Navdeep Singh Brar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Another
! "#$# %&'('
& )*+'
, +, ! " #" $% " #" $ " #" " #"
#&
" $ !" , - '.
/ '() * +
#
## # +&,$-(. # '/) 0 ", 11 &2(/3/4"(4535"(4443" (436."(46.4"(5776"(563./8/(# 9
1 # :"&2(/3/4/8/(
1 # '4) *
;; 1
< " < 0 #
1= 10
1 # , # 8783/8/( 0 # 8(8(/8/(
1
> ?1 &
< 0
(;84/8/8 11 < ## @A ?
<&,$-(. #0 1 11< 110
=
# 1 -
'5) * &
< # #
1
';) B # 1 8783/8/("
(/8/(< 0 1 ## , #"
#$ #1 #" 1 # , 11
# ,
" ;78 , # < * 1
1 # < = /383/8/( , 1 &1 ;
C
!""D" 11<
< - #$%& ' (
$%)
* !" #$#! !%
* !" #$#! #%&' &'()*
+ , - +
./ 0
'
11!" #$#!
'
./ 0 2 3 '
'
& (1*
&'()*
./4 +40
'
11!" #$#!D '7) * # # 0 1 11 # #
, <" 0 /60< <9 8(8(/8/(* < # - '
) (/83/8/8" < 0 &
1<*< 90
1
B C #% 1#5.
6DE '
) , 1
#/8(7 11" # #
0 ! , 1 1 =
< 1
0/8(7 5;8 < , 1
# 10 # # # # , #E '
) , =
F 0 $
0/8/8" <1 1
1
=
E '
) : 10" 1(/7'#) 1 # 1" (.45 '
" 1)" $ # ! 11 #" <1=
# 1 # # # , " # - CG. 5 4. ' 67 ') B10" 0
< " 1 0
1=
< /484/8/8 0 > ?1 &
* * + , - . '/ %01)2)2 # ! ! 3! ! !4 , <" #1 0 1 1
& 01 # ## # -# #
= 0 '3) * & (583/8/( # , " 10 8786/8/( 1 0 <0 1% 1 ", " , #! 1 1 #
1-/" 1 '6) , 10 + 0 " 0
#&
"1 $ !" 1 < <1 < < 10 10 90 0
1
< 0 &
1
# 11 # 6 1
0 10" <1 <
#=
# $ #! 11 # 1 #<# 1 #
11 #
< 1 1=
6 10 # -
#% 1# ' 5 4 . ./9 : 1# 0
&
#%7 '.) B # 1
10 #
#
0/8(7"548< 1 1
0 # # @ 10?
11 # 0-< 9
1 # # 1 110-< '(8)
"
0/8/8"
# < + 0 @ 10? 11 =
# , #,
@ 10? 11 # < # 11 11 @ 10? <1 #110 1 9 , " # 7 1
0 10 '(() &
"
" 1
, # <
# /; /6 0 1
& 1
# 0 0 $
1" /;8;/8(7, 1 1 # 1 # # # " 1=
< #1 '
)" '
) '
) #1 ;/" #0 +
##1'
)"1 # 1 1= ;0
1
# 1
# 0 ##
10 <440 8(8(/8/(
110 < :=- # # 0 1;0 < < 10 ! : <11" = <
#440 8(8(/8/( '(/) * " 1 # 1 + # (( 1
0 0
# /484/8/8 > ?1 &("0 #
" 1 #1 =
F#
# # 10
'(4) " 1 # 1 + # 1
# 11 1
0 10 11
1(/7 1 <
= =* "
# # -$
## #< #1" < * " 1#
# 11
#1 < /484/8/8
;<.(+*=1#$#$8& +>4=0=+ 2>& ?
=>=>2@; >=
10 1= <
1 '(5) , 1
" ! " 1 # 1 '
&2-(/3/4-/8/()
F //83/8/(
'(0123
6$' 6 ' ! ! /7# " $1 >
& + </ < #1 1 1 #0" <
" 1
=# < <# 10=
1 #0
9 "
#" 1 #0 <1 = # # 1 # 0
1 # #
1 # 1 1# # # 0# < 1 #F < < < 1 0 # # # < +
1 #
9 < < , < 1 < #1 9 #11 # 0 < 0&
1 #01# &" #
# " 1 '(;) "1 # 1 '
&2- (4535-/8/() > ?1 &
*5 , 5
'6* %6%.%' (7 6%%%!% 6 !% -)228/ $ 998- +
0 1" 01
## ,< 1 #
# 1 0
1
1<B # 1
< #" <
1 0
1 # * 1*= & 1H1# 0 #" /884 <
9 " 0 <11 + 10 '(7) $% " 1 # 1 '
&2- (4443-/8/() <1
1
0/8(. <11
/8/8#
# " # ## >
#" #<
11<
@ ? " # @ ? "
1 1@ ? #
#
#
#> << ! = F# +
< 111 #
'(3) $ " # '
&2-(46.4- /8/() 1 &
+,:)$$09:)2&; - 5 < !% =% ,*> ? < !%/ # 848//8/8 # # 0
# # <
1=
1
'(6)
" 1 # 1
#
# #
0 &" $ /68//8/8F(583/8/81 10 #
9 <
# 1= '(.) ! > ?1 & /58//8/(
+,-/%&9&2 )2)2-
5 < !%=% !<%/" 1 # + 0
<
1
" < 0#4 <1 < 0
< <+
F # #1 #
1 #0 = # < # 1 #=
/8/8<1 1
1 #1 (5" (." /. /( & , > # > ?1 &
< <1 < <
110
< '/8)
# /;8;/8/(0
11 >
&
+ :%9@)9 )2)&-*5 'A* 5< 5 .% , < !%/ '.) <
&
# 11<
1 # , # < <1 <
1
1 1
8(83/8(6 '/() "1 # 1 + # (487/8(6 0 > ?1 #
, %&)$;@1)2&B- >6 5<!%=% ,<!%/
# (58(/8(6" < * 1 1 # <8(83/8(6*
" <1 11# + 1#
0 /8(; ;7 0
# 1 # 1<++
#
# " < 1 I
/8(6=
" ! + # # # < 10 # #+
1#
/8(6 11
# ##
< 10
# # # # 1 <
0 11 >
& '//) B # 1 1 # > ?1 &
C ( .%*?
55 6 D -&@89/0))2<
< 1 = ##
1 1
# 1#4 '/4)
# 0 1 # 1" #1 1 (886/8/( 1 % 1 " , " , # ! 1 1 #
1-/" 1= " <0 < 0&
'0 )"< # 11
: " # < # " < # # 1
# 1
/6 4/ '0 +
01) 1= 0 /60 - 81
+ ; > ./ (+;>.* #% 1# 0 #% 1# ' 5 4. ./ 9 : 1# 0
5 4. ./ + .
+ ; ./ + A ./ + ;./ - + ;> 9
+ ;> ./ : ;0
@
#%1# 9 A & #%7 '/5) * &
0 , 10
< 1(/7 1"< 0
" # -$
## #< 1< # 10"
10 # '
/)< 1/;8;/8(7" # F1 & 1
<# 0
# " 1 & 1
< J > $
# 1
/; 0 /6 0
# # & 1 , # * " & < #
#1
#
= 1
1= 10 # < 0&
<
, # < 0&
1
< & 1
+ # 1#
/;8;/8(7 '
/)
# 1
/;/60* 1#
#1 1 1
$1 >
&
> E9#')" # # # #
#<
# 1 # 1# 0 #110 < 0 $1 >
&<+
< # <
< 0 < 0 &
$1
1 1 #0 # 0"
#" # # 1
<9 11< 0 1'# 110 1(/7 1) '/;) * &
1 1
1 0 1 1=
#
1
0 /60 10#
#/8(7" # #
0 ! ##
10 # # # <# '/7) , # < 0 0 # 0 0 1 11 F# , ## 0/8(7* &
#
" # 1F1 1
0 '/3) : " # ##
0 /8/8 ' 11 0 )" # < + 0 ! 11 # , # * " # 0" 1
#
+ # 11 < 1
& 1 0 * " !"#$%&'
$'
( )('%*+,!&
&
#
+
*5, 5
'6* %6%E$#') '/6) * &
< # 1 # 1< < 110
1
< # @ 10?< 11 # 0 #1 1 # "
=
1 0
# 0 * 1 1 1
# 11 # " 11 # 10* 1 1
< #1 11 # 1 /8/( 11
# $
# 1 0
'/.) * &
$ #
1= #
#
'
)"'
)'
) # 0
1 1
#1 #1
# #1 # 0 $!"
1=
1
, 5E;#') 1 0 " # # 848//8/8
< 1
0 /8(7" &
#
# 0
1=
1
,
# & 0 1 # 1
#
#" < 0/8(7 110
< 110
1# #><"
- # .!.
,/ ! %0( 1,. !.!2/ . 1*/3 3 $
& -%% %"#
$4 -!3 5 - # 63 &.!
#" 1 +#< 0 0"
"# #1 1= , =# < < <1= # 11 # # # # &" " " #1 < =
#$ #! 11 # 1 # <# 1 1 #<
#
1
, 1 < #0 $ #! 11 #< &
1 #0 &
" #0 > 1 *
# #" &
# # F # 0=
1= '48) * #
#1 =
1
0 +
1&,$ , #" #
110
0/8(./8/8'< <11 10<
= 1
) , <"
# # # #" 1# # 10 10 # &,$ *
#
#1
= 1
'4() , " &1
#
0 1 # 1 # 11
1 (/7 1<
= =* 0 1
# 11
1 #1 <
# 1
0# * 0
0 # #
= #
0/8(3"/8(6"/8(./8/8< 0< # ## '4/) :
" &
< ##
10 '44) # '(' - #.#$78%#7 .#
9:8