Baba Farid Vidyak Society v. State Of Punjab And Others














!
 "#
$
"

%&'

&#(& &












&
& ) !&#

 






  



 !"#$#%&'%    

"

$"(  '() #*" 

+,#  +-.

/012+ 34'5623-'74++225'6/7.4+6 ""

78*9":;-#<# "

!*'8**::;-#<"*,"

 '*"(;--7;()

===== 3-'74++225'6/7.4+63

":

%*>>)(#8>;* (*9", "8 / 

;

;

;
? ;
?

;
?

;
@
;
@ ;


@#
@@


 8#,#9**:"# (:  "  *  ,";    *  "<"%  <:<#    *  "# ,#:#*>,(8#"#",# %*,,:: (*"%"*>("

!"*&<;*" 8&"> / 




;:#












1"#  (:  ,,"8    *:    *  ," ( >#**,"#(:*" :%#*#











 ,("*##",","9**"":<*," #*:##9"A(#<#-A("@ %<"(#" (# %*'7<">;*#(:*" : "A>,#">,%>>,#(%;#* *< *#9**,",-A(";(#" 9***,"%9:#A>,">>,#(%

.9<";"#"9,# %*:"#::";*#;<# -A(" ;9*" %*::";* (# ) "# %*-(7":;() ; "<#**"9# >,#(%B"8"##"#"<"%*>">* ,"

.( >#**"#"#",# %*::"; *#;##<#:9**"#(9**"* ,"9:#A>,"">*#; (>":% "<#*"<"%9 #">*," *8"(#**,"*#  :*9*99:# (*A>,

@

.("*"( >#*9**,"%:# ,,: "*>>";!"#&; 8*,,::(*"%; *:"#,,::(*"%;<#"#"##
@


 -A(" ;#>#*,,:9*(88%"9*<"; % ,8"%,#,&8"#"

.:( >#*<#











 -A("?;*,"*#:#*,,:"8<":8"(#; :(#8*8"(#*99:#A>,">>, #(%<9 8*" :#(:%">* (# %*7<">() .9<";*,,:: (*"%##<""*#8"(##,#"#"9** ;*;,&8#"%,"#" 5*""; ** >,(8#"#"": : #

1"#(:"*,"( >#**," *#":":,("*#",","#A>,98"# *,"%;#*"8"#;"#" -A("
* *#:89**,",

**"*#;:"#'(:( >#** "<"*"#(:,*9**,,:: (*"%; <#  -A(" ; ###  * ,,:; *  > 9   &# %"

6*<*"#:"#(:"*," ?

When the petitioner filed an appeal before the appellate authority vide Annexure P-9, various grounds were raised, including the ground that the petitioner was entitled to exemption from stamp duty, and this aspect was specifically mentioned. However, when the appeal was decided by the appellate authority vide Annexure P-11, the same was not even discussed and the order passed by the appellate authority is a totally











* cryptic and non-speaking order.



-  ,"(:  *"  (88  *  *  "#"  ,#  %  * ::";*#;(# "";*::"*#*:#* *"9#%>,#(%;#"#8:%;*,,:9 #># -,"(:*"#",# %*,,::(*"%9(:# *9**8"(#&*,,::# %*," 9"(*#"#(#::#*"";
;*"#",# % *,,::(*"% :(:%,&8#"%,"#" 

6:#:9*""*(:"#" 5* ,,::(*"%;9*:A"8,9"C()(#:,%; 9(> ##*,,: %888"# % #:89**8"(#& %*,"*,,: (*> * # %*,,::(*"%;



69*:"#(:"*,"** ,"%98"#A>,">,%8>,#(%9* *#  ,("*#  ,","  ":"  #  A>,  9  8"#  %  * 7<">:;*9<";*"#(9#(# %* ,,::(*"%

6  <9    *  "#    #  "(>;  ::  * ,",":%::9# 5*"#"##
@


,# %* ,,::(*"%*" %#; 8,&8"#" 5* >"">## &*,,::(*"%#"###











+ *,,:"* %#"8::*8"(#& %*," *,,:

5*"*"#"*:: ,#9*"*,,:># #*::  (:(# %*":""#",# %*,,:: (*"%9::*,""#",# %*(";*("* >#% "<*>"*#*#* "#",# %*,,::(*"%:%*8"(#**> ("#"#"

@

/#:%;,&8"#"*:: ,#"# 9*:9#"8<8#C(,,"(%*"8*," "*(:9*,"#*">*">#%

1 "%:8"#*,"":::8::% ,"> :,:<: :*>"#9*:9;##* 8"(#,,::"#%&

6("*"#"#*;#("8*,#%* ,",;">"#"9,#



;9** ,"::#;"<"%*:: #">*,"::* ,,::(*"%##*,,:

 
%&,!"##
,

!
"# 

















































%")!

- *- .

 **",&8B"#DB/ **""," : DB/