High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/45163/2016allowed

Sanjeev Goyal And ANR v. Gagan Goyal

2020-03-02Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi11 pages

! "! !

! "

$ %

! "

& '

$ # $%# &

( )$"

*+, -

! .*+, - $/

- $

$# )*) *"0 - $/ %

# ( $ - #)#)*+,-")! ,- . & /01. 234 5 1. #)#)*+!"6) ! ,- . & /01.4 3%.1. 23 3 "-,33 ,334" --, 5

-0 $ " , 6 6 - 3 ,"

* 7% - 8

8 - # %

893 )*:

)!) $ 0 + ."#*'"

"#$*5 0$$,-0 9,3$"

- 5# 3$ ", , 3 ,"3 0 5 - , - $ $

",- 3 5 $ - :

- * -, ## -#- $ $

5 : )"0 5 $ ; -,3$, ",- ; /

9 *'" 5 $ # +0"( $ ,," & ',,3$0 "-$ $ #0# 350"

2; 3<5*, 33 3 ; 3 $ , ", =0#- 35$,--, ,3- 3 ,0" - ,," & ' ,3 3 , 3"0 - $ ,# 3 ; 3 $, ", : )"0 # 3 &=* , * ) /

* '" *

"$ - ,* '" ) > '" # '" # 2 -

*& ' ,,3$0 +3#*";

# - ,0 < /

'" 3 $ - 0" 5

: )"0* : 5 5 , 4",

)") $ # 5 #)>>*'" $ 5 0 # $ =

*& ' +3#* 5 # - - ,*

: )"0: 5 *5 5 0,; -; /

9 * '" - $"

# 5 5 , ",0" 5* # 30 0 ;- ,"$"

# 5

, ,"$"

# 5 ,," & '0

5#0 ,;

0 3 3 0 "#

" +,," & ' ; 3, $ 3 0#

5$ 3"- 3 5 - - ?>/

5 # "

, %% 5 , >*

- 8 >8,) /

*'"

$, # , ,3$- # - $ " , % -

# ,," & ' +3# +3 "

# = ,," & ' 5 ,, ," , % >5 ,," # 5 ,4"- , # 0 + -.", # *'" "#3

% +,," & '-

"#$ # ,, ,3$ -

)*)

# ,4"-,," # )"

#$,- $$ * ,3$-$$," ,

- $ 3 $ ",,"3 05- , 2 $$,5 $$ 0,," & ' # 3 - $- = # " - $ * + ."#*'" $ 3$"# %

,,05 -"$ ," ,"3 "# 0$ ", 0 ,3$30$, -0" @ 0 - 5 0 3 - - #"3 $ - $$, 0 0 $$ 00 ,33 ,, # ?### *,3$ - $ $

> " - $ $ " ,

)$"

* " - #" ,"3 4" 5# $ - $ " 4" - " $ $

, - , $ 3# $ ", 3 05-,5" -" , 2 3$"# $ 0 + ."#*'" , , ,"3 ,"050$ ",-"$ ,",

)+) @ 0#- 35 5 $ $, ,"3 , @ 0 -50 3- #"3 3$"#

"-- - 33 # 2 5 "-- # " , , 5$ ", ,"3 4" 05-, 2 - * 3$"#

30 $$, - ,30 5 > "$$ - #"3 " -

$, , 0 % & '%

(%#

&& )* )* ,, )* --

$ # )* " #"3 - " -

= *

! .* " -

$ & ' # #" $$, - $ ",# , 0 - 0 # ,"3 4" ,"050 $ ",-"$ ," ?"

* $ -, -

3 $ -= "%- - ,"

* 76 2 $$, - $ ",# , 0 3-- #- $$5 - $$ ,# , , ,"

, ,," 5 ,5 4" 0; , $ ", "#3 - "0 ," 2 3$"# - , - ,"3 3--

#- $$ "-- - 33 #

)-) - * $ 30 3 > "$$ - #"3 " - $ & '# $, , 0 .

/$% . )* )* ,, )* 00

*5 , 3$5 +$$ "

;-"

, ,0;* " ( 1-

# $ !

% &

' & !

( ))

* "+ >% & '%

(%#

&& )* )* ,, )* --&80"$ 3"

0 " ( ,-"

(

( (

( ! %0

)6)

"4 , 4 " 5 '%

( 8 /, -9 #

# ::0;

, (% 5% '%

5%% <8 /, -0 #

# 91;

,$%#

5%%8 )* ,,)* 0 ;

% <

=%&%8 )1* ,,)* )1* > ;

?% $$# % &%

# <8 )* ,, )* :19 )1* > )* :;

%% @ 5# %

) '

%*8 )* ,, )* 9- )1* ,= " 5"&

# % = "

4 8 /, -:0 #

# 1

6 7"""&

"8(

* "

! 1

1 (

" &

* (

" &

! //

" &

! "

(

"""""7 9":

; 6 7

! %0 .

(

);)

(

! %0

(

1 ! %0 =': #9 "1""78 >"

" 3

(

" ! %0

> @ 5## @ $# B &

# )* ,, )* -00$$,"

5 $ -0&# "

-" 75 0 # $$ 0 "03$$ $ $$, 35 $$ - 0 # "#3-&80"$ 3"

/$% . )* )* ,, )* 00

=$$5 0&80"$ 3"

$$, - , 0 33- - 5 "5# $$0- &80"$ 3 "

0 $ - "#3 " ( ,! %0 "1""

! %0

)<) > 5 - 0 -

"#3 - &80 "$ 3"

* #"3- " - $ & ' # $$,- ,0# 00 3-- #- $$ - 3 $ 0 + ."#* '" $ #- $$,5# $, ,"3 , 5 4" -@ 0 -50, 3-- #- $$ "-- - 33 # 2 3$"# "-- - 3 ,-#" , ,- "

, # , 5 $$ # - , , ," 0 5 - "$ ," $ ,", 5 5# ,"3 0$, - 5 @ 0 -*-*50 3 -- #"3 2 3$"# * - *00 0 "

@ , -$5 " , 6-

- ,"

# -" ,

> $ , * $ & '# ; ,3$ @," $ -$ $ /

*2 *'" 2

,3 $$, 3 / %

77 * :2/ +- % 5 # # 0& ' # ,3$ <"3 0 ;

<"3 3#$ -<"3 < /

* 2 *'" , ,3$

), ) <"3 ; <"3 5 ,4""#3

0 -.",# *'" $& '- 3 /

777 & '

; 0- &#

5 3$ -,3$<"3

-3 < /

*2 *'" 2 $ 5 $ ", ,"3 - , $ $ " 3-,3$ 05- ," ,

$ $

0 $ $ 2 ,"3 4" ,"3 - $"0,"

*""0 #" , ",- ,"3 5 , - $ # ,3- ,3 $ < /

*2 *'" -

" $ $ , - , > , "

2 2 % # % <2 332%

% ---)1* ,, )* 8 &80 "$ 3 "

@$ ," $ ," 3" 0 " 5; 5# 3 @- $ ,", 2 #- " 3# ,," - , *0" # 3#3- $ ,",0

$ 0," /$ ,0- , - 3,

>-$ $ ,5 ", 3 5 0 "# , " ,* ,"

"03#3" $ 3# ",

3 ; 0 ,-

),,) > % B#

(%8 )* 9*5 0 &80"$ 3"

0 #- ,

- 53$" - 5 ##,* , 3 ; 0 @3# 3 5 * "

8 -", " , 0 @3# ", 5 # *5*3$

, "# 0 $ ", 0 $ $$ , - " $ $ , - , /$ ",50," $ & ' #- $$, 5 $ & '#5#$$ ", @3 5 *-*@3 0" ,$ ",

> -, , ,"3 , * $ 5* 3$"# *$$, - , 5 5$ ", ,"3 4" 0 $$ 0 5 - , 0 "33#@3#,, 5

# =0 >=2 1. $;#9 ( B 9/ $ 0 ( B 9/