← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/45571/2018disposed of

Gurmeet Ram Rahim v. Central Bureau Of Investigation Special Crime New Delhi

2018-12-03Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram18 pages

      

 

          

  

   !"#   ! $ %

! &'

!" () !*# +!

,( (!&-  # ( 

 !""  

 ./ 0(. !0( .#!0( (..

  !0( #    ." !0(  # ( %

11111

  #         (    #   #     (  " 

23  # ((((4 4 50

+ %6#

(78"#  9(   . !

:8  ; 

 ) &5"6< '"$<"

<

<&-  (( =  '

 ( (" 

 !>!2= ('

>  " 

"

<

&-    ( ? $%&'())*+(+,-(+./*,)'%0 + ( 

##   (( 4  (78  ( "  4 ((   # ( %  

    ## 8

#  (    (  ##   ( - 

(( (" 

>78

0  8(   

  8 (   ( #  

 ( # ( 8  ! ##   - (78 #    ("  4 ##   (



(  78         

    (       

   (      - 

  (  "   > !-  #  < #<

" ( ##    7 ( 

( ((((4 4 #

(78 "#  9(   . !

:8  ; !-  7@ 

 # #   , (

#    7  #    ( ( ##    ("   =(- "  4

;

 (  

   #   <

 0 8     

( (

 ## 8 #   - 



#

((78

0  8A #   ( ##( 78-8

&=2   (" 

(- "  2- - ( 

(78  ( ((( 2  , (

7    

- 

-((7 ( #

!-

-((!( (8- ( (( ( 

## #   ( - 

 ( (  (  +   " - 

+ ((       -  ( (-  7 

  #  - ## (#   !

- !   

  (     - 

 

%+   , (

7 

 7   ( ! - (7(    ( #

 ( 7 8   78

 (  

, (

#   

 (#  @(  : B7 0#+ +2+3"-.4,+./*,)'%$% "*+*) **+'+.5,+3 67"81#&'%,**+()*,+.+./$%,) "*+*) 9&*5, :

" #-*2+ ,+'(+.+./++./*,)'%$% ;+3",))3&()//2+./*,)'% 67":1#'&3$)3&+./+.*,)'

$%"*+*):6 7"8# -3+<+' +3&9&'+.)$%"*+*) +,+'+%,*'+ 67" #.-. ./-+$%'+ &33+9&(+'"+(+3+./+.*,)'

:

:617" !=+,-'++>->&33+,",)-?,$%"*+*) &@+'+* '3 ! # @(    :  ",+?&.*+3+$%"*+*)  )3,- 1:6 7 !

#@(   78:  9+(+3,()/,+(()/A+?-3.%+'-$%"*+*) +,+'+%,*'+ '3! # @(  @  :   ))3)%,+-.$% "*+*) +@+%*,+.8'3!

!@(   &3&?&'-9**+2+ +./*,)'%$%(;)'' :

8 #@(  @: 

 '+$-.?&(+'!+35,+./",+,$%"*+*) &@+'+*+./+.*,)'

:'3! 81 ##   , (

 # ( %

7  ( (

#;

( 7 #

(78  :

7   #       ( 

8- # 

( ! 8(   3 (! -       8, (

 7  

##

A ( 0!#    3 (   -  # # :(    (

#  (



8    # (( -

(

 

/    #   ! # #   !

 ## 8#    - 

!-  #  #  7 

8  - 

   

+   @ ( (       ( #(

0  8- 



  (#

8  - 

7 

/ 

+- 

!--   ( ( - 

- ## ( ( < ( ("   =/##   (78 #   -  ##  - 

!-  -  (# 78

0  8- 

 # #    (

#   ! 78-    #    ### (8! !  

8

-   ( 

   #    7   81:      /!    ##    -  (  78    #     # 8     ##   -

 (!- ! -    ( ((

  ;#-  ("  4*

8 +- 

!- -  - ( - 

(  -(# 

/#    - ## ("  4              8     #    !  -  

#((  ( ? ")5*-.:

 

  

     

      

   

         

   

 

                     

  

 

 



    



      

 

       

    

 



   

  

    



  

!

"#$%#%#%#%#%#%#%# & 

  

' !(!



% 

)* 

   





   

 

  "+ ,     



 

  

  

             ,

   

           

     





!-.     

 



      

       

  

  

   

 !  .  

  

    



 



 

   

  !/

  

 

 



 

     



    

 

!/  



 

  





'  

     



!  

0  



 



  



 

%



         

    0       





! / 



""1  

 

 

 

1$ 

!2



 '     



   

  





       

      

   

!- 0# # "  4 - 

 ! 8 8  % #    

( 

#(   8(  

8( 7 ##  8    ! 3 8!  #(

 ((78 7  ! 8

 

#

- #

#- (  ( ;



 3 (7#((  7    ( ! !  

8 (( 7 ## 

    3 8  /   ( 3  

   ( <   (7 

8( 7  / 

8 (( 7 8 7+ (7878  



/#- - 7  7 ;(!

 !    

8   (  ( 7 8   (      ##    (     8 7      !   7(

-  

(  7  7 3 8!  -   

     #!  

0  8 (# 

8 ( - - 

(( 

8    

8

 ( 

( (( 

87#  #

   

  

8    

(        #

  " 

= ( =!- #((  ( , 1$!  3     

 

            4      

       

 

 

 

!

56!.  

  



 

 

        

 



    

!7 "6  

 

      

     

     8 

 

0 9

 

 

 

   



  :          ;

  

  ;

                



 



  ;

    







  ;

    









;

    



  



     

 ;

    



  



1<;

5   



 % 

 

 

 

    





$1= $1=6 $1=>  $1= 5

$1=? 

$1=4 / ( 

@+A=<7!7 . 

  

 

   



      :     0       

  

  !

$  

      

   

  

 





+A 

 

           :         



  

  



  

     

          

     8 

    

         

0    !

@    



















   8     0     

   

          0!

 +  





     

1<     





  8   

   

 % 

   

       

       

  8   ;

   





=

 

    %     !

=/  



      

 

  

   





    

B

 

     

         

 8   

      

 





 

 0 

!

1

  



           



     



  

+!

A!&







   









 

"



 8   

 

           

     

  



      

 8   







 



  



;    

"=  

 

      

  

          

 





 

 " %%%%%%%%%%%% "<1! 



   



  !/   





:



 

 8   

 





           

;

   







 +@;

  



 

$ 

  =          



      %           

   



  

  





  





  

=

1$;

           





=@;

        

  %   

 

 8     



 

+

1$ ( 

   8  

   



  !

     



   



  



   

          

 !- *  #    #

   "   =    !   

## 8         #         !   

 ## ( (# (  ( 

%  #    -( #.  @ (    ; C /!. 

(    ( # ( -

 - 

( ( ( -; C   

  "   =##  (!. 

3 (

 (#



- #    

;

C / 3 ;

 



 

$

 =  !(!       



   %      

    



  

    



  





 

= 

1$ !(!!

 .       





= !(!!;

  6      

  %   

 

 8    



 

+

1$ !(!!

0# 7  (#

  ( "   =  -   7   .  

 ( -  

8 (## (

( !

( <-

7  0 @ (    =5'6!=5>6 (  # ("   =  #(7   7 ( (8#  -(. 



   ( 7%   5'6576"  =-  8+#    7 . (   (8 ( "    = 78

#        (

#  

( (  8#   - ( 7+#(   #7    

    @  ! ## (## ( 

-(  (.  - 



-  (  #  (

D 8    (78#  ! 

-  (   . -

- 3   (  

8  -.   - 

 

78#    ## 8 #

 (!8((

8-   - 7@   ( 78#   

 7  ( -(   

8-  #   3  7 (78#  - -(  (  % - 7 -((.    #      ((   (  "   >56         (  8#  ( 7 ## ( (/ .  (   -  7  (#  !78    # ("   =(

(  

  78#  ;

3 !- ( 

 (  



#8# - (

 (  



8  #     (- 

!- 3  (78#   - -(  % .  # 



 (( ("  >56"   = (3 (7# (( (

  ( -  #  ( ## 8  

      (9   

87

(   #(( 8(( (  

-7 #  #  

  ( -  (@      

; 8   (8

* 

   #   78-  (  ( 

(78

  

!

* -  (  ( 

(78  ! (   8#  (  (

 ; (   -    /-    8 ;  (  ( (  (8 (- - #((78  (7

* - ( ( #

   :-! (87 (

( (  

(78

* (       " ( ( - 7 -  (78

* #   ( 7 8! #- (

* #       7  ( ; #( (     /       ##   7 (        #

#( ("  =5'6 (=5>6 ("   =( 78



 #  ( +

 (<  ("  >56( ( -   % ! ( ( #   7- 

((#   - 

((   (  ( #       (    7          #@(   - ( (  8  7   (      7   (       (     

  8! (- (7( (#### 8( ( 

   - 

 78 7

   (    (  

 -   +

7-   (   (   ((78 # 

#  ! ##  #  3  7

(  78    #      -   -(     %     

. -  ( 8  ("  >56(  8#  ( #  #   78 



 

( #(#   (    ( "  =5>6(-  ( 8#( ! !  #   +#(   #7   (  ( (

8  . /  # "   =56

(   . # ( ( 

 -   E  .    ;

 ### B   (      



87

( /          #     ( ##   ( "  =5'656( ( E -  #   ##  8B E  (8 .  (     B/  (    7-((    .  - #/  -  ## 8 (  7(  "   =56(- .  -   ( -  (87 . (      ( (

- -((78#   -    $ ("   =56!.  (      ## ( /

8  ((    .     (# "   =56(

 (     ! (  (

-

# ( 



     "  =506 ( 7  ((-

4+#

8 



(( ("  >(7 



((  ( 8 /-( E   8(!-

# ( 8- ! 8#  ( 7%

  56"  >(;     - 

(((      ; (- # ( 8   ( ("  =(! 7 (78 ( ## #  ( # "  >56(.

78! 7   7    ( (# " 

>56( ( +   ! !#  

(78- 

(     !-((  ("  >56( # ( 8  ( ( "  =( ## ( / (    ( #   #

-#   ## + - 

    (( # ( 8   ( ("  =( /  ##      (    ##       !   #   # (-  (   (   ( 7

 !   8877 ;#

(;/  (78

   ( (  (        8(- (   ##    -   



8 (       7  ( 8  ( 

( - #(  ((-  ((/ (

  ;( - -

((  

   7 (# (   8   #@( 8  7 ( $ (     ! ! ( ;

 ( -  ##  ((  ## 

#     (             (   ( -(

8 ( - #   ! 

  ! - (7(8  ;  (  7  ( /  7  

 (  78  @   :      

,+.+.@+29&(+'"-.4,$%"*+*) +@+%*,+.8'!1 1 

  #

(  ( ? ?

     

     

          

   

    

          



      !

0   

   

  

   

    

   

            

   

  

 



! 

 

  (    & D

   

  !2 

 (    & D

      !6  "  /    2 ?

 



  

   

          



!  4       

      

  ,- 



      

  

! C          B

        

 

!/                      



    !.

 







 



  



   

  !

. 

        



    

 

               

  

 

      

     

!/  





 



 



,E  -  B

!    

   B     !

4  

 8



    





   !4     



,



B

 -!/



           

   

 



 



 





B

 



!.



  

     6   @          / !

 " / 



 

 

 

 

 !6

        

   



     







,



 !-.  

 

 6  " / !

4  

 C  

  B 

    

     !>    

        B   

 

     !

/ 

       !

.





                     ! &            

   



   0

         0!  6  

 0

 

   B  !

4  

 2 

       

  !.  

 

  

  !/           

!/ 

       



'

   



  

 

     

  B  

         !.  

 B

 



  

 !/  







    

          

  

   

B



   !. 

B

  0       B  !.    





 







!    !$

B  /





          



0      

 



(  (

 !- * # 

(  7    (

-  (7! 

(( -#   

7 ( ( 

(  ( 0     (

# 

(7  

(   @(  !   7 (-     ( 7

((78 

:-! !

(    

              

 0  8 

#

( - 3 (78 (#   !

#87

((

 -7!# #   # 8

-( ( # ((((4 4 50

+%6#

(78"# 

 9(   . !

:8  ;  ) &5"6<  '  "$<"

<

<&-     ((  =  '   (   ( " 

 !>!2= ('

>  "  "

<

&-     ( ? $%&'())*+(+,-(+./*,)'%0  78  (- (     

- (%#      



#- ( ( 

(( ("  >( ( ## 8 ! !

   8 ((

8  ##   78 / #     7  

  

-(   

#            ;(   (  + 7 (( ( ##   (78 (

 "#  9(   . !

:8  ;  "

#  7# (-  # (--;

(   ##   /  

#  (#

78-

#  7( -

7( ((78  ( 

 

(  

#  -

 ( 8 8#  ( +    (    

 ! "

   #!$% & '  D #;

< ( F <& D#7 F <&