High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44268/2014allowed

Gobind Gulati @ Gopi & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2016-05-20Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

!"#$#%&'&() *

+&($ ,-!"&!-&!' .&!($"/#0'

#"&"&(#0'

1#0','

2"!"#!03!(!!($!("/#0 #'.($#("'

) 45 2 6 52 0#'#(") 06126/#0!($0#7!("2!&(&8$9%!"#'8 0"/#.#"&"&(#0' '2,.0&3!00!8''&'"!(" !03!(! 0(7- !""!(2&$/,82#(&0$9%!"#8:&"/8 00!"/!72#"/&8$9%!"#800#'.($#("

;/#"/#0"/# #.0"#0'-%!-(#:'.!.#07!3+#!--:#$" '##"/#<,$=7#("> +#0##00#$""/# #.0"#00(" ? ;/#"/#0"/#<,$=7#("'/,-$+#0#.0"#$&("/#$&=#'"> 52

5 /&'.#"&"&(/!'+##(&-#$,($#02#%"&( 0 0 @,!'/&(="/#0$#0$!"#$

B 8.!''#$+3 "/#-#!0(#$,$&%&!-!=&'"0!"# '" -!''8!0&$!+!$89&$#:/&%/!( !..-&%!"&( $!"#$ B

* 8 &-#$ +3 %7.-!&(!("0#'.($#("/#0#&(,($#02#%"&( * ? 0 8 :!'!--:#$8!($"/#%0&7&(!-%7.-!&("$!"#$B

8"&"-#$!'

:!' '#(" " "/# 2"!"&( ,'# &%#08 -&%# 2"!"&(2#%"0B8!0&$!+!$8"0#=&'"#0!( /#.#"&"&(#0'!-' '##C@,!'/&(="/#'!&$ 8$!"#$

80#=&'"#0#$ ,($#02#%"&(' 8?8 8B88B 8* !"

-&%# 2"!"&( 2#%"0B8 !0&$!+!$ !-(=:&"/ %('#@,#("&!-.0%##$&(='!0&'&(="/#0#07 /#.#0,'!-!--#=!"&('7!$#&("/#%7.-!&("&-#$ +#0#"/#-#!0(#$--!@!!=&'"0!"#+327"2,(##"!.!0"(#0' !'/ ('"0,%"&(8 ??8 '"-082#%"0?8!--!+=!0/8!0&$!+!$8 '/:'"/!"%7.-!&(!(" 7.!(3$#!-'&("/#%('"0,%"&(:0C /#!%%,'#$ 7.!(38(!7#-38'5&7&"#$8 ,0=!(8="! :0C"/#%('"0,%"&(8#A#%,"#$07"/#%7.-!&(!(" 7.!(3" "/##A"#(" '%00#'80:/&%/.!37#(" ' B%00#':!'

7!$# /#+!-!(%#!7,(" '?8?88*B:!'"+#.!&$ !-(=:&"/&("#0#'"!""/#0!"#D.#0!((,707,=,'"8

? 2&(%#"/#!%%,'#$#!0-&#0C#."( 0#,'&(=!($"/#0#!"#0.-!&(-3 0#,'#$ " .!3 +!-!(%# .!37#("8 "/#0#0#8 "/# %7.-!&(!(" ',+7&""#$ ! %7.-!&(" $!"#$ **

+#0# "/# -&%#

77&''&(#08 ,0=!( %%0$&(=-38 "/# .-&%# %!--#$+"/ "/# .!0"&#'!($!'C#$"/#7"#("#0&("!%7.07&'#/#0#!"#08"/# !%%,'#$!-(=:&"/*7,'%-#7#(%!7#""/#&%#%7.-!&(!(" !"2#%"0?8!--!+=!0/!($,($#0"/0#!""C&--"/#7(=,(.&("8

? 0%&+-3+"!&(#$"/#'&=(!",0#'/,'+!($%7.-!&(!("(+-!(C .!.#0'!($=!9#"/#7"/0##.'"$!"#$%/#@,#'!7,("&(=" ' ?8B8BB!($"-$"/#7"/!""/#&0!%%,("'!0#'#""-#$!($&"/# +!-!(%#!7,("&'%-!&7#$8"/#3:&--+#C&--#$ "&'!--#=#$&("/# %7.-!&("!0#"/!""/#'&=(!",0#'"/#/,'+!($"/#%7.-!&(!(" ( +-!(C .!.#0' /!9# +##( +"!&(#$ ,($#0 "/0#!" !($ "/# %7.07&'#&'0=#$ /#-#!0(#$,$&%&!-!=&'"0!"# '" -!''8!0&$!+!$89&$# &7.,=(#$0$#0$!"#$

B 8'#(""/#'!7# ""/#.-&%#'"!"&(00#=&'"0!"&(%!'#!($&(9#'"&=!"&(,($#0 2#%"&( * ? 0 8 ( "/# +!'&' :/&%/ &( @,#'"&(

:!'0#=&'"#0#$ /!9#/#!0$"/#-#!0(#$%,('#-'0"/#.#"&"&(#0'8"/# -#!0(#$2"!"#%,('#-8"/#-#!0(#$'#(&0%,('#-00#'.($#(" !($/!9#!-'%!0#,--3=(#"/0,=/"/#&-# " &' (" $&'.,"#$ "/!" ' 5&7&"#$8 ,0=!(!%%,'#$ 7.!(38:/&%/.#"&"&(#0'!0#&0#%"0'!($

&%##!0#0'8/!$=&9#(!(0$#0"'!'/ ('"0,%"&(8 :/&%/27"2,(##"! %7.-!&(!(" :&# =0!'#(6!,'/&C8&'"/# .!0"(#0 /#:0C0$#0&'$!"#$

/# ""!-%'""/#.0<#%":!' ' %00#'"%7#',""/!"&("/# !=0##7#("8"/#0#:!'!(!0+&"0!"&(%-!,'#0'#""-#7#("$&'.,"# "!-'%7#',""/!"(

?8'!'/ ('"0,%"&("/0,=/

"/#&0 !$9%!"# &'',#$ ! ("&%# " ' 5&7&"#$8 ,0=!(8 0!&'&(=!%-!&7 '88 ?8?*.-,'$!7!=#'/#("&%#:!'

$,-3 0#%#&9#$ +3 '!&$ ' 5&7&"#$ (

? (

?8'!'/ ('"0,%"&("/0,=/&"'.!0"(#0'/:!0,""

6!,'/&C&-#$!%7.-!&("+#0#"/# 77&''&(#0-&%#82#%"0

8 !0&$!+!$ ((#A,0# 8 :/#0#&(8 :/&-# '"!"&(= !+," "/# $&'.,"#!($%7.-!&("0#=!0$&(=((.!37#(" '88 ?8?* .-,'$!7!=#'8&":!''"!"#$"/!"(

?8!7##"&(=:!'/#-$ &( :!0 448 2#%"08 !0&$!+!$8 !" !+,"

)

8 :/#0# !%%,'#$"87#("&(#$&("/#%7.-!&("8!-(=:&"/'7#*" B,(C(:(+,(%#0'%!7#.0#'#("!($',$$#(-3!%%,'#$*!($ '"!0"#$,'&(=&-"/3-!(=,!=#!($"/0#!"#(#$"/#%7.-!&(!("" "/0:/&707".-0"/#+,&-$&(=!($"/!"(#"/#,(C(:( +,(%#0 .-!%#$ ! .&'"- ( "/# "!+-# !($ !%%,'#$ " "/0#!"#(#$ "/# %7.-!&(!(" !($ !'C#$ /&7 " 0=#" !+," "/# .!37#("8"/#0:&'#((#:,-$C(:!+,""/#:/#0#!+,"' "/# %7.-!&(!(" " ,0"/#0 %7#' ," "/!" ! 7##"&(= :!' /#-$ +#":##("/#.!0"&#'(

8'&=(#$(EB

8!"'8 ,0=!(8&#&%#"/#!%%,'#$8:/&%/"/# !%%,'#$!0#&%#+#!0#0'8:/#0#+3'/!$!=0##$".!3

'?8B8BB #0"!&("/#0%($&"&(':#0#!-'&(%0.0!"#$ /#'!&$7&(,"#'7##"&(=:!''&=(#$+30 26!,'/&C80'

!'/ ('"0,%"&(!($02,(&- ,."!!($0'/C !'"=&80

* '5&7&"#$ "!-'%7#',""/!"!""/#"&7#7##"&(=8 07 "/# '&$# ' !'/ ('"0,%"&( 0 =#0'#( 6!,'/&C8 !0"(#0 /,'+!($"/#%7.-!&(!("2,(##"! 80!(<6!,'/&C8 2&"# (=&(##0 !($ 0 &0!(<!( 2/!07!8 $9%!"#8 :#0# !-' .0#'#(" /#(8 "/#0# !0# $&'.,"#$ :0&"&(=' $!"#$ B

((#A,0#'B !($ 8 #A#%,"#$ +3 "/# .!0"(#0 ' !'/

('"0,%"&(8 9&$# :/&%/ %/#@,# +#!0&(= 8 $!"#$

0 '8B?8*:!' /!($#$9#0!($ ' E-!%'

:#0#0#'.#%"&9#-3.!&$ ("/#'!7#$!389&$#:0&"&(= E 8'!'/ ('"0,%"&(,($#0"C":&"/$0!:!--"/# %0&7&(!- %7.-!&("'8-$=#$:&"/"/#!0&$!+!$.-&%#/#'!&$:0&"&(='!0# /!($ :0&""#( !($ (" "3.#$ /#'# !0# "/# :0&"&(='8 :/&%/ "/# %7.-!&(!(" %-!&7' "/!" "/#'# :#0# +"!&(#$ +3 =#""&(= /&' '&=(!",0#'(+-!(C.!.#0' /#%0&7&(!-!%"!--#=#$+#0#"/&' ,0"&'"/#&(%&$#("

8:/#0#&("/#!%%,'#$8!"#0+#&(=%!--#$!($!$9&'#$+3 "/#.-&%#"'#""-#"/#&0$&'.,"#8!0#!--#=#$"/!9##("#0#$"/# &%#"/#%7.-!&(!("!"2#%"0?!--!+=!0/8!($!"=,(.&(" +"!&(#$ "/# '&=(!",0#' =!0'#( 6!,'/&C /,'+!($ "/# %7.-!&(!(" (+-!(C.!.#0'8:/&'!-''"!"#$"+#0#!-+0"/#0 6!,'/&C8.!0"(#0'!'/ ('"0,%"&(!($!""/#'!7# "&7#/!($#$9#0"/0##.'"$!"#$%/#@,#'0 '?8B8BB" "/#/,'+!($"/#%7.-!&(!("!($!-'=!9#"/0#!"""/#/,'+!($

"/#%7.-!&(!(""C&--"/#7/#%7.-!&("/!'+##(&-#$+327" 2,(##"!8 :&# =!0'#( 6!,'/&C8 !' .!0"(#0 ' !'/

('"0,%"&( /&' ,0" &($' "/!" &( 9&#: "/# %($&"&(' &( !=0##7#("8"/#.!37#("0+!-!(%#"/#0#&'!%&9&-$&'.,"#!($ !0+&"0!"&(%-!,'#&'!-0#!$3"/#0#+#":##("/#.!0"&#'&("/#'!&$ !=0##7#("8:/#0#+3"/#:0C0$#0:!'.-!%#$:8"/&' ,0"&'

" (-3 '## :/#"/#0 "/# %%,00#(%#8 !' !--#=#$ ( **

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

=!0'#(6!,'/&C/&7'#-$&$("&-#!(3%7.-!&("&':&#:!'("

B .0#'#("!""/#"&7#:/#("/#!--#=#$%%,00#(%#"C.-!%#&#(

"&'7#("&(#$&("/#%7.-!&("&"'#-"/!""/#-&%#

77&''&(#08 ,0=!(8 !($ /&=/#0 !,"/0&"&#' %!--#$ +"/ "/# .!0"&#'( **

!($!'C#$"/#7"#("#0&("!%7.07&'#8" :/&%/ !%%,'#$ !=0##$ !($ !-' !=0##$ " 7!C# "/# +!-!(%# .!37#(" ":!'"/#0#!"#0"/!""/#.#"&"&(#0'!%%,'#$9&'&"#$"/# &%# "/# %7.-!&(!(" !-(=:&"/ *7,'%-#7#( /# #!0-&#0 %7.-!&("+306!,'/&C8!'$&'%,''#$!+9#8'/:'"/!"'!7# "3.#&(%&$#(":!''"!"#$"/!9#"!C#(.-!%#&("/#3#!0

? 07!--38:/#(!.#0'(%7#':&"/"/#7,'%-#7#(!($:&"/!=,(8 /#7!3+"!&("/#'&=(!",0#'"/#"/#0.!0"3(+-!(C.!.#0'8+," /#:&--(#9#0/!($9#0.'"$!"#$%/#@,#'""/#..'&"#.!0"3" &'("$&'.,"#$(+#/!-0#'.($#("'"/!""/#'!&$%/#@,#':#0# #(%!'/#$(EB

8 B

!($

0#'.#%"&9#-3&# +#":##(?7("/'"/#'!&$%%,00#(%# &0'"!--8"/#!%%,'#$:&--(#9#0/!($9#0"/#.'" $!"#$%/#@,#'""/#..'&"#.!0"3!"=,(.&("!($"/#(#(',0# "/!""/#'#%/#@,#'!0#/(,0#$ #0"!&(-3&"/#'#%/#@,#'!0# =&9#(8"/#.!0"3/!($&(=9#0"/#%/#@,#':&--%#0"!&(-30#@,&0#'7# :0&"&(=/#%7.-!&(":!'&-#$7,%/-!"#0&#(

&# !"#070#"/!(*7("/'"/#%%,00#(%#!($!"#0#(%!'/&(="/# %/#@,#''7#%%,00#(%#/!$"!C#(.-!%#8"/#%7.-!&(!("0 /#0/,'+!($:,-$/!9#&77#$&!"#-3!..0!%/#$"/#.-&%#

!-(=:&"/"/#'!&$%/#@,#'8'"!"&(="/!""/#'#%/#@,#'/!9#+##( /!($#$9#0""/#7!"=,(.&("!($..'&"#.!0"3/!'+"!&(#$ '7#:0&"&(=:#9#08"/#%7.-!&(!("!($/#0/,'+!($$#%&$#$ "#(%!'/"/'#%/#@,#'&0'"!($"/#0#!"#07!$#"/#%7.-!&(" /#:0&"&(='7#("&(#$!+9#!0#&("/#/!($.!0"(#0'!'/

('"0,%"&(/#!%""/!"(&77#$&!"#%7.-!&("""/###%""/!" '!&$%/#@,#':#0# 0%&+-3 /!($#$ 9#0 ""/# %7.-!&(!(":!' 7!$#87!C#'&"#9&$#(""/!"&"&'!%(%%"#$'"03".,"%0&7&(!--!: &(7"&(8'!'".,".0#'',0#("/#!%%,'#$"!=0##""/# "#07' " +# $&%"!"#$ +3 "/# %7.-!&(!(" !($ &07 ' !'/

('"0,%"&( /#0#0#807"/#0#=&(=$&'%,''&(8&"%7#'," "/!"%7.-!&("&-#$+327"2,(##"!+#0#"/# ,0"!':#--!'"/# 0#=&'"0!"&( "/#0#" &( .,0',!(%# " "/# 0$#0 $!"#$

B 8 .!''#$ +3 "/# -#!0(#$ ,$&%&!- !=&'"0!"# '" -!''8!0&$!+!$8&'("/&(=8+,"7&','#.0%#''

,0"%%0$&(=-38"/#.0#'#(".#"&"&(&'!--:#$!($"/#%7.-!&(" $!"#$B

8"&"-#$!'

8"/#&7.,=(#$0$#0$!"#$

B 8 .!''#$ +3 "/# -#!0(#$ ,$&%&!- !=&'"0!"# '"

-!''8 !0&$!+!$8 ,($#0 2#%"&( * ? 0 8 0$#0&(= "/# 0#=&'"0!"&( ! %!'# !($ "/# 8 $!"#$

8 0#=&'"#0#$,($#02#%"&(' 8?8 8B88B 8* 8

E !"-&%#2"!"&(2#%"0B8!0&$!+!$ !-(=:&"/ %('#@,#("&!- .0%##$&(=' !0&'&(= "/#0#07 !0# /#0#+3 '"!($ @,!'/#$

52 *

'<C'