High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2816/2011disposed of

Sadhu Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-03-08Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill8 pages

!"#$#% &'()&!*( ##+## !, -, ) &

)!./ +## 0 !'! 1" 231 # & &&33

, !" 1,# ,4.&#)!'56'7

,(0 !,# 1,#&,/.&!*((46 !##6 )!./#

( 0 !, 8 ,'

44!* (

0)! (/5)!',& ! 9%6$$96$: #-'.)'*4! !' ,', '' ##%6 5,!' )'

5 1* ,6 5 6 3)'(!6 (5' ( 0 !, *)5; )!', (

, ' & ! !' !!

'(4 )!',*

,4 !( )!', & !9% !' 0; !

#<=!'6!' )5

0;4! !6 ),(,)!',* 40540, !4!

, 7! '; > ?4 !( )!',& !$$9 !' 0; !

#<=!'6!' )5

0;4!

!6 ),(,)!',* 405 40, !4!

, 7! '; 6 !' ! ;, )!', & !$: 6!' 0; !

#<=!'6!' )5

0;4!

!6 ),(,)!',* 40540, !4!

!4 !(# **,7' (,*! 6 ( 0 !, 0, ,,' ! 005 /

, ( 5,!' & ! )'*6 3)'(!# 87,6 7' .)'*4! '' :##6 ( 005 5' /; (

@A 0 !, (' /! ' 4 ' /; ( 5,!' '' !5 & ! )'*6 3)'(!# &55 **,7'6 ( 0 !, ( 0, ,,'(0, !,7 !0 !# 0, 0, )

##6

405!! 4,. &!*( * ( 4! ,

,''

( !## 5 6(5 !*8(( !0(81!. &!*( !' ! *!', &!*(6 8 ,755!* ! 1,) , /,!* ,* , ! # :$6 8(, ( (, !0(86 !45;6 ! 5 5 !* 8( ( 8 6 ,/! B), !' (,

(5',! 5 ,47,&!*(C

( (,!0(8D8, ,755!* ! ( ;0 ; /,!* * , ! # <9$# (;55('* ! (( )

(!58

! 5&!*( 755* 4/6

& !&4,56 !E),/ )(855 /!*

! 5 &!*(2 /, (,!58# / ) $#$ 0#4#6 8(! (; (' , (' / ) <= ;,' (! &(/ ( 8F6(46(;0 ;',7!/;( !0(8! 56 8( ( 8 * !* ! !

1,) ,6 8 ( /; /)

)!./

'8; 6/!*',7!7,;(*( 0'/;&F( ',7,#3, !(

405!! 4 F!

8((!4

(/) ',7,8 &'()&!*(8((,* , !!)4/,

(/) %$# , )5

(

, '6(;0 ; 8 ,!! 0 #(

405!!2 !0(8! 5&!*(6 (', 7'!.), 68(, ( 8 ,/! B),''( 5 #55((, (5',!68( 8, !* !(/ F 6('5 , 7'!.), #G(5(

405!!8 /) ; ! F!* ,

( !.),' !' ( ' '6 &'() &!*(6 ',7,(' 5' 4( 0 #(!.),'8,,4 7' ( 053)'(!

,(,4!#(

, '

@$A ('

),,' ') ( , ( !' !*5*! ',7!*

&'() &!*(6/) ',7,#,)E8 !/;(0

,,* ,

# ) !' ;0 ; !7 57' ! (

'!6 (' /! F! ! 0 ! /; ( 0 7' 0, 44 # &)/ E)!5;6 ! 7, &!*( (' 0, ') '

) ' &'() &!*(!'(8 ,, '!'5,,5 ' !/5# ,

405

( !7 * !6 (55! 8 0, !' ! ( ),# 7!*

)!' 0,4 6

(,* )!', & ! 9%6 $$96 $: 8, ,4' *! (

) '# ( 0, ) ! ?4!' G,# &#B# &(,46 1'

,6 G&)F(', (! &!*(6 G$1!. &!*(6

G:*,&!*(6 G<,5! ),6 GB45'7&(,4 !' G944!)5-!

'B)4,# &4!

(

) ')!',& !$$,# ## 8 ,

,'' 8(,! ( ' ( ( (' 5 5; /! '!' 54',5# ( 5,!' ,5 ), ('6 ' / 76

' !' !!

' ( 0 !,

) ' )!',& ! 9%6 $$9 !' $: !' !!

' (4

, ( 7, ) )/ !7 !!

6 0)5' ! ( , 0,

.)'*4!# !0056(5,!'0055 ),(')0(5'

!!' !!

(0 !,# (7(,'(5,!'

,(0, !' 8((,/5 !

* !(, )*((,

@:A 3,!'

, ( 0 !, ( 7(4!5; ,*)' ( ( 0, ) ! '' !

?4!

405!! 4,.&!*(!' (0 ! ,*,' (!7 *!*

,6 05 &!*(# &55 ),(,6 ( /!

!!'' ( 1!.&!*(C G$D!( ?4! !'0 '(( ;0 ; 8 /!* ',7! ! 8, !* ' 8( ) *7!* !; *!5# ),(,6(5,!'

)! 5( )/4'((

'!!E) !('

),,'!/, '';5*(6( 87,6 !

;8!

),,!

6('/!?4!'#( 5 ( 8 ((0, ) !( 5' 0, 7 *! (

) '0 !,6/;

!'( ('

, !/5'

)/# !( (,(!'6(5,!'& )! 568(5 , )!* ( ,*)4! '7!

' ! /(5

(

) ' 0 !,6( ,*)'((*)5

(

) '

'0, 7' /; ( 0, ) ! /; 5'!*

*! !'

!7!

!* 7'!

# (5!F7'!

!( /!*

405!!),6!

! /

)!' 8( ( 855 , !' !'!* ,

,'' /; ( 5,!' ), /5 8#3,!'&

)! 5( ),(,,*)' ( /!* ( ',7,

/) 6 8( ( /**, 7( 5 C

40,' (;0 ;D6 0,)'!',7,68 (/ )!'! ');

( 0 !,

) ' ',7 ( /) 4 ', 0'8()4 ,6 ) !!' )4 0 !6*7!*')

,!''5*!

(,) ,

(, 'C##(',7,

(, 7( 5 D# () 6 0,;,

, ( ' 4 5

0, !0 !( /!4'#

@<A ,(,!*(5,!'

,(0, !' (7!** !(, )*((,

6 ,75'( 8(5 ,

,'!* ( !'!*

! !' !!

!* ( 0 !,

,'!*5;6 ( 5,!' ), /5 8 ,055' ( 05 , ' /; ( 0 !, ,*,' !

!') !*

,'6

, (, ! ( ! ( 4! )!',& !$$,# ##6(0 !,('(4 5 '4' (8 (8( 8 ',7!*(/) !E) !(4

),,!

#() 6(,,4! !

(!* /'5'!( ,*,'!'(,*)4!, '/;(5,!'

)! 5!( ,*,''

# &55

),(,6 5,!' ), /5 8 ('

* 55;

)!'(('(

!')

(0 !,/! )0,*(6 ( 8 )5' !

(7 5' 8; 4 ( !# ( 5,!' ,5 ), (' !

' ( G: *, &!*( '0 '!( 4 !;((, ' !8( ((

'!''

),8 8'!

)*(!'

),7( 5 !4

)5'

(,#() 6 7( 5 4( '('),!' (?,4,*(6( 4

)5'(7/! 5; *('/; ( ',7,

( 7( 5

4!* 4 ( ', !# 8 ),(, !

' ( ') 40

( /) 6 455, 7( 55F;0 ;8 / )!' * (,'!'),5#8

),(,

)!'(!

5) !,*,'!*(;0 ;* !* ! 8, !* '6

)5'/',8! !(/

( 05!# 0,( ) '; ,

05 ' !,

,'/;( 5,!' &

)! 56 ( 0 !, ( 5,'; )!',* ! 0, '

4 !( <'; #

@A 3,!'

, ( 0 !, ( ,5' )0 ( .)'*4!

( !2/5 &)0,4 ), ! 1(' , F, - # &

1(, (,6 %9 ,5# 3## :%6

!!' (8(!0 !*, )''!5; , '8( )F!* !

(00, (!*7( 56(',7,

(7( 5 !!

/(5'5/5#&55 ),(,68(5,5;!*)0 !(.)'*4!

( ),!&)!5- #&

)!./6:CD C,4!5D :9%6

!!'' ( ( !2/5 ),

5) !((

(0 !, /)0(5'6 (!( )/ !7 !!

40 ')0 !(0 !,4; /,') ' !5,';)!',* !/;(4# ( !2/5 &)0,4 ), ! &

)!./ - # &),/(F (6<CD C,4!5D:%<68(5 !* ' ,',

( *( ),6 (,/; ,') !* ( !!

' )0 ! (

) ' ## ;, ( 0, ' 5,'; )!',* ! /; (4 ## :6 '; 6 8,'' ( !!

? !( (

) ', 0 !'! (,!# 8 (5' )!'," H9# ! ( ! ! ( )4

, ( !' !*5*! ',7!* ( /! /5 ('# (

), ( /!

! !5; !

!*(!

, !!)4/,

, '

'! !'( 5 !

' ( 8 ( 7( 5 ',7, (7 /! 55; , ( !' !*5*!# 4 ) ',7!*!',)!F! 6!, ( !' !*5*! 4!!, , ',7!* 8( ;

)( )5 '7!), ) !() 4 (, , !

,)5 , !

05!

58(

4 !, *# (0, * ! 6 80, 76(75 55, 0

, 58# 4! 8( ( 4! ( 6 ! 0 /5;6 *,')' (4 5 (,/ ), ( ' ( ( ! 0 4 ( )/ !7 !!

/;0;4!

40! !#(,( 58 !

, (

), ( 4054! ( 58 ( )5' 7, *

/57 )

(! ) (

'! 0,

) 57 , ,(7 4 8( ),77, ,005'

,5 8( (6!

@9A 8;6 8 , (! '(# &) ( '75 0!*

! '!*, ) 0(!

! ! ! ,',5;

;# )!* *

/ 05 /

0' ! 55 )4 !

# 3 (0

, ,(40 )!

) 8 ,(57!*

, (!'(5)?), ) 5;40,4!5#'5 ;6( 0,!

!*,

*!I (

,, 74 ), /) (, ,

! 8(! ( ',,!

! 40,7 ! ;'0!'!*)0 !(

#! ), 0!

!6 8(,8,

! ,!' ;((*( ), ( /! 8;' 8; /; ( 0

4, ; ! 005;!*(0,!

05(0;4!

40! ! ,

, ,')

: '; # / 5)5; ! ( ,54

4 05 ' ;40(;# 6!8;4

F,;

.) # ) .) J( 8!!* *5 ,;J6 J( 7,*! 4 , J !' JE)!

7,)J , (' '# &) (

,4 /5*( !

!5; ( 57

( 7 4 /)

4!;

(, , )!' (4# )545; (, ( (

0)/5 !.)'

5 ; 4#! ),786( !!

!;, 40 '/;(,51* ,8( (( /!

,4'/; (0055

), ( )5'/,') ' ?4 !( #K (0 !,( )!',* !0, '

4 !( <'; )

(4?4)4 !!

!;,40 ')0 (4 / ' (, )/ !7 !!

, 5 , 0, ' 6 (,

,6 ! 78

(

, ' .)'*4!

( !2/5 &)0,4 ),6(05

(5,!'

,(0 !,

, ,') !* ( !!

40 ' )0 ! ( 0 !, 0, '5,';)!',* !/;(46 !!

0'# '4'5;6 '(

,/! B), 8

! 5 ('

),,' ! (

'! ') ( , ( !' !*5*! ',7!*

( 0 !,# &55 ),(,6 / ( ( ), /5 8 (7

'!' !!

'(0 !, !(/

7'!

,'#3,!'

,(0 !,

)5'!

! ) !; 4,5 55*5; , 0,7, ; ! ( !'!*

@A ,

,'' /; ( ), /5 86 8( ( 4; 8,,! !, ,!

/;( ),! ,7 !5.), '

!# 87,6F!*!

! ', !(* !;

'/;(0 !,

,(0, '

;, !'0 !, /!* ,

!',6( !!

,') ' ?4 !( !55

)! #(0 !, (55 ),,!',/

,(,5 ),6 )!',* ( ,4!!* !!

? 4 !( 6 ?

5)'!* !( !'<'; 65,';)!',* !/;(4# 0 '

!(/ 7,4 # #$#% ' G((,&0F!*= !'" = G((, 0 ,/5" =