High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/266/2006disposed of

Bhag Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab Etc.

2016-12-15Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri,Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri9 pages

! "#$%$$ &'( "'&"

* (

+",-"

!."

/# 01/ (/( 2 01/ ((3

!"" # $% #"%$#&' () "

" "*

! + /& !&)* )45 )67# , ""!""# " "#" - " *"$.# "$ "

"""# '/ # "0 2 .#""" 3405 " * 6 34078

#$ !/ "$" 15+

858 # " ! "#" - ""!"# "+

'9 '#$#9 '

/ "! 9"9" .# "$ "

"""# # " 5+

858 340 " "/ $ "

""# "0 '/" 1 "#

+ +

+ , #

: " !"""!" 1 : "

""9'"# *"$.#"

:10 $" 9!#! " $ '// :0

:" " *#! 0+03

" " " "

"!""" , $" "9" .#""" 1 : " "$".#""" """ / $!"! 9 !"" , $ '9# .#"""" ' "$

8 !#! " " * 9$/! "" .#" # ' " #"";"

/ !#! " .#""" """ " "!< 8 '"$'/ / ""

! "

340 # " ! "$ "" 2 # !"" " " "9$/! """ * # '# "#" '# # ''"$ $" ! $" " "$ ! "&# $9 =' #!9#" 819: * *(

&)"

)!4$% 5$7(;$< 8(),:+66'):+66*(

&)"

)!4 $%5$7(=<( '9 "$' " ='#!9# "

63 $"; >" ' "! 9' /" !- ' % !9

# "/ ;"#;;9%!9 ,99#""

? % !9 # "/ ? 2 $ " # "9" = $ !"

.#""" '"

" 9 >"-"!" '" " "@!"

" 9 >" @9" "" "

" "" "" """ ".#/$ # "!!!" /# " @!" !! "9!/!"$" $/ "/ ! /- "

"" #"! " "

" 4 , " ' # !" # .#"

9 "#" " >"

" 9, !! " '"$ " &# " 9!" " " ! "$ " 99 " 431 !" ""

"$ #! /" 433! " "

#9 , " =' " " #" "

9 /" '"$! @! ""#/ - >"""! 9 "

" !!/ / .#""" # #$/ ! "" # !! ' # " !" "

/!"

#9!" "

, "'"*!"$" $"" " ' " ""A# 9*!"$9!"" " "$ 9*' !" "#9.#" "# "

" " "

!#'""# @"/ ##'"#"!"/ #$/! "" '" * + ""9!"

""$#" ' "$"

.#""" " !" " " 2 &# $9 "# '

!"" "

"/"9!/ 9"!"

? ' 9" " #"#"" " 99!"$ .#""" #$ /# !/9!" .#" " "$ "

.#""" " 9# "$ !" "$"- "" $ " - "$ .#""" 9 " /'"

# "/' "$ !! "

!9""$ 9*!!"! " .#"

" "0"

""@", "!"!"#/" ! #9"@ " "

2 " "#! "

" .#""" # " 1 " ! "$ .#"9 " 1 ##9' !" 9" " 9-! "$

# # ""$ " "

" "$ 9.#" " 9$" " #""'"$ $ " " ""

" 1 / "!" # !/ !! # ! 9 9# "$9$/.#""" " "$" .#/$$" *"$ ""$ "9!" " B .#"/ 9 !/'"$ .# /"

#$ ' " '# + "!/ " 9!"$/ "" !""$" "$" !" 9 #'& .#""" 3

431""

9!"" ! "

#'.#"

""'/ (! "$! ! " " """ .#"""! "$*/ " "'"" " " ""@* 9 /, !

" " 9 "$ " $ .#" '/" " # !!, !! " " 97 - (),:+66 '):+660! 5#!8 #!9 # ' "*"'#"/

"#9- ".#""" !""" '/"#"$"

""# "0 340:+ " *"$ #$/! """ "" , !" ":

"9##/9 "!!"' '/"$" 1508 " * 3 , #'.#/ '=!

= ! "$""" " "

"" # "00: 44: '/"

"" 13 44 '/ " *"$ #$/ ! "" " 1 $" "!"$ " ! ":

, ".#""" $ ' "$ # 9 '"$.#" $" " !!"" 9" , *#!! ".#""" ! "$ ! # /"!#'" "$ C 1

+ * ! #

! "$'//"$"03 "!""9' "

*"$ ".#" !#'""""$"9 ' " #"$ ! / "!"" !#'"

!#! /""#"/ .#"""! "$ , *#!! .#"# '# "

/" $9 9"*#$ ' "

" "#$ #"$ ! / ! "$

? "$ # !" '/ " '! "

!!"" ! # "

< ! "$# "

""" " /

44:

4 '"

! " 1 "'" -" .#""" ' $ '/ "!"" -" * # #'

19: * 0! 5#!8 " '@

' # '!!"'"

' *!"$"

" !#""#9 " "'" 6(

) )! " *(

4 $>>? 5;7(?>< 61 * )") ** "!&(&):4$>=57($;><-#

# / ='#!9##$

""" 9 ' " (

) )! "0!5#!8 " 9/ ' ! !#! @

6 " 8"!!" '/ #$/ 9 *!" !" 9*"$ # "

#! " " " " " 9" 8" #9"*'9/"

!!"" .#"""# " 1'# / " 9 "! """ "

'/ " #"/ " 9 7 , !!"'""/ "

" "

" / "# #"

/ .#"""! "$# '$#9

" /'& " ! &#"

/# #" , " " (

) )! "0! 5#!8 !! "$/ " " 6(",

*"') /

6 @ 6 & :.6A

!0 .

) * +! "'(

A*/& - +6&-"

)!4$>>5?7 (<4 " "# 6-(

) )! "*(

4 .#" "

""# "05 8 "# " $! "

"9 " "/ "$ # "

D ? &# $

!" * " 9" " "#'&/ 9"" 9!" !/ 9 %"

"$ " #"/ " 9 "$ 9 "9! #

C/"035 8$"

!" 9.#""" ' !""*, .#" "" ", !!/# .#""" "$' " !!" ' /!# " !! @!'/@" ! # "035 8 "

"' , @"

!.# "

""# "05 8

"# " # "$#"/7 , # # !"#/" $"

/ 9/'/+ / #/"9"

/ " 19: * (),:+660!5#!8# ' "' !"" (

) )! "0! 5#!8 ' "# '.#/!!"' "$ "

# ! @9" @ "#

$ "$ $ !#! .#""" , .#" !#'"!#!"/$ !"! 9 "'#" #"";"$ " !#!!"

" ".#"""

+9 #""; "

!#!.#" !###'.#"

:.#""$ 9 :10 # " #/0+03 , .#""" !""9#"$1: "$"/ !#! /"$$!"!"#$ ' #""; ! 9! "$3 30 ! 3 , " #'"#9" "# "# !#'"!#! "$"# #" " ' " 9 '/ =' #!9 # " 6 "6 & ):6 B ) ).) "1

*/& !&+

)!4>5?7(?=%<4 " $"/' $ !#!# '!9""' ! "$# " 1 '""" ! "* !#'"!#!# "$" " # !""" "$ B@ !" &# $9 "! # 6-" # 9" " #'" "!# """" .#"""! "$ " !!

"$#! 9!"- ' "

"/'# 9* " *!"$" " $"!!"

"9" -" !9""' !!!# ".#" "

"" !#! " # 9" " !# " /!#'"!#! '" '/ "#"

) "5#!8 / !#! '" '/ " #")" 995#!8 E$""63!

+) @ )!*(

)A"45?7$ (??%<4 "# - # !#! " " .#" "! 9*"'# / "$ ! * "#" /" 9 " "$ /""" ! "$ #9!"

-# " ".#" /#&# " 9 !!9!/7 -6 * 3&+66)"

" )* " ""

)!4 =57 5 * 67=%=<4"

""""!!"$'

! #'9" "$$ # "" #'& .#""$"$-""

.#" !"#!#'"!#!'#""

!#'"!#! $ .#"""" '9 .#"""' " "

9/'# " "9 !! '#"" !"#!#'"!#! " " "!#"" 9 !#! #$ !#'"!#! #'9" 9 $

# $" !#'"!#!# " "

.#"""! "$ " " " "

$7 A "

"9" !"!"" 5/( 2 5(3 7 $%$$ !*"$F(

EF (!' EF