← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/4545/2015allowed

Rakesh Jhunjhunwala v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2015-09-10Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan16 pages

          





!

"#$#%& '('         ) *$+$   

 

  &

,- '

 

 .

- /



 

!    



#"

* $ % $  % &  $ '( 

$  % & $ '(

    & $ '(     )  "& #$*&     )+& $ '(

 )  *"& $ '(   ,   .

- /0

'

1* &



   ( -.

+ +  (  /0++1   2&  3 "

 ,4 5



85 6 

/1( 9 

' : $ ;

(

<""

'( 9 =  2& 

"



85 6 /$> ? 2 



 ( "

 +& *" /0@+A   2

'



B  6 



$

   "& *" /$> ?72&  

' 





"

  ,(

 

  & 

   ,

 

$  



 '



- 6 

   , ?

 

 

  

 & 

    9

 (   

   

 #( ((

,

+ 

  ( 3 3& 

- 6 7









"&  (





((





 *  #(

 ? , 

((

 

((

,

+ 

 "

 *  %

#( '

(



76. 665 /$> ?

72 "  ((

B 6 6

' $> ?B

(

#( ((

,

+   $ ;



B 6 6   ( 3 3  

- 6 7

 > (

  ((

,

+ 

 

" + &  ((( "  (

  

&  C 7 & '

( /$> ?82

$((

,

+   



.8 6 $> ?5 /(  " ?

&

   "

" ( ?( 



-8 6 7& 

    ( "

 

" (

 ((

,

+ 

 ((



"

  (    (  "

 ((  ? :( 



(

 

(

'&   "



"

' 

@  (& 



( ( ( "

D?

'

 #% %"# *5#"

$ -#6#

!

5'

'' *

%

%!

% *0 183  '

*$7 %!*

/+6 * '

5'

 :

#2

/2 ;

%!

*$0 1 3  4 9 4'

%#

*

5'

<< * =<*

*6 #% +%"#2

%!

% *0 1 3

 9 '

$7 <*

5'

# 7 6#"

2$ 6<2 =0    1*2'3 >9 '

''

* ;

%

%%

2# $ %# 5'

/ *

%!

% *0 1?3 ?

 4(9 ?'

/

'

5'

)#!7;

!7 * % ''

%!

% *0

1>3   ?9 >'

'''7 *6 + #"

2$ - !'

5'

7

%!

% *0 13  8(9 8'

*@ /+6 * !!

* 5'

1

 27#3

%!

% *0 1>3  ?(49 ('

/'/'7+@

5'

)'/'

)*

%!

% *0 1(3  89 '

#% 6

%!+$ *# $ *<*

#% -#6#

!

5'

*6

#%A7  #%

%!

% *0 1 3  449 '

 % *  %B

%!#

5'

$# %

2:

-#6#

!

%!

*$0 1 3

 49 '

' %A "7 *# 5'

7 *

%"7 * #A - !'

1>3   89 4'

'' 7*

5'

 @ /+6 * 7

%!

% *0 ?

13

- +%@ :

%!

*;

%

?>9 '

 <$# !$ - !'

%!

% * 5'

< "# +!#"# A#$ *

%!

*$0 1 ((83   >(9 '

+%@ :

#%  %B

%!

*$ 5'

+* %!*

* $ !

#%7 ((4 +<< 1 3  ((9 ?'

7*

 @ * 2$ +*$ - !'

*$ 5'

 $ #%

#%

.*2!

1+:"% #% % *#5

-#6#

!0   1 (3  >9 >'

7 *

% 7 %!

7 5'

C 6#%$ *#%

"7

%!#

5 '

- !'0 8 13 ? 89 8'

'/' 26#

 5'

 27# !6#%#$ *

#% %

7*

<<

2$30

  (?  8 9 ('

*;

%

%!

*$ 5'

7 @ % -

%!

*$0 (( +<< 1 3  49 '

 @#5 7 < *

%!

*$ 5'

!

% - / <*0 1 43  44

%!

 '

@

 5#%!

*  5#!

$ %# 5'

* $7 *

% *0    %2#%

 '

   3 "

 /$> ?

2&



"

/$> ? 2

' /$> ?72&

"

  E   

(   

(   , ?(  

   (  ('

("

 ((

, ?

+   "

'?

  *& '

(    (   



  

   

" 

$

   " (

(

((

"



( &   "

  ('





'

 

9

(   ?( 

 



  (  '"

 6F 3

  ((

,

+  " 





( 

   

& 

(    

  A   +

#% 6

%!+$ *# $ *<*

#% -#6#

!

5'

*6

#%A7  #%

%!

% *0 1 3  44

+%6

$ *#5

-#6#

!

5'

%+

  1 3 "

>





  

 '"





(    (   " &  (  (

(

"'"

 "  (  ' (    + ( 

    

 

 (& "

(    +&   >("

    (  ( -.

++



&  

   &  ( 

"

(

 $



 "

 /$> ?

2&



"

/$> ? 2



' ( 

$

   "& *"& 

' 



   & 

? :( 

 

" 

$

   "& (

(

((

"

(('

( 

   



 ?   





( (  & "



&  ( 



3 

@  

( 

 (

   



"  (



((

((

,

+ 

B 6 6

' $> ?B

 ( 

(

" + 

((

,

+ 



(



B 6 6

/$> ?82 (

C 7 & "

    (

#(  B 6 6

@

 (

  ( 3 3 (



- 6 7&   

  ((( "  #( ((

,

+ 

?

# '?

( ( & ?

 :( 

 ((

,B

 /$> ?

2& ( "

(

((      (' #( ((

,

+  '"

 6F 3

  ((

,

+ 

'"



 &   +   ((   (

 3  ( (

(( ' &  (  ( ( (  (



3   - & ("

' ' & 

   ((

,

 "

" ((

,

+ 

 ('

''





"  @  -/

&  ?( :( 

 '    *  #( ((

, ?





E( ?( 

    ( ( "

(     " 

 C 7 & ?( 

 

 ' 

  ((

'&     ? :( 

 "



  

 #( ((

,

+   ('

("

"



" ((

, ?+  ?

 :( 







 "

 ((

,B& 

 '  

 ((

,

+   "



@ (  (  

> ((

,

+ 

" ( ?(    ?( 

((



 

 ,B / 2& ( "

"





" (

 ((

,



(  (

 " 8.

?



(



.8 6 7

'& ?( 

 

  ?((

,B

  (

  

  &   3 

&

 (



" &      @ 

 (

    "

( 3 3  *&   

 #(

& 



 ((

? :( 

 

  

C &  "



"  (   +



(   & "

( (  (

'  

""   &

 (&

 ('

("

"



" ((

, ?( 

@ ( &  (



((

   (

 '



((



     "

 6F 3

  ((

, ?(  (

  ( "

#( +   >

 

 "

( 3 3 + "



"





"





$

   "&

"

'  &

 

  (

 

(









  (

   ("

'?

 (

 ' (  (   &

 ' 

(" (

 (

 3 



"

 ((

( (   (

 





"  

"





@  (& 

(  ? :( 



  +

 ( " & "

(( (

(( '   " 

& ( "



 ( "

"

+       

 (  

(&  &

 /$> ?

2& 

"

/$> ? 2 ' /$> ?72 (



3 &      + "

 





(   &  

   

   '& ( 

 (

& 

 

  &

"

"   ( @ 

(    ( ( ( ( 

>  ( 

(

&

  "



"      &

(  (( (

 ( (

 

(& 

1   +  !6 +$+%!*



%!

% * )$'

 6#2 !+

%!

*$0   44

( @ "

 (

  '    #( ((

,

+  ?>(' #(  

( &  C



6. 665& 



 ( +&

"

( " C $> ?- '   " B5 ?

& 

(  (    

"( '

@ ( & 

 "





" 

   ( ((   "

 6F  &  



   ((

,

+   (



 (  



E( 

 #(   %

#( 

"'"



 

'"



 

" 

' 

"

   

(    

'  

" 



 $ "

  #( ((

, ?

+ 

 '  &

  ( 3 3   ' #( (



  

 ( "

 "

(' 



"   '  

C & #( (



   ?



( 3

   " ((

 

 #(&   *  (& 





?

>(' #( 





( "

 

G   (( (& 

  ((   (&  '&

 " &  

 (

""

 

"&  &

& 

"

' & (



3 

'?

' 

  +        1   +

 "

+ ( "

  +

 1   +

@

 5#%!

*  5#!

$ %#,$ ( /2   "  



(   & ( "

  



' '

1   + 

 @

 5#%!

*  5#!

$ %#,$ ( /2&  ( 



(   (& 

 D?

  



             

               

     !"# " $% &''(    )  # *   $+%  &'',"-  -    

 .

&''/    0&''/"

  

 -           -         0   

 "   



      0   ) !    "1 ) !  

0 



 !     0 

  !

! 

                  0        ) !!"  !

0

  $($ .          !  0                   !

2   !

     

0 

   0  "     0                   

 20

1""." !

        0

 ! "  0  0 

       



0 

 0             00    ".        

0 

 0        !         0  0         



  $($      1""  ."    1    

 

 3

4

 0! 5   $($       !   !

0    0   "     20

                  3    4   

0     

 0     

        "6   

  

      7

 $   

0      



    0  "                          !

0" .  ! 0    2                          0   

 

0 

 0     

        -    -  

 

$($"8   1   + %#

* ,$ ( /2&  ( ( (   (& 3

(' (

' '

1   + 

.

7&  ( (

"



 (& 

 D?

 9   !# !"%"1"   

     $:/ $($ .       !  

53 

"$'$$ &$4 &$"-  -    

 

"   :($++,"         %   $++/"            

            "       0

 &'/$++/"  0

  !       0

 

!  "

    "     !     2       

                                     "        - 

 !0   

0   %

 ;

 

 0 

  0" 

"  .

         0    $&          0   0           

      

  0

  0  0  ".

           2          $++<

  0       $++/ -  

 ;     - 

 ";

  2     

";   

  ! 0  

0    - 

0     "=    > ?

 

  !"    31    4  !

.

! 3 4# "!" 3* !" 1 4

7 #2   !"9  0"

  ; ?

"!"70?

    ! ! 

 



;



  (/& 

   

$+@:3  A

B4 -        

 53 

":<$<&  &,4  &," 

>

 0 ! 0!   0       2        2   C  

0       

0

 

0

   

0

   0

2   0;

 ) >   

  (/&       )    !   >   



 :+@ 

"   )   >   

  (/&

! >   

  :+@ 

    

 0-  



 ;

         02

  -       ";

!  

   

 0

   

0   0                          

  0 ! >     

2   !  0 

"  $:   >    !   >  0   ;



  !  0    "8 .  

 

 ; 

         



!  -       0 

 

 0

   

0

 0       

         !   >  0     0  ;

  

2   

 

 !0 

!     

    0) >   

  (/&



" ))) ))) ))) ))) ))) ))) ))) 

          

       

               

0       

 0   0

     

0     

 0     "

3D   1    

  

  #  !"

;    "4     

(   ) 0       

               "E !! !                 "  .2  0    )  

    -     

   0    

                "  F    

     

      "   0 !      

 0          $++/0 !    &''( -    ;

   0   

      :'"'+"$+++ 9 :&

 !) >   

  (/&

 -      "E 0      ;

   

       

         -       

  " -     1 "++:

$

  &'',        . 1         

  3.:4   -   

   "8 @ 

   

 3 "

(  ( "&

  '"

   (  ( -.

++&  " '

C@ (    

   ( '&  

"

 "

     ("

 "

  (

 " (( + 



3 "

(  ( "

<>(

  (  "

 (

@   '

&   "



  (

 /$> ?

(  ( " "

  

(

    ( +

(  (





"

& (

 3  ,   "  + "

( (

(( ( ( (

'& (

      + ( 

'    

'

((

 '

   ( (

 (  ( +3

 /$> ?

2& 

"

/$> ? 2& /$> ?72

?

 

3  '& 

3    '?

'

&     '&  (

'('  1 .

- /3 6B$