** , $*/ *; -=?@ "

, 5 . 3 */ +

434+4,)

-C ) *" , '

" +

* 0"2/ , "

3 + + *

-> $ *" , 2"

3 ; ,$*/

; '* 3 34/

, / 2 + + /

$*/ .?

-=?C ,

* /

2 2 +

4 , 34 $*/ #"*

* +

" 3 +

,, (

&"/ , -5 /#"

4 -==D

4" "

"+ &+ 5 (

(

&"/ , "2#$ 5 ,,

, , 0"* 3 *" , * ..

-< -==D +2 #$ */ "+ ", .D -< -==D ) / " 4+ /#"

5 - "+, 4 2 / +

2 30 * , / #"

, $*/ +

/ 4 -D "

3 ++

*)* 3" *" ,; -=?@3") 2

; , /4 "

;

* 4

2) , B* "2 # $ , /

4 , $*/ +

3 + ) , "

4* , $*/ ++ ,4, ,,5#$ ' "

4 ",!,!!'"29#$ 8:/ ',

2 , #$ 5 ,,++ 2)

4,"

B* "2 "2

) ,, 6 , 2"/ 3 3 ) )

+* #$ 5 ,,)2,!,!!+" * 34# $ ,!,!!, /+," *" 3

, ,

B* " /, /

* ,

3 4 / , "

*//

4 "

)

) /, *" , ; 5/ 2 , ; , -=?- * ; , -=?@ +"/

/ * 3 + * 3

+ *; + " 42

' "*'

"*"* *"/* 2 *", ; )

+ ' # $ 5 ,, )

* .C -=??'+ 2 2.D'<<<G5+

0 4"

* 34$*/ / , / #"

'$ ,,'

; -=?@ / / *

* *" 3

"* 3 ,

3 + * 3

/) "* / 34 2 )

$ *" , ,"

"2 - . ) + / ; ,-=?-+

)6 "+ ) 4 ,, ) ; 34 2 ) ** * + ),( *>?>=, ) * 2 ; + "* * ) / 34 +4 , * 4 ) + /) 3 ,

+ ; +" 4 ) -= $ *" ,

-5 ,, 2"

* 3 / 2 + , ; <= -=?-)

) ; ' ,, B/

+ , + 2, ( 22 + +* 3 ; B/ ("

(2 ;5D'+, 0(2/ 2 + , ; <= -=?- , 2"

3 + ) 2 4 ; <= -=?- + " 4 ) ) * , - . ) ; <> -=?@

; <= -=?-+

)6 ,,*

* , / ,,* , ("3

2 +

* *4 , ; +

*4 3 2 2"

, 4 / 2 + ; +" 4 "*

+ * 4

/ ) ; 34+4, * 4 )

$*/ 4, , + )2+

/ #"

5 - 2)

; -=?@+ B* "2 ,,, /

* + "

* / "

"+ &+ +

,!,!!+3" 34/+2) #$ ,* +"

* 34#$ / , / , * "* ,!,!! )

+ , 4 , )

/ ; "

3 + ) *//

, ++ * 2; 3 2 " 34"*" * *"/* "3 A"

, +

A" 2

/ ** " + 34 "

3 +

3 ) * 2 ,

2" *

2 2

* "2 3

) 34 ) ' 2"

/ *" "* 3 ,

3 +

* , 4 -=?? "+, 4 -==D 2 '

/ "2*3 + .<

4 *" * )

4 *

) ) " +

; <= -=?-

-=?@ 34$*/

2*// ,* 3"3 ; +

* 3 34/

, / 2 + ; /

; +

" 4

0(##'$

) ; <= -=?-' ,,*

* , / ,,* , ("3

2 +

; +

B/ ($ ;5C+ , + 2 ; <= -=?- 34

( 22 + , + 2 , /

; -=?@ / 2 + ) ,, B/ ("

(2 ;5D, , / 2 + 0(2'+ , + 2,,

; ("3

2 6&"/ (66 B/ ;5@ ; + "* 3 ,

/ ,

)

; $*/ + ,

/2 / *

*2 )

/ ;

$62 3) ) 3 "

+) *//

, +,*+

*2 ** "; <= -=?-+" 4 ) 0(##'$ 1

* ; <> -=?@

; $ ) "2 9" ): 6 , ,* ; 3

* 3 34 /

+ * 3

; ,-=?- , / 2 + 3 ; /

; +

, / 2 + $B/

, + +

," / + )

' ) "2 9" ):

, /

* 2 ,2 +

*",; -=?@+" 4 ) .1 $ "

, 3)

) ** " *", ; + ) ** * + + + )

'3 "

) 2

; + 3

) / 2 " " 34"*"* *"/* &"''(#2&$'(3#0 .@ "3 A"

, + +* , *

,2, "

3 +* 2; <> -=?@ 3

* , +

) , / ,* ) , , * *" 3

/ 4,

" 34"*"* *"/* E .C ,

2,"

+ 3

)6 , ,* * ,

* )

4 / + )

'3 "

3 +) * ; -=?@2)2

+*+ 3 *"

, 0"2/ +

2) 34 "

3 ", /

* "3 A"

, + * 2 ,

* , ) B "

* ,

) / + / * *"/* , +%5 8!#% !

%%! ! ## !

'$ 2 %# #

2"% /# 2# !

%% ! 9 ! : !% 2 !# !

%%!

6 2 !### !

!# %# ;

# & # *%% !-% !

*%%!"!%#%&< # "$ !%% !

&$ 2 ; !

-!%

$2 ! = # $ # !

!% ! ! - ! !%9 %! ##

2/2;

!!#

# !

! $ $ , !

- ! %% !#$ 2!%

$ *%% ! - < # !# < *%% !%! # #:%&9 . *%% ! - < # !% !> : -% %# !"%&

! %& *%% ! ## !

!% ? ! ## -

!% #%& !

#-%"#

$# ! %& !

'! $ !

!# #%# !

*%% ! < # !

# :'$2 !< %!# !

%& "# !# !

! ! #-%" !

! : '$ 2 !# # $!%!%%! & %% ##

!% 2 ! : '$ 2 !

# !

$!% *%% : = "# !

'! $@ "# ! # - $!# !

-& ! )#" $ ! #-%"# $# !

%# ! ! % $!

!$! A $ ;

! !#%& ! $# #-%" "# !

@ "# B# ! -% !# = # !# #-%"# "# $# !

#!# %&#!$# # & # & '$ 2 # ! $" -& -%

!!-%%!;" !-"!$

!%2 !!

#-& !

%%!

!%&

'$2 9 $ !

9 ! ; " '$ 2 ! $ %& $ !

9 !# # !

!$" -& -%! % &: - ! !% 9 %! !

!! #!

!# '$ 2 ! $ %& ## 9 * ! %&!$ '$2 5 (&( .> "*"* *"/* 3,+*; -=?@+* *" 3

/ 4,

"*" * *"/* 2 , / )

* $*/ 3 )

4 2

+ + **

3" ) ",

4 ; '2* 3 "2

3" 2" 4

/ )

)* , /

2 2 ; * 3 )

+ 4 " /2*

2),

4 , 34 /

* *"/*

) 2 4 -=?- ; <= -=?- 2)

,) * "2 ,, ; <> -=?@ ,

2 ,"

, A"

+* , *

*" , ; " 4 ) E;

; ) */ + ),( *>?,) *

) ; H ,* 34 *" , ,,5

- "

3 + ) * ; 3,"*"* *"/* , +%5

7 9:

* ; -=?@3"

; /

; +

)6 9:

2) , B* "2 ,,5# $ , /

* ,

4,$*/

9: $ "2 +

34 ,,

+ $*/ + " 2 / 9"2'

"* ) $*/+,"2/ / , *" , ; 3" ,* +* )

) 3 ,

) "2 9" ): + $*/ +

2+ /#"

5 - / , *",; : 9): "

**, $*/

* ;

4 2)

,) .D $*/ + )2 ,) ' / 4F

/ $ ' $ ' $ ' # $ / #"

;

*"2; <= -=?- 2)

/ ; * ; -=?@$*/

) 3",

4 34 2)2

2 2 ,,5 #$

* ; , +%5 = ! %!#,! (! 8!% ! , , , !-, ! !

$! =- &! ,! ,!, ,!,!!=!$!)#"$,!#,!,-!!#!, )#!! 2!! 3!!% !- ! -!! #&! ! ;%& =!&!#!# , #&! ! =!"$!

;!"!%!#& #!,!,!!-& #$ & , (!8!%! !-& !$ %!# )#" $ )#!! 2!! 3!!% !- !# !# %% - $" !&! & #!-"5 .?

/ 4'

! 2!,,' (

' (+ #

* ,* 49,!,!! &+ 5(

,,5#$ + <1 -=?-

; <= -=?- .= A"

+* , *

2) 34$*/, 2)24

4 ,,5#$ +*,/ ;

3 E $*/ + *"2 ; -=?@

3 + *)* 3" ,* " / , # $ + "

* 34/,!,!!+ " , / ,", #$ +2) 4,

4/ "

3 +) *

/ ; 2 " +* ,!,!!+* "* + / ,#$

+ ) $*/ / 4 , / *6 , "

* , * "* , ,!,!!

* ; -=?@ ) '

",,* ) /4,$*/ ; ,

* / 2 / ,

+ 6

*"/ 4 ) , 2 34 ,

)

4 / ,* * $*/ ,)"

4, #

)

,, )

* / "

* &+ " ,!,!!

* ; *; 3 A"

4,"

'"*'

) 6 , 4 ""

/ +"*/ ,

+ ,$*/ 1< $*/ , 3 ,) + "2

B B* ,,

" 3"

*",; -=?@34$*/ ) +

, ,,'++

2) 4

4, $*/

, ; *; '

,"2 * / , ,, 3 , ; <> -=?@ / 4 4)

2 " 2 ,,

2 "

, + , ,

1- "

3 +) 2) ""

/ * ,* *; / +/

2 2 , ; ,-=?- ; +

* 3 34/

; , -=?- 3

/ , ; , $*/ /

* + / * ; /43 "

4 2"2 " 34

'+ * 3 3 ; , 4; -=?@ + 2 "/ 4 + 2 4*"" +" ) " )

4+ 2" 2 2"2 ; 5/ 2 ,, ; <= -=?- *; -=?@+ 0" "/

*" 4 ) + , ,* $*/ )

)* , /

2 *; * 3 , /+/ 2+ , ; 6+/ 0(2'! -!#!++ / 2 + , ;

* *"/* ' /

,, ; ,* +

)62 ; * 3 ) ; * , , / , *"

, ; , -=?- + 34 $*/)4* )

2 2 3",

4 ,

2) 4

3" 4 +

, * ; , -=?@ +

34/) +, ) / 3 +

-=?- , *", *; 2)2

4,"

2 ,, ,

, "

*// "

2) 34 *" , ; + ,)"

2 2 2 ,,

, , + */

'/43 3 *" ,+ 3 4 3 *" , " 2) /' /4 B* " / + *,

*", ; ,* 4 ) ' ,* *" A"

434 )2 ,*/6 ; ) B"

* ,!"

% &

&"!

) , +%5 7 / ! ! ! !

-9 ! !# !

%%! -& !

%# !,

%%!

!%- < %% !

! %& "# ! !

!# -9!

#!& & %# ! !, %% "!%# ;

-9 !# ! %% !

! - !

! C "#

< %% ! $!

#$ ! ! !% -! "& - # ! !#! !% !-!"- $!!&$

! !

#"#!% # -!" ! !- !% !A#$! !#!# -!" < %%5 1.

$*/ *" , ; + / 4 )2 + / #"

5 - 3" , / ,* ,

* 3 + ; <> -=?@ + "

, "

$*/3

, "

, / #"

+" ) ,)"

/ 34 2)2 /0 *"6 ,

4 / +" ) 2

4 ,"

B* "2 ,,5#$ ,

* ; "

, *" , ; ) , / "

* , $*/ +

*"2 ; <> -=?@ 2

,, ,

/ ; * 4 * " 4 "*" * *"/* 3" *" , ; -=?@ +* " 4 ) *" , * ; <> -=?@ +" "/* 4

)* , ; <= -=?- 1@ ) /) * *

* )

* 34#$ .C -=?? +

* )2 .D'<<<G5 +

0 4"

* 34,

/ ,

+ 2 /

; <> -=?@ ; <> -=?@ 3

3 " 4 ' +2 , *+

) 4"

+ *" ,"

4 , * '"*' * * 1C

" , " 2 ) 4 , ; -=?@' *"3" , 4 ) 3 */ +

, "

4 34 +4 , )

)

+ ' "

2 4

* ** " -.) 3 */ +

, "

4 34 +4 , )

" /4 3) *"' "3 A"

, + , / * +

,)"

, 1> /

** 2, "

3 +"

-D

)

0"2/ *

343 "

3 +

" , ,,

3 / +* "2" 45,

&($)&*' 06 %&)$ * - # >DE