Sarabjit Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another



 
    
 

 !

"#$#% & &

'

( )*# '#%+, &&&

# #% ( -$& '

 .%* ) %! % , ( &&& $/%!

% $
0 12&'
  


 
 


  
 




 4&  


 
!

 "
#
 
 


  


 
$% %& &%$$

%'

%( &%$& !) 
 &

 (
 *#
+ *

 
,



 





+  


"

 




 

 
"
 "


 
-./ 0 $1&
 
$'

%2 &%$%


2&%

(2
. 
 ,
$34%
 


 
,
5
" 
6 " 
,*

7
 


 




 



 

 

 


 
! 
0 &#



-./ 
 
7
 


*

 
8 

 
-
, 
" 



 
%3 %9 &%$1



 

          

 

 

    !

 "

 #  $%  

&& 

 

 & '  ( )   * *+ !

 "

  + 

#

)   ,- !



".

 .+  (.  /

 *+    

  &&    

  '

.+   (.   

   0 

.

  #    

    ".

 .+   (.    &

 # 

     

 

 . 

1    & 2.# 

 .

  

 

 

   

 &

 

.+ &  . & 3

/

  .  & 

 & .

  

 

  4

 

       . & 3

/  .+   (.  

 %    &&

"

 

.

.

 .+   (. 

.

  



  6.

    7   



 %    &&



&& 

 

  

+

 %  & 

 . &      &&

4 



 %  

 

&&        . & 3

 8

0  

 &

 

. # .

 

  6.

  

7  7 1 

  & !

   

    .

 



&& &       

+

 

      

 / 4





9 &

    #   .

  &&      3

 / ".

 

.       6.

        

. # 4 7

 

8 .

  + 

0 &     

  

.



 #      & , & 

 ) &

    .

 +    

   

-    ) &

.

  

. #  6.

&  

   





 

. 



.

  '

.+   (.     .  

. 

. #  6.

".

  

.      6.

    7 & 3

7 

0  

".

  



   

.   #

) &

      &  .

 & :

" 

.

 .+   (. .

  

&& 

 

   .

   

 &

"

 

.

    6.

& 3

0 & *+ & *  

.  

  #

    



) &

    .

 

.   #   .

.  



 # 

 

 &    .

00   .

) &

 

  

$

 .

  



  .

00

  

.   #  

;



*


 


+

 






 
, 

 



 

+ 
 
 

 

.



:

*


+  

 "


"



  &'

%& &%$&



 *








"

 
 





-./

 
 
+ 
 
 
, 






 

 
 
  ) "

+
7
 
, 


 "
  %3 %9 &%$1
!) 
 9#
:









 "

:

 
+ 
 


*


 
, 
 %& $$ &%$'
!) 
 4#



0 ,/ 94$9 &%$1


*
 
+ 
" 








 


:







 
:

"
+ 



 

 
"


, 



 



 

,/

(%9&2 &%&%
;
:




-./ +

 "
+ 

 







 "

- 
+





 

+ + +


 



;
:

 



"
"




5 
 



 
 



 
 


""
 










 "

:

 

*

 
, 
+  :

*

"




"
 


 "

:

 



 


*


 
, 

 
:




 
+ 


"

*
"

*


 




 ;




"
 
+
 


 " 

 
 
+  
*

 
, 
 
 

 
"
 "








*
 

"



"

*
;*

:





 

  






*
   
 






 









 

"
 "*
 ;+



! 

+

*#

<

+

"

 

*


  
 
 


"
 


"


 





"



 
"

  
+

*


 

 
 


 "
-./


 
 
 




, 
 




"

 





"

 "



 
%'

%( &%$&
 



 "









"

 
 
$% %& &%$$
+ *






+  
+
 




 

  





  
%'

%( &%$&




"

"*



  "
+

 
 


 
*


 
:





 

 

 




- 

"

 
 
 
= "
 ;+




"
  
+

* 

"



"

 




+ 
*
"



" 
 






 *

0

 
 

 


" 
 
 
 ;









) 
+

"



 
*

, 


 


 *
 

*
;
)"


"
 





 







"


*


 *
7




,

," 
 
$'1(







+

*

 
"
 " 
 
7
+

*
) 


+ 
*

$33&

"

*
" 

 

+
 "



"



*


 *>

+
"*>
 ) 
 






 

.
*
"  



""
"
+
*
) 
*




  


"
 



 "
"

 

+

 
*

 
, 

 "


 



"

 

 

"


 





+ 


 

  
 

" 
 

7
 
 
"

 

*



*


 
 
+

*

 


*

, 

?

 

    

   !
+

 

 
 
  

"

 
*




 
"
*


*


"
 

*



*
 @

 


"
*







 
 
 ?" #$$%&'( )

( % &'!
* ,
 
+
+  
*

, 
+

+ 



*



, 
 


*




  


 


 
+

  
;
"


  


 
+ 








  






 

 " 


  - 

6



, 

?- '

.

 

& $ /01 2  

    ) "



 


 



23& ,  ,


) 

 
 

" 
 +

*
 



*

 
+

*
"


   
 
.
+ 
 

 

"

 

*

 


+ 
 *

  


  
 
   

 " 

 

 
 



*

  ,
7
 




 "

) 
+

 1   &   

   

  

 .

  9 &   

7   &  #  

 & "

 #  "





  #  & 

.   . 

&

 .



&  

     # & 

 

 & "

 #   

&   6.

 

  



 

.

#  

#     .        &   . &   

.  

 & "

 #  ) .

.  # 





 .

  9 &   

7 & 6.  &  <13    

  

6.

 

    &  & .  .

   

& .



   .          &

.

  



.

# 

 #   .

    

#  . & 

&     $ . 6.

  & -

) 

  &

 

       #  .   

 . 

 &

 .



&  

.  



   + &   .



  . # 6.  +

- 

- # %.    

&   .

  9 &   

7 ;

0

*

"

 

*




  

 
+

*

 

 
* 
= 


"
, 

?3

-   

 3$  . 4  5 &$

/ (#'$36   % 
* 777&  
+ 
 )
, 
 

 
 



 
 "

 

*

 


    &  

 & "

 # "  



&   & 

.

 6.

   . 

.   #   #    =   6.



  &  .

   .  

  &  

 & 

 #    &   &&

    #   

   . .

 

>'1 &  



 ?

 

.

.   &    & 

.

    8 &  





?

 

   



& .

        #    & 



     7 &  

+ &  

&  .

    

 

 &     &  .

  

    

 &  .

  

 *.

  

    & 

.

  

.  

 & 

 # 

  

 &    

  

. & 

 & 

 #  &    



;

7 






= 


"
, 

 





, 


6 

"=  
!

#
+



+
+ 
 
+
* "

*
 
, 

?( 8#% #9(#

#'

% -$& #$, ( 8#% '

% %! % , (:4

;6<&
&&;
(#=#% ><76 4

*


 
, 




?

!?, , (-$&'

 @ ( > 4

'

%>#% @ ( > 57 :& 

 

*


 


   
 


  *
 
"
+



 
+


 *
+ 
;
*
"
"


 
, 




 

  
+ 
*



"

 


.
 
 
  


+ 

*
 



 ;

;

"



 




 
, 

*

, 

:


*
 +


+ 



)





, 


"

*
 



 *
  


" 
 
 *
 

"
  



 +

7
, 

 @ 


 


23&
,  ,



 "  
 "

 

*
   
, 

+


= 


"
, 
 



+






 *

+
 " 

 
)


 
"


"










-

 ;

"




 "
 


  
 
"








 

*


 




 
+ 
:

 "

 


, 



 
 
 "
 +
 

 
+

 
 
 
;+ 
 


;


+


, 

;

:



" 
  /  *

+




 

, 


*
"





 "

"

 ; < .>A 4

 

<
 ; A 
 B
0 <
/ 


 B 0