High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21249/2019disposed of

Chandan Kumar Jha And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2022-12-20Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger10 pages

"# $$

!" #

# %& $ '

' & ''( %)*'+ '%$

'( %)*' + ,$

-% %,(

.(-'/ .'0'( %)*' + $% ' ( $ )*+, This petition has been filed for quashing of FIR No.218 dated 04.12.2017, under Sections 323, 324, 326, 148, 149 of Indian Penal Code registered at Police Station Bhargo Camp, Jalandhar (Annexure P-1) and all the consequent proceedings arising therefrom, on the basis of compromise dated 15.07.2018 (Annexure P-2) arrived at between the parties. Vide order dated 09.05.2019, the 122'3''4 '5 '2 was directed to record the statements of the parties with regard to the genuineness and validity of the compromise.

In compliance thereof, the Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Jalandhar has submitted its report, vide letter dated 30.07.2019 which indicates that the parties appeared before the Magistrate and got recorded their respective statements with regard to the validity of the compromise. As

-- per the report, the compromise arrived at between the parties is genuine and without any pressure or coercion from any corner. Relevant extract of the said report is reproduced as under:-

! "

!$ &

% %

(

!$ !% )

( '

*+,+- (

*+,+-

(

% (

(

)

.*,

,*+0,+- /,//00-01'

% ,1+,+1 2

'2+, '% $ 02% ,0,' '6 +'22 ,** %$

,')/ * %%,*'

(0,,') '%,' ,6' ,'

/*6$ 6 %'%,7,')/-**'

,"1 3 3'

,% ,7,')+ , '%,', '%*6$ 6 0'

%)2'

27'%0,'7$

%* 2+ $% ,'

'4' '%,' ,6' ,'

/ 2%'%, '%*6$ 6 , +'22 ,$

'%02%,2$/ 44$'*'%'67/0, $'

-- 8'

% ' * 2 % ' '7 % $

%43'

,4+'+ '%"13 1 ,') ,'

% , 2'

% * 2 + , $'

'% ,') $

%,+2 1

( 9/2$ 6 / )%,',+ , + *'

$ $ 270,$'

(0,+22'$'

(/ 7,,'*,'% 0')' ++220 ,$

9/2 $: ,*'

+ !

" #$ %& ' # " ( ") * ,'

,2%'

% &;

2*5

% %

(

7 )

8 &

(

/,+

( ( (

%8 (

( 9:;<

& ;< %

(

( )

%8 (

(

% % 7( % 8 (

)

% (

-<-

%% ( ( =

: % )

(

)

(

( %

)

% (

% % =

(

& 8 & ( % % )

(

7 (

( %

(

% (

( (

(

%) ;<

(

& )

4 22+ , ( , / '%$ *$2 + : * 4,$0

% *<=0 66'

>%/7, 9/2$ 6 , 6' + +"&& ," - "&& .)& ")" ' # "

" #$ %" ' # "/ ( +(, '6 '

: '*%'

% & ? ,/ '%$ *$2 0,*,6 4+ 6, $ *% , /-*( 6'7 / 66'

% , +2204 $ $ &

-@- ?*<=$ ) ,, $0

+, 4, $ )''/ +,$ *

+'7*

* ,% +- * ,$ ) % *+ 0 $0

127 *4 '%$ ) $0

0,*,, , 4, A ? ,)*'+,- %*+, 4, 3'

,'"

1+ 6'$ '* 6'2$ *%4 ,4 %,'' 26,'

)%'/0, ++% '%,)*6 , '6'

,)*'+ - %*+ ,$ $ +*6$%4'++*B,2 *6$%4'++*(,$0 +,* 4) %/7 , $ ) + * C + , % + 6'2 *% (DE ,$0 3'

,% *<=

' '*%)+,++* ;*6$%'/2 ?1+ 64'$0,, '* 6'2$ *%4

*6$2' ,2% / 3'

,% : * + - %* % *<=(, 4, 6 )'2'0,, , % +- *02%- +7,: * +,, $0 A ?<B,2,, $0 +, 4, ,'

'0% '6/'%$2%,'

/: * %A * ,%

+- * $ )''/ +,$ *

+'7* A ?@ , %* '

0,, ' *6$2' "

1+ 6'$ ,2%/3'

,%,4 %,', ++% '%)*6,') 2%,% $( )2) 26'27 ,+'* '%* *6 '* +'*,*'

'%:,'

) 2'/ '+$ *$2 *'/+ 62'%A ??1,: * +,$0 % *<='%0,2

-?- %'240,'$2',',% $,'

/ 2%(, 4, 6 ,')% 4'

%,' '%4 ')7+, ++* '% ++* )2)4 6'2 %$ ')7 ++* *,'

6 % ( '$'%%'*7*' '$$ $ '27/3'

,%,4,,)*6 ,+'627+, )*6 ,') 2% , % $ *, ++* '

(

$'F4($ )'' /,')' 6$'*$

*7 ,%* *0,, '2 *,*'

+%% , )

%4 26 + $/2* $ ,4$

+ ++* A ?E

% 4 ,% + 6 ++* ( , 6'7 / * 6'2*'

0,*,,')') 0,264 $ %6' 26+'*)2% $ ,7 '%'% *+4 +'

,: * +,, $0 3'

, ** %A ?= 6'2 *'

)2)4 ++* 0,*, '

+ 6 *66 *'2( +'*'2( 6 *'2( $'

,$ 62'

' '* 0,'

'227*)2+2') 6'7'$$ $ '

' +'22 + 3'

,4 0, $'

,') 2% , % $A ?D1 *,'*'

(, 4, 6'73'

,,* 6'2 $ *%4 + )0 + , *6$ 6 /0 , % $' (,$

/27+'*)* 6'%, *'+'* 6'2$ *%402%*'

'%$ -%*A'% ?C , 7':*$,$ *$2 $ $ ?='%?D'/)!*6*++* )2)4 , +'*'2 '% *6* 022;/4 + , ' ,')

-E- 6$2*' 0,*,2/7%,%6'+'6 % $ /0$ )'% $' , 4, 02%/- +% %*243'

,0, ,++% )2)%' '*)7'F'+'*'2 *6*+ '% 6 %6' ,* 3* +,'**6$2'%+$,+'*'2 *6* 602204,,/'2'* 1,6' ++) #0 ,' ,# " ! #$ 1' "'

( 2 3 +(, 9/2$ 6 ,'

,2% ,',6'

0,*,*'/*'4 >%'

'2' , 6' 0,*,,' +- %:,/6'2%$ ')7

*66

+'++*+ *,' ' ,'3'

,4+0,*, 02%)

%$/2* (, *'3'

,,"1)0+,

26'

)%''64 ,$'

,/ )'+, 9/2 $ 6 : '*%'

% &; GDB, 6;$'%,2%,''

$$ %*C

0, , 3'

274%%/7,*6$ 6 /0 , $'

$* + ++* H*6$%'/2I 0, , ' 7 + '60 F( , : '; %'

7 $0

-%$' 4, % *<= ) % , %

*2<+, (*'/ )F%/7%,6 '%/% +*C

(0 ',' *,$0

+0%'6$2% 4, / : * % *'

+227 , *: + 3'

,4 * 6'2$ *%4 (/'

46%& ' '%++*+ ,++*,* * +, *7A

+ ,- 7(+'7A 2'

7' +*6$ 6 /0 ,'** %'%,)*6A) %*+,'** %

-=- $

($ '%'+ ,**

* + ,$ $ % ++*'%5 , 2)'* % ' J

')4 '$$ ' % , '+ ;

'% $'

'% 04,4 $,$*2'

+'* '%* *6 '* +, '*'

(, *

*2%)F$0

% *<= 3'

,,* 6'2 $ *%4 + ,+2204 '

& +,'** %'627'** %',2K#,*,K /,,'

/'*3%, *'

/7, *$'2'4 '()2 *#'

%('2'%,'

)% -%46%'%ECC=

'2+-%46 ,0 ,',- ' '*%%

*?1 0 /'*F'%,6/+2+,'%(0,*, '

;)'2$'

) (,*6$2'''%,

+', %%4')'7)%* '2+-)2 ',2 K#,*,K /,'%$ %*%*$7+*6$ 6 /+ , )2 *#'

% ,'224%**

*$ 6'+'*'$$'

/' 2+

66 %

'%4/0,$'

24-

/4*'

%,*6$2'' ,' +,% $*'/ '%/ ,*F4,

*7'2'

4 '

02%*'

4 ')$/2** 7 ) ,$ % ++ '7* 6'2'*% '%

)2)%'7, *'

) ,"1, *'

%' /'*F,7'

CE'%,

,4 * % ,0 ,' , /+ '+ , $ $ % *6$ 6 ( '7 0'

% *% ' $ % /0,$'

) ,$'

, 0)2(0,'7* *

-D- *6$2 ( 022427 '% )2'

27 ,') / % ,

%++ * '%0 ,'** %'3 , % $A ) , *6$2'' 2F27 $$ , *'

+ , $ *'%*'+,$ *%4 2F27/'

+-%*'26 ) ,/-*+2'0 022 )%0,,$'

2),

%++ * '% *, $'*+227 *;: '% 2) ,'

67 : ,4 )'* ,')4/ 2)%( +- * 02%/ )%/7+ *4,$ % 4 4

+ * 6'2$ *%4 : *, '%,*6$2'''

% +,

'6 '

'50( , 3'

,4 + * 6'2 $ *%4 022 '%)'*$'*(,'

67('%+220 ,$'64 ,$'

0,,')%*%%+ 4'%+ 4)'722;022'%,') )4'* '4' '*, , A '% *' + , $ *%4 2F27'%)'*'7 +- * : ,*'

+'%6 '+* 6'2- * 602%

6';++*%'**$'*+,'6*'/2 26 /0,$'

'%5 2''*3'2+, " , '

'%'/)(,$ $ '220%'% ,* 6'2$ *%4 ,'+ '%*'

FIR No.218 dated 04.12.2017, under Sections 323, 324, 326, 148, 149 of Indian Penal Code registered at Police Station Bhargo Camp, Jalandhar (Annexure P-1) '% '22 * 3'2$ *%4 '

4, + 6('

,%,/'

+ *6$ 6 %'%@CEC= :

; %/0, $'

0) ( , '6 02% / /-* $'76 + * +

-C- C(CCC5;/%$ %/7,$ 0,, -

* "!.

/ + *

0"1( ( 2"1 3*24 '%, '%'602%/

$+ , '6+$ $' 0,,F02%4+ %*'2 $ %

$ %+,'+ '%

22$%4'$$2*' (+'7( ,'22 '%% $ %+ $$ )' ,

6'%$ B,, $'F45 '

%& L B,, $ '/2& L