High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/500/2011allowed

Surinder Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab

2015-12-09Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

!"# $#%&'&()#%#*+#,- !"# $#%&'&()#%#*+#,- !"# $#%&'&()#%#*+#,- !"# $#%&'&()#%#*+#,-. . . . /0,&($#,/&(12!($!("2#, #"&"&(#,'

3#,'0'

/"!"# 0(4!+ #'5($#("

) ) ) ) 6 7/ //

6 7/ //

,#'#(") ,#'#(") ,#'#(") ,#'#(") , 89!:&!. $;%!"# ,"2#5#"&"&(#, , //#<2(.

0(4!+ ===== ===== ===== ===== /

. #"&"&(#,' 2!$ !%#$ ",&!: &( $!"#$ > .0($#,/#%"&('

($&!(#(!:$#. >

66 ,'2,".,#1&'"#,#$!":&%#/"!"&(&"?!450,! ,&!:0,";&$#40$1*#("@,$#,$!"#$ > - ,$#,#$"2#%(;&%"&(!($'#("#(%# "2#5#"&"&(#,'A0! %**&''&( #(%#50(&'2!+:#0($#,/#%"&(

(!(!55#!: &:#$+?"2#5#"&"&(#,'."2#&,%(;&%"&(!($ '#("#(%#!',$#,#$+?"2#",&!:0,"B#,#052#:$+?"2#

55#::!"#0,";&$#,$#,$!"#$ -

#(%#."2# 5,#'#("5#"&"&(+?"2#5#"&"&(#,' ,'#%0"&('",?.&(+,&# .&'"2!"(> !"!+0"C) .&("2#!,#! 0'D/"!($!450,!.!%%0'#$

'2<80*!,*!(!1#$"#'%!5# ,*"2#:!B 0:%0'"$? "2#5#"&"&(#,' ( C> .5#"&"&(#,'B#,#$&,#%"#$"

"!<# !%%0'#$ '2< 80*!, " !+!:50, ,* #(",!: !&:.

!"&!:! ( >> . 5#"&"&(#,' 5,$0%#$ !%%0'#$

'2<80*!,+# ,#"2#0,"'!" !+!:50, %%0'#$ '2< 80*!,B!'!1!&(5,$0%#$+# ,#"2#0,"'!" !+!:50,(

-> 2#,#! "#,.5#"&"&(#,',#!%2#$!450,! ,*

!+!:50,!:(1B&"2%D!%%0'#$ '2<80*!,+?",!&(!($ B#,#"+!,$!+0' ,!"&!:! ,* 0'D/"!($.!450,!+0"

!%%0'#$ '2<80*!,*!(!1#$"#'%!5# 7#!,(#$%0('#: ,"2#5#"&"&(#,'2!''0+*&""#$ "2!" &( $#5!,"*#("!: 5,%##$&(1'. 5#"&"&(#,' B#,# #E(#,!"#$ ( $#5!,"*#("!: 5,%##$&(1' !' B#:: !' %,&*&(!:",&!:.5#"&"&(#,'2!$ !%#$"2#'!*#%2!,1# 7#!,(#$ /"!"# %0('#:. ( "2# "2#, 2!($ 2!' 55'#$ "2# 5#"&"&( +0" 2!' !$*&""#$ "2# !%"0* #E(#,!"&( "2#5#"&"&(#,'&($#5!,"*#("!:5,%##$&(1' ( "2# 5,#'#(" %!'#. 5#"&"&(#,' B#,# %(;&%"#$ !($ '#("#(%#$ +? "2# 0,"' +#:B A0! %**&''&( #(%#50(&'2!+:#0($#,/#%"&(

/#%"&(

,#!$'!'0($#,)D

'%!5# ,* %( &(#*#(" , %0'"$?

(#1:&1#(":?'0 #,#$+?50+:&%'#,;!(" (#1:&1#(":?'0 #,#$+?50+:&%'#,;!(" (#1:&1#(":?'0 #,#$+?50+:&%'#,;!(" (#1:&1#(":?'0 #,#$+?50+:&%'#,;!("G92#;#,. +#&(1 ! 50+:&% '#,;!(" :#1!::? +0($ !' '0%2 50+:&%'#,;!(""<##5&(%( &(#*#("!(?5#,'( %2!,1#$ B&"2 , %(;&%"#$ !(? #(%# H, :!B 0::? %**&""#$ " %0'"$?I. (#1:&1#(":? '0 #,''0%25#,'("#'%!5# ,*%( &(#*#(". '2!::+#50(&'2#$B&"2'&*5:#&*5,&'(*#(" ,!

"#,*B2&%2*!?#E"#($""B?#!,'.,B&"2 &(#. ,B&"2+"2J 20'. B2#,# ! 50+:&% '#,;!(" &' (#1:&1#(" &( 5#, ,*&(12&':#1!:$0"&#'!($!::B'!(?5#,'("#'%!5# ,*%( &(#*#(",%0'"$?.2#&':&!+:# ,50(&'2*#(" 9 ''&'"!("/0+('5#%",/0<2$#;/&(122!$ &(;#'"&1!"#$"2#%!'# 5#,0'!: 2&''"!"#*#("!:'$#'

(":#!$&( #,#(%#"2!"2#2!$%::#%"#$!(?*!"#,&!:" '!"&' ?2&*'#: "2!""2#5#"&"&(#,'2!$+##((#1:&1#("&( 5#, ,*&(1"2#&,$0"&#'!"2#,&(2&'%,''D#E!*&(!"&(.2# 2!$'"!"#$"2!"2#%0:$("'!&$!'"B2#"2#,!(?5#,'( B!'(#1:&1#(",("&("2&'%((#%"&( 2#,# &' !:' ( "2#, #;&$#(%# ( ,#%,$ " '011#'" "2!" "2# 5#"&"&(#,' 2!$ +##( (#1:&1#(" &( 5#, ,*&(1"2#&,$0"&#' #"&"&(#,'B#,#!:'5,%##$#$$#5!,"*#("!::? ("2#$#5!,"*#("!:5,%##$&(1'."2#%!'# "2#5#"&"&(#,' B!' "2!" $0#" '0$$#( ,0'2 !" "2# 0'D/"!($. !450,!.

'2<80*!,"!<&(1+#(# &" "2#'&"0!"&(.2!$*!(!1#$ "#'%!5# "B!' 0,"2#,"2#%!'# "2#5#"&"&(#,'"2!" "2#?B#,#("(#1:&1#("&(5#, ,*&(1"2#&,$0"&#'("2# $#5!,"*#("!:5,%##$&(1'.5#"&"&(#,'B#,##E(#,!"#$ "2#%2!,1# ,!*#$!1!&('""2#*!($&"B!'2#:$"2!""2#? 2!$("+##((#1:&1#("&(5#, ,*&(1"2#&,$0"&#' 2#,#:#;!("5!,!1,!52 ((#E0,#D @D,#!$'

!'0($#,)D

F,* #;#,? #;&$#(%# %*# ( "2# &:# $#5!,"*#("!: #(A0&,? !($ %(%:0'&( ,#5," (A0&,? &%#,. ,* "2# "2,012 5#,0'!: B,&""#(,#5:? "2##*5:?##'.&"2!'+##( 0($ "2!" "2# !::#1!"&( B2&%2 2!' +##( :#;#::#$ !1!&('""2#'##*5:?##'."2!"2!'+##('"!"#$" +# %&(%&$#("!: &(%&$#(" +? (A0&,? &%#, !($ "2#?2!;#+##(#E(#,!"#$ ,*"2#%2!,1#!'

"2#?B#,#("(#1:&1#("2#,# ,#.+?%(%0,,&(1 B&"2"2#%(%:0'&(,#5," #(A0&,? &%#,.$0# " ((D5,;&(1 !::#1!"&( !1!&('" "2#'# #*5:?##'. "2# ,$#, &' 5!''#$ " %('&1( "2# $#5!,"*#("!:#(A0&,?&(" &%# 5&#' "2&' ,$#,+#5,;&$#$""2##*5:?##'J 20'.&("2#5,#'#("%!'#.5,'#%0"&(2!$ !&:#$ "5,;#&"'%!'#!($"2#0,"'+#:B2!$#,,#$&(,$#,&(1 "2#%(;&%"&(!($'#("#(%# "2#5#"&"&(#,' ,#;#,. 5#"&"&(#,' 2!;# +##( #E(#,!"#$ &( "2# $#5!,"*#("!: 5,%##$&(1'

%%,$&(1:?."2&'5#"&"&(&'!::B#$ (;&%"&( !($'#("#(%# "2#5#"&"&(#,'!',$#,#$+?"2#0,"' +#:B0($#,/#%"&(

&''#"!'&$# ('#A0#(":?.

5#"&"&(#,' !,# !%A0&""#$ "2# %2!,1# ,!*#$ !1!&('" "2#*

#%#*+#,-. #%#*+#,-. #%#*+#,-. #%#*+#,-. *!2!;&,