Sagar v. State Of Haryana






    
 

 





 !!





""##

$%    "

   


 

   
  
  & 

 '%( !# )!*+, 

 & "

& - +
+ , ) ', .

/

 



!

"" ! !

* !

!

 2

, %" )!
3)
4

, !



4 

,

 !

)! 6%*, #, 2+ +%*+, "

*  2

  "%!+ 5# % )

8&
,  

!

!

* !

!

,

+%*+

"

  !* 



,



!

6%*  , !(", %",

!

%5

!   

 /  !*% !("!( "! "

"!

!

%!* ! !*

!

#, ,

( )  
&
, 

5 !(" %5

!     !("!( %"

!

!

5 (

**!

5  2 !

!

5!

5 (

**!

5  2    ,

+%, ! #

!

+ * !

!

"" 5

%



 

 

" % !

, 

#"+!

!(

 ! &#! 

!,
!!# 9!, #, * 

"

7%(  5!

,



(!!

/*% ."!

#, #,

%#

%

!!* !:%!

!*+ 4;% #   !"

!(

!, 8" +

+ 7%(

&< 

#* )%58" &

 (, !

)%58" !"

&< , !

)%5 8" 7!

)!*+, =>("

 .


5# ?+%" )!*+

)" !

&#!  !  + 7%( +
/*% ."!

#, #, '(

+! # !* *!

3 . @ A ! =>("

 !

)%58" + (5! )!*+ 1+

+/ % )%58"  :"+#

&<



=>("

 !

)%58"  7%(  <!

 !(

B=>& C !* 3



, * 

"

5!* 5%*+

+"!

#, 5

! 3

5/ ", ("#

"

7%(

&<

  )%+ 7%( %, 2+

B=>&  , 2+!

##*

%

'(

8% !

1 !!* 8 , #D



 /

5%



+%,

#* (

&<    ("+

"

 5!

, 2

! ?

  :"%!

!## * ?

9

5# - (  / # - &#

!* *!

3 .

3E

(  / # 5!* ! "

D

 /!* 5!  

?

 :"%!

!,

5%



+%, 2+

+/

##

!

 

5%

-!#( 

 !* !## * ?

9

!## * '

+!,

! !## * '

+!,  "

2 (  / # 2+ (%#

+!



##

%,

+/ -

+! (  / # 

(  / #

("#

!

 ""!* (  / #

("#

!, 



+ 5/

- %

-/

(  / #

("#

!D

("#

! !! 

+ 5/

F)F, 2+

##

%, * 

"!" 5#2

2 

(" *!D

"

7%( ##



+

("#!  F)F

-

B-!C

BCD

2+ ("#

( 7%(

 %!*

, !:%/ %

!

("#

#!

!* !*+

D

( !

("#

!

5/, 2+

"

+! !*+

#*

+! " ! 2 " #

"

2  !## * '

+!,

+! (  / #D

+

, ((5

(!#/

("#

!

"

+!

'(

."!

#, #, 2+



(   "

7%(

&'8
+ !* +

%

!

!

!, "

7%(

(!

/*% ."!

#, #, 2+ % %(5

!:%!
 

 E

<!

 !(



&#! 

+%*+ =>("

 .


5# ?+%" )!*+ *!

((!!   "%!+ 5# % )



) !



8&
)



8!

&
,

  5/ *

-"

( / '(

."!

#, #, " ( ( > (!

! )!

"#  %  !"

+

, !

"# B=>& C

"#  %  ""

 &+ * "+ B=>&

B=>& C

"#  %  2 #! -

+#"

(5!# "+ "% / )%"! 

&#! ,

!( 1

+

" ?#

#/!*

 #!

2

 #

""



 2


  % )




!(! & %,

A )%""#(

/

("#

 
"" / "!

B #-+



&#! 

+%!*

"" /

&#! 

!  

, " ( ( > (!

5/

%

'(

."!

#, #,

?     

" ( ( > (!

!,  #

# +

+, 2+! + 2 2 ", ""





 

"#!  ! !G% (( B=>& C 5/  

((5

(!#/

 A 

,  &

#!

& ((%, 

#!

- "

$!-

#!

?

55% 2

    

, "

! #%

2    % &

#!

& ((% 

,

5 

%

", F)F

+!#! #!

2

$!- +

#!

?

5%,

+

"! /

#

+%#!*

5% %"

(

!  F)F

+!#! #!

2

+/ 2

!## * ?

9 2+ F)F !!*

(  / # %" 2+! + $!- +

#!

?

"!##! !

"

!!* (  / # - .

)+! !* *!

3 . &  A

& 

5  2 "!##! !

(D

! !## * ?

9 (  / # - &#

!* *!

3 .

3E (!*, !* ( 7%(

"

7%(  )%+

"!##! !

-

+! (  / # 

+!

("#

! (  / #D

$!- +

#!

?

- %

-/

(  / # "

"!"

 +!

(" *! "

2+ ##

 D

F)F * 

5#2

2 


! (

- "D



#!

-

* 

B 5#2

!*+

!* "

 )%+

("# 

2+

""+!*

5/ !

!*

"!##! ! ",

& 

%

! !:%/D

F)F

## +!(

& 

"

-!*

#"+!

##D



#!

-

+!(

$!- +

#!

?

F)F

##

+(, 5# -

 * "

!#!

!:%!

+!(,

%#

2+! +, "

!D

%# ! !/

"#  %  ( !!*

%

#(

! ! #%

  8 "%%   ! #%

B=>&EC,

$!- +

#!

?

*

  5%+

"!", - B=>&

2+! + ""



 #

, 2+! + #  (* B6)C ("# !("! +

""

 &  # "!"

("# !("! +

- "! "#!  ! !G% (( B=>& C )!

"# B=>&C "#  / ""



8 "%%   ! #%

B=>& C,

 *

 

B 5%+, - B=>&

2+! + ""



 #

2+! + #  (* B6)C ("# !("! +

""

 &  # B

("# !("! + 2

- "! "#!  ! !G% (( B=>& C )!

"# B=>&AC "#  / ""



8 "%%   ! #%

B=>&C,

"

*

  5# - (  / # - .

)+! !* *!

3 . &  A, 2+! +

- "!

"#!  ! !G% (( B=>& EC

8 "%%   ! #%

B=>& C, F)F, +!#! #!

*

  (  / # - 71 H7=

+%

*!


%(5 "#

+%

%

(  / #, *

 , - B=>&C 2+! + ""



 #

2+! + #

+ # (* B6)C ("# !("! +

""

 &  #

("# !("! +

- "! "#!  ! !G% (( B=>& C )!

"# B=>&E "#  / ""



6!

(

(( B=>&

"#  %  ""

 # !

"# B=>&

*

""





 

, "+ * "+ 2 ##   "

##

!#  , #

! F)F, +!#! #!

2,



$!- +

#!

?

5%, 2 % !## * ?

9  





 )! 

   > #%!#/

!

5#

%

)!,

+% ! 



 &! !"

*!

, 6%!# 6% !  ? , #,

 -!*

"!!

!

%#




+!#C
% 





E " % > (!

/



, %5;% #/,

"%5#!

" % # " % !   

#%

" %

,



!

6%* 2 " !* % )

&
, 2+!,

"#  !  ,

, !(

# !("#!

! .2, +

#/    !  

   





 9  %#

!



%5(!

,

+%*+

/ 

 % , 2+ " !#/ ""

 5>

&<

, &<

 !5

"

! !(!

/ # #!!*

"!"

"


.2, %5(!

! 

! #%

"

=>& 5!

;%

+ ""

  / ((

 
;% #/,

*%

2+

+ ! ! + (/   %# ! 

((

%" , %#

#/

" %

**,

,

!  #

!

;%!

5!* ;%

+!( 

   

A 

%#

*%

!("%* !

!

!,

, ;%

+   

%" ,

!(" %"

!



!

6%*  , ! (!

2 +/,

 

%

/

/ * (! "" !

 "" !

/ !  *( 

* 1+, 

!("%* !

!

!,

,

!(

% 
      

     
     

   



 
    

 ?



%" ,

+! " !#/ "!

!,

("!

+! " ! > (!

!! +!,

 !5

"

! !(!

/ # !#!

!*

 5#2

 ! !:%/ %# !(

#/ #

(!





! !

!* "!

!

5 ,

5

+(, 2

! /

"

+, 5! 2+ 5 ! !!

% %#

#/, 2+

+ !  !

!% > (!

%" 5

/ 

%" ,

+% %** !*,

"

%-2

5

+(  2+

/

!(

!

2

+ ,

+%

/ 

%"  1+,

+(

!!

5# !  5 ( "

-,

+5/

   !*,

 !# 5!#!

/

"

!( !

 ,

+5/

 

 

"

#!!*

5#2

 
 

       

     !

  
  


%!*

% ! !*

! 5!*

I8,

! !*

!* !   , "%

"#!  (  %!*

%

5!* "%

"#!  ( ,

!*

% ! #%

2+! + =>&

!

!* 

=>&

5

!( >

+!



 

   

 

 

    

 !

  "# !

$ !%  %
 &%!% 

'# "( % )% * +  "

,% -.&.

&%"% '% %



 # "/  

 

%

0# / $

#% / 

  # %/ #



% % %) # 

*  %  % % 

% ) */ *  %"

%#

%".

 % #

% %" %"

%)# */ *  %"

  %"



!%$ )% ! 

*.

1# % %$ !

!#"! "# 

  0#%

%"

% 

%+ $!

 % "

)% !.

%+ $!

  )% ! %"

* 

'% %



*/

 " -%% % -%**#( %*% % '%+%( &%" % &#/ %"

3 +% % 1%))# %"



* %) # 

# %) # ! $ !

%)# 

*/ *  %"

  %"



% %$ 

%+ $!

 * %".

#** "

*

.

.

)/ ! $ !

%



* %"

  $%   -%% %"

  )  %*%( &%" 

%%) (
%
%*%(  "

'#%%  %"

'% %

%"

3 +% % 1%))# 

%+( % 1% * + (  "

-%% !% '% %

%"

*

 $ / %  "%/

  $%   %

 %$ 

%#!

 

%" '#*% 

%%$  & !(
% 1% * + (  "

,%    '% %

 ! $ !

%)# 

*/ *  %"

  %"

% "

%"

 

1%)% 5%"%%



*  / .

% " $ !

*/ *   / '26'7

  # #*) %"

3 +% % 1%))# %   !

 % %.

&%" % " $ !

*  / .

8 4- 4 9 "% &  %"

-%% %"

  )  %*%    !

) "

 * %"

 !

 %" 1%)% 5%"%%

 *   "

$

%! ,% %"

%" 

%%$ (
% 1% * + (  "

$

%! ,% % * !

 *   "

1%)% 5%"%%

 " !

  *  / .

8:

;44<

*%+ - % % %"

 % %

  *  / *% '#*% 

%*%

%"

%" '#*% 

&# '#*%  % !.

=  "





# *  /

   *  /

%" %"

3 +% % 1%))# 

#  +/

 *  /

%" %"

"

   %$ !

  %"



  "

%"

%" 

%%$ .

8

  %"

 *  *  / .

2

"

+



  "

 *%>)%+

%" %"

 %*% % '%+%

"

"%"%

%$ !

  %"



!

 ! %"

%" '#*% 

&# '#*%(  "

$

%! ,% .

= -%% % -%**#  "



%

 /   !

 )%+  "

%"( / % %%/.

%"

%

"

-%% %"

&%" 

%%$ 

% "

)/ ! $ !

    %

%"

%*% % '%+% ) 

-%% % 

  *.

3 +% % 1%))#

% "

%"

*   *.

=



+ !

 %%!

% "

%" 

%%$ 

% "

%"

%#"

?#  

 *( "# 

    "% %"

%+ %.

%$ + % "

 *  / %"

+ #"



#

% "

 #

&/%*

*%%

#

*/ *    # % $

%! 1%  %?%.

2 +  #"%  %

*  / .

;

  @ * % +

"! %) #  %*.

+ !

 % !  $"

 %* %"

% " /  % "

%  %"

*/ %  % %"

%#"

?#  

%".

 %+ %"

%+ %(

"

.

2 " 

# %*

 

  

%   #     "

 

%"

   #    $  !%#.

&"> 8 "

#"&%!% 

'# " = A &"> 7!

 & %?

%! -

 -  &%!%#%( '% %

=  &"> 7!

 & &%0%

;

. >'% %

-

 &% &%"% '% %

&"> 7!

 &% # 

 -

 &% &%"% '% %

"%"

<



4B

 !*

5 >

!*

% ! #%

 #

+! 

#/  *%!#

! #

%

%!*  / (  / #

=>& ,

! !*

!* !   ,

"# +!!*,

,   #!*

+(, *!

! !

5!* > #%!#/ -2

+!( )!  "%%  

+,

+%*+

 / (( =>& ,

 / (  / #

-! )!*!!

#/, ! 




5

5#

!

5#/ / !*

%

 % =>& ,  5

5#

"

""!

!

# , ! 



5

5#

5!*

*!5# ! 

%** !

 !

!

! !  1+, 5

((

 #%

+#!*

(

! /

 / 9  %#

!



*% 5

%

 /,

"%%  

 / ((

! ! *%,

!5% *%!#

"

+%

 %# 

%" , (% +

,

+/

 !5

"

! !(!

/ # #!!*

5#2

%

+,

+%

"!", /

+%*+

 / ((,

 

1+,

+%*+

!

*%,

5  ! + (/  ((

%" ,

 %#

 !!

!,

 %# 

 % ,

+%

+5/ -

" %

** .2,



!* +!

,

5 %5(!!

%" ,

! %(!

2 +/,

, ! : 

 



       #!!*

5

*%(

5 (  ,

"(!,

!



!#

5#/ / !*

%

! #%

 "

! !

# , !((

 / !

;%!

! #%

=>& 2+5/

 *%!#

((!

!*

(% " , 2+ ;% 

+,

+%*+  / (( =>& (  / #

 ,

!

 

! !*

!* !    1+, 2+

 / ! !(!

/ (  / #

5

 #%

+! "# ,

+% -2 #/

8


;%#,

 / ! !(!

/ (  / #

 #%

!5# "#

-2 #/

+% %#

*%(

/,

(  / #

"# ,

#

!

 /, 

*% 5

%

!  ! 2

(% +

,

+/ "# ,

#

!

 /,

+%*+

*( 5!* "#/

! !*

!* !    E I% +(, !



#/ !    ! > (!

!, % , %"

*! 

! #%

+%  #!*

 / -!,

*!  /,

+%

!

 

! !*

!* !   ,

4,

"#

!

 /  2+

/

!(

!

2

+ ,

*! 

((

%" 
;% #/,

 #%! 5 ( "

-,

%   !*

%

 %

((

%" , 2

+,

+% #%

!#/ +!(, 5! !##!"

! ,

 / -!,

!

 

 #%

!5# "# ,

-2 #/

%,

% ##/

%

!

!%  /

+,

!

 

! !*

!* !     -!*

5 ! ,

+%

!*!*

(

! / !*

((

%" ,

+5/

%

 #%,

! ((  2+ +%*+  , "%%  

! #%

!

#!!*

5#2

" =

 %# 

!( 

- " -!*

+! " !

 !!

!,

5#2,

#!,

,  #!

+%*+ %

+

"!" .2,

! " -!*  


%2+#(

!("

5 %

 !  5 ( ("!

%(,

+ !  !

!% > (!

, %"

 %#  2+5/

/ ! 

5 ( (5!#!G,

 !!

!

 %# ,

5(! +

  +

+!, -!* ! !("( (5##!+( , ! !,

+! "!%#/  

2!

!* ,

+5/

   

 %# ,

+% -!*

% +%#

%

!( 

+5/

"!(  !,  ;% #!

/

5 (

!*,

+%

/  !

 %!*, 

%

"!",

"-

 %# , + 

!( !

,

+%

%,

%

 !,

-!,

!

 

A 

% ;%#

+ , "(!   !

!*

5 ((,

 %# 

 % , 2+

 !5

"

! !(!

/ # #!!*

5#2 "!"



5  !



 !!

!

%" ,

 %# ,

,

((

%" , 

"" ,

5 ( *

"!(  ! (!

- # !* !("!

/ 

 % , ! !,

%

2 " 2+! +

"

+% 2!#!*,

!( !

 ,

!  !

5 (   !#,

,

+5/    !

!*

*%(

%" ,

5 (

 5

%

 %#

!

 

"

  

# 

"/ %"

5/ "

%

 &<

#*

?    &<

" 0#% +!,

+!* =>&

#



"/

%"

5/ 


 , "

%

", 2!*

+(+ *!

+ -

+("%( + >

%#

!:%/

!

*

#%* " !#/

( ( !:%! ##

!:%! 2  # 

( (

2

 # 

%! !

%

! / %

% #

( ( !:%!

 !  &<

5/

>

+!

 .

#

 C @  *

!

   *#  

%%



 * %

!

 +#

$

$ !



%"

 .

.

& "

#"

 C

@

.

*



 /  " #* !

.

  * $ !

  

! %  "#"

%"

!

 %)"

* %

%$ / %"

% !

#



 #%

%$ /.

:.

& "

#"

 C

@

* 



 % %$ # % !

% 

 "



 %# %.

  * $ !

  

#"

% !



 #%

%$ /.

.

)%

 C :

@

* 

  !  " ?

.



 !

% #" / !

*  *% %   * %

!

.B

! !(!

/ 2 "   +2

&< %!*

% -!*

 !!

, 5



!

6%*   8

 !!

"-

J!:%! ( !

" ( ( "

+

5( %

-!,

 %K . % "-

 #

* #  (* B
.719C,

,



=> 2+! + !

* !* 2+! + !

?   ,

+% "

+! "!! =>& 2+! +  !*

%,

,

(5

!

?  

5, !

" !

##/ 2+  !

!% > (!

%"

! " % ,

   %#,

+5/,

   !* ;%

!

( ( !:%!  #  & 2,

% +, !#!

%



#

"

5/

,

+%

-!,

%
;% #/,

+5/ (!

! 

5



((

%" 

 



=>L



I)9  , ! 
 3 





+%*+


5# !+ 7%( 3E 4739   > (!

! 5!*

I)9  , 0#%



#  #,

+%

>"

 , 2

+!

 >

 #%! !"# $%  
5%) % / @%* %   % "

# 

"  

 @ )   #! * %

.

# ""

% #)?"





! %

 

"*    

 !  %"

! #.

1%"

#  @%* %   # 

)% "

% ! $ )

A

.

% ""

7@ )  

& +( 7@ ) 

&  %"

7@ ) :

' .

.

7@ ) 

&%)( 7@ )  %

& ( 7@ )  )

2& ( 7@ )  

-% ( 7@ )  "

' +( 7@ )  !

-%%( %"

7@ )  

1% % %"

7@ ) 

8%"+    % "

 

% .B D@@ &  



 #

 " &.

;

.

;%*

@ )   ! 

, #
%" 8#*%   # $ &  8#*% E1F 2&  8#*% E1F -% 8#*% E1F ' + 8#*% E1F & + % %

"  !%"

&  % %

"  !%"

-%% 8#*% E1F 1% % 8#*% E1F 8%"+ 

8#*%   # $ :

' 8#*% E1FB



#/!

5  #%!,

 2

>"  , 2-!*

I)9  ,



+! > (!!*



# #  #,



+, 

% ##/ 5!*

! ,

" % +  !! !5#/ ",

5#

+%( 5# 1+,


!" !

" % 5 % 5#

5!* ! ,

5#  %!*



5#*!*

5# *%"

, /

+5/

!

! 5#

 

 #%

5# *%"

, " !

##/ 2+  ! 

% 

 , %** !

5#

! 5 =>&



5#*!*

5#

,

+%

+%*+

 

% !*

I1





 

8 ;% ,

!("%* !

!

!,

,

;%

+2!

   ,

5 ( " !#/  ,

, !(", %"

!



!

6%*  ,  

%

/ * "!

/,

5%!

/ * (! "" !

!,

, 

"" !

!    8 ;% ,

+ !  (!

"" #,

,

! !(!

! !#,

+%" ! 

+2!

- % /,

+%*+



!

6%*  , +2!

 2!* ((!



* !

%
"" /,

/,

   2,

#/



>"!/

"! #!(!

!#!*

"" #

   

2 +2!

+  "

 

   $  % &  "  
 #
'()*+(    
(*'(*,+-*./0123,*.+41*5  *+34 (*'(*,,*-4,'.6)* *+34