High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/4640/2014dismissed

Aruna Rani v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-02-07Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan7 pages

!"#$#%&'#(#')#!% * +&##,-(-%.* * ' %+ +%- #&-&-%#'

/#'( ( 0&+&# %1+2+%!&3#'( #(4%!#%&(

'#(#%&. '0+&2-' +&3'#5!),+&#'&3#4#&-&-%#' '%6 '+-%55 %1+2 ' 0 +%!3+7+5!),+&#' '#(4%!#%&(% & /-!#'!#'!+&#!9*

54+((#!2:&3#5+( :++% +44;-,+&-%4'##''#! %!#'0#,&-%9 $)#!2:&3#4'(#, &-% 7+(+;;7#!+%!&3#4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(3#'#-%%+$#;: &&+$= $+'5>+;-& = $+'2&3(%(0 23+(33+%!#'+%! %-(3= $+'(%+;!#) +1 7#'#( $$%#!&+,#&'-+;+(+!!-&-%+;+,, (#! %!#'0#,&-%(?5@

9 '#)-(-%4#&-&-%3+)-%"2##%-;#!5&3#(+$#3+(2##%+,,#4&#! -%&3#;-"3&'!#'!+&#! ?

954+((#!2:&3#;#+'%#!!!-&-%+;

0#((-%( !"#5(3-+'4 '+%!+,,'!-%";:&3#'!#'!+&#!9*

4+((#!2:&3#'-+; '&53+(2##%(#&+(-!# 3#-%(&+%&4#&-&-%3+(2##%-;#! %!#'0#,&-%? ' (##6-%"A +(3-%"&3#'!#'!+&#! ?

9 @4+((#!2:

&3#;#+'%#!!!-&-%+;0#((-%( !"#5(3-+'4 ' '+:#'-('&3#'!#'

!+&#!9*

4+((#!2:&3#'-+; '&&2# 43#;!

+%!,%(#A #%&-+;;:4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(% &3#'#-%&+,#&'-+;+(

+!!-&-%+;+,, (#! '-#+,&(&3+&7 ;!'#A -'#%&-,#+'#&3+&+,$4;+-%&7+( ;!"#!2:' %+ +%-54#&-&-%#'3#'#-%7-!7(36= $+'+((#'&-%" &3+&3#'3 (2+%!3+!!-#!-%&3#:#+' <<@3#'#+&#'3#'+&3#'-%;+73+!

##,&#!++$-;:4+'&-&-%-%73-,30 23+(33+%!#'5#;!#'2'&3#'3#' 3 (2+%!7+("-)#%&3##%&-'#'#(-!#%&-+;3 (#5&3#'2'&3#'-%;+7%+$#;: +;!#) +17+("-)#% (@5C-%,+(3+%!+(347+("-)#%&#$+%& = $+'-#$-%'(%&3#,$4;+-%+%&D-;;'#,"%-E-%"( ,3+$-;: 4+'&-&-%7+(+;((&+&#!&3+)#2##%#B#, &#!$4;+-%+%&+((#'&#!&3+& #+';-#'&3#(343+!2##%"-)#% &%'#%&2 &&3#'#+&#'(3#7+(3#'(#; ' %%-%" + (#7-%" +%! (&-&,3-%" &'+-%-%" ,#%&'# -% &3# (34 '#,-(# +;;#"+&-%(+'#&3+&% *

<+&+2 &9 73#%(3#7+(7'6-%"-% &3#(34+&&3+&&-$#0 23+(33+%!#'+;%"7-&33-(&7(%(%+$#;:

&&+$= $+'+%!>+;-&= $+'+(+;( %-(3= $+'(%+;!#) +1 +;%"7-&3,#'&+-% %-!#%&--#!4#'(%(3+!$+!#+',-2;##%&':-%&3# (34+%!&'-#!&&+6#4((#((-%&3#(342:4 (3-%"&3#,$4;+-%+%& +%!&3'7-%",#'&+-%+'&-,;#( &(-!# 4%+43%#,+;;3+)-%"2##%$+!# &&3#4;-,#&3#+,, (#!+'#(&+&#!&3+)#"%#+7+: #(4#,&+2;#(&3# ;,+;-&:-%&#')#%#!+%!&'-#!&##,&+,$4'$-(#7#)#'5+;!#) +15 2'&3#'-%;+7&3#,$4;+-%+%&)-(-&#!&3#3 (#&3#,$4;+-%+%&+%! &3'#+&#%#!3#'+%!&3#'#2:%#"+&#!&3##'&(+%:(#&&;#$#%&&2# +''-)#!+&"+-%(&( ,32+,6!'4 !+&#!

< %!#'

0#,&-%(@ 5?5@

5@5 ?5 < 7+('#"-(&#'#! &#',$4;#&-%-%)#(&-"+&-%&3#,3+;;+%7+(-;#!+%!-% 73-,30 23+(33+%!#'+%!+;!#) +17#'#%$-%+&#!+(+,, (#!+%!&3# 4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(3#'#-%7#'# %!&2#-%%,#%&(%&-,#!3#'#-%

9 +2)#5&3#+44;-,+&-%-;#!2:&3#4'(#, &-% %!#'0#,&-%9 & ( $$%&3#4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(3#'#-%+(+!!-&-%+;+,, (#!7+(+;;7#! 2:&3#'-+; '&2 &-%+'#)-(-%4#&-&-%4'##''#!( ,3'!#'3+(2##% (#&+(-!#)-!#-$4 "%#!'!#'!+&#! ?

954+((#!2:&3#;#+'%#!

!!-&-%+;0#((-%( !"#5(3-+'4 ' @ >#+'%#!, %(#;+44#+'-%"'&3#4#&-&-%#'7 ;!)#3#$#%&;: +'" #&3+&&3# #)-(-%+; '&3+(#''#!-%+;;7-%"&3#'#)-(-%4#&-&-% +%!&3#'#2:!-($-((-%"&3#+44;-,+&-% %!#'0#,&-%9 &-( ,%&#%!#! &3+& &3# %+$#( &3# 4'-)+&# '#(4%!#%&( 3#'#-% 3+! 2##% (4#,--,+;;:$#%&-%#!-%&3#,$4;+-%&73-,3;#!&&3#'#"-(&'+&-%&3#

+%!( ,3)#'(-%7+('#-&#'+&#!2:&3#,$4;+-%+%&-%3#'(&+&#$#%& 2#'#&3#'-+; '&&-(( 2$-&&#!&3+&&3#4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(3#'#-%+'# (%(0 23+(33+%!#'+%!+;!#) +1573-%& '%7#'#&3#2'&3#'(-% ;+7&3#!#,#+(#!3 (2+%!&3#,$4;+-%+%&+%!+(( ,35&3#'#7+(+ ,$$%-%&#%&-%+%!$&-)#&&+6#',-2;#4((#((-%&3#(34 %,# 4+'&-,-4+&-%-%&3#,, ''#%,#3+!2##%(37%5&3#)-,&-$-(#%&-&;#!-%;+7 &3+)#&3#+((+-;+%&(C4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(3#'#-%4'(#, &#!+%!4 %-(3#!-% +,,'!+%,#7-&3;+7

#',%&'+5, %(#;+44#+'-%"'&3#4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(7 ;! ,%&#%!&3+&&3#-$4 "%#!'!#'3+(2##%4+((#!-%+,,'!+%,#7-&3&3# 7#;; (#&&;#! 4'-%,-4;#( ")#'%-%" #B#',-(# 47#' %!#' 0#,&-% 9 < ' +%!+(( ,357 ;!%&,+;;'+%:-%&#'#'#%,# %(#; ' &3# 4+'&-#( 3+)# 2##% 3#+'! +%! 4;#+!-%"( % '#,'!3+)#2##%4#' (#! 0#,&-%9 '#+!(+( %!#'.

! "#" $%& '

$'(

) * )

) )

+ ,

)

, ++

$#'(

) +

++ ) + +

)

$'-

)

++)+

* )

)

, ++

$ '(

$') $'

)

$'/

, $') +

0 1

++ 2 3##B&#%&47#'7-&3&3#, '&&( $$%4#'(%(&3#' &3+%&3#+,, (#! %!#'0#,&-%9 &(&+%!&'-+;-%+4#%!-%",+(# ,+$# 4',%(-!#'+&-%2#'#&3#%F2;#0 4'#$# '&-%

"#+%!-&7+(3#;!+(;;7(. 3

+ +

) )

)

+ ,

! "#" $%& '

) ,

)

7 )

2 %+'#,#%&1 !"$#%&'#%!#'#!2:&3#%F2;#4#B '&-% $%

& ' #

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

&2#-%%,#%&5-&-(%;:&3# ,$4;+-%+%&F( (&+&#$#%& '#,'!#! 2#'# &3# '-+; '& 73#'#-% (3# '#-&#'+&#!3#'-%-&-+;)#'(-%+%!&3+&+4+'&%'#(3#)-!#%,#3+(2##% 2' "3& 2#'# &3# '-+; '& 3# '-+; '& 73-;# +;;7-%" &3# +44;-,+&-% %!#' 0#,&-% 9 < ' 3+! '%-(3#!

'#+(%-%". -

+ +

+ + +

, 7

+ 0+ )9 :+ :+

+ ,

! "#" $%& '

+ - 3

+ :+ ) 9

:+ :+ + +

+ +

7 ; 0

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

#'#&3#'-+; '&%'#(3 #)-!#%,#3+(,$#'&3&(37&3#,$4;-,-&:&3#4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&( -%(+'+(&3#+;;#"#!#%,#-(,%,#'%#!3#,$4;+-%+%&3+($#'#;: '#-&#'+&#!3#')#'(-%+&&3#(&+"#!#4(-&-%2#'#&3#'-+; '& %,#!#!;:5&72'&3#'(-%;+7&3#,$4;+-%+%&-#2'&3#'(3#' !#,#+(#!3 (2+%!3+)#+;'#+!:2##%%$-%+&#!+(+,, (#!+%!+'#+,-%" &'-+;3#4'#(#%&4',##!-%"(7 ;!

* % &3# &&+;-&: &3# ,-', $(&+%,#5 &3-( '& -( &3# ,%(-!#'#!)-#7&3#&3# #)-(-%+; '&73-;#4+((-%"&3#-$4 "%#!'!#' !+&#! ?

9 @+%!&3#'#2:!-($-((-%"&3#+44;-,+&-% %!#'0#,&-%9 &( $$%&3#4'-)+&#'#(4%!#%&(3#'#-%+( +!!-&-%+; +,, (#!5 3+( '-"3&;: +44;-#! &3#&#(& ;+-! !7% -% $%

*,+(# ( 4'+ -%-'$-&:-%&3#-$4 "%#!'!#'-( %! ,,'!-%";:5&3#4'#(#%&4#&-&-%-(!-($-((#! ; ,6:

D3#&3#'(4#+6-%"C'#+(%#!.

#( D3#&3#' #4'&+2;#.